Why metal poles?

Geo-TH,In

Well-known Member
And why between existing wires?
cvphoto85964.jpg
 
The metal poles are above the trees which in storms cause power outages. It looks like they intend to move the wires up and take the wooden poles down.
 
Looks to me like the metal poles are going to replace the old wooden post, and stick the wires up higher by a good bit. To get wooden post strong enough to carry the load at that length, would probably cost more than the new steel post do. I would think steel post would last longer too compared to wooden.
 
That's what I thought too.
Lineman must have traded in body parts for rubber Male parts. Brass will conduct electric
 
30,000 t0 45,000volts per inch....just keep the correct inches away. 100,000, about 3-4 feet. If you test, let us know how it works out. :twisted:
 
We see a lot of large new poles going in made of: laminated wood; galvanized steel; and some that look like a composite.
 

Why? Because metal poles are higher priced and utility companies have money to burn since they can pass the cost onto the customer. Have you ever seen a utility get tools from HF? Have you ever seen them do anything without a few supervisors to watch? Have you ever seen a utility over-engineer a project to death with countless engineers and still not get it right? I could keep going but would need another cup of coffee.
 
George, metal poles much bigger than those got snapped like toothpicks last year when a tornado went into Seneca, SC last year April 13.
We had power out in the lower half of our county for 3 days.
Don't know how they got them replaced so fast.
Fortunately we had a generator to keep us going.
Our son kept his huge poultry operation going with 2 huge generators.
Richard in NW SC
 
Jessie,
I was waiting on someone to mention
higher voltage lines.
In town they used taller wooden poles and
ran new lines from sub station. Attached
old wires below new lines on new poles.

Metal can rust. Poles were alongside a
country road prone to flooding . On the
other side of the river is a natural gas
power station. Be interesting to see what
they attach to metal poles.
George
 
Good Neighbor George, its been a while since I practiced power distribution engineering but they were coming in favor back then due to their strength, longevity, didn't rot, withstood wind and they don't have to chase tree huggers away to cut down the poles lol

Metal is a much better conductor then wood DUH If you look at many aerial HV service lines notice how the very bottom wire right below and relatively near the hot high voltage conductors is the earth grounded Neutral conductor. And in my day at every 4 poles we ran a bare No 4 copper wire unprotected down the side of the pole to driven ground rods...If a hot breaks loose it falls on the earth grounded Neutral below it (subject to time and current) can trip the breaker de energizing a dangerous line. If a hot breaks and falls on a pole if its conductive the breaker will (subject to time and current) trip, again hopefully de energizing the hot line and there's a better chance of that happening if the pole is conductive versus wood. And it may fall and not come in enough or long enough contact with the Neutral or a pole to throw a breaker AND STILL BE HOT WITH HV AND KILL YOU DEAD

Anyway NO GUARANTEE THINK WHATEVER YOU WISH, that's how HV Power Distribution experts, engineers, professors I had and companies explained it to me, but that's been a while, maybe things have changed since then ??????? NOOOOOOO WARRANTY MIND YOU Ive seen plenty of wood n plenty of metal poles and there must be a sound reason (including safety among others) why they are used even if little old me fails to understand it ....... It been too long since I was up on all this grrrrrr

I found they pretty well know what they are doing when it comes to high voltage and safety for the linemen and passer bys should a line break free and fall down. Better hope it falls on a good grounded conductor be it a metal pole or the Neutral immediately below long enough it so its de energized ???? A copper wire or a metal pole is less resistive and better conductor then the human body and it only takes like 0.030 to 0.050 amps to mess up your ticker OUCHHHHHHH.

Don't take my word for it however, consult high voltage distribution engineers to see the advantages or disadvantages and why they might choose wood versus metal and where and in what applications ??? Im too darn old n rusty to know for sure

Keep warm George

Neighbor to your south, John T
 
Being one of many utility workers myself, who daily replace wooden poles,It makes good sense to use the metal structure when ever possible. When you consider you get 30 years+ out of metal vs 15 to 20 years using wood, I would consider that to be cost effective. Also keep in mind, here in Virginia the SCC watches utilities closely on how the dollar is spent. Just saying.CM
 
The line through my property has the earth grounded neutral at the top. This is a main line feeding from the Jeffrey Energy Center. 288kva iirc.
 
The top wire is feeding my transformer. Has a fuse link before transformer. One night a fright flash, big boom and a fried squirrel was on the ground. I had no power.
 
