Cleaning Starter Solenoid Contacts?

I have a Massey Ferguson 275 (Diesel) that has developed a habit of just clicking the first time I turn the switch, then cranking and firing the second time. It still starts fine, but I'd like to fix this. I have checked battery and cable connections and they seem fine. I'd rather not just throw a new starter on it, and suspect it's the starter solenoid rather than the starter motor itself causing this. Just curious if anyone has tried disassembling the solenoid and cleaning the contacts inside, on a similar solenoid?

Picture of starter for reference:

1795004196278.png
 
I have a Massey Ferguson 275 (Diesel) that has developed a habit of just clicking the first time I turn the switch, then cranking and firing the second time. It still starts fine, but I'd like to fix this. I have checked battery and cable connections and they seem fine. I'd rather not just throw a new starter on it, and suspect it's the starter solenoid rather than the starter motor itself causing this. Just curious if anyone has tried disassembling the solenoid and cleaning the contacts inside, on a similar solenoid?

Picture of starter for reference:

View attachment 169868
That looks like a Lucas Starter. I think some of those solenoids had the cap held by the case being rolled around the cap to hold them on. You might not be able to get the cap with the terminals off that type as you can the Delco starter solenoids. The type in your picture would be a replace the solenoid type, unless the cap is held on with screws. The Delco type has screws holding the cap on. A picture looking at the terminal end of the cap of your starter solenoid would be more useful.

With the tractor in neutral, will it crank the first time if you jump between the battery post of the solenoid and the start terminal? If so that would indicate a high resistance leading to low current to the solenoid, somewhere in the start circuit (start switch, neutral switch, wires or connections).
 
I doubt lightening will strike twice in the same place, but my Oliver 1365 was doing the same thing. The exiter wire on the solenoid coming from the switch was loose.
 
I've taken apart and cleaned the contacts on a couple of solenoids. Not sure I'd bother to again, because usually when they start to get suspect the starter itself is usually not far behind, and these days aftermarket starters are surprisingly cheap and reliable. But it's certainly doable in some cases. Depends on how the solenoid is fastened together and what it uses for insulation between plunger, windings, and housing.

The ones that have a peened/swaged lip can't really be taken apart without cutting. But the ones held together with long rivets or bolts are doable: If it uses rivets, you can replace them with long machine screws. If that's a picture of your exact starter then it's easy as it's held together with studs/bolts. But it looks like that pic may be taken off the interwebs? If so, it may not be the same as yours. You may find that your old one was rivetted/swaged, while the new ones are bolted.

When they come apart, take a look at what they use to insulate the plunger from windings, and the windings from the housing. The plunger usually slides inside the magnet windings inside a plastic/silicone-like tube to prevent contact with the windings. And sometimes the same material insulates the windings from the solenoid housing. But much older ones use a kind of heavy, waxy resin paper as insulation in one or both spots. Hopefully yours is the plastic/silicone type, as they usually come apart and go back together easy. I have cleaned up a couple of the old paper type, but with that older waxy/resin paper style, the paper stuff is often dry/cracked and falls apart when you open it up, and then you can't reasonably get it back together without some short in the insulation.

So it's definitely doable in some cases, but not all cases. Not going to hurt to try, unless you find you can't get it back together and need the tractor asap. Is yours the type of starter where the solenoid also shifts the gear forward in the nose cone? Looks like it might be if that's an accurate picture? Or is yours the simpler/more conventional style where centrifugal force alone kicks the gear out on its meaty threads. I hate the style where the solenoid plunger also shifts the gear in the cone: You can't bypass/short that style to start it when you're in a bind. With the simpler centrifugal spin-out type, you can always (carefully) short across the primary contacts to see if it is indeed the solenoid that's the problem. And if really in a bind, you can always bypass the solenoid on those types with one of the old, round, high-amp push-button starter buttons and some heavy gauge cables - like all the older tractors had before they used solenoids.
 
Thanks for the replies, gentlemen! I think this one will come apart by taking the nuts off the through-bolts, but have not tried it yet. I’ll also try jumping the start terminal directly from the battery power terminal and see if that makes a difference; I’ve not done that yet.

And fortunately, solenoids or even starters are not too expensive. I just wondered if it was worth trying to fix instead of replace. Thanks again!!
 
I've taken apart and cleaned the contacts on a couple of solenoids. not sure I'd bother to again, because usually when they start to get suspect the starter itself is usually not far behind, and these days aftermarket starters are surprisingly cheap and reliable. But it's certainly doable in some cases. Depends on how the solenoid is fastened together and what it uses for insulation between plunger, windings, and housing.

The ones that have a peened/swaged lip can't really be taken apart without cutting. But the ones held together with long rivets or bolts are doable: If it uses rivets, you can replace them with long machine screws. If that's a picture of your exact starter then it's easy as it's held together with studs/bolts. But it looks like that pic may be taken off the interwebs? If so, it may not be the same as yours. You may find that your old one was rivetted/swaged, while the new ones are bolted.

When they come apart, take a look at what they use to insulate the plunger from windings, and the windings from the housing. The plunger usually slides inside the magnet windings inside a plastic/silicone-like tube to prevent contact with the windings. And sometimes the same material insulates the windings from the solenoid housing. But much older ones use a kind of heavy, waxy resin paper as insulation in one or both spots. Hopefully yours is the plastic/silicone type, as they usually come apart and go back together easy. I have cleaned up a couple of the old paper type, but with that older waxy/resin paper style, the paper stuff is often dry/cracked and falls apart when you open it up, and then you can't reasonably get it back together without some short in the insulation.

