JD 40 U Starting Issue

MZ Ranch

New User
So the background history on this 1954 John Deere 40 U is that it wouldnt start and wouldnt charge. The electrical is the original 6VDC Positive Ground system. The tractor is on a ranch of my sons in Idaho. I worked on it for about two weeks last year and got it up and running by replacing several of the ignition parts that I purchased new. I then had the generator rebuilt last summer at a local rebuild shop and was able to get the tractor charging the battery as we worked with it all summer and this spring. The other day my son turned the tractor off and when we went to restart it, it would not even crank. I troubleshot the electrical system and it seemed fine but on the off chance that the cables were corroded and wouldnt carry the load to the starter motor I replaced them. Also cleaned up the starter motors start switch. This cleared the no turn over issue but still could not get it to start. So we thought we would push start it in third gear. This was probably a bad decision. As the temperature in Idaho was around 28 and the oil was so thick it couldnt drain down through the filter into the lower pan quickly enough and it started coming out the oil fill tube on the top of the engine. When the ignition selector is in IGN my voltmeter shows 6V to all the correct terminals including the coil.
My Questions:
Going forward can you, or should you, push start this type of old tractor?
What might be the next test I can do for not starting with the electrical ignition system now that it will turn over on its own with it's starter motor but won't fire/start?
 
Yes, that tractor can be push/pull started. I would use 4th gear.

I'm scratching my head about your report that oil is coming out of the valve cover fill tube.
Using the dipstick is the oil level OK ?

I had a 40 (once) that had a worn starter Bendix. Every once in a while the starter would "jam" and the engine would appear
to be "locked". The "solution" was to loosen the starter - shake it - tighten it back up - and go again.

My first test would be to pull the coil wire out of the distributor - hold it close to the block - try to start - see if the
coil is delivering spark to the distributor. How much would a couple new plugs cost you?
 

cvphoto78953.jpg


Trying to add a photo of the tractor in this reply. First of all thanks for the quick answer about the ability to push start or tow start. I live in Nevada and will head up to the Idaho ranch in a couple weeks. Maybe when it is a little warmer. I was thinking of buying new plugs even though they were new last summer. Then I will try the coil wire to the block spark test. Should I use a voltmeter when testing the circuit or perhaps a wire puncture wound tester?
 
I think it would be wise to check your
oil level first before you try to crank
it again. If it's correct you need to
pull the valve cover and clean out the
drain holes in the head with a coat
hanger or other piece of wire. It
doesn't drain through the filter. Very
little oil gets to the top so if it's
coming out the fill tube it's almost
completely stopped up with crud in the
head oil drain holes.

If the crankcase is overfilled you have
a bad seal in the hydraulic pump.

Most likely you just need to clean the
points but if the new cables are smaller
than an 0 you aren't going to get the
voltage/amps you need. 00 cables are
better for 6v.
 

6V at rest ........however while cranking it will develop VD and only have 2 or 3 volts to apply to the coil . Not enough voltage to jump a spark across the plugs and ignite the air-fuel mixture .
Needs more battery and less resistance in the cables and connections .
Parts can be replaced but until the voltage is measured while cranking and the voltage drops found . She wont start .
 
You are correct I have not measured for the voltage drop yet. I will do that when I return to the ranch. The new cables are 00 cables.
 
Replaced cables with 00 cables and yes I was planning on checking the oil level and making sure the seal between the hydraulics and the oil isnt leaking through. I dont think it is but with the cold weather in Idaho as we were trying to push start the tractor there is a possibility of a seal being damaged. I will definitely have to clean all the ports out and just for the cold weather Ill probably put in a little thinner oil. As we were push starting the tractor I could observe the oil pressure gauge near the front right side of the engine and it was reading maxed out 40 psi. Any other insight that you have please let me know.
 
"[b:654c4848f0][i:654c4848f0]What might be the next test I can do for not starting[/i:654c4848f0][/b:654c4848f0]"

You might consider replacing the condenser.

