Steve in VA

Well-known Member
I'm in the earliest stages of thinking about, considering, trying application of biochar to a test area in my orchard grass. There is a small area that has very "thin" soil but all analysis report normal levels of everything they test. There is a pretty big biochar facility about 90 min away in Floyd so not a big hurdle to get.

So, any experience with it? If you did, we're the results what you hoped for?

TIA
 
I'm in the earliest stages of thinking about, considering, trying application of biochar to a test area in my orchard grass. There is a small area that has very "thin" soil but all analysis report normal levels of everything they test. There is a pretty big biochar facility about 90 min away in Floyd so not a big hurdle to get.

So, any experience with it? If you did, we're the results what you hoped for?

TIA
Steve, our youngest son and a friend of his, who lives in Panama about half the time, did some biochar many years ago on a small scale.
The friend was going to try to get some folks in Panama to try it for there gardens.
Never heard anymore about the project.
 
My wife buys it from a commercial supplier for the garden. I have tried producing some myself having operated an OWB for over twenty years to heat our home. At the end of each heating season I end up with a large pile of wood ash and have tried using it in various ways. What I have noticed is that pile of wood ash has a considerable amount of charred bits of wood (charcoal), that is what you want. I have made a screen to separate that charcoal. Remember you are building the soil microbiome not applying high concentrations of commercial NPK.
 
It seems it would be a very slow soil build, offer you something a decade from now as it breaks down and builds a bit of top soil over time. A wonderful goal but one that is difficult to afford or see through as you need something working next spring for your crop, not sit around for years waiting for the soil to balance itself?

In a big picture. Also if you have thin soil, you need to change the whole process of saving your top soil to ever build it up. Tillage and regular fertility and all that needs to match.

For a hobby half acre, it’s a fun experiment. Seems most folk that start the experiment move on to something else before they actually get there. As a farmer I appreciate the goal, but I have to snicker a bit at the heavy promoters of this as something ultra green and natural. It’s plundering woodlands to feed your crop land. Fine, but we would have to clear cut the whole country to get enough char to replace the regular fertilizer. I’m not knocking it, just don’t think it’s some sort of magic perfect farming method either.

A good spreader full of manure solids would be my preferred option to get somewhere….. probably can do both manure and the char and get somewhere faster, but that takes a lot of management to make it all work. Balance the N with the fiber breakdown and all that.

Love to hear how it goes for you in the future, I’m not as negative as I sound about it. I love to see results of new ideas, or very old ideas recycled into new ideas. :)


Paul
 
It seems it would be a very slow soil build, offer you something a decade from now as it breaks down and builds a bit of top soil over time. A wonderful goal but one that is difficult to afford or see through as you need something working next spring for your crop, not sit around for years waiting for the soil to balance itself?

In a big picture. Also if you have thin soil, you need to change the whole process of saving your top soil to ever build it up. Tillage and regular fertility and all that needs to match.

For a hobby half acre, it’s a fun experiment. Seems most folk that start the experiment move on to something else before they actually get there. As a farmer I appreciate the goal, but I have to snicker a bit at the heavy promoters of this as something ultra green and natural. It’s plundering woodlands to feed your crop land. Fine, but we would have to clear cut the whole country to get enough char to replace the regular fertilizer. I’m not knocking it, just don’t think it’s some sort of magic perfect farming method either.

A good spreader full of manure solids would be my preferred option to get somewhere….. probably can do both manure and the char and get somewhere faster, but that takes a lot of management to make it all work. Balance the N with the fiber breakdown and all that.

Love to hear how it goes for you in the future, I’m not as negative as I sound about it. I love to see results of new ideas, or very old ideas recycled into new ideas. :)


Paul
If I go with it, I'll definitely provide follow up. Your points are well founded and I appreciate the feedback.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top