Re: General question about arc flashes

Philip d

Well-known Member
Im an electrical apprentice and my boss is a voluntary
fireman. He said on a call they were at the triplex snapped off
a house and was dancing around in the yard on the utility
side. He had all hes gear still on and slowly walked along
stepping on the triplex and flattened the break out enough
with his boots before getting too close to it that it separated
enough to stop arcing. He picked it up and another fireman
apparently said to him what are you going to do now your so
smart? He said this! He shorted the hots out causing the fuse
to blow at the transformer. Keep in mind it was dark would be
quite a flash
 
How about 3000 amp,900dc, generator to generator busbar short?? lots of smoke and molten copper
balls across the deck: Scary to think and do the calculations of the millisecond capacity of the
arc itself backed up by the utility supplying it ?
 
Wow yes that would cause for some instant panic! They teach us that higher DC voltage is way more dangerous than AC at the same voltage. Yesterday we went over DC power supplies in class, half wave, full wave ,full wave bridge rectifiers along with different types of filters and regulators. Lots has to happen to convert a sine wave into an almost straight line.
 
And since that fuse is on the high voltage side of the transformer it almost requires a direct short like that to blow. Something to think about when working the triplex and service entrance equipment.
 
I retired after 40 years as an electrician, I got to see a lot! From working in older houses where I saw a 4 fuse panel in a bath tub, yes bathtub. It was at the opposit end of the plumbing so was safe(not). I heard and saw the aftermath of the chains drape across 250 volt DC crane hot rails ( Bethlehem steel). And I had the pleasure of closing a 200 amp 480 volt breaker into a dead short, had I not used a broom handle to close it I might not be here. It makes you pucker when working on old machine, the control circuit was 480 volts with 40-50 + year old wire going through limit switches and bush buttons. Glad I made it to retirement. joe
 
Assuming a 200A, 120/240V service, by code it is OK as long as you have the three feet in front and three feet wide and door opens out.
 
Phillip, as a 36 years worth of experience electrical lineman, I can honestly say your instructor is not the sharpest tool in the shed. Great deal of respect for firemen, but things like that put ideas in peoples heads. Had it been a larger transformer or fused incorrectly, he could have very well got soooo much more than he bargained for
 
Arc flash usually isn't a problem with homes. That small transformer on the pole will limit the fault current, and thus the energy to the arc. If you have something other
than the standard 200A service, that changes things.
 
A 200 amp disconnect in a high rise bus run was tripping . It had tripped the main . My co-worker tried to reset the breaker under load . I wasn't sure if he jumped or was thrown back
by the charging handle. When the main reset the 200 amp disconnect several stories up exploded { it was concluded Square D had left an extra 1/4 twenty bolt between phases which
eventually wore through the plastic coatings Which caused a phase to phase short. All the lawyers came running out of their offices saying when is power coming back Well my boss is
on the phone with Square D in Ohio so they can start making a new piece of bus duct. Lawyers were not happy with my answer. The wall in the electric room looked like it was shot with
a copper pellet shotgun . We were lucky we did not kill someone.
 
Lots of electricians on this board. I got journeyman
card in 1974. It wasnt until about 1995 that arc
flash became a prime safety focus and proper
safety gear became a requirement in industrial
applications..
After a couple of training sessions ya get a new
attitude about it. The training films show some
horrible burns and deaths etc, hard to watch.
And household electrical systems have more than
enough power to blind and burn. Removing a panel
cover is one of the most hazardous steps and a
proper face shield is a wise choice.
 
miangus and RJKeith regarding my homes service and complications to what you are saying. I moved in to this home 22 years ago. Soon after, I was surveying the service to it which is in back between our street and the homes that face the next street over and serves both. My home is one of the first built on this block a is one of few that has an overhead feed most others are buried, which this point really adds nothing to this question. Anyway, the pole my drop connects to does not have a transformer there are 110 phases strung between the poles and these are obviously what feed my home. There are two if not three transformers along my block. I have always assumed that the two or three all feed into the phase lines giving us a redundant power supply if one of the transformers failed. This discussion got me thinking that maybe my assumption is wrong and the power company may not connect the transformers this way. If one did fail how would the power company know? What say you? If they are hooked together could that cause strange occasional flickering on one of the phases in my home? The first picture shows one of the transformers behind the home 2 houses to my south, sorry not real clear due to the trees. The other is the drop to my house.
cvphoto115669.jpg


cvphoto115670.jpg
 
As you say and see in the photos its hard to truly say what is what, so a guess is that there are 3 transformers, each of them are connected to a supply HV phase, each transformer is supplying a set number of 120/240 house services, example phase A = 4 houses, phase B = 4 houses, phase C =5 houses.....a way of balancing the utility load equally, instead of one large transformer= $$$ and if one of the three, was to fail or have a supply phase loss, not everyone is in the dark.
Hope it makes sense or what you are seeing.
 
Sorry Phil, could you tell me what ..HV phase.. means in this case? The three lower wires are the two 110 feeds and a neutral. I am talking about the three evenly spaced ones there is a single lower wire that is the cable TV. All 4 houses fed by that pole connect to those. Mine is the overhead drop and 3 others are buried. My assumption has always been that the transformers along the block all connected to those three lines as did all the homes on the block. So simply would a power company ..parallel feed.. transformers to a line in this manner? Because the question in my mind came up when the comment was made that a short in the feed panel would blow the transformer fuse before a serious arc flash occurred. But in my case if the assumption is correct the fuses on all feeding transformers would have to blow so you would have the possibility of far more amps or kw. Sorry if any of the terms are incorrect.
 
Each distribution transformer has its own fuse sized based on its maximum current. In Canada say you have a 75 kva transformer (about as big as theyll use on a pole) with lets say 7500v on the primary (power line) feeding 240v split phase secondary which is center tapped so you get 2 lines at 120v and one neutral that is system grounded at the pole. A 75 kva transformer could easily supply up to 3 homes each having 200A services. 75 000 va (volt amps , similar to watts but other factors involved) divided by 7500v is only 10A. That fuse would be 10x 1.25 so itd most likely be 15A fuse on the primary. BUT for a fault on the secondary to create over 15A on the primary is a whole nother deal. On the secondary side you again take 75 000 va this time divide by 240v and you get 312.5 A , to create a 15A current on that primary itd take 390A fault on the secondary. BIG boom!
 
According to the NEC, electric panels are not allowed to be installed in closets. NEC 240.24(D) states,

Overcurrent devices shall not be located in the vicinity of easily ignitable materials, such as a clothes closet.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top