You might also consider installing an ignition "[i:654c4848f0]bypass[/i:654c4848f0]".

Take a look at the [b:654c4848f0]Lamps and Ignition Wiring[/b:654c4848f0] diagram below.

cvphoto79015.jpg


Note the non-original, brown lead from the starter switch to the coil.

Take a look at the photo below.

cvphoto79018.jpg


Note the terminal on the side of the starter switch.

Take a look at the photo below.

cvphoto79019.jpg


Note the NEGATIVE terminal on the coil.

Install a bypass lead wire connecting the starter switch and the NEGATIVE terminal on the coil.

When the starter switch is engaged additional voltage is provided to the coil.

Hope this helps.
 
This looks like an awesome idea. Thank you for the great detail. I will definitely try this when I get back to the ranch. Thanks for the help.
 
Thanks for the starter switch pic James. I have hunted for one like that several times in the past and couldn't find it. NAPA, here I come. Lol

Just out of curiosity what was it supposed to be used on?
 
"[b:654c4848f0][i:654c4848f0]what was it supposed to be used on[/i:654c4848f0][/b:654c4848f0]"

Installed this switch on "[b:654c4848f0]1011[/b:654c4848f0]" one of our 1953 Model 70s.

Take a look at the diagram below.

a155461.jpg" width="650"


Note the black wire that is connected to the starter switch and ignition resistor.

Take a look at the photos below.

a155462.jpg" width="650"


Note the side terminal on the starter switch.

cvphoto79184.jpg


Note the black wire connected to the side terminal on the starter switch leading to the ignition resistor.

a155464.jpg" width="650"


Note the black wire from the starter switch connected to the "output" terminal on the ignition resistor.

When you press down on the starter pedal, 12 volt power temporarily goes directly from the battery to the ignition resistor and coil at start up.

Take a look at the diagram below.

a155465.jpg" width="650"


If the ignition switch is [b:654c4848f0]ON[/b:654c4848f0], then once you release the starter pedal, the power comes from the ignition switch to the ignition resistor and coil.

Hope this helps.
 
I totally agree the oil should have flowed through the filter and down into the pan. I am going to make sure all the ports are clear and I will put a new filter in it. I may try
a thinner grade of oil just for getting it back up and running. You guys are great I really appreciate all of your input and your ideas. Like I said earlier in some of the
threads I will be returning to the ranch in either three days or 3 Weeks Weather Highway permitting.
 
I have another coil and I may put it on its the original that I took off last summer. Also as far as the condenser goes last summer I had to ask Napa for a condenser for a
1951 Chevy Engine 6V 235 because it was the same condenser.
You guys are great I really appreciate all of your input and your ideas. Like I said earlier in some of the threads I will be returning to the ranch in either three days or 3
Weeks Weather Highway permitting. I believe the coil is hooked up with correct polarity but I will definitely recheck it. Anyway I can bench test the coil?
 
I have been watching the responses to your post to see what the usuals had to say. My turn. Yeah, the excess oil in rocker cover area is a problem. The good side of it is the valve stems got a good oiling. Could be return holes are sludged up and could be cleaned/opened up. Have to remove hood and rocker cover to find out. As for oil, I use Wallymart house brand and for type of use these old tractors get it seems to work fine. I have a 40 std and it has had 10w-40 oil in it for years, big reason was years back I had to have it start when cold with just the battery. So, go to 10w-40 oil 20-50 for hot summer if you want. The other thing that is most times overlooked with these old tractors is the starter needs some attention. Over the years the bushing dry out, accumulate crud, and cause drag to the rotation of the armature, not helpful when starting cold. Also, the brushes often need some cleaning or replacing adding to poor starter operation. Most rebuilders do not put enough of useful lube where needed. Best to clean bushings with solvent and then soak for a few days if possible in ATF. For assembly I use a mix of Moly grease and ATF, so it is a slurry, use a brush to apply. Lube the drive mechanism, too. Give the starter a good tune up and that can make a big difference. Good cables and good battery should get engine running. I am surprised that there was no solution given by converting to 12 volts. I changed my 40 to 12 volts long ago and am looking to change it back to 6. Reason--When the starter drive hits the ring gear with 12 volts it really woops on the ring gear teeth. I had to replace it on a 440 I bought that was 12v. The engine usually coasts to a stop at the same place so that is the spot the takes the hit. HTH
 
