Bargaining for a Junker

RedMF40

Not from Iceland!
I bought a tractor yesterday, pretty much the twin to my Massey Ferguson 40. Except that this one is badged both 40 and 50. Ok, I’m sure I’ll get it straightened out. Haven’t actually looked at the ID plate yet. Just looked and the sheetmetal says 50, the ID plate on the tractor says F40. Same as my tractor. I’ll go with 40.

Even though this sounds like a lateral move, it’s a bit of an upgrade for me. The engine sounds strong and looks tight. And it has some kind of loader that works. The main issue—among other things—with my tractor is a rear main seal leak so bad you may as well pour the oil on the ground when topping it off.

I drove 80 miles to see the replacement Massey. I knew pretty much what to expect: A junker that needs a lot of work. In that respect I wasn’t disappointed. All hydraulic hoses need replacing, and it looks like they grabbed whatever they could off a scrap machine to replace the ones on the tractor. Some were almost as long as your garden hose. Some weeping around the hydraulic cylinders as well. Rubber so-so all around, but I saw that in the photos. Power steering works well and the brakes are strong and quiet—a serious shortcoming on my tractor. Sheetmetal is mostly intact, not all bashed in and pretty rust-free. Aside from faded paint, it looks ok.

Asking price at the Mennonite Kubota dealer where they took it in as a trade: $2800. Once I saw the tractor, I knew instantly they had almost no money in it. If they gave the Kubota buyer any kind of credit I’d be surprised. I talked things over with my contact James, a nice enough guy. Very affable and helpful, really didn’t care one way or the other if I bought this old heap.

“$1500,” I told him, knowing he wouldn’t go for it.

“Naw naw, I’ll let it sit for that.” He thought for a moment, or pretended to. “Best I can do is $2250.”

No way I was going to part with over two grand for this thing.

“$1800,” I told him. “Best I can do. And I’m reluctant to even offer that.”

The two of us knew the score: He knew that I knew the dealer had very little if anything invested in this machine. He could sell it at any price and still make a few bucks.

I even told him, once I saw it, that he couldn’t have given much for the trade-in. He laughed, and didn’t disagree.

“I guess I can do $2,000,” he said.

Still too much.

“Well, that’s that. It was a nice drive up here.”

I headed for my truck. It actually was a very pretty drive, and I’d taken almost all back roads. The additional $200 wasn’t going to lead to my financial ruin—it was just the principle. In reality, my initial offer of $1500 was closer to the tractor’s value. At auction, which is where it was probably headed, the price might have gotten bumped up to $1800.

“I guess I can do $1800,” he said as I was climbing into my truck. I have heard this about bargaining with this community: Be prepared to walk away. Apparently it’s true; and it’s not like it was a conscious effort on my part—I just didn’t want the tractor that badly.

I can’t say this was a spectacularly good deal. I do think with a little work it’ll be a good tractor—and what I paid was about what a new middle-of-the road riding mower costs new these days. Maybe less. And I can’t skid trees with a riding mower or hook up three-point attachments and run them off the PTO. And it’s a classic-looking old tractor. And if I sell my old Massey as-is which runs and works and has myriad problems, I may almost break even. Obviously, I’m still trying to convince myself that I made out ok. Time will tell.
 
At least you got to have a good haggle. Last vehicle I bought it took three weeks to get to a number I was relatively comfortable with. Like you still more than I wanted to spend. It really was mentally exhausting.
 
Are you talking about a regular 40 or a MF40 industrial?
I have the industrial model, I don’t know anything about the regular 40 model.
 
You probably did alright, at least everything’s working on it and good brakes. That’s better than the bucket truck
Haha, good point. It's hilly around my place and the brakes are a problem on my tractor. Also, the little tab and teeth that act as the parking brake are broken off so I have to shut down and put it in gear when stopping on hills. All of that is in good shape on the "new" Massey.
 
At least you got to have a good haggle. Last vehicle I bought it took three weeks to get to a number I was relatively comfortable with. Like you still more than I wanted to spend. It really was mentally exhausting.
I didn't mention it but it was like he was pulling numbers out of the air. We were both more or less comfortable with where we ended up and no one took anything personally. He was pleasant to deal with. I'm sure the guy who listed it online got less of a commission than he was hoping for but oh well.
 
