Ia Ag Economics

Icuby

Member
Acording to local TV media this is in real good shape as the farmers are buying big ticket items. This was reported from the ag equip. showing in Des Moines.
 
Here's an interesting article about farming and economics
http://www.brownfieldnetwork.com/gestalt/go.cfm?objectid=436821CC-5056-B82A-D0B9750F2B20F754
in short it says that the number of farms is up???, but when you read further it implies that a small percentage of farms are actually making a profit.
 
I am not a expert or even a knowledgable novis.
But my common sense meter has been ringing off the hook for the last 2 years about this.

Buying land, equipment ect when the price of both are high. based on a comodity that is over valued. Does not make long term sense to me.
maybe if your plan was to get in and get out right away. Ok as long as you dont get caught like the last home buyers did.

If it was me. I would be banking the wind fall and buying the land and equipment for cheap when the crash comes. And it will come.
 
I think everybody should look back farther in
history. My understanding is all models for farm
investment only go back to the 1950's. If you
look at depressions of the late 1800's, 1919, etc,you will see a tremendous transfer of wealth
from rural ammerica to the Wall Street Bankers.
The same thing is happening today under our noses. The result will be lower commodity prices, land prices, and machinery prices. In about 2+ years the rural wealth destruction will
be enormous. Then the cycle will reverse for those that can survive.
 
CAS....how is wealth currently being transferred from farmers to Wall St. ?? Last time I looked, farmers were reporting record income (if you look at a state by state 2008 yr end summary) and Wall St. has gone from a Dow of 14,000 to Dow 7,800 ??? How is wealth being transferred away from farms ? Are you not including current value of LAND.....I find it kind of hypocritical that farmers always want to talk about "things not good" but never take into account the appreciation in land values over the yrs. Not saying it couldn't go down, but just as ANY business would do, at the end of the year you have a net worth which includes the value of your land.
 
I dont see how anybody can say farmers are doing good.If they could find a dummy to buy their land while its high,and get a good price for their machinery,they might sell out now better than any time in a long time.When you consider what it costs to plant crops or raise livestock,the price of equipment and land,and just the same old rip off way the market treats them,all of them should really go on strike.My daughter in law bought a package of steak today at 9 dollars a pound.What was beef today?Not much higher than last year and maybe even lower.
 
Trucker40....we never pay more than $5.95lb for T-bone when it's on sale once month. Everyone has a right to pay more than something is worth but I don't see why you would want to.
I think you are making the point I was trying to make in my earlier post...if you are losing money every year farming...stop. A better farmer will buy your machinery and land..period. I have been attending farm sales for last 10yrs. and I monitor land sales on a monthly basis and I have yet to find any losers. Where are all these farmers who have been losing money for yrs., their current equipment has no value and their land has depreciated ??
 
I just went and looked at the beef and hog prices,both down a lot from last year.My point is farming has nothing to do with the"market".Farmers get robbed,and middlemen get rich.They have gotten away with it so long they think they are entitled to do that.Thats your Wall Street uploading wealth of farmers.
The price of land is high now,it wasnt always,but it will go down.I help a couple of farmers and see that bigger is not better most of the time.Compared to the early 70s to now,a"farmer"struggles to get crops planted in time,then struggles to harvest them.If it werent for Roundup they wouldnt even be able to farm at all.If they passed a law,and Roundup and other chemicals were banned,farming would disappear as we know it now.It wouldnt even take that,a disease in corn,chickens and other things could wipe them out.Very few could survive if they missed a couple of crops.If banks dont loan them money this spring,things can get a lot leaner for everybody.
Basing anything such as you say you do is not even a drop in the ocean as to what is involved.Family Farming is suffering its last pangs of death,there is no sugar coating that fixes it,and what goes on from here is not the best of farmers,its the ones who can get money.Its always been kinda that way,except now its critical.Its actually stupid to try and put a nice neat little explanation on how good farming is when there is so much wrong with it.Maybe if you read a history book,and one that actually is honest,you might kind of see what happened.Easy as I can make it is this,the price of everything has gone up at least 10-20 times what it was in 1970,and farmers pay is struggling to double.Thats a weird way to pay back people you owe your life to.Time to get a new way of looking at things unless you want to starve in the future.Farmers care if you starve,Wall Street doesnt care about you at all,and Wall Street doesnt care about farmers.
 
