hretter

Member
I have a 1951 Farmall M. This morning I went to start it and the starter kicked in and out (bad starter button) and the engine backfired and blew oil out of the
breather. After that, the starter just spun. I removed the starter motor and I can turn the flywheel with a long screwdriver, but the engine won't turn. I put
it in gear and I can still spin the flywheel and neither the engine nor transmission engage.
What the heck is going on?
 
Two possibilities None good. One is a broken crankshaft at the rear main, the other is sheared off flywheel bolts. The bolt failure is less grief, but both are likely to require a split unless you can move the FW rearward enough to get the broken bolts out. Jim
 
Not to question your intelligence, but when you say you are turning the flywheel is it the whole mass of the flywheel or just the ring gear teeth? Asking because the flywheel starter ring gear may have split and is just spinning freely. Never seen it happen but not impossible because they are welded to form the ring. Sorry to say but I fear one of Jim's diagnosis is more lkely.
 
The whole flywheel turns.
1) Can the crankshaft be replaced through the oil pan?
2) When in gear, why won't the rear wheels engage? Does that point to broken crankshaft rather than sheared bolts?
 
Engine will need to be pulled out for crank replacement. The front timing gear cover will have to be removed. And in back the flywheel bolts need to be remove from the crank and the clutch input shaft will have to clear or pull out of the pilot bearing. All easiest accomplished by pulling the engine off the bell housing in my opinion. Your gear disconnection dilemma may prove to be interesting, I have no clue on that other than the input shaft is severly out of alignment due to the crank being broken??
 
if you need to replace the crankshaft then the engine must come out. then you remove flywheel . then strip front of engine down to bare block. engine should be in an engine stand upside down to work on it properly. sounds like you need help on this project. its not like just removing the crank and putting another one in. there is clearances to measure. and rod brgs. may need replacing. then there is the sleeves and pistons and rings. the top end also might need work.. its just like one thing leads to another.
broken bolts or broken crank... when you turn the flywheel and have unit in gear the rear wheels will turn. but if the coupler is broken then the trans will not turn. so you better check and make sure the front engine pully is turning or not turning when you turn the flywheel with the bar. because your post is confusing. you are saying the engine wont turn when you turn the flywheel. and also saying the trans wont turn when its in gear when you turn the flywheel. according to what u say that means that 2 breaks would have had to happen. the coupler or clutch rivits let go. and a break ahead of rear seal.
 
If the crank is broke and it's just a fair to average m
With average or worse tires and no power steering and no live hydraulics junk it and buy another m they are so cheap should be able to get a good m for 1000-1500 area why waste the time fixing it part yours out and move on
 
The engine must be removed the split is between the frame rails at the rear, and the engine plate at the rear. The front casting (bolster) and radiator are removed. this requires splitting stands, and a strong engine hoist, and a service manual. It is not a novice job, and at least one experienced mechanic should be involved. Jim
 
Sorry for the confusion. The tractor is in 1st gear. I removed the starter. I can turn the flywheel with a large screwdriver through the opening for the starter. There is no wobble in the flywheel. The engine does not turn nor does the transmission engage - the rear wheels don't turn.
When I put the starter back in and try to start it, I get the same results - neither the engine nor rear wheels turn.
To remove the engine, do I need to split the tractor? Thanks.
 
Does the clutch pedal still have free play? Maybe crank broke or flywheel bolts broke and shifted flywheel to rear enough to disengage clutch. Or flywheel bolts wiped out clutch parts. Take all spark plugs out and see how far back some compression is when turning hand crank. If crank broke at center, valves and pistons on rear cylinders will be out of time when turning flywheel. If compression all the way to number 4 trouble will be near rear of crank at flywheel or near. Unless you have 2 unrelated parts fail at the same time.
 