Are you talking about a regular 40 or a MF40 industrial?
I have the industrial model, I don’t know anything about the regular 40 model.
The base F40 is a Ferguson Ag tractor. Some were Massey Ferguson F40. Massey Harris called it a MH 50. The model was right in the combined Massey - Harris - Ferguson time frame.
 
Are you talking about a regular 40 or a MF40 industrial?
I have the industrial model, I don’t know anything about the regular 40 model.
I have the regular--or rather I have two of them now. My first real farm tractor and I'm a believer in the Z134 Continental engine. It is nearly indestructible. I ran the new Massey this afternoon, topped off the antifreeze and checked for leaks all over. Ran it at idle for about fifteen minutes and so far so good. Engine oil is steady at the full mark, will change it and the hydraulic fluid which is milky.

What engine does the Industrial model have?
 
You're right, he probably was pulling numbers out of a hat trying to gauge your seriousness. Most dealers won't give anything over scrap for old tractors. They just don't want them in inventory. Even transporting them anywhere after trade eats up profit margin. I'd imagine they probably gave $3-400 for the tractor on trade, max.
 
You're right, he probably was pulling numbers out of a hat trying to gauge your seriousness. Most dealers won't give anything over scrap for old tractors. They just don't want them in inventory. Even transporting them anywhere after trade eats up profit margin. I'd imagine they probably gave $3-400 for the tractor on trade, max.
That sounds about right.
 
I bought a tractor yesterday, pretty much the twin to my Massey Ferguson 40. Except that this one is badged both 40 and 50. Ok, I’m sure I’ll get it straightened out. Haven’t actually looked at the ID plate yet. Just looked and the sheetmetal says 50, the ID plate on the tractor says F40. Same as my tractor. I’ll go with 40.

Even though this sounds like a lateral move, it’s a bit of an upgrade for me. The engine sounds strong and looks tight. And it has some kind of loader that works. The main issue—among other things—with my tractor is a rear main seal leak so bad you may as well pour the oil on the ground when topping it off.

I drove 80 miles to see the replacement Massey. I knew pretty much what to expect: A junker that needs a lot of work. In that respect I wasn’t disappointed. All hydraulic hoses need replacing, and it looks like they grabbed whatever they could off a scrap machine to replace the ones on the tractor. Some were almost as long as your garden hose. Some weeping around the hydraulic cylinders as well. Rubber so-so all around, but I saw that in the photos. Power steering works well and the brakes are strong and quiet—a serious shortcoming on my tractor. Sheetmetal is mostly intact, not all bashed in and pretty rust-free. Aside from faded paint, it looks ok.

Asking price at the Mennonite Kubota dealer where they took it in as a trade: $2800. Once I saw the tractor, I knew instantly they had almost no money in it. If they gave the Kubota buyer any kind of credit I’d be surprised. I talked things over with my contact James, a nice enough guy. Very affable and helpful, really didn’t care one way or the other if I bought this old heap.

“$1500,” I told him, knowing he wouldn’t go for it.

“Naw naw, I’ll let it sit for that.” He thought for a moment, or pretended to. “Best I can do is $2250.”

No way I was going to part with over two grand for this thing.

“$1800,” I told him. “Best I can do. And I’m reluctant to even offer that.”

The two of us knew the score: He knew that I knew the dealer had very little if anything invested in this machine. He could sell it at any price and still make a few bucks.

I even told him, once I saw it, that he couldn’t have given much for the trade-in. He laughed, and didn’t disagree.

“I guess I can do $2,000,” he said.

Still too much.

“Well, that’s that. It was a nice drive up here.”

I headed for my truck. It actually was a very pretty drive, and I’d taken almost all back roads. The additional $200 wasn’t going to lead to my financial ruin—it was just the principle. In reality, my initial offer of $1500 was closer to the tractor’s value. At auction, which is where it was probably headed, the price might have gotten bumped up to $1800.

“I guess I can do $1800,” he said as I was climbing into my truck. I have heard this about bargaining with this community: Be prepared to walk away. Apparently it’s true; and it’s not like it was a conscious effort on my part—I just didn’t want the tractor that badly.