Trucker40....please give me the names and phone numbers of some farmers who "care if I starve"..... I'd like to get on their list for handouts. Seems a whole lot easier than working and using my hard-earned money to buy food.
Your flawed logic would also then lead to things like Miller/Coors giving me free beer, Toyota giving me a new truck, doctors giving me free health care....oops, somebody else is already promising to do that.
Bottom line, I know many "family" farmers who are multi-millionaires ( in your spare time please once and for all define for all of us "family".) Again, if you are going broke farming...stop. Many, many Americans have had to take different jobs, move to different cities, make drastic changes in their lives....it's called LIFE. Their is no RIGHT TO FARM enumerated in the Constitution the last time I checked.
 
Well,I guess you and I arent going to agree.I gave that a good try to explain it to you,and you come at me all sarcastic.Right to farm?Farmers dont care?Yeah you can believe that!I dont care if you starve either.However in about 20 years,when Wall Street owns all the farmland,and you actually are starving to death,dont say I didnt tell you so.You are so far from anything real,there is no talking to you.I pointed out that "farming"as it exists now is highly vulnerable.You want to make it some big money play.I say farming is not fairly compensated,and you say the big ones will eat the small ones.Thats about to fail completely and miserably.

Look,if you gave a farmer the land,the machinery,everything,he would struggle like the rest of them do unless they own thousands of acres.The only way they own thousands of acres is if somebody gave it to them.For your logic to work,a man has to be able to buy the land,the machinery,and have sense enough to run it profitably.That means its sinking,not rising.Farmers are grossly underpaid for their products and citizens are grossly overcharged for their products.This wont last.Im tired of it already,but younger,madder people will emerge sometime and take it away from greedy hogs that have it now.The sooner the better.We need a big adjustment from the top down with lots of that money flowing the other direction,but not so much it makes us the same as the greedy hogs that have it now.
 
You kind of make me mad with your attack on me and not even saying anything about what I said.Thats dumb on your part,lowers the value of your"opinion"which was wrong to begin with.You are some kind of educated paper pusher of some sort.If its so good farming buy you one and all the machinery.Never mind land is sky high and machinery is in outer space and prices paid to you are scraping the bottom of the barrel.Some real smart guy like you ought to do that just to prove to me how wrong I am.Yeah right and pigs fly!I doubt you would last 6 months.If you managed to plant something that grew it would cost you 4 times what it would a real farmer,and when you harvest and see you are going in the hole instead of making a profit you probably will have a coronary.Then we wont worry about you starving to death because if you dont get to the hospital in time you probably are going to be pushing up daisies.
 
Farming is all about cycles. I saw the property next to me worth $800, $2100, and $900. Those are selling prices. Land has no value at all if you aren't selling. Just like housing, every house in town over inflated for the last 5 years, now it is deflated to less than it should be. That only matters if you were selling or buying tho. Farmland also goes way up & way down.

Grain prices have been pretty good the past 2 years. Grain farmers should be happy. Livestock farmers - not so much. They have had to feed expensive grain to cheap meat & diry producers.

2009 - and beyond - look very scary. Fertilizer costs more than the crop is worth at this point in time. Ecconomy going down, grain prices seem to be headed down too. What do we grow, what do we plan for? Future looks just as scary to us as it does to town folk. Losing your job is scary. Losing the whole farm - is even scarier....

--->Paul
 
As a livestock farmer its not my business to be a social worker and figure who is starving or not and its not the consumers business to worry about whether I'm making a livng or not.Prices go up and down thats just the way it goes and if a person is not ready for that then farming is not the way they should be trying to make a living.The biggest favor the gov't can do is stop all gov't payments to farmers and let the real farmers farm and let the welfare farmers go to work at Walmart or drive a truck.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top