(quoted from post at 15:20:54 04/22/21) Being one of many utility workers myself, who daily replace wooden poles,It makes good sense to use the metal structure when ever possible. When you consider you get 30 years+ out of metal vs 15 to 20 years using wood, I would consider that to be cost effective. Also keep in mind, here in Virginia the SCC watches utilities closely on how the dollar is spent. Just saying.CM

We just got new power poles with 34kv lines along our farm as a secondary source to a nearby town. Creosote 50+ footers and only buried 8' feet deep backfilled with AB3 gravel. Ground wire on the top. Some were green like they were treated with copper.
Go figure. I got the old poles for projects.

My problem with the metal poles is that they are supported by a bunch of bolts at the bottom. If they are worried about the base rusting out, then so can the bolts. That will be worse for filling up with crud blowing in there and no one to keep them clean regularly. Wait till the local vandals go out there with their hacksaws.
 
I don't know what the expected life of a wooden electric pole is but I knew of some that were over 50 years old. DTE, now our electric/natural gas supplier, was forced by gavernment to replace these old poles. They had been writing off expenses for replacing poles without doing it.
 
(quoted from post at 16:31:54 04/22/21) The line through my property has the earth grounded neutral at the top. This is a main line feeding from the Jeffrey Energy Center. 288kva iirc.
ust my years of observation, so like John, no guarantees, but I think out in country, away from human traffic that the ground is on top for lightening protection and in city where lines are closer to earth & potential contact, that the grounded conductor is on bottom as an aid in preventin human contact..
 
I think the main reasons for metal poles is they are easier to install, more reliable, durable, and environmentally friendly.
 
Yep Ive seen those, HV long transmission (we had around 300,000) is unlike the typical say 12,470 Y 7200 three phase or 9600 volt single phase city and rural lines.

Take care now

John T
 
Thats right George, HV in city and rural might be say 12,470 or 9600 Volts in which case the Hot is up top and the earth grounded Neutral on bottom......HV Transmission of 200,000 and more is a different animal, scares me lol

John T
 
Hey JMOR, indeed HV lines (talkin 200,000 and more) may have a set of twin STATIC GROUND wires (NOT conductors) up top for
lightning and surge protection. Thats a different thing then the say 12,470 or 9600 in town where the actual hot conductor is
up top

As always fun sparky chatting with you, take care

John T
 
Maybe the EPA has banned some of the chemicals used to treat wooden poles in the past that made them last a long time? Definitely wouldn't want to be around the steel poles in
a thunderstorm.
 
Simple answer, cost. They are cost effective in certain applications but not all. They are usually used for transmission lines. Wooden poles are favored for distribution lines. Its all about costs. Short term and long term balance.
 
I assume there are calculations on the distance between poles, the number and size of the wires, and so forth that make metal cheaper than wood.

It seems just from observation the taller the pole the more often steel is used.

Paul
 
That makes sense. Reliability is probably the nest biggest factor after cost. If a distribution line goes down a few hundred customers might be affected, if a transmission line goes down tens of thousands of customers will be affected.
 
Because we've already cut down all the trees tall enough to make them out of wood.

If they put them in line with the existing poles, they probably don't need to purchase any additional easements. I'm guessing they'll remove the old, lower voltage, transmission lines once the new ones are on line.
 
You need to visit the SE USA more woodland now especially the pines the wood poles are made from than ever in my lifetime.There are some 30+ inch diameter Poplar trees on the hillside beside my house that my father once planted corn on.
 
> You need to visit the SE USA more woodland now especially the pines the wood poles are made from than ever in my lifetime.There are some 30+ inch diameter Poplar trees on the hillside beside my house that my father once planted corn on.

I wonder why we don't make power poles out of poplar. Oh yeah, it's one of the weakest woods available, which probably is related to its very fast growth.

In fact, I've lived much of my life in the south. Pretty much all the old-growth longleaf yellow pine is gone. Trees big enough to make 130 foot tall power poles? Fuhgetaboutit.
Old growth longleaf pine almost gone
 
Lumber yard at the I64/US 250 interchange at Crozet VA keeps about 10 acres of long pine poles to be debarked and sized for whatever use almost all the time.
Another larger yard at Dillwyn VA on US 15 does the same.All power transmission lines close to being 130 ft have always been steel.
 
