Farmall Super A starter serviceable?

Tophers_Farm

New User
Farmall Super A starter was hit or miss last year.

Upon pushing the button often nothing would happen then randomly it would fire right up.
I put oil in the little filler hole, but there wasn't much of a difference it was all or nothing, it seems to be an electrical contact issue.

This year so far the starter won't turn over at all. Is the starter serviceable or should I just buy a new one?

Also we started it with compression and it ran fine for about 5 minutes the stopped suddenly, I read something about priming the oil pump after it sitting for a few months, could that be an issue? I've never done that in the past...
 
Do you have a saddle switch on your starter? if so that is where I would start looking. They don't make that great a contact and doesn't take much to burn the contacts and they don't work. Sometimes a bug will build a nest in them too. Saddle switches were not a great idea. Also if the starter won't turn make sure the motor does turn. Old Farmalls can have the starter lock up against the ring gear and can end up stuck in two gears as a couple of possibilities why they wont crank.
 
I'm going to second what Charlie said about the starter switch. My John Deere B has what I believe Charlie is referring to as a saddle switch. It mounts directly on the starter motor. Mine started getting hit or miss then quit completely. Their fairly common, so easy to source a new one, and easy to replace. As for the motor itself, yes there are many parts that can be ordered to repair them; brushes, armature, bearings, etc. Good luck and start with the switch first.

JD
 
I can rule out the switch, I took the switch off and shorted out the contact directly.
Motor turns I had it running easily via compression.
I'll start dismantling the starter and see what I can find. I'll need some help there as all of the vocabulary i've read so far (armature, brushes, etc) mean nothing to me. Downloading the parts manual so I can see what's what. Thanks for the help so far...
 
Can I just hook up the battery directly to the contact on my workbench? Would be a lot easier to troubleshoot if I didn't have to work on it at the tractor...
 
Yes you can work on it on a bench. There is one thing about that, in that it may turn over fine on the bench but not have enough oomph to turn the tractor motor over. That's usually caused by bad windings. You say you jumped it straight to the starter motor from the battery and it turned over? That would indicate starter switch. If it didn't then yeah your going to have to tear into it. But don't worry they're pretty straightforward. Heck it could be something as simple as just needing to clean the contacts on the armature. Let us know how it goes and if you get stuck just holler and some on here will help you. I believe this site carries most the parts you'll need.

JD
 
The contact on the starter? Maybe Im forgetting something, but if that is working, then it would be the saddle switch, not the lug, unless its just so wore out the cotacts arent contacting? IIRC, the last one of those I did I just cleaned up the lug with a file and changed the saddle.
 
Really need to use a simple $5 test light before taking anything apart. Guessing can often multiply problems and always wastes time and money! If this is a 6v system, a 12v test light will work, just be dim.

With a test light, connect the clip to a bare metal ground on the starter case.
with the probe end, touch the cable stud, the stud itself, then try the starter.

If the light comes on, the starter is bad. If no light, power is not making it to the starter. Keep checking back to the contactor, battery cables, loose connections, corroded connections, find out where you are losing power. Always check under load, as in while holding the starter switch closed.

Just be careful! It could start cranking anytime during the test! Be sure it's in neutral!!!

If you do go into the starter, chances are the brush leads are soldered in. Some are held with screws and are an easy fix, but the soldered ones are best left to the pros at the starter shop.
 
Yes they are serviced. I get bushings and brushes from Napa. Cost about 20
I test the armature with vom .
Test field coils
I have my son turn the armature commutator on a lathe just enough to get clean up .
I put in new bendix spring assem. Sometimes
Also the condition of the ring gear has much to do with the starter locking up. They always stop at the same spot ,so most of the wear is at one or two places
I say suggestion is rebuild it .
Have not found one that we could not redo .
 
John, yes that's pretty much what happen on the Deere. I thought about filing the mounting holes in the saddle switch so I could move the contact closer. With the switch off the tractor you can see the wear but it's deceiving as when the saddle switch is on it can contact on one contact and this will stop the travel so it doesn't contact the other contact to make the circuit. If his is in fact a saddle switch mounted on the starter then the only way he could jump the starter would be to remove the switch, can't access the starter lug, hence if it started less saddle switch then bad saddle switch.

JD
 
Update:

I took it apart to inspect the armature and commuter, although a cleaning wouldn't hurt it doesn't look that bad.

I wanted to try to connect it to the battery on the work bench (maybe the battery amperage is not enough to turn it against the motor), but when I went to insert the armature I can get the shaft at the end to insert into what I assume is the bearing at the back of the starter housing. It's weird because there's not exactly a lot play in there, any pointers there would be appreciated.

Just to clarify as more than one person mentioned it, the motor runs fine from compression, it's really a starter or electrical issue.
 
I found a great video to help!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQ00AG9d42c

I thought the cover and case were all one piece because someone had put scotch tape over the clamp.

Making progress...
 
Do you have the tin band over the brush access windows off number 12 in the attached diagram? That will have to be off and the brushes worked out over the commutator ..thing with copper strips on it on the armature.. I am just assuming when you say ..putting armature in back.. that is where you are installing it. As in I call the front of the starter the part the gear is on. Tell me exactly what ..starting on compression.. is? Only thing I have ever heard that apply to is locomotives and large stationary engines like they have in municipal power plants in which case they use air pressure. Never heard of it being applied to a smaller engine like in a tractor.
CNHI Super A starter diagram
 
Guessing you figured out that you have to find a way to hold those four brushes back while you reinsert the armature. Lots of creative ways to do it involving zip ties, fingers, screwdrivers, tape, etc..

Also the brass segmented thing that the brushes run on is called the commutator, like a Russian potato.
 
The saddle switch will wear which can cause the contacts to make a poor or no connection. I suggest ruling out the saddle switch before opening the starter.
 
Update: starter turns fine on the work bench, but does nothing on the tractor (still shorting it out to bypass the switch just in case).
Tested the amperage on 3 batteries (all good) even tried using the MF 85 battery which is two honking 6v in series (the farmall is converted to 12v).

So what could it be?

I'm at a loss now, I'm to going try cranking it by hand...
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top