off topic. insurance claims with at fault party.

INCase

Well-known Member
trying to keep this generic (2 major insurance companies)

Got rear ended about 1 year ago. Guy admitted fault, police report says at fault and was cited as well. he was driving for work in a company car that was leased thru enterprize (name on registration).

our insurance took care of our part except they will not pay the fairly high deductible until they get paid.

Have talked to both on numerous occasions. their insurance has paid me for the "appraisal clause" appraisal fee i had to do with my insurance. so they have somewhat, indirectly, agreed/admitted to liability.

My insurance is says they have sent several "demand" letters for payment. their insurance says they have not gotten anything. My insurance says they submitted the demands thru some "insurance claim portal" between insurance companies?? THeir's says they get them via email.

also my insurance took it to arbitration, which in theory, should not happen if there was no claim or demand for payment. my insurance also says the arbitration was declined due to "no proof of liability coverage by the at fault party". ???? Their insurance says arbitration was declined due to "jurisdictional exclusion" (??????) from what i read that is only for issues between countries not between states. ????

so i think maybe some issue with my company not submitting correctly? and maybe/likely some stalling on the other guys insurance?

So what do you do in this situation?? I'm inclined to call the guy's company and inform them of this so maybe they'll push their insurance.
 
State laws vary. In my state, when one of my vehicles was hit and the other driver was at fault, my agent had me submit a claim on the other driver's insurance. He said that if they didn't pay, my insurance would pay and go after the at fault driver's insurance. Your deductible shouldn't have anything to do with it since you weren't at fault. In my case, the other insurance paid me in full, my insurance didn't have to get involved. It may have something to do with differing state laws. If your insurance is paying you and then going after the other insurance company for reimbursement they should be paying you in full. Again, since you weren't at fault, your deductible shouldn't have anything to do with it. But I'm just going by my experience and by what I have learned about North Dakota laws. As others said, I'd contact the insurance commissioner's office and find out who is responsible for payment under your state laws. And maybe they will light a fire under both insurance companies' azzes!
 
Here in Nebraska you can file a complaint with the State Insurance Commissioner and the company has, by law, 15 days to respond.

I tried it once and it worked. I got twice the settlement I was offered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 504
State laws vary. In my state, when one of my vehicles was hit and the other driver was at fault, my agent had me submit a claim on the other driver's insurance. He said that if they didn't pay, my insurance would pay and go after the at fault driver's insurance. Your deductible shouldn't have anything to do with it since you weren't at fault. In my case, the other insurance paid me in full, my insurance didn't have to get involved. It may have something to do with differing state laws. If your insurance is paying you and then going after the other insurance company for reimbursement they should be paying you in full. Again, since you weren't at fault, your deductible shouldn't have anything to do with it. But I'm just going by my experience and by what I have learned about North Dakota laws. As others said, I'd contact the insurance commissioner's office and find out who is responsible for payment under your state laws. And maybe they will light a fire under both insurance companies' azzes!
Also in ND. If you file against your own insurance they do not pay you your deductible unless it is recovered from the at fault’s insurance. I’ve filed claims like this a couple times because the at fault insurance wanted to play games. Both times, my insurance received the subrogated payment including the deductible within a day.

Also if you file against your own, you are not allowed any diminished value claim.
 
I got rearended a little over a year ago; no serious injuries, thankfully. The young man who hit me gave a bogus insurance card and I thought I was going to get only an uninsured motorist settlement. It turned out that there was a policy and it was the same company I had. They were great and gave me a fair settlement but it still took around a year to get it all done. The ER bill held things up. There were some possible outstanding expenses but the settlement was enough that it would cover it. I was surprised at how long it took even with a slam dunk situation.
 
I've been fighting Geico for a claim since Sept 2025. Their insured rear ended us and both of us had broken backs, and I had cracked ribs. Geico claims is the worst of the worst. They sent a deferral letter to my insurance company saying their driver was not at fault(she was). My insurance has paid, and paid, and paid for hospital claims, and Geico is fighting every bill. I emailed the insurance commissioner in my state, only to find out they are not on the side of the consumer. The commissioner and all the underlings are ex-insurance empl, and they don't care at all if the consumer is getting the run around. They mostly only care that the various insurance companies don't get sued.
 
I think I’d contact the insurance commissioners office asap and get the ball rolling before any more time passes

So he was under insured or not insured through his company? I am unsure why your insurance would pay otherwise?
 
I've been fighting Geico for a claim since Sept 2025. Their insured rear ended us and both of us had broken backs, and I had cracked ribs. Geico claims is the worst of the worst. They sent a deferral letter to my insurance company saying their driver was not at fault(she was). My insurance has paid, and paid, and paid for hospital claims, and Geico is fighting every bill. I emailed the insurance commissioner in my state, only to find out they are not on the side of the consumer. The commissioner and all the underlings are ex-insurance empl, and they don't care at all if the consumer is getting the run around. They mostly only care that the various insurance companies don't get sued.
Looking at Indiana's insurance laws they seem pro insurance company
 
I think I’d contact the insurance commissioners office asap and get the ball rolling before any more time passes

So he was under insured or not insured through his company? I am unsure why your insurance would pay otherwise?
That isn't clear. liberty kinda sounds like maybe they didn't have coverage at the time based on the reason the arbitration was declined (have heard 2 different reasons) . but why would liberty pay me the appraisal cost if not??? Indiana requires proof of insurance directly from the insurance company within a couple weeks of the accident from all parties involved.

if time permits i'll probably send a complaint to the Insurance division today. Not sure who to complain about. I really suspect my insurance is incompetent and may not have filed correctly and don't care. but liberty's emails have been illogical and contradictory.
 
After reading about all this insurance I’m glad we have no fault in Manitoba. Doesn’t matter who is at fault everything but your deductible is paid for. I have never fought for anything. Always got paid.
 
Before KS was a no fault state I had to call the insurance commissioner once and it worked well for my issue. Nowwith no fault it is a lot less comples to sort it all out. I know this no longer matters in the OP's particular case but it never really matters what the investigating officer thinks (unless it is a fatal and then the court cares aboout what the testimony is) nor does it matter a lot when the other driver confesses fault. All companies have their own investigators who call the balls and strikes for them. It generally works OK.
 
My wife got hit awhile back by an uninsured driver. My insurance paid the repair cost and filed a suit against the driver to reclaim the amount. If I remember correctly they would not pay the deductible amount till they got full payment from the uninsured guy. Never did get it.
 
That isn't clear. liberty kinda sounds like maybe they didn't have coverage at the time based on the reason the arbitration was declined (have heard 2 different reasons) . but why would liberty pay me the appraisal cost if not??? Indiana requires proof of insurance directly from the insurance company within a couple weeks of the accident from all parties involved.

if time permits i'll probably send a complaint to the Insurance division today. Not sure who to complain about. I really suspect my insurance is incompetent and may not have filed correctly and don't care. but liberty's emails have been illogical and contradictory.
At the very least you deserve to know why.

And maybe like others say they might be going after the other driver and there’s nothing to pay out until that happens.
 
I think it matters what insurance company you have.
Yeah, you can get cheeep insurance, but what happens when you file a claim is what it's all about.
 
I was side swiped and the other insurance would not pay. I paid the deductible and my company fixed the truck. About 6 months later I got a check from my company for the deductsble
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top