(quoted from post at 04:14:17 07/03/16) Sorry for the confusion. The tractor is in 1st gear. I removed the starter. I can turn the flywheel with a large screwdriver through the opening for the starter. There is no wobble in the flywheel. The engine does not turn nor does the transmission engage - the rear wheels don't turn.
When I put the starter back in and try to start it, I get the same results - neither the engine nor rear wheels turn.
To remove the engine, do I need to split the tractor? Thanks.

I think I would drop the belly pump and have a good look up inside. If the tractor is in 1st gear, but does not move when you turn the flywheel, maybe, just maybe, it is the starter ring gear that has failed and is not a broken crankshaft. Replacing that ring gear will STILL require splitting the tractor.
 
Explosive fracturing of the crank, or bolts, could have shattered the coupling, or driven disk hub, or broken the clutch shaft. My grand fathers Ford Falcon
broke a crankshaft that when fractured acted like a one way clutch and pushed the flywheel rearward 1/2 inch each revolution. AN interesting failure to get at
the cause. Jim
 
Curious about your location--can't find a M in my area for less than $2500-$3000. I'm hoping to pick one up this winter to put under my 2MH corn picker.

Al
 
Would dropping the oil pan and then observing crank while turning hand crank help? If crank is broken under cylinders, it should be obvious. If broken at flywheel end, I'll have to split tractor. I'm pretty sure I have to split the tractor (doesn't sound TOO difficult) to find out what the heck happened. I don't think the flywheel moved back, as the starter can still engage and turn it. I suspect and hope that it's only sheared flywheel-to-crankshaft bolts and a blown clutch.
It is a fine machine otherwise and I hate to part it out.
 
(quoted from post at 11:24:47 07/03/16) Would dropping the oil pan and then observing crank while turning hand crank help? If crank is broken under cylinders, it should be obvious. If broken at flywheel end, I'll have to split tractor. I'm pretty sure I have to split the tractor (doesn't sound TOO difficult) to find out what the heck happened. I don't think the flywheel moved back, as the starter can still engage and turn it. I suspect and hope that it's only sheared flywheel-to-crankshaft bolts and a blown clutch.
It is a fine machine otherwise and I hate to part it out.

Yes. Dropping the oil pan is a good idea.
 
Tractor guy am located in Minnesota bought several h farmalls run like a top new tires on them 800-1500 max how many u wanna buy market completely dropped out of h and m tractors
 
I don't have a hand crank, only electric start. I can turn it with the fan blade and I can feel cylinder coming up on compression stroke.
 
Parting it out is an option that is becoming more and more appealing. It has wide front end, 3 pt hitch, Super M cam-driven hydraulic pump, and power steering but I could transfer those to another M.
 
(quoted from post at 18:55:35 07/03/16) I don't have a hand crank, only electric start. I can turn it with the fan blade and I can feel cylinder coming up on compression stroke.

So.................when ya turn the fan, does the flywheel turn???????
 
(quoted from post at 19:02:08 07/03/16) Parting it out is an option that is becoming more and more appealing. It has wide front end, 3 pt hitch, Super M cam-driven hydraulic pump, and power steering but I could transfer those to another M.

Where ya located?
 
I'm in eastern NC but when the time comes I'm willing to travel a bit for the right tractor at the right price.

Al
 
In gear even with crank or bolts broken tractor should move as clutch should still be engaged if clutch has any free travel. Im goings with flywheel ring gear.
 
Ok. This morning I went out and turned the fan and the flywheel moved. I put it in gear and with enough movement in the flywheel, the wheels attempted to move.
I told my wife, this thing my start today. I put the starter back in, put it in neutral and tried to start it. Nothing. I put it in reverse and hit the starter
button. Nothing. I removed the starter and made marks on flywheel ring and the first two inner joints I could see. Replaced starter and tried to start it in
neutral. I turned off ignition and put in reverse and hit starter button. No movement, just starter noise. I removed starter and the flywheel hadn't moved at
all; the marks were right where I made them.
I can turn starter gear in one direction until it's at its outermost position and then turn it in either direction. One way is more difficult than the other.
Looks like something blew in the starter mechanism.
 
