DTV ON HOLD

Anonymous-0

Well-known Member
What a bunch of crap! I just read in the paper that external_link wants to push foward the date for all tv's to be digital, because the goverment ran out of money for the coupons! If it aint broke dont fix it, why do we need digital tv anyway? Hasent analog worked fine for the last, hummm 40
@uc#$%^ years? Its no wonder this country is so screwed up, worrying about stupid crap like our tv signal.
 
It's NOT a matter of NEEDING digital TV... it's a matter of reducing the bandwith needed for TV so more of the RF spectrum is available for the government to auction off for business use.
 
yep, our representatives on the hill have nothing to worry about except trivial garbage like this. Don't you wonder what bills got passed at the same time as this to get this passed. I for one have gone on my state website that has my reps and have starting checking bills and legislation and have been pounding their e-mail. Now it seems like everybody wants to point their fingers at someone else. time to clean the house!!
 
and another quick thought - maybe the bailout recipients could make their first loan payment and the government would have enough to keep handing out the $40.00 coupons! one million coupons and you not even close to a billion dollars. i'm truly proud to be an american but the people running this country make me sick
 
Hey, people have had 2-3yrs to prepare for the switch. If they haven't bought a new TV or a $40 converter box by now, maybe they should take up reading books. It would probably be better for the country anyway.

The government shouldn't have had a coupon plan for the converter box in the first place. In the "old days" if a change like this happened, everyone took responsibility for themselves and nobody complained.
 
I never understood why the goobermint was handing out the vouchers for the converters anyway. Seems like it's the teevee advertisers that benefit from teevee, so they should be paying for the converters. If the people that they target their ads at can't receive the dtv signal, they won't be buying the product, so it makes sense for the advertisers to pay for the conversion.

Kinda flies in the face of the whole idea of bigger government, though. I can see why they didn't do it that way.
 
Hey, I dont care about the time line or anything else. I have Direct Tv so I think I well be fine. Wife wants local channals, so I told her to get the box. I could care less about our local news, I have the internet remember. Im just saying the goverment could spend there time and money more efficently.
 
I sort of agree why DTV and from what they have been saying it doesn't work well and the people that have it set up right now are having problems with it fading out and all sorts of other things. Then to top it off they say not only do you need that box but you also need a new antenna which is another $100-500
 
This is the FIRST intelligent thing I've ever heard him say! DTV is a huge hoax and isn't even available for all areas who now recieve analog.
We get 8 stations analoge, and 6 stations digital. Three of these DTV stations are PBS, two are the same, and one is a worthless Spanish station. We get one FOX channel, and a "WB" station. No CBS, ABC, or NBC, which means NO LOCAL WEATHER. For people who depend on up to the minute weather during severe storms, this is crucial. Even though the staions are broadcasting in both digital and analog (and at full strength digital...), they don't come in. Analog, they come in great. I've talked with several people in this area, and they are in the same boat. Another thing, even the DTV stations that DO come in, they go blank in wind or inclement weather.

Oh yeah, this is with a new antenna AND a new digital TV, not the box.....
 
Also you say " If people havent bought a new tv yet or the box" Cant you see the gov just wants you to spend your money, not to mention were are all the tvs from the 80s 90s and now that dont work gonna go? to the land fill? I just bought a sony wega 6 years ago, it works fine, now I have to get another tv or some stupid box to make it work. Bull enought is enought.
 
My TV is old enough a converter box wont work anyway(no audio and video plugs on it),and I dont need to spend several hundred for a new one right now,so I told the kids to get ready to watch videos.I have taught them the lost art of playing checkers.The local radio still gives us a heads up on the weather.I think its just a program to force people to go to pay TV,because the government makes more tax revenue when people pay for it,just like on your phone bill.As far as Im concerned they can stuff it!
 
My converter box is coax cable in and out. And in order to hook my DVD player up to my 1979 Sears TV I got a RF splitter so that I could hook a coax up to the ant. screws. Don't need the separate cables for L, R, and picture.
 
