More tractor troubles...need input please!

WILL1E

Member
1955 Ford 850 that was converted to 12V by previous owner.

A week ago i went to move the tractor for the first time in several weeks. Put the key in an zero anything when i depressed the starter button on it. So i just assumed the battery was dead. Hooked it up to my pickup to try and jump it...still no luck. I let it stay connected for 15min and tried again and still nothing. So i took the cables off the battery, hooked the negative to the frame where the paint is rubbed off and tapped the positive stud on the started and she fired instantly.

Pulled the battery that day and took it home and put it on the charger. Charged said 25% when i hooked it up and she was charged up to 100% by the next morning when i remember to check on it again.

Reinstalled the battery this weekend...same problem...no juice :( So i got the meter out and tried to figure out where the issue is. Keep in mind i'm not electrical savy and i know just enough about using the meter to check voltage and continuity.

**Keep in mind that without the key in, you can hit the starter button and the tractor will try to start. However, it will keep turning over but it won't start.**

Vertical (home) position of the key is how you can insert and remove the key. I think i normally turn the key clockwise when i go to start it. The key will also turn counter clockwise from the home position....not sure if the tractor will start in that position or not...never tried it.

On the incoming power side of the starter solenoid I have good voltage 12+.
Regardless of what position of the key, when i depress the starter button, i never get any voltage at the output side of the starter solenoid.
When i put the probe on the small terminal (not sure where this wire goes) i get a 12+ volt reading when the key is either in the home or counter clockwise position, but 0 when i put it in the clockwise position. When i depress the starter button those voltages drop to zero.

Key at home position:
vgW8mPyl.jpg


Key at clockwise position:
movQc7ql.jpg


Key at counter clockwise position:
Z61QnKZl.jpg


So i feel like this tells me the starter switch is functioning properly. Is it that obvious that it's simply a bad starter solenoid, or do i need to check something else first?
 
Jump across the starter solenoid (big stud to big stud) to see if it could be in the solenoid, you also could have a dead spot on the starter, I have had that once or twice over the last 70+ years, sometimes
you can get the starter to rotate just a little and it will not do it again for many starts later.
 
But wouldn't what i did by hooking the jumper cable to the positive terminal of the starter essentially the same thing?
 
First thing. Have you cleaned both ends of both battery cables and made sure the ground cable is connected to good clean metal? One of the starter mounting bolts is a good connection point. Also check the cable into the terminal end connections, they can fail internally.

Have the battery load tested. It is possible to show as charged and still not be good.

Boosting direct to your starter shows the starter is ok, the problem is ahead of that.

This post was edited by Jim.ME on 11/22/2021 at 06:51 am.
 
What confuses me to is that there is 12+ volts at that little wire on the starter solenoid when i'm NOT touching the starter button, but then it drops to zero when i DO depress the button. I would have expected it to be the opposite.
 


Unhook the small wire and see if the power is on the terminal or the wire. If the terminal is live, the starter button provides the ground to complete the circuit to pull the large contacts in. When you push the start button the light goes out as the button contacts completed the circuit. If this is the case, I expect your solenoid is a Circuit 2 type shown on this sheet "wore out" posted a few days ago.



mvphoto84884.jpg
 
(quoted from post at 09:44:16 11/22/21) ..... put it on the charger. Charged said 25% when i hooked it up and she was charged up to 100% by the next morning .......
f your battery was only 25% charged, it is likely junk. If so, need to figure out why - is there some sort of drain when the tractor is off, battery just gave up, etc.

or do i need to check something else first?
Yes, check your battery. Using your volt meter, check the voltage of the battery with every thing off. Then check it while trying to start. If it drops to zero, or very low, good chance the battery is junk. Have it tested
 
If i wanted to order up a solenoid to be prepared for my next trip up (tractor is 2hrs away), any idea which one i need since it's a converted 6 to 12 volt system? Prefer to order on amazon if possible.
 
OOOhh, geezzz, here we go again... PO changed to 12 v. blah,blah.. Look at pix 1, That is the wrong solenoid to start the tractor using the neutral safety start button on the top of the transmission or the button on the SOS. The start circuit goes from key switch, in one small terminal on solenoid, out the other small terminal and to the push button to make contact to ground, thus engaging the solenoid and closing the high current circuit to the starting motor.. NOW PAY ATTENTION Just because the solenoid has 2 small terminals does NOT mean it has the internal wiring you need. Old Ford cars had 2 low current output terminals but that is NOT the one you need. NAPA did have the correct one some time ago, don't recall part number. I got one that is wired internally correct but the housing has S and I by the two small terminals. Verification by meter is required. Older Western snow plows had the same solenoid to control the pump, don't ask how I found out. Anyway, you should have a unused wire that connects from terminal on solenoid to the start button. And yes, it is a good idea to leave that safety start button in operation. try email if you need more help
 
(quoted from post at 15:02:13 11/22/21) If i wanted to order up a solenoid to be prepared for my next trip up (tractor is 2hrs away), any idea which one i need since it's a converted 6 to 12 volt system? Prefer to order on amazon if possible.
his one on left will work on 12v, but there is a 12v version but I don't know the number.
This type must have the battery connected to proper large terminal. Have you tried a direct ground to small terminal?
be4JrzA.jpg
 
