Cab or not ... what do you think?

Anonymous-0

Well-known Member
Looking at getting a newish tractor in the 50 hp range, probably Kubota, for a small beef farm and woodlot. Never had a cab on aa tractor before, but I'm wondering if it would be a good idea or not. Somedays I think the tractor would last longer, but other days I think I would just destroy it in the woods.

I only put about 200 hours a year on it, so its certainly not critical. Be nice in the winter, but probably just a pain in the summer.

What are your opinions? Location is eastern Canada.
 
For plowing in fall 12 hours a day - sure gld I have a cab on that tractor.

For planting corn in spring - just boought a Ford 5000 to use without a cab, because I hated planting through the cab on the 7700.

Depends what you do. Cabs get real hot in summer, an A/C sucks up a lot of power, and the visibility & ease of getting on & off are much better without the cab.

If it rains, or cold wind, or long hours, a cab is sure appreciated.

Myself I would not want a cab on that size tractor for what looks like short jobs around obsticales.

But that's my preference. You have to know that even tho I have cab tractors available, I leave the bale spears on it & just blew snow this afternoon with the cabless tractor - it's more nimble..... Not everyone will agree with me on this. :)

--->Paul
 
I went without and stand by that.

in 2007 we got this new kubota. With a cab. I hated it. I eventuially just took the doors off. ITs like sitting inside doing nothing, atleast it was with me. I just felt isolated from the farm and the world in that thing. When it started eating transmissions and we had to go shopping again, we got an MX5100 (52 horses) and its the best tractor ive ever run. ITs powerful, smooth, fast if need be, the transmission is great, and best of all theres no cab. It doesnt usually get about 90 here, so were not that bad off. I"ll take being out with the dust, the noise, and the world over being secluded in a miserable cab. I love it.

Its kinda sucked this winter though. But its so worth it.
c2080.jpg

c1872.jpg
 
Buy one without a cab. You don't have the draw-backs of a cab including rattles. Spend the money that a cab would cost and build a good shed for it. Kubotas are good tractors.
 
A Kubota cab will surely feel nice in those Canadian winters. Kubota is top of the line in both tractors and cabs. They're OK in the summer because they keep chaff and dust out and you can manage temp to whatever your heart desires. If you get a cabless model, FEMCO sells a great weather shield custom designed for the teactor for $500 US. I have one on a Kubota M6800 and I also affix a storm window to the ROPS so that I'm almost completely shielded from the wind. I agree with you on cab damage in the woods. I use mine in the winter in the woods a lot and a cab would have seen considerable damage by now (7 1/2 years). Your call.
 
Keri in the 50 hp and up M series kubotas 67%
that this dealership sold last year were cab unith. As the h.p. goes up the percentage going to cab increases. You are going to have some looking to do because KUBOTA offers the L series in 50 h.p. the M series and the MX series so lots to pick from. If you get hung up send me a e-mail and I will try and help. 23 yrs Kubota experience
 
I grew up running tractors without cabs. Then came the early cab tractors. I little improvement, but not much. Modern cabs are really nice, but I wouldn't have one without heat and a/c. Just getting old I guess but I have my choice of a cabless or a cab tractor in the winter. The cabless sits. In a couple years I plan to buy a new 45-50 hp. tractor. I don't need a loader, but it will have a cab.
 
thats exactly my fear - that with a cab it would feel like sitting in a car. I do enough of that with my day job.

Glad to hear you like the kubota - thats the model I am looking at as well. Out of curiosity, any idea how much fuel it burns?
 
I vote FOR cab, one simple reason. It may just save your life. If you ever roll a tractor you will thank the cab many times over. I rolled a IH 1066 moving hay on 100 percent ice covered roads and walked away with only a blood blister on one finger. Was going slow enuf that only one side window broke. If no cab I could have been dead. DOUG
 
Not Much. I love that tractor, and besides, us "yuppies" dont have a time table so we can wait for nice weather.

It is like a box. The cab on the little kubota sucked too. Im 6' 1" and couldnt really move around in that thing. It was louder inside then outside.

The MX5100 barely uses fuel. Even under load. I use ours for everything from plowing to pulling trucks out. Its in alot of videos on youtube.

Id say 1.5 gallon/hr at 2/3 throttle and some load, 3 or 4 gear.

The transmssion is great. Its so easy to use. Its just a well built, well thought out machine. Id highly reccomend it. The exact opposite of the POS B3030 we had.
 
If I was ever in the market for a new tractor, I wouldn't think of buying one without a cab and 4wd. A cab in the wintertime makes the tractor a lot more useable and the air conditioned cab with the radio would be nice in the summer too. In the woods just be careful not to break the glass as that would get expensive. The squeaks and rattles of cabs are pretty much a thing of the past now.
 