That is what I was trying to say To Far Gone, Not everyone wants to buy a new tv for this crap. In these tought times! come on, is this goverment that stupid? well.............. yes!
 
About 6 months ago, there was some news report that the govt had already auctioned off $200 to $300 million (or maybe it was $20 to $30 billion) of the TV broadcast bands to the cell phone companies. Meanwhile the govt talking heads tell us "poor folk" that the govt needed the airwaves for homeland security communications. What a crock of $hit!!

Just follow the money.... Who profits from this huge market change? The cable and satellite TV companies, the TV manufacturers, the digital converter box manufs, the large retailers like Wal-Mart, Best Buy, Target, Circuit City etc. When the TV stations originally gained their license (late 1930's to early 50's) and broadcast frequency, it was determined that certain radio freq bands would be dedicated to the public usage for TV, radio, amateur radio, emergency services, etc. During this last 8 years the FCC has been totally compromised and corrupt, and has done totally what they (support of big business) want. The rights of the US citizens have been badly trampled in the mad rush of businesses salivating and then madly chasing to get more money. We have been fed a bunch of lies...even by PBS!!!

My converter box coupons expired one day before the stock of boxes at Wal Mart became available. We were rejected as "illegal for us to sell you that box with the $40 coupon". I called govt phone number and waited more than 45 minutes for "help". I live in MN, the "help lady" was reading prepared script she didn't understand for someplace in Oregon, and at the end of the speel asked if she answered our question. When I emphatically told her "NO" she got all bent up and told me that she had given me the right answer, but I was just too (ignorant??) to understand. Of course the "help" is contracted out to some company that is making profit from low wage people who know almost nothing about RF or maybe anything else for that matter. Just more business making more money (from our taxes)in this huge scam.

Some neighbors have told me how smart they are by now getting cable or satellite for $29.99/month. But they didn't read the fine print, that is the 3 month "introductry rate" which then automatically goes up to $100/month.
One of my daughters and fiancee got caught in that scam, and can't afford to throw $100/month down the rat hole. As they already had cable when the coupons were available, they were not eligible for coupons. So now they are screwed.

Can the new Washington crew straighten this mess out?? I really doubt it, there are too many big $$$ people and companies making huge profit from this move toward "a better picture" for us poor slobs who can't afford to outrageous monthly bills.

This whole thing STINKS!!!! Like a herd of rabid skunks!!!

Paul in MN
 
I am not happy about the new TV either. But on top of that. Grips me that I pay to watch their advertisements now. Can't even watch News on tv with out it jumping to advertisements every few minutes.
So the advertisers are paying to some big shot like Turner and them. Then we pay to watch that same junk to.
Would not be paying for any TV these days. But my wife wants it. So .. well that's how it goes.
 
Wait a minute...you can get FOX News, but not NBC, CBS, or ABC?

Sounds like you got the anti-"lying abundant media" package...so ENJOY.
 
Thats what I figured too.In these tough times,plants closing every day here.We are suppose to tighten our belts and hold on for the ride,but Go Ahead and buy a new TV anyway.How will You watch the dang thing without the electric bill paid!
 
Uh, Ray, external_link wants to push the date BACK, not forward. So you should be happy if you don't have to make the switch next month.

As for why the switch to digital, it's because digital is better. Analog TV is over SIXTY years old. To put it in perspective, if telecommunications technology progressed at the same rate as television has, we would all still be cranking our phones.

Actually, there's money for the coupons, it's just that everybody waited until the last minute to order them. So the Commerce Department can't send out any more until they know how many get used and how many expire.
 
My old TV died in 2007...so when we bought a new one, we knew that DTV was coming and bought an HDTV so we could receive the digital signal. Anyone who bought an analog set after DTV was announced, as I see it, did the damage to themselves.

On analog, I had 4 commercail network stations, 1 independent, and 2 PBS outlets. On digital, my NBC affiliate has already staked out 3 digital channels; the CBS, ABC, FOX, and independent station have only staked out one channel each. The PBS outlet, which had two channels on analog, has 4 on digital. Plus, when the signal comes in, I receive another digital independent station that has 4 program channels.