I can’t say this was a spectacularly good deal. I do think with a little work it’ll be a good tractor—and what I paid was about what a new middle-of-the road riding mower costs new these days. Maybe less. And I can’t skid trees with a riding mower or hook up three-point attachments and run them off the PTO. And it’s a classic-looking old tractor. And if I sell my old Massey as-is which runs and works and has myriad problems, I may almost break even. Obviously, I’m still trying to convince myself that I made out ok. Time will tell.
I don't know the tractor so looked it up on Gemini.
It gave me this:


Mf 40 tractor specs

The Massey Ferguson MF 40 is an industrial utility tractor produced from 1969 to 1975 (sharing its core powertrain with the agricultural MF 135). It was commonly configured as a tractor-loader or tractor-loader-backhoe (TLB).

Engine
Options:

Diesel: Perkins AD3.152 — 2.5L (152.7 cu in), 3-cylinder, liquid-cooled
Tractor Data

Gasoline: Perkins AG3.152 — 2.5L (152.7 cu in), 3-cylinder, liquid-cooled

Gross / Flywheel Power: 42 hp @ 2,000 RPM (some manual specs rate up to 45 hp)
Tractor Data

PTO Power: ~38 hp (live 540 RPM @ 1,500 engine RPM on manual shuttle models)

Max Torque: 120 lb-ft @ 1,200 RPM (diesel)

Electrical System: 12-volt negative ground with alternator
Tractorparts.com

Drivetrain & Mechanical
Drive: 2WD with heavy-duty industrial front axle and planetary rear drive axle

Transmission Options:

6-Speed Manual Shuttle: 6 forward / 6 reverse (3-speed sliding gear with planetary high/low and mechanical shuttle)

4-Speed Instant Reverse: 4 forward / 4 reverse with torque converter and foot-operated directional pedals

Steering: Hydrostatic power steering

Brakes: Dual mechanical dry disc brakes with parking latch
Tractorparts.com

Differential Lock: Hand- or foot-operated mechanical rear lock

Hydraulics & PTO
Tractor Internal Hydraulics: Open-center system (for 3-point hitch, if equipped)

Loader / Backhoe Pump: Front crankshaft-driven gear pump

Flow: 20 GPM @ 2,000 RPM
Tractorparts.com

System Pressure: 2,125 PSI (loader) / up to 2,500 PSI (backhoe circuit)
Tractorparts.com

3-Point Hitch: Optional Category I (often omitted on dedicated backhoe units)

PTO: Live 540 RPM (manual shuttle models only; not available with Instant Reverse)
Tractorparts.com

Dimensions, Weight & Tires
Base Tractor Weight: ~3,700 – 4,260 lbs (bare tractor, varies by transmission)
Jensales

Loader-Tractor Weight: ~5,085 lbs (without backhoe)

Wheelbase: 77" – 84" (varies slightly by front axle setup)
Jensales

Overall Width: ~75" – 77.5"
Tractor Data

Height (to steering wheel): ~55.5" – 58"
Tractor Data

Ground Clearance: 12" – 15"

Standard Tires:

Front: 7.50-16 (6- or 8-ply industrial)
Jensales

Rear: 14.9-24 (6-ply R4 industrial)
Tractorparts.com

Fluid Capacities
Fuel Tank: 10.7 gal
Tractor Data

Engine Oil: 6 qts (including filter)

Cooling System: 10 qts
Tractor Data

Transmission / Rear Axle: 8 gal (shared sump)

Torque Converter (Instant Reverse): 13 qts

Power Steering Reservoir: 1.6 – 1.7 qts

Loader Hydraulic Reservoir: 6 gal (frame-mounted tank)
Tractorparts.com

Common Attachments
Loaders: MF 32 (2,500 lbs full-height lift, 4,000 lbs breakout) or MF 34 (self-leveling, ~2,500–3,000 lbs lift)
Tractorparts.com

Backhoes: MF 52 or MF 54 (~10' to 12' digging depth)

(Note: If you meant the later MF 40B [1976–1981] or the older Ferguson F40 farm tractor [1956–1957], let me know—those are distinct machines with different specs.)"


Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

I'm thinking you can't buy an 8N Ford for that and it is WAY more tractor than an N - or a Jubilee - or even a 600.
So I think you did good.







Searching the web
 
I don't know the tractor so looked it up on Gemini.
It gave me this:


Mf 40 tractor specs

The Massey Ferguson MF 40 is an industrial utility tractor produced from 1969 to 1975 (sharing its core powertrain with the agricultural MF 135). It was commonly configured as a tractor-loader or tractor-loader-backhoe (TLB).

