Latest Wacky Cobbling: Combine Shed

DanielW

Well-known Member
Here's my latest hairbrained design: A steel-hoop shed. I bought an old Gleaner F for a couple hundred dollars last year, but didn't really have anywhere to store it. Our main shed is too full of more important equipment, and the pole-barn door is just a little too narrow for the header (which I don't want to take on and off all the time). Because I didn't have much invested in the combine and wasn't sure if I'd keep or scrap it, I just threw some old tarps over the critical areas last winter and backed it as far as I could get it into another shed to at least keep the engine covered.

But this summer I had a chance to use it, and it performed admirably. So I thought it worth getting a proper roof over it. I came up with this design, very roughly based off the old 'Nissen Huts'. For those not familiar with them, they were the sheds popularized by the British in WWI as quick, cheap shelters able to be built with no heavy equipment and using common/cheap/light components. They're the round buildings you see the RAF pilots scrambling out of in all those 'Battle of Britain' type movies. The US military later took the design and came up with the Quonset hut. I always liked the Nissen hut design myself: Not quite as strong as the Quonset, but still a solid design. And unlike a Quonset, you don't need continuous walls (I just used sono-tubes with embed plates on top to weld down to) and all parts are easily replaceable. Plus the designer (Peter Nissen - a major serving in the British army) was also a Canadian engineer. Admittedly he went to what's now the chief rival engineering school to mine. But I suppose I won't judge him too harshly, because my university didn't even exist back then.

I drew the parts up in CAD, had them cut on the plasma table at work, and whenever I had a few spare minutes I welded up another section. There were two knarly, lop-sided pines that had to come down to make room for it, and I was able to mill all the 2X6's I'll need for it from those trees. The little old Belsaw performed admirably. It's the smallest and chintziest of all my old sawmills, but it's the one I use most often because it's so easy for one person to use. I was off work with our new(ish) baby for a few weeks, and you can see my unconventional babysitting methods in a couple pics. Baby (and dog) loved napping outside and watching me work.

Had a couple hours free yesterday afternoon, so I started bolting together and putting up the arches. Only got three (of five) done, and even those not completely. But enough to (I think) prove that my guesstimates for sizing and steel strength work. Very happy with progress thus far, and happy that it'll be large enough to store a few other things that I usually have to leave out as well (backhoe, haybine, bale wrapper, etc.). Overall inside dimn's will be 20' x 40', and made so I can easily extend it in 10' sections in future.
1792759947280.png

1792760760943.png

1792759990259.png

1792760065511.png

1792760176362.png

1792760215288.png

1792760236552.png

1792760259749.png

1792760299552.png

1792760323863.png
 
Had another few free hours, so got the last arch and the remaining 2x6's up. Just have to weld in a couple pieces of cross-bracing and it'll be ready for tin. I really wish I made it longer. It would have been minimal extra effort to go one or two more arches to make it 10 or 20 feet longer, but oh well. Won't be too hard to extend even after the tin is on. A good project for next year.
IMG_20261027_155819.jpg

IMG_20261027_145438.jpg

IMG_20261027_155953.jpg
 
Last edited:
Had another few free hours, so got the last arch and the remaining 2x6's up. Just have to weld in a couple pieces of cross-bracing and it'll be ready for tin. I really wish I made it longer. It would have been minimal extra effort to go one or two more arches to make it 10 or 20 feet longer, but oh well. Won't be too hard to extend even after the tin is on. A good project for next year.
View attachment 168355
View attachment 168356
View attachment 168357
I like it. You are fortunate to have access to metal-making!
The shape should allow the wind to blow by, not take such a beating.
Good work!
 
I like it. You are fortunate to have access to metal-making!
The shape should allow the wind to blow by, not take such a beating.
Good work!
Thanks! The tin just arrived yesterday (about 3 weeks later than it was supposed to). All the bracing is in, so hoping to get it finished this weekend. I've been off work for several weeks and we've had superb weather. But of course the steel was delayed right up until now when I'm back at work full time. So instead of finishing it in the perfect weather we've had and when I had loads of time to do it, I'm back to only having a few hours between other farm jobs on weekends. And this weekend (when I hope to get all the roofing on) is supposed to be hovering around freezing temps with a mix of rain and snow. Should be fun to be clambering over a slick steel roof in those conditions...
 