So I've actually got more choices on DTV than I had on analog. No signal problems 99 percent of the time.

Mom, on the other hand, wouldn't get off the dime tosend for the coupon for the converter. So my wife sent for one, and gave it to her. Mom let it expire. Now that it's almost time to switch over, Mom's finally sent for a replacement coupon. I told her I'd connect the converter for her when she got it, but so far she doesn't have it yet. So I figure a failure to react in a timely manner on HER part does not necessarily constitute an emergency on MY part. I've tried to teach my kids about actions/lack of actions and consequences...never thought I'd have to start teaching a parent.
 
I agree with you.We have one spare TV set up on the DTV box and have no complaints but we live in the "Valley of the Sun" and nearly any kind of an Antenna will work here. I see additional Stations coming in that never did when it was Anolog.We subscribe to Direct TV on our main viewing TV's so we have many options to view.I like RFD,Speed Channel and any others I can relate to. PPV is a very good option,See current Movies with out leaving the House which is alright with me.
 
DTV will not be good for me. Antennas suffer from every disturbance, wind shaking the power lines in the signal path, vehicles passing by the house. I have Winegard's largest and finest rooftop antenna with rotor and amplifier, new less than 6 months ago. Station that my analog set would receive with NO antenna connected now breaks up and freezes with digital on the new antenna. Converter box, digital set, same problem. Analog set on same antenna does fine. Fooey on DTV!
 
TV's without the audio/video input jacks can use an RF converter. Buy at Radio Shack and other places for $20-$25 and hook up to the antenna input on the OLD set.
 
I haven't looked since I have Direct TV but the last time I got one it cost me over $100 and I put it up last year just for radio. My mom on the other hand has antenna TV and her antenna is old so I figure she will need a new one and we live way out in the middle of no where so I know it will not be chaep
 
Ya if you live close enough to the station for a cheap one to work but me and my mom are over 100 miles from a station so a cheap one will not cut it. BTDT and the last one I got cost me well over $100 and it was not the top of the line back then
 
Well, I've been a ham radio operator for over 30 years, there are two other hams in this house. I have taught electrical engineering and avionics on the college level. Also worked in land mobile service. (I tell you this to establish that I know a bit about radio and electronics.)

Now - digital is probably more efficient, and they can get more bang for the bucks. BUT with digital, you have to have a perfect signal. Otherwise it breaks up and drops out. With analog you can put up with a little snow. Digital is long gone. We live in a fringe area, and there's only so much you can do with antennas, preamps, etc. I'm afraid that this digital revolution is going to be a major disappointment. Already looks like we're going to loose several stations, and one complete network. Putting it on hold while the govt. catches up will only prolong the misery. When the finally do throw the switch, there's going to be a bunch of unhappy viewers, trust me on that!
 
Looks like you didn't take any electronic classes in school.And have no idea what the radio spectrume is.
The current 1941 era analog TV standard is a half baked b*stardized approach because of whinners in the 19503s.
Oh boo hoo, whaa whaa . My old black and white TV won't work on the new fangled colour signals that I don't want.
So the luminance signal,the chrominance signal and audio component on a sub carrier. Uses a full 6Mhz of band width which includes 250Khz of "wasted" guard band on each side.
If you haven't noticed. There are not making any more land and they are not making any more radio spectrum either.
Digital carries more data with less loss of signal quality on less band width.
TV channels 1,70 to 114 were lopped off to provide radio spectume for pagers, cell phones, emergency services etc.
2-51 will be the new range of channels.
 
As an amature radio oprator (KE5HBD) I can say that the digital changeover in my town is causing alot of inter mod trouble here.

There is nothing wrong with analog signals or digital as long as they are maintained.

Theres nothing worse than alot of intermod to spoil a good ole qso or listening to your local lawenforcement on a scanner.

Its called free air and that goverment is content in taking the free out of free air.

At one time you could put a yagi in the air about sixty foot and pick up alot of things.

Now its pay for everything.