So do you think that you misdiagnosed the broken crankshaft or are you just stating in this post that you are realizing a problem with the starter as well? Put it in 5th gear and try turning the flywheel with a screwdriver in the starter teeth again. Road gear (5th) will get the quickest reaction between the flywheel/clutch/ trans input shaft rotation and the rear wheels. If it turns the wheels one way then turn the flywheel the other way and you should get a change in wheel direction. All this is to confirm the transmission is functioning as before the incident. This is for the determination of you having more then just an engine problem. Again double check that the front of the engine does not turn with the flywheel.
 
There is just too much unclear information here. If the ring gear is slipping on the flywheel you should be able to tell by using a screwdriver to pry on the ring gear and if it turns and the flywheel doesn't then it is slipping and needs to be replaced. Some of the observations don't seem to make any sense. I am sure if any of us with tractor mechanics knowledge could see it we could diagnosis it.
 
I've been following this thread mainly to acquire information and trouble shooting techniques for my future knowledge. I have never experienced anything like this or even heard of such a combination of possible issues before and this thread has seemed to become un-jointed to me in achieving any satisfactory diagnosis. From some of my trouble shooting experiences I would like to propose the following:
1. Push in ignition switch to the off position and remove all the spark plugs.
2. Remove the starter.
3. Jack up one rear wheel where it will turn freely and block the tractor.
4. Place the transmission in 5th gear.
5. Rotate the raised wheel and either check yourself or have someone see if the fan turns with movement of the wheel and tire.
If the fan turns then the entire drive chain is intact and should function as normal except it is still possible the ring gear is slipping on the flywheel. If the fan does not turn then you will have to isolate where and what is the point of failure. I would certainly start by taking your starter to a good auto electric shop or auto parts store that has test equipment to see how the starter is behaving by knowledgeable individuals.
I hope this is of some benefit and helpful but I don't have anything else to offer relative to the catastrophic failures which have already been mentioned except that if your fan doesn't turn when the rear wheel is rotated something along the drive train has suffered a failure and most likely technical assistance is going to be required to facilitate the necessary repairs, Hal.
 
Some of the observations don't seem to make any sense.


I agree 100%. Seems to have gone form a simple diagnosis to major problems at the drop of a hat on this forum, and not just this post.
 
Second post on topic ask if sure the flywheel was turning with the starter gear and was answered yes and when doing that the engine or wheels didn't turn when in gear. So no simple answer to that, unless you come right out and say do you know the difference between starter gear on the flywheel and the flywheel. Second poster already said he didn't want to question his intelligence.
Now after a lot of posts sounds like starter or starter gear on flywheel if it is turning on flywheel. Simple to check crankshaft. With starter out turn front of crank and starter flywheel gear should turn along with flywheel with no load.
 
None of us are there to make the same observations as the original poster, so we can only go by his description of the problem. It sure sounded like a broken crank, though, nobody really questioned his statement "only starter noise."

Most likely the "starter noise" was just the ZING! you hear when the Bendix is broken and isn't snapping out to engage the ring gear. That's a broken starter, not a broken crankshaft.

A new Bendix drive for the starter, and a new starter button is the quickest and cheapest way to get this tractor running again.
 
Nothing directed at you Mr Slater, by no means! Seems it has gone from broken bolts and crankshafts to the starter not engaging the flywheel.
 
Leave the starter off and pull the tractor to try and start it. If things are already broke. will not hurt it much more. If starts and runs good. probably bad starter.
Always try simple things first.
 
It's definitely a bad starter. Being rebuilt at shop now. I will install it and try again when ready. Thanks all.
 
The starter is busted. It's being rebuilt now and when I get it back, I'm pretty sure it will start.
I don't know why I thought the engine wouldn't turn when I bumped the flywheel. I can definitely see the fan moving when I do. Really bad observation on my
part.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top