I am interested to see what you are using for steel roofing? Must just be flat galvinized steel? Caulking at the overlap? Good luck and hope you have some help to get her done this weekend .
 
Thanks Tom. I'm using this profile of galvanized from Agway in Toronto. It's their cheapest profile and a pretty good price (though still not quite as cheap as the stuff from the Mennonites). Unfortunately I can't use the Mennonite stuff for this, because they only have the one profile option, and it's the standard/conventional profile with taller ribs. I needed something with the old-fashioned short ribs that would curve over the surface without kinking. I've used this profile on curved surfaces before and you can curve it to a surprisingly small radius before the ribs kink.

I may use a strip of butyl tape between the the overlapped ribs, but more likely I'll just not worry about it. A 3/8" rib is pretty low, but I think (/hope) it'll still be sufficient to prevent water backing up through. I'm willing to risk it for a crude shed I built on the cheap anyway.

The only thing I don't like about this profile is the 37" width. I hate installing steel roofing with sheets wider than about 34". With 34" or narrower, the sheets are narrow enough that I can stand on the strapping/purlins next to it and (barely) reach over to the far side to get the farthest screws in without needing to be on top of the steel. Anything wider and it's just a smidge too wide for my arm to reach that last rib. I'm half tempted to rent a manlift for the day to make it easier, but so far I've been too stubborn/cheap to go that route.
1794581175187.png
 
Last edited:
Got it finished between yesterday and this morning. Bit of a hack roofing job in some areas, but oh well. I learned a thing or two for next time I build one of these: Like most steel roofing companies, with this company if you go to a thinner gauge, the yield strength of the stock increases (often substantially). To get this tin on time, I had to go with the production run they were doing at the time, which was 26 gauge, 50 ksi yield-strength. The last time I used this profile I used the thicker (but weaker) 24 gauge, 30 ksi stuff. What a difference: Trying to get this higher-yield stuff to bend over the radius was like working with spring steel. Not too hard to bend, but certainly hard enough when working by yourself, having to be standing/leaning into it, keeping it aligned, and fastening all at once. I'd definitely opt for the thicker/weaker stuff next time I do a curved roof. Though knowing how much stronger the thinner stuff is, I think next time I do a flat roof I'll go with the thinner/stronger stuff. It certainly opened my eyes to the fact that thicker isn't always better/stronger.

I also changed my sheet length spec. before ordering: I was originally going to do the wrap in two pieces: One short piece covering about 1/3 or the wrap, one long piece covering the other 2/3. But I decided that handling 22' sheets would be too much of a pain by oneself, so I went with a three-piece setup: 13' sheets on each side, and a 12' sheet across the top. I wasn't anticipating how hard it would be to keep things aligned in this three-piece setup. I put the sides on first, and thought I was doing a pretty good job keeping them aligned & plumb with the opposite side. But if any piece was off even the tiniest smidge from plumb with the opposite side, the top sheet wouldn't mesh in the ribs at all. Once it was curved, there was zero ability to 'fudge' it side-to-side. As a result, the overlap between top and side sheets looks like a dog's breakfast (what I have circled). Not my proudest work.

Oh well. Now I know. It has a 12" overlap, and is steep enough that I don't think I have to worry about water/snow backing up or blowing under there. Not perfect, but I don't think $300 combine and the few other pieces of 60 year old equipment will care too much. Total bill for concrete, steel for the arches, hardware, tin, and welding supplies was almost exactly $5500 (CAD), which I'm still quite happy with.
1794834441266.png

1794834480796.png

1794834516471.png

1794834555228.png
 
Last edited:
Looks like a darn nice job to me. I have no idea how the heck you put that on by yourself. Could you add some more screws in the overlap to close up the gap?
 
Nice building, you did a great job, especially all by yourself. (y)👨‍🌾
Thanks. Not quite all by myself however: Dad showed up as I was working yesterday and that certainly sped things up. He's never been overly comfortable at heights, and a medication he's on now makes him a little shaky sometimes. So I wouldn't exactly ask him to be up there with one foot on a ladder, the other foot holding down a roof that's trying to spring you off, and both hands being used to align and screw the roofing down. But I was still very grateful to have a second hand - even if just to hand me up the impact driver every one of the (many) times it fell off my belt it still saves a lot of time and climbing.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top