Hey guys, thank you for all of your help. All of your suggestions lead me to the problem. I tested the coil ohms and they were exactly the 1.5 for the 6 V coil. Then I tested continuity through the coil wire to the distributor and it was good. I replaced the spark plugs and tested the spark plug wiresTo the distributor. They were good. I then tried to hold the coil wire to the block to see if I had any spark. With a 6 V system I had none or was so weak I could not see it. My voltameter showed that there was only a slight voltage drop to the coil wire from ignition it was still reading a 5.7 V while we were cranking it over. I did change the oil and oil filter and put in 10-20 weight Wally oil. I made sure that all ports through the block were free and clear so that the oil return to the pan was absolute. I then began looking at the points and condenser and how they were opening on the high side of the cam of the distributor. I found that they had collapsed, or had worn to the point where they were closed all the time. I replaced the condenser and the points, set the Gap at .020 put it all back together, and it fired up like a top. I am now working on exciting the voltage regulator so the amp meter will work with the generator. I have tested it with my voltmeter so I know that it is actually charging the battery.
Sincerely I want to thank you all for your suggestions as they all combined to lead me to my problem.
 
Hey guys, appreciate all of your help. All of your suggestions lead me to the problem. I tested the coil ohms and they were exactly the 1.5 for the 6 V coil. Then I tested continuity through the coil wire to the distributor and it was good. I replaced the spark plugs and tested the spark plug wiresTo the distributor. They were good. I then tried to hold the coil wire to the block to see if I had any spark. With a 6 V system I had none or was so weak I could not see it. My voltameter showed that there was only a slight voltage drop to the coil wire from ignition it was still reading a 5.7 V while we were cranking it over. I did change the oil and oil filter and put in 10-20 weight Wally oil. I made sure that all ports through the block were free and clear so that the oil return to the pan was absolute. I then began looking at the points and condenser and how they were opening on the high side of the cam of the distributor. I found that they had collapsed, or had worn to the point where they were closed all the time. I replaced the condenser and the points, set the Gap at .020 put it all back together, and it fired up like a top. I am now working on exciting the voltage regulator so the amp meter will work with the generator. I have tested it with my voltmeter so I know that it is actually charging the battery.
Sincerely I want to thank you all for your suggestions as they all combined to lead me to my problem.
 
Hey guys, thank you all of your help. All of your suggestions
lead me to the problem. I tested the coil ohms and they were
exactly the 1.5 for the 6 V coil. Then I tested continuity
through the coil wire to the distributor and it was good. I
replaced the spark plugs and tested the spark plug wiresTo
the distributor. They were good. I then tried to hold the coil
wire to the block to see if I had any spark. With a 6 V system I
had none or was so weak I could not see it. My voltameter
showed that there was only a slight voltage drop to the coil
wire from ignition it was still reading a 5.7 V while we were
cranking it over. I did change the oil and oil filter and put in 10-
20 weight Wally oil. I made sure that all ports through the
block were free and clear so that the oil return to the pan was
absolute. I then began looking at the points and condenser
and how they were opening on the high side of the cam of the
distributor. I found that they had collapsed, or had worn to the
point where they were closed all the time. I replaced the
condenser and the points, set the Gap at .020 put it all back
together, and it fired up like a top. I am now working on
exciting the voltage regulator so the amp meter will work with
the generator. I have tested it with my voltmeter so I know that
it is actually charging the battery.
Sincerely I want to thank you all for your suggestions as they
all combined to lead me to my problem.
 