So it's definitely doable in some cases, but not all cases. Not going to hurt to try, unless you find you can't get it back together and need the tractor asap. Is yours the type of starter where the solenoid also shifts the gear forward in the nose cone? Looks like it might be if that's an accurate picture? Or is yours the simpler/more conventional style where centrifugal force alone kicks the gear out on its meaty threads. I hate the style where the solenoid plunger also shifts the gear in the cone: You can't bypass/short that style to start it when you're in a bind. With the simpler centrifugal spin-out type, you can always (carefully) short across the primary contacts to see if it is indeed the solenoid that's the problem. And if really in a bind, you can always bypass the solenoid on those types with one of the old, round, high-amp push-button starter buttons and some heavy gauge cables - like all the older tractors had before they used solenoids.
MF 275 used starters with the mounted solenoid that pulls the lever pushing the drive out into the ring gear, similar to the starter in his picture. His starter needs a mounted solenoid to engage the drive, a remote mounted "Ford" type relay will not replace the solenoid on his starter.
 
Suggest you get some numbers with VOM . What is it when you first start (click) and when it starts.
Video will help.
I’ve had cable that look fine and weren’t.
With starting battery the circuit is heating up to make your connection.
 
I have a Massey Ferguson 275 (Diesel) that has developed a habit of just clicking the first time I turn the switch, then cranking and firing the second time. It still starts fine, but I'd like to fix this. I have checked battery and cable connections and they seem fine. I'd rather not just throw a new starter on it, and suspect it's the starter solenoid rather than the starter motor itself causing this. Just curious if anyone has tried disassembling the solenoid and cleaning the contacts inside, on a similar solenoid?

Picture of starter for reference:

View attachment 169868
I've only worked on Ford independent of the starter type solenoids. On those I drill out the rivets, flip the 3/8" studs around to the unused other side and remove the disc and turn it over giving me totally new contact areas. I have a couple of tractors needing solenoid attention so I'll be back in there. One is on a CIH and is integrated like the one in your picture. Will be a new experience.

On the less complicated side, removing all the terminals associated with the starting circuit...control and high current, shining up all the contact surfaces and reassembling properly can make a huge difference in starting performance.....its not necessarily inside the solenoid where the problem is located. BTDT numerous times with multiple tractors to keep tabs on. Most tractors ground the battery and the case of the starter to the engine frame....That is different metals in contact with each other, and with current flowing through them, corrosion is present and inhibits good current flow resulting in problems starting. Take them apart, shine them up, squirt a little oil on them and secure properly.
 
MF 275 used starters with the mounted solenoid that pulls the lever pushing the drive out into the ring gear, similar to the starter in his picture. His starter needs a mounted solenoid to engage the drive, a remote mounted "Ford" type relay will not replace the solenoid on his starter.
Ah, fair enough. Never really liked that style, but still rebuildable in the same manner. I have an old Allis 7045 with that type of starter that had a bad solenoid since I got it. I got that tractor for scrap price (quite literally), with a bad hydraulic system. To start it with that bad solenoid when I didn't want to put any money into it until I got the hydraulics fixed, I ran some welding cable from the battery to the starter through one of those old-school high-amp ignition buttons (like the picture below) and put a piece of baler twine around where the solenoid sucked in the fork to engage the bendix. To start it, you'd hit the button and put some tension on the twine at the same time to spin the starter and engage the nose-cone simultaneously.

Did that as a quick/dirty fix just to allow me to start it temporarily, figuring I'd fix it properly as soon as I got the hydraulics fixed. Two years and all I've done is upgrade my pull rope from sisal to plastic twine (though I did fix the hydraulics). Rather embarrassing if anyone saw it, but I don't really need/use that tractor for much at all.

1795026948297.png
 
If the solenoid is like a lot of GM starters. The contacts wear down over time until they can no longer make good contact with the disc. They can be turned 180 degrees or simply replaced. On a tractor. I would replace them with a new solenoid or contacts.
 
Any solenoid I've had was riveted together. That would be too much trouble to me to take apart and put back together, especially fighting a spring.
A lot of GM type solenoids held together with two screws. Just remove the screws and they will come apart easily. The spring holds the disc away from the contacts until the electromagnet over powers it and allows the disc to make contact. Most can be done easily without removing the starter From the vehicle.
 
A lot of GM type solenoids held together with two screws. Just remove the screws and they will come apart easily. The spring holds the disc away from the contacts until the electromagnet over powers it and allows the disc to make contact. Most can be done easily without removing the starter From the vehicle.
I don't think a Delco type or Ford type has much bearing on his solenoid, I believe his MF 275 has a Lucas starter, based on the picture he posted and the parts book. Some Lucas caps were crimped on, and some weren't, he will need to see which he has if he wants to try cleaning the contacts.
 
Thanks, everyone, I appreciate the replies! I haven't had time to work on it yet, but it is indeed a Lucas-type, and I think it will come apart without uncrimping, just by the looks of it. When I get time to tinker with it I'll let you know. Good idea to do the voltage drop test; I'll give that a try too.

Thanks again!
 
Any solenoid I've had was riveted together. That would be too much trouble to me to take apart and put back together, especially fighting a spring.
That's not a problem....all my Ford recoveries were plastic bodied riveted together...just drill them out and when finished put a bolt and lock nut where the rivet was located.
 
Lucas used to supply replacement solenoid contacts for some starter motors. Lucas master parts catalogue will show if you have starter type and model number.
SadFarmall
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top