(quoted from post at 08:25:08 04/23/21) > You need to visit the SE USA more woodland now especially the pines the wood poles are made from than ever in my lifetime.There are some 30+ inch diameter Poplar trees on the hillside beside my house that my father once planted corn on.

I wonder why we don't make power poles out of poplar. Oh yeah, it's one of the weakest woods available, which probably is related to its very fast growth.

In fact, I've lived much of my life in the south. Pretty much all the old-growth longleaf yellow pine is gone. Trees big enough to make 130 foot tall power poles? Fuhgetaboutit.
Old growth longleaf pine almost gone

True.
The trees planted by man for harvest have been genetically altered and/or selected to grow fast.
"Fast" does not equal strength in most cases.

A wooden pole tall enough and strong enough to equal metal is a unicorn at any price anymore.
 
One more thought, the utility companys decision to use wood versus metal poles may well be based on the available supply, initial cost, long term cost, longevity and durability, ESPECIALY REGARDING THE EXTREME TALL POLES of which wood MAY NOT EVEN BE READILY AVAILABLE ???

Based on my education and experience in the power distribution industry, the utility has more expertise and knowledge than any of us here so will likely continue to do what THEY determine best and NOT care much about what anyone here may think lol In different electrical fields where I have been involved, when it comes to high voltage, transmission and linemen safety THOSE PEOPLE ARE THE BEST INFORMED AND SAFETY CONSCIOUS out there.... I couldnt believe all the training and step by step safety procedures used in the HV transmission industry. When they choose to use wood versus metal you can bet a ton of study and research went into the decision

Best wishes yall take care n God Bless

John T
 
(quoted from post at 15:09:16 04/22/21)Wait till the local vandals go out there with their hacksaws.

Because wooden poles are so vandal-proof... Where are all the vandals with their crosscut saws? Where are all the vandals with their chainsaws?

Lots easier to sabotage a wooden pole than a steel one.

Besides, that's WORK. I thought vandals didn't want to work... Oh yeah, they don't... That's why you don't see electric poles cut down by vandals ever.

Electric companies have been using steel towers for transmission lines since there has been electricity. I don't see why this is so strange and confusing.
 
The large lines are for transmission lines of large amounts of current at higher voltages than the small, wood pole line carries which are called distribution lines.

We have quite a few similar around me with the taller metal poles carrying transmission lines and the wooden poles carrying the distribution lines.
 
(quoted from post at 10:17:51 04/22/21) They're doing that here too in N.W. Ohio. Looks VERY dangerous putting those up between live wires!

Yes, it is, but they're professionals and they have techniques and processes to follow that keep them safe.

Wooden poles are no less dangerous. Stop by the local power company's display at the county fair. They'll give you a demonstration as to how dangerous touching a live power line is, even with a wooden stick. The power will travel down any moisture in the wood, instantly boiling it, and BOOM! Exploding stick/pole/board.
 
(quoted from post at 13:20:54 04/22/21)When you consider you get 30 years+ out of metal vs 15 to 20 years using wood, I would consider that to be cost effective.

15 to 20 years? Most of the electric poles out here to the farm were put up by the original Rural Electrification Act of 1936. The holes were hand dug by a local family. A few were replaced when new houses were built on the road, and when one was accidentally bumped with a farm implement and was dangling from the wires on the next pass.

It was only in the last two years, late 2019 into 2020, that the poles were finally replaced, again by government money. This time Cuomo's Rural High Speed Internet project. The wires had to be raised to accommodate the fiber optic line for Internet.

They didn't replace all the poles, and the wires are still the original 1940 wires.
 
That's what I was thinking, Higher voltages, higher off the ground, greater spacing between wires.
 
You state Electric companies have been using steel towers for transmission lines since there has been electricity. I don't
see why this is so strange and confusing

AMEN my friend. I started practice in the Power Distribution field like 50 years ago so like you its NOT strange and
confusing to me ........Theres a time and a place for wood or steel SUBJECT TO several well founded scientific and engineering
considerations

John T
 
You state Yes, it is, but they're professionals and they have techniques and processes to follow that keep them safe.

EXACTLY DITTO they know what they are doing and it was my experience when practicing in the field THEY ARE ONE OF THE MOST
SAFETY CONSCIOUS INDUSTRIES OUR THERE yayyyyyyyyyyyyyy for them. I doubt they place much in what any of us here may have to
say lol

John T
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top