Damon
N.E. Texas
C Allis #552
KE5HBD
 
Problem is some of those converter boxes are terrible.
Get a good one that is HDTV with the HDMI output. Or a decent TV with the built in digital tuner.
 
(quoted from post at 23:23:54 01/16/09) Problem is some of those converter boxes are terrible.
Get a good one that is HDTV with the HDMI output. Or a decent TV with the built in digital tuner.

I dont use Morse Code HI. Morse Code is a thing of the past for myself and have not used it since boy scouts to get a merrit badge.
 
And that good UHF antenna will work until February and then many of the temporary digital UHF channels will go back to their old analog channels but transmit digital on them so you will need a VHF/UHF antenna then.

Gerald J.
 
well, i get 5 channels on my analog tv and antenna. i get 1 channel with the digital converter box. so tell me how much better it is.
 
Don't have digital at the house yet, but come here to where I work and tell my why the new tv we have is so much better on the DT side over analog. We have a new antana 30 feet up on a tower and we get one station that you can watch with out cussing on DTV. Yes it would be nice if we could get all the other channels that are on DTV but we can't. We have spent several hours move'n the little antanna around try'n to get the DTv stations but they will be a blue screen more than any thing else.

If you ask me it's a way for the TV folks to make those of us who live more than 15 miles from the station to pay for satalite. But hey thats just me.

Dave
 
You moron analog tv is-was the most reliable thing we had going in this country. Now every time it rains or a cloud goes over the digital satellite signal breaks up. The lotto machines in the convience stores are now hooked up to a digital signal and they are already saying on the news tonight how they wont work half time already.Not that I care. The guy you're replying to might be an electrical engineer for all you know you arrogant dipsh@t.
 
One thing for certain. davepal certainly has zero idea about electronics.
Sat TV goes down because home owners want to smallest, cheapest dish that doesn't stand out.
Also rare is the dish that has been peaked and tweaked for max gain with a meter.
Installers get them operating "good enough" on clear days but being off the ideal position. The signal can be several db less than whats available.
If the manufacture says a 12" dish will do. They are saying you really need an 18" dish.
 
Wait a second. Somebody installed a TV antenna without a rotor??? Who on earth would do something like that???
Also unless a antenna top amp is used with RG-6 cable. Most of the signal picked up by the antenna is lost before it gets to the TV.
 
FCC will auction off the bandwidth for channels 52-70 for a few hundred billion.

(Hmmm, some of it I *believe* is being kept for a new public safety band)
 
There is no such thing as a digital antenna.
Mount an antenna on a rotor, use an antenna mounted amp and low loss rg-6 or better cable. No problems.
 
Satellite tv goes down because the signal won't travel through the rain and clouds in thunderstorms and hard snowsqualls. If you had any friends they would probably be telling you that their digital tv goes out sometimes when it rains. I don't have a cheap dish. I have no obstructions whatsoever to the southern sky. For somebody that has no idea about electronics I sure have enough of them and have done a lot of house and pole barn wiring. You just have the idea that every body but you is cheap and broke and can't afford a new tv, or a new tractor, or a new generator, or a decent satellite dish, or a good convertor box, or a new car, or any education, or any knowledge of anything. How people get like you is beyond me.
 
DTV reception will improve after the analog transmitters are shut down.
Some problems are due to "noise" from both an analog and DTV transmitters in the same area sharing the same channel.
Other problems are people purchasing $39.99 converters with $40.00 vouchers. Sorry folks, a $39.99 signal converter works as well as a new $39.99 tire on your car.
If the converter doesn't say HDTV with HDMI output. Leave it on the shelf or bring it home and use it only for a paperweight.
 
I understand that but the problem is the digital signal is a lot lower in power or doesn't broadcast as well so if you have an old antenna that gets you by now it will no long get you by in the near future. So you buy a new antenna at $100 plus and amp another $30-100 so it adds up real fast.
 
it's a little blade syle antanna that the guy at radio shack said we needed. It came with a 40' camble, not sure what kind. We have it U bolted 30' up a 50' tower just out side the lab window. The tower is for a radio antenna used with some of our in house SCADA equipment.