It started eating them.

The dealer told us it could handle a two bottom plow, 1 row cultivator, 6 foot disk. It couldnt. They insisted it was something else and its normal for the transmission to drown out a scalded dog in the cab. We got them to come work on it. They picked it up (twice), but it was never the same. Then we went shopping.

The B3030 is an overgrown lawnmower with a cab. It just is. Its poorly thought out, poorly laid out, and a bad design.
 
Working all day long in the cold of winter i vote cab but I use mine in the spring an early summer doing hay I would go nuts with that cab on trying to get around trees and under low hanging limbs and just getting off an on tens an hour for some dumb thing. It really depends on what and when you are doing it. Not good in trees will cost more fixing it than its worth. I use an orchard model case 485 with no roll bar an its nice to know you can get in tight places where the roll bars or cabs will only get you in trouble. On hills and in muddy areas get a cab or at least a roll bar. Of course it kind of depends on the tractor my small Kubota I wouldn't get on it without that roll bar my Case orchard I don't think it roll over if you turned it over.
Walt
 
I live in Western Montana and raise beef cattle on small irrigated ranch. I have a couple of open station tractors and I'm 66 years old. I wish I had a cab tractor with the wind is blowing and the snow falling. I don't have trees to worry about and the next tractor I get will have a cab. I'm just too long in the tooth to be feeding cows through long Montana winters out in the open.
Any tractor with a cab or a ROPS is going to have trouble in the woods unless you prune the lower limbs off the trees. In fact if they have a vertical exhaust pipe they'll have trouble in the woods. You'll have to find a compromise.
 
I wouldn"t have a cab. I run an open station jd 4430 a lot and love it. I"d get an open cab 4840 if I could. Something about it that makes me feel alive. I like feeling the wind on my face even in Indiana winter.
 
LOL you did.

Look at it this way.

There were a few inches of mud out there. I drove slow. That tractor will go twice as fast. I really dont see any harm in a few doughnuts. I even hosed it off after. (flame away)
 
Soooooo, Thats what Lanse looks like. Seems likes the neighbor girls would always be coming over to see what tractor he was working on!
 
OK ,,its like this.. If you have 5 tractors ,one should have a cab , Thats my practical observation ,And experience for a normal farm , if for any reason just because of the weather conditions ,,If You can keep up the air conditioner and never go in the woods , , and never have to stop to adjust ,unplug, recalibrate , hookup ,fix ,or watch equipment without the cab and door getting in the way or tearing the h*() out of the cab by dragging pipe wrenches and oily and muddychains thru the door without breaking the glass in the back window with the round baler tieoff mechansim,....sigh! Tell me if any of this relates to You guys out here that work with equipment that is new to 50 years old....LOL ! , Yes sir a cab would be great on every tractor ,, However I prefer a open station for 99% of the work I do here .. But I sure am glad to have a cab for the cold runs between farms in the winter time ,, my 2 cents, jim
 
I felt the Vermont January wind on my face today as I went down over the hill on an open station tractor to plow out a couple of drives in town. Alive is not the feeling I got. 7 degrees on an open station tractor with a steel pan seat. That seat never warmed up and made my rear very cold, and my toes got uncomfortably cold too. Now, if I had a cabbed tractor, I could do it in a lot more comfort than bundling up and still getting cold.
 
I've run both thru the years, a cab tractor is harder to keep clean or you want to try and keep clean on the inside after climbing in it with muddy shoes. The windows always need cleaning and the rearview mirrors need adjusting. At times you will want to dust the interior to make it look new again.

When I was growing up we ran the IH "H" and "M", 460 and 560 tractors and I must admit after being out on them all day and then come home feeling the dirt on you was a good feeling, a feeling I don't feel when I come home from my job now! I guess I'll have to roll around in the field now when I get home to feel the dirt on me again!!
Plus back then the girls liked my tan I got from driving those tractors.
The only thing I wish I would of done back then is wear earplugs.
 
Personally I think the automotive feeling is a good thing. If you wanted, you could open the windows and doors when it was nice out, but the rest of the time you could be more free to use your tractor in any kind of weather. Cabbed tractors can have the luxury of a radio too.
 
Kari: I definitely think you should have a ROPS canopy for around the woods. Over the years I had 3 tractors with cabs, very nice if your clocking 1,000+ hours per year and someone is taking the time to clean both cab and glass weekly. Two of my tractors ran around the clock on custom work, rain or shine, in summer. Cab is almost a must under those conditions.