Engine
Options:

Diesel: Perkins AD3.152 — 2.5L (152.7 cu in), 3-cylinder, liquid-cooled
Tractor Data

Gasoline: Perkins AG3.152 — 2.5L (152.7 cu in), 3-cylinder, liquid-cooled

Gross / Flywheel Power: 42 hp @ 2,000 RPM (some manual specs rate up to 45 hp)
Tractor Data

PTO Power: ~38 hp (live 540 RPM @ 1,500 engine RPM on manual shuttle models)

Max Torque: 120 lb-ft @ 1,200 RPM (diesel)

Electrical System: 12-volt negative ground with alternator
Tractorparts.com

Drivetrain & Mechanical
Drive: 2WD with heavy-duty industrial front axle and planetary rear drive axle

Transmission Options:

6-Speed Manual Shuttle: 6 forward / 6 reverse (3-speed sliding gear with planetary high/low and mechanical shuttle)

4-Speed Instant Reverse: 4 forward / 4 reverse with torque converter and foot-operated directional pedals

Steering: Hydrostatic power steering

Brakes: Dual mechanical dry disc brakes with parking latch
Tractorparts.com

Differential Lock: Hand- or foot-operated mechanical rear lock

Hydraulics & PTO
Tractor Internal Hydraulics: Open-center system (for 3-point hitch, if equipped)

Loader / Backhoe Pump: Front crankshaft-driven gear pump

Flow: 20 GPM @ 2,000 RPM
Tractorparts.com

System Pressure: 2,125 PSI (loader) / up to 2,500 PSI (backhoe circuit)
Tractorparts.com

3-Point Hitch: Optional Category I (often omitted on dedicated backhoe units)

PTO: Live 540 RPM (manual shuttle models only; not available with Instant Reverse)
Tractorparts.com

Dimensions, Weight & Tires
Base Tractor Weight: ~3,700 – 4,260 lbs (bare tractor, varies by transmission)
Jensales

Loader-Tractor Weight: ~5,085 lbs (without backhoe)

Wheelbase: 77" – 84" (varies slightly by front axle setup)
Jensales

Overall Width: ~75" – 77.5"
Tractor Data

Height (to steering wheel): ~55.5" – 58"
Tractor Data

Ground Clearance: 12" – 15"

Standard Tires:

Front: 7.50-16 (6- or 8-ply industrial)
Jensales

Rear: 14.9-24 (6-ply R4 industrial)
Tractorparts.com

Fluid Capacities
Fuel Tank: 10.7 gal
Tractor Data

Engine Oil: 6 qts (including filter)

Cooling System: 10 qts
Tractor Data

Transmission / Rear Axle: 8 gal (shared sump)

Torque Converter (Instant Reverse): 13 qts

Power Steering Reservoir: 1.6 – 1.7 qts

Loader Hydraulic Reservoir: 6 gal (frame-mounted tank)
Tractorparts.com

Common Attachments
Loaders: MF 32 (2,500 lbs full-height lift, 4,000 lbs breakout) or MF 34 (self-leveling, ~2,500–3,000 lbs lift)
Tractorparts.com

Backhoes: MF 52 or MF 54 (~10' to 12' digging depth)

(Note: If you meant the later MF 40B [1976–1981] or the older Ferguson F40 farm tractor [1956–1957], let me know—those are distinct machines with different specs.)"


Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

I'm thinking you can't buy an 8N Ford for that and it is WAY more tractor than an N - or a Jubilee - or even a 600.
So I think you did good.







Searching the web
Thanks, I guess Gemini doesn’t like older tractors. Mine is mid-50s, probably 55-57, never checked exact date. Engine is the bulletproof Continental Z134 gasser four cylinder with six speed hi-lo tranny (3 and reverse in each range) and set up with a loader (Ford on mine and Kelley on the new arrival). Power steering on both tractors.

In all fairness, I hardly ever see any turn up at tractor shows and that Continental engine is getting more rare and something that people are looking for. I think it was a pretty popular tractor in its day, wonder where they all went?

(Exact model, from the data plate: F-40) I think there’s a bit of confusion about what these tractors are actually called.
 
I don't know the tractor so looked it up on Gemini.
It gave me this:


Mf 40 tractor specs

The Massey Ferguson MF 40 is an industrial utility tractor produced from 1969 to 1975 (sharing its core powertrain with the agricultural MF 135). It was commonly configured as a tractor-loader or tractor-loader-backhoe (TLB).