Dave
 
Quote" For somebody that has no idea about electronics I sure have enough of them and have done a lot of house and pole barn wiring." Unquote

There's an explanation why you don't understand. House and pole wiring is electrical, not electronics.
 
Sorry, no wonder Rat Shack/The Source or what ever they are called are going broke. They sell their customers equipment that doesn't work.
Also being mounted on the side of a tower.It's possible to null out the intended signal and reflect in noise from the metal structure.
 
I think it is called PROGRESS, you get a better everything, Todays cars beats driving the old tin lizzie,if you get the trend.
The same is happening here so seems to be a WW trend.
 
But thats my whole deal. This is a new tv, with a new antenna and analog works better! The analog is a little fuzzy some times but I am at work and I just have it on to have some moise here in the lab. I keep it on PBS, ABC, CBS, and NBC which ever one has a news show on. I don't give a rats rear bout seeing every thing in "crystal clear" picture. Just don't want blue screen with no audio half the time. If I had the sound I'd deal with no picture. I wish the DTV worked, the PBS station in KY has four digital channels and only one analog. There is always some neat history or news show on one of the 4 but I can't get them to come in well enough to just listen to them while I work.

Dave
 
As seen on a previous post, draw a shotgun when the meter reader shows up.then you pay for electricity and tv with time.
 
The vhf antennas are already there on rotors.Uhf antennas are small.There were no uhf stations here when the antennas were put up.
 
I just hooked un my ZENITH box this AM 17 Jan getting 18 channels clear as a bell on rabbit ears on an old set im at least 49mi from closest tower didnt even know there were so many stations in this area. So dont say they dont work.
 
Look at solidsignal .com they have honest pricing.Shipping is high on the big antennas because of Ups oversize ripoff prices.I bought in lots of 12 and got prepaid shipping from instate distributors when I sold antennas.Channel Master made good antennas that stood up to Maine weather.There is much ripoff and BS going on with DTV beware of crooked sellers.Neighbor bought a cheap antenna,It lost all elements the first winter.My Channel Master antenna has been on the shop 40 years, still in good shape.My house antenna has suffered from falling tree limbs,Ill replace it when I know more about the DTV.I remember people buying 600.00 color consoles and trying to get a good pix with 2 buck rabbit ears.
 
Does anyone know if Canada is eliminating analog TV on the same date as the US?

My parents get a few stations from Ontario, and are wondering if they will loose them. Presently they don't get any digital signals from over the lake.
 
Once the trees leaf out they will interfere with the signal.Snow on the dish will stop the signal.Ive seen some good high readings flop in snow and rain .I can remember a fellow who lost reception on channel 7 when the trees leaf out.I have put antennas in some odd places to get a vhf signal.
 
I've heard that along with better signal, it has to do with opening up more analog bandwidth. Apparently TV signals take up a lot of space in the spectrum.
 
Problem is that is the wrong antenna mounted in the wrong place.
There are not enough elements to obtain enough mechanical gain. There is no amplifier. The tower behind it is causing reflections. The SCADA system above is making electronic noise and drowning out the DTV signal. There is no rotor. Ordinary basic coax cable both attenuates signal and absorbs electronic noise instead of shielding noise from the TV signal.
The existing system will work about as well as mounting a 3ft high sump pump in a 5ft deep sump. And setting the switch to start the pump at 4ft water depth.
You can't cheat the laws of physics.
 
Often buick posts good information. But on this thread, it is an attitude of superiority and insults to others. My converters are Zenith DTT900, purchased in the first week that converter coupons were issued. My antenna is Winegard HD8200U with antenna-mounted Winegard preamplifier AP-8700, downlead is RG-6 coax. The antenna has a Channel Master rotor and is actually higher than the power lines, 7200 volt single-phase, which border two sides of my property. With the converter and with a new TV with ATSC tuner, my reception with digital is not as reliable as it is with analog. Now, will I get an attack or truly helpful information?
 