My third tractor stayed at home, baled hay, mower conditioner, etc. I always figured the worst dust one could get in a cab was hay or grain dust. I found my operators didn't want that tractor for baling hay. I had a tractor about same size without cab. In the end we removed doors and back window for haying. I realize cabs are much tighter on new tractors today than back in 60s and 70s, however cabs just don't lend themselves well for some work and haying is one of them.

Since I retired I had an oportunity to run a tractor mounted eastern Canadian blueberry harvester for a guy. He had 3 of these harvesters, one on an open station IH 484, second on a Ford 4610 with cab and the 3rd on a 80 hp Kubota with cab. These blueberry harvesters take a bit of getting used to skills. He gave me the Kubota, told me not to try and follow the 484 as he'd had dozens of operators, and no one could match the 484 or the guy that operated it. I thought to myself, "NOW THERE IS A CHALANGE IF I'VE EVER SEEN ONE." I decided to get a few days in hone my skills then one day I saw my chance to follow the 484. When he was fully loaded, I followed him to the waiting truck to off load our product. We both had same number of boxes. I turned to the owner, and before I could say anything, he said, "you didn't beat him." I responded, "Oh yes I did, the fact I was following 484 every trip I made around that small field was 28 feet shorter than his round." He agreed I was right, and knowing I had years of tractor experience, sat me down and asked why they had never been able to do this before. I said the single biggest reason, not many people can do precission tractor work from the confines of a cab.
 
Apparently Mr. T-Rev doesn't spread liquid manure with his open station tractor. All he would have to do is accidently spread into the wind once to change his mind about how great they are. :'D
 
In the woods, as long as your roads are clear enough, still the glass is not all that hard to break, just have to be careful, clearing brush and other tasks sometimes like to send things up at you, or poke at you, but you do need to have a rops/canopy.

For doing hay, you need A/C or you will be taking off some of the glass. I was running this M-F 1530 loading hay for my neighbor, small but did a great job of gathering and loading these round and large square bales, had to keep the door open and not catch in on a bale or something, that and the windows open, too hot in there, thought it was a good model, his son uses it in his landscape business, not heavy useage, he told me they were real disappointed with it, ended up in the shop, disassembled for some transmission work, last I heard they could not figure out what was wrong, long time dealer too.


Hay7307008.jpg



Hay7307035.jpg



Hay7307024.jpg
 
Cab's, cushioned seats, rops, power steering, fenders, rubber tires, pto shields, parking brakes and hearing protection are for city farmer wimps.
Real men don't need or want that sissy stuff.
 
Another possibility is a soft cab. We had one on our old backhoe and it was not too bad. All you need is a set of rops and canopy on the tractor and you can probably find a kit for it. Its cheaper than a glass cab, opens completely in the summer, stops the winds and holds heat in winter, cheap to replace torn vinyl(i guess thats what it was). Now it does not last as long as a glass cab, and when it gets dirty over time it will cloud up, but again it is replaceable. I think the kit was $350.00 from the case dealer but that was 19-20 years ago. Glass cabs do need ac, especially if in real dusty/thick conditions. Ran a glass cab backhoe pushing dirt one day after "drought" condition summer. Dust so thick you couldn't see 25 feet in front. No AC and had to keep windows shut to breathe. I bet it was 95 degrees in that hoe. The heat from the machine came up through the floor and made it extra toasty from the already 90+ degree day.
 
First thing that crossed my mind when you mentioned "woodlot" was a lot of busted glass. Only time I really wished for a cab was haying on 95 degree days- but that wouldn't work so well either, because with older equipment you need to be able to listen to what's going on back there, and get 'er stopped quick when you hear something you don't like. 'Course, I'm not feeding cattle in a Minnesota winter, either. But overall, for a small farm and general chores, I think a cab would be more trouble than its worth. BTW, I just got a 2 year old Kubota MX 5000- 50 HP, and I love it. Has 340 hours (the former owner traded up to a bigger one).
 
Kari,

I don't know all the details of a beef farm and what you to as far as cutting the wrap on the bale, bale spears, bale feeders, scooping poop etc. Then you mention a woodlot. You'll break a lot of glass.

With was I do a cab was a complete pain. I grown trees. I run a tree spade on my tractor and sprayers etc. When spading I am always adjusting something or on and off the tractor.

For this cabs are useless. Now I have 3 tractors none with cabs. Got rid of the cab tractor. Winter doesnt bother me so plowing in a snowstorm in kinda fun.

So you'll have to look at all your chores, if you are up and down the tractor all day, I doubt you'll want a cab.

Rick
 
He apparently has no allergies either or some of the hay dust Ive run into would choke'em down real quick.I used to think I didnt need a cab either,but bad allergies and humid weather convinced me otherwise.Ive got open station too,but You can damn sure bet which one will be pulling the baler when its 110 degrees out.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top