Engine
Options:

Diesel: Perkins AD3.152 — 2.5L (152.7 cu in), 3-cylinder, liquid-cooled
Tractor Data

Gasoline: Perkins AG3.152 — 2.5L (152.7 cu in), 3-cylinder, liquid-cooled

Gross / Flywheel Power: 42 hp @ 2,000 RPM (some manual specs rate up to 45 hp)
Tractor Data

PTO Power: ~38 hp (live 540 RPM @ 1,500 engine RPM on manual shuttle models)

Max Torque: 120 lb-ft @ 1,200 RPM (diesel)

Electrical System: 12-volt negative ground with alternator
Tractorparts.com

Drivetrain & Mechanical
Drive: 2WD with heavy-duty industrial front axle and planetary rear drive axle

Transmission Options:

6-Speed Manual Shuttle: 6 forward / 6 reverse (3-speed sliding gear with planetary high/low and mechanical shuttle)

4-Speed Instant Reverse: 4 forward / 4 reverse with torque converter and foot-operated directional pedals

Steering: Hydrostatic power steering

Brakes: Dual mechanical dry disc brakes with parking latch
Tractorparts.com

Differential Lock: Hand- or foot-operated mechanical rear lock

Hydraulics & PTO
Tractor Internal Hydraulics: Open-center system (for 3-point hitch, if equipped)

Loader / Backhoe Pump: Front crankshaft-driven gear pump

Flow: 20 GPM @ 2,000 RPM
Tractorparts.com

System Pressure: 2,125 PSI (loader) / up to 2,500 PSI (backhoe circuit)
Tractorparts.com

3-Point Hitch: Optional Category I (often omitted on dedicated backhoe units)

PTO: Live 540 RPM (manual shuttle models only; not available with Instant Reverse)
Tractorparts.com

Dimensions, Weight & Tires
Base Tractor Weight: ~3,700 – 4,260 lbs (bare tractor, varies by transmission)
Jensales

Loader-Tractor Weight: ~5,085 lbs (without backhoe)

Wheelbase: 77" – 84" (varies slightly by front axle setup)
Jensales

Overall Width: ~75" – 77.5"
Tractor Data

Height (to steering wheel): ~55.5" – 58"
Tractor Data

Ground Clearance: 12" – 15"

Standard Tires:

Front: 7.50-16 (6- or 8-ply industrial)
Jensales

Rear: 14.9-24 (6-ply R4 industrial)
Tractorparts.com

Fluid Capacities
Fuel Tank: 10.7 gal
Tractor Data

Engine Oil: 6 qts (including filter)

Cooling System: 10 qts
Tractor Data

Transmission / Rear Axle: 8 gal (shared sump)

Torque Converter (Instant Reverse): 13 qts

Power Steering Reservoir: 1.6 – 1.7 qts

Loader Hydraulic Reservoir: 6 gal (frame-mounted tank)
Tractorparts.com

Common Attachments
Loaders: MF 32 (2,500 lbs full-height lift, 4,000 lbs breakout) or MF 34 (self-leveling, ~2,500–3,000 lbs lift)
Tractorparts.com

Backhoes: MF 52 or MF 54 (~10' to 12' digging depth)

(Note: If you meant the later MF 40B [1976–1981] or the older Ferguson F40 farm tractor [1956–1957], let me know—those are distinct machines with different specs.)"


Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.

I'm thinking you can't buy an 8N Ford for that and it is WAY more tractor than an N - or a Jubilee - or even a 600.
So I think you did good.







Searching the web
The F40 was a Ferguson. Some were labelled MH 50. Some may have been labelled as a MF 40, but these are agricultural models not the industrial you got info on. Look up a Ferguson F40.

It would be interesting to see pictures of the tractor in question and its complete serial number tag.
 
The F40 was a Ferguson. Some were labelled MH 50. Some may have been labelled as a MF 40, but these are agricultural models not the industrial you got info on. Look up a Ferguson F40.

It would be interesting to see pictures of the tractor in question and its complete serial number tag.
I’ll take some pics tomorrow.
 
I'm thinking you can't buy an 8N Ford for that and it is WAY more tractor than an N - or a Jubilee - or even a 600.
I'd rather have the loader and the power steering. My 8N came off an estate auction and it's been a good machine. But you're steering it by hand, and the three-point won't lift with the clutch pushed in. An 8N at that price probably needs some work too.

The rear main would worry me. That's a split, and I'd be paying somebody for that one.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top