Watthour
Member
I resurrected 29 Deere and two Case tractors that I know had not been run since 2002. The photos show some of the worst of them. If the tractor is going to be put to field work straight water might be better for cooling, but it isn't going to help for corrosion protection and certainly won't protect from freezing.
As an aside, one of those "saved" was a '36 B that I had nickel welded the block back in the '90s due to a frost crack in the outer casting - It hadn't damaged the bore. It was welded, needle-scaled hot, then shot peined to relieve stress and hide the repair. It was at that point that everything got anti-freeze as a precaution.
Those with a good concentration of coolant were still pretty clean, and only got a cold water flush to chase out the solids. Others had to be picked out, as above. That's 25 years of coolant mix with nothing but good results, at least in terms of longevity.
As for the non-tractor items (Case), the '36 RC had a radiator problem that I couldn't resolve easily. That needed to be re-tubed, and GOOD radiator shops are about as rare as hen's teeth any more. Somebody had to do it.
http://www.wwdsltd.com/files/RadiatorTubeFitment.jpg
Of course, after swaging in about 100 feet of copper tube and burying it all in a couple pounds of acid-core solder, it got coolant mix right after testing with water.
As an aside, one of those "saved" was a '36 B that I had nickel welded the block back in the '90s due to a frost crack in the outer casting - It hadn't damaged the bore. It was welded, needle-scaled hot, then shot peined to relieve stress and hide the repair. It was at that point that everything got anti-freeze as a precaution.
Those with a good concentration of coolant were still pretty clean, and only got a cold water flush to chase out the solids. Others had to be picked out, as above. That's 25 years of coolant mix with nothing but good results, at least in terms of longevity.
As for the non-tractor items (Case), the '36 RC had a radiator problem that I couldn't resolve easily. That needed to be re-tubed, and GOOD radiator shops are about as rare as hen's teeth any more. Somebody had to do it.
http://www.wwdsltd.com/files/RadiatorTubeFitment.jpg
Of course, after swaging in about 100 feet of copper tube and burying it all in a couple pounds of acid-core solder, it got coolant mix right after testing with water.