I've not heard that, and can't imagine that would be the case. Different frequencies. There would be a huge uproar if that were the case, it's just not so. While the government is pretty messed up, even they wouldn't make a mistake like that.
 
It's irritating to hear the wailing of jaiyinny and his ilk. He small mindidly crys great personal loss about a topic he knows nothing about.
He's the same kind of person that moans about radial tires, airbags, seat belts, fuel injection, automatic transmissions, anti-lock brakes, electronic ignition etc.

The other irritant is the person who expects gold performance with bronze level input.

Here is initial post. Sounds like a general complain about everything in the world rant.

Quote"What a bunch of crap! I just read in the paper that external_link wants to push foward the date for all tv's to be digital, because the goverment ran out of money for the coupons! If it aint broke dont fix it, why do we need digital tv anyway? Hasent analog worked fine for the last, hummm 40
@uc#$%^ years? Its no wonder this country is so screwed up, worrying about stupid crap like our tv signal. "
Unquote

As for your system.. The 8200 antenna is the poorer choice. It's tuned to receive channels 2-6 and the FM broadcast band. This introduces both excess signal and FM noise into the front end of the amp.The amp is saturating and odds are the TV tuner as well. It will improve when the analog systems go down for good.
The HD7697P or HD7698P will provide better signal, less noise and less wind loading to the tower/rotor.
Location being framed in by the power lines is not the fault of the DTV system.

My super dupper whiz bang turbo mega blitzburg antenna system doesn't work worth beans at the moment either.It's bringing in too much signal and saturating now that there are more than twice as many channels carrying signal. Too many signals and too strong is as detrimental as too few and too weak of signals.
Somewhere in a TV junk box here , there is a variable power supply that maybe compatable to replace the fixed voltage Channel Master supply currently in use. Dialing the gain back can clear the picture by dropping the noise level And not saturating the wave forms into distortion and/or flattened peaks.
The amp is supposed to compensate for cable loss. If the signal is too weak, distorted or over whelmed with noise. The system can't work.
It's a little about signal strength and mostly about signal strength vs. noise.
 
Winegard recommended this antenna. But my earlier point is confirmed. Analog TV did not create the power line situation either. But analog tolerated it better. Analog is also not so sensitive to signal strength. Apparently the digital signal must fall within a narrow range of strength to work. Apparently just one bit of the signal arriving out of perfect time or one bit missing and the things just "panics" and stops. Cable is not available at my address. Satellite offers so much that I do not want. Sports, MTV-of no interest to me.
 
I'm looking at a HDTV fta with the HDMI connection.A built in terrestrial digital tuner and an over sized 39" steerable dish. As my Sony TV Bravia system has HDMI inputs but no digital tuner.
The fta should bring in a few network stations, pbs, nasa and such. And DTV from acros the lake and as it's introduced here.
No interest in adding the codes for full but illegal access. As previously stated, there is too much trash out there to watch already.
 
The laws of physics works well with analog and that is my point. Here where I am setting and with what I have to work with analog is better.


It's kinda like tractors, there is no one thing that works for every one. Some are just better in some situations. For me analog is better.

Dave
 
Try picking up analog with the new blade antenna. It won't work with analog either.
The current setup is like trying to bail out a boat using a fishing net instead of a pail.
 
Watch'n analog on it now,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

Seems fine to me.

Yes picture is not the greatest when the wind is blow'n but it beats the blue quiet screen I have with digital.

I am telling you, and you can come here and see it for your self. With a new tv and a digital antenna the analog works better here with what I have to work with.

Dave
 
http://winegard.com/offair/pdf/HD7697P.pdf with a rotor, preamp and rg-6 cable

I looked at the rat shack site and there is only 2 antennas out of 59 listed worth taking home.
 
A couple of more factors/
#1 The analog transmitters are currently running full power and the dtv transmitters are running partial power until the analog transmitters are shut down.
#2 The dtv signals are not being transmitted from the same towers as the same network's analog signal. The digital tower maybe farther away from from your antenna than the old analog signal.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top