FRAM is back at Walmart

Like anything when you have a low end line to meet a price point the entire brand name can suffer. FRAM has some good stuff but they also have some bad stuff.

I don’t trust wix since Mann bought them.

I’m using mobile 1 extended performance oil and filters on my gas cars with normal change intervals and the best Napa filter on my diesel tractor
Now the napa golds are made in Asia!
 
I’ve never had an engine fail from the oil filter. I think it’s more of a long term thing though. Either the filter doesn’t filter well or causes a restriction and over time your engine gets more wear because of it.
I would still put money on most engines fail due to neglect and whatever oil is in the crankcase and filter on the block gets the blame. For every brand oil and filter there are plenty of people out there to curse it and blame it for financial ruin that now has lasted for generations.
 
I’ve never had an engine fail from the oil filter. I think it’s more of a long term thing though. Either the filter doesn’t filter well or causes a restriction and over time your engine gets more wear because of it.

I am with you on that.
Regardless of what is on the oil cap. My gas vehicles all get 10W30 Rotella T5 engine oil. It contains more ZDDP than Mobile 1.

Mobile 1 = 890 ppm Zinc, 815 Phosphorus
Rotella T5 = 1450 Zinc, 1050 Phosphorus

I would almost be willing to bet that if a lot of Chevy truck owners ran Rotella T5 in those bad machined engines they have. Their engine would last a little longer. Zinc and phosphorus would go a long way in filling the gouges left in the engines.

If I want to go. I am going regardless of the price of gas. I would rather have an engine that will get me there and back than worry about saving 5 cents on a tank of fuel.

If you worry about the oil filter. Change it mid way between oil changes.
 
With all this discussion of filters. I’m just wondering if anyone has had an engine fail because of a bad filter?
Not an engine failure but the last 2 Mobil one filters I used worked loose.I always hand tightened my filters starting in the late 70’s after one time over tightening one.guess I need to use the filter wrench at least sparingly
 
Not an engine failure but the last 2 Mobil one filters I used worked loose.I always hand tightened my filters starting in the late 70’s after one time over tightening one.guess I need to use the filter wrench at least sparingly
Maybe your grip isn’t what it used to be? Or my main problem is you can’t get a good grip because of the filter location on modern vehicles.
I usually snug it a little more with a filter wrench.
 
Not an engine failure but the last 2 Mobil one filters I used worked loose.I always hand tightened my filters starting in the late 70’s after one time over tightening one.guess I need to use the filter wrench at least sparingly
The installation directions are on most all the filters I buy....gasket contacts + 3/4 turn. I have had a Generac home standby generator since 2014 and the only problem I had with it was the seam where the oil filter canister is connected to the base was leaking because, it was apparent to me when I removed it, that it was put on with a torque wrench set way too tight......at the factory.
 
For 30 years maybe more I apply grease to the seal and tighten up one full turn. I have performed thousands of oil filter replacements maybe I was before my time. I did have one leak the filter cracked around the base I am sure it was a manufacturing error. Putting motor oil on the seal acts like a lock and worst when you go a full turn that's why I switched to grease. I use to see plenty of other shops oil filter installs its scary to run across so many that felt like they got lucky it did not fall off. I will grantee that anyone that goes behind my installs will say give that man a metal he made sure it would not fall off : ) BTW I use oil filter cap wrenches made for filters I have no problem getting what I install off. Its those that are to cheap to invest in tools to perform the job that mess them up.


Have we been doing it wrong
 
For 30 years maybe more I apply grease to the seal and tighten up one full turn. I have performed thousands of oil filter replacements maybe I was before my time. I did have one leak the filter cracked around the base I am sure it was a manufacturing error. Putting motor oil on the seal acts like a lock and worst when you go a full turn that's why I switched to grease. I use to see plenty of other shops oil filter installs its scary to run across so many that felt like they got lucky it did not fall off. I will grantee that anyone that goes behind my installs will say give that man a metal he made sure it would not fall off : ) BTW I use oil filter cap wrenches made for filters I have no problem getting what I install off. Its those that are to cheap to invest in tools to perform the job that mess them up.


Have we been doing it wrong
Been changing oil and filters in vehicles and all kinds of machinery for 50 years.these 2 filters are the only ones I have ever had a problem with
 
Not an engine failure but the last 2 Mobil one filters I used worked loose.I always hand tightened my filters starting in the late 70’s after one time over tightening one.guess I need to use the filter wrench at least sparingly
I have that issue now as well. I’m not old compared to most on this forum but my muscles are getting very weak. I have a hard time opening the drain plug without an extendable ratchet.
 
Like anything when you have a low end line to meet a price point the entire brand name can suffer. FRAM has some good stuff but they also have some bad stuff.

I don’t trust wix since Mann bought them.

I’m using mobile 1 extended performance oil and filters on my gas cars with normal change intervals and the best Napa filter on my diesel tractor
I figure Mann is better than many. like so many things filters are also getting consolidated. Mann owns Purolator as well. (was Mann/Bosch joint venture) Mann makes alot of OE parts.

Have used Wix for years. and Napa when Wix used to make them

Just bought a filter for the IH 444 at the CaseIH dealer here. It was $18 with tax. Napa wanted about $25ish pre tax. made in Mexico.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top