"[b:654c4848f0][i:654c4848f0]replaced the condenser and the points, set the Gap at .020 put it all back together, and it fired up like a top[/i:654c4848f0][/b:654c4848f0]"

Thanks for letting us know the solution to the problem.
 
Hey James thank you for all of your help. All of your suggestions lead me to the problem. I tested the coil ohms and they were exactly the 1.5 for the 6 V coil. Then I tested continuity through the coil wire to the distributor and it was good. I replaced the spark plugs and tested the spark plug wiresTo the distributor. They were good. I then tried to hold the coil wire to the block to see if I had any spark. With a 6 V system I had none or was so weak I could not see it. My voltameter showed that there was only a slight voltage drop to the coil wire from ignition it was still reading a 5.7 V while we were cranking it over. I did change the oil and oil filter and put in 10-20 weight Wally oil. I made sure that all ports through the block were free and clear so that the oil return to the pan was absolute. I then began looking at the points and condenser and how they were opening on the high side of the cam of the distributor. I found that they had collapsed, or had worn to the point where they were closed all the time. I replaced the condenser and the points, set the Gap at .020 put it all back together, and it fired up like a top. I am now working on exciting the voltage regulator so the amp meter will work with the generator. I have tested it with my voltmeter so I know that it is actually charging the battery.
Sincerely I want to thank you all for your suggestions as they all combined to lead me to my problem.
 
Hey 6cyl, thank you for all of your help. All of your
suggestions lead me to the problem. I tested the coil ohms
and they were exactly the 1.5 for the 6 V coil. Then I tested
continuity through the coil wire to the distributor and it was
good. I replaced the spark plugs and tested the spark plug
wiresTo the distributor. They were good. I then tried to hold
the coil wire to the block to see if I had any spark. With a 6 V
system I had none or was so weak I could not see it. My
voltameter showed that there was only a slight voltage drop to
the coil wire from ignition it was still reading a 5.7 V while we
were cranking it over. I did change the oil and oil filter and put
in 10-20 weight Wally oil. I made sure that all ports through
the block were free and clear so that the oil return to the pan
was absolute. I then began looking at the points and
condenser and how they were opening on the high side of the
cam of the distributor. I found that they had collapsed, or had
worn to the point where they were closed all the time. I
replaced the condenser and the points, set the Gap at .020
put it all back together, and it fired up like a top. I am now
working on exciting the voltage regulator so the amp meter
will work with the generator. I have tested it with my voltmeter
so I know that it is actually charging the battery.
Sincerely I want to thank you all for your suggestions as they
all combined to lead me to my problem.
 
Hey, thank you for all of your help. All of your suggestions lead me to the problem. I wasnt going to change it over to a 12 V system, as I kind a like it as a 6 V positive ground electrical system. I tested the coil ohms and they were exactly the 1.5 for the 6 V coil. Then I tested continuity through the coil wire to the distributor and it was good. I replaced the spark plugs and tested the spark plug wiresTo the distributor. They were good. I then tried to hold the coil wire to the block to see if I had any spark. With a 6 V system I had none or was so weak I could not see it. My voltameter showed that there was only a slight voltage drop to the coil wire from ignition it was still reading a 5.7 V while we were cranking it over. I did change the oil and oil filter and put in 10-20 weight Wally oil. I made sure that all ports through the block were free and clear so that the oil return to the pan was absolute. I then began looking at the points and condenser and how they were opening on the high side of the cam of the distributor. I found that they had collapsed, or had worn to the point where they were closed all the time. I replaced the condenser and the points, set the Gap at .020 put it all back together, and it fired up like a top. I am now working on exciting the voltage regulator so the amp meter will work with the generator. I have tested it with my voltmeter so I know that it is actually charging the battery.
Sincerely I want to thank you all for your suggestions as they all combined to lead me to my problem.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top