(quoted from post at 17:36:49 11/22/21) OOOhh, geezzz, here we go again... PO changed to 12 v. blah,blah.. Look at pix 1, That is the wrong solenoid to start the tractor using the neutral safety start button on the top of the transmission or the button on the SOS. The start circuit goes from key switch, in one small terminal on solenoid, out the other small terminal and to the push button to make contact to ground, thus engaging the solenoid and closing the high current circuit to the starting motor.. NOW PAY ATTENTION Just because the solenoid has 2 small terminals does NOT mean it has the internal wiring you need. Old Ford cars had 2 low current output terminals but that is NOT the one you need. NAPA did have the correct one some time ago, don't recall part number. I got one that is wired internally correct but the housing has S and I by the two small terminals. Verification by meter is required. Older Western snow plows had the same solenoid to control the pump, don't ask how I found out. Anyway, you should have a unused wire that connects from terminal on solenoid to the start button. And yes, it is a good idea to leave that safety start button in operation. try email if you need more help

Oh geez is correct. An 850 had a 3 terminal solenoid OEM!!!!
 
(quoted from post at 08:44:16 11/22/21) 1955 Ford 850 that was converted to 12V by previous owner.

A week ago i went to move the tractor for the first time in several weeks. Put the key in an zero anything when i depressed the starter button on it. So i just assumed the battery was dead. Hooked it up to my pickup to try and jump it...still no luck. I let it stay connected for 15min and tried again and still nothing. So i took the cables off the battery, hooked the negative to the frame where the paint is rubbed off and tapped the positive stud on the started and she fired instantly.

Pulled the battery that day and took it home and put it on the charger. Charged said 25% when i hooked it up and she was charged up to 100% by the next morning when i remember to check on it again.

Reinstalled the battery this weekend...same problem...no juice :( So i got the meter out and tried to figure out where the issue is. Keep in mind i'm not electrical savy and i know just enough about using the meter to check voltage and continuity.

**Keep in mind that without the key in, you can hit the starter button and the tractor will try to start. However, it will keep turning over but it won't start.**

Vertical (home) position of the key is how you can insert and remove the key. I think i normally turn the key clockwise when i go to start it. The key will also turn counter clockwise from the home position....not sure if the tractor will start in that position or not...never tried it.

On the incoming power side of the starter solenoid I have good voltage 12+.
Regardless of what position of the key, when i depress the starter button, i never get any voltage at the output side of the starter solenoid.
When i put the probe on the small terminal (not sure where this wire goes) i get a 12+ volt reading when the key is either in the home or counter clockwise position, but 0 when i put it in the clockwise position. When i depress the starter button those voltages drop to zero.



So i feel like this tells me the starter switch is functioning properly. Is it that obvious that it's simply a bad starter solenoid, or do i need to check something else first?

An OEM switch was 2 position only, Home (vertical) and on (clockwise horizontal.)
 
(quoted from post at 18:36:49 11/22/21) OOOhh, geezzz, here we go again... PO changed to 12 v. blah,blah.. Look at pix 1, That is the wrong solenoid to start the tractor using the neutral safety start button on the top of the transmission or the button on the SOS. The start circuit goes from key switch, in one small terminal on solenoid, out the other small terminal and to the push button to make contact to ground, thus engaging the solenoid and closing the high current circuit to the starting motor.. NOW PAY ATTENTION Just because the solenoid has 2 small terminals does NOT mean it has the internal wiring you need. Old Ford cars had 2 low current output terminals but that is NOT the one you need. NAPA did have the correct one some time ago, don't recall part number. I got one that is wired internally correct but the housing has S and I by the two small terminals. Verification by meter is required. Older Western snow plows had the same solenoid to control the pump, don't ask how I found out. Anyway, you should have a unused wire that connects from terminal on solenoid to the start button. And yes, it is a good idea to leave that safety start button in operation. try email if you need more help

OOhh, geezzz. Look at Circuit 2. That is an insulated base solenoid, it has power from the battery through the coil to the small terminal all the time, the coil is energized by grounding the small terminal to complete the circuit. You may say it is not be the right one. However, the service manual and parts book show a 3- terminal solenoid (NCA11450A) like this one. It will work with one wire from that small terminal going to the starter button which makes the ground for it when pushed. And many of the aftermarket solenoids found using that part number are listed as for 6 or 12 volts.

To WILLIE,
1. Have you had the battery load tested, given the questionable status first posted?

2. Is the small terminal live when the wire is removed from it?

3. Then what happens if the terminal is grounded with a jumper wire? Make sure the tractor is in neutral before doing this

This post was edited by Jim.ME on 11/22/2021 at 04:32 pm.
 
I WAS WRONG ON THIS HAVE TO EAT CROW. Can this be just switching the battery cable with the starter cable? Should work on the 3 terminal solenoid with ungrounded base. Just forget all that I put in the previous post, I'll go away now..
 
(quoted from post at 23:42:50 11/22/21) I WAS WRONG ON THIS HAVE TO EAT CROW. Can this be just switching the battery cable with the starter cable? Should work on the 3 terminal solenoid with ungrounded base. Just forget all that I put in the previous post, I'll go away now..

If he removes the wire from the small terminal and it has power on the terminal, with the battery cable connected, It is hooked up correctly. If it doesn't then he needs to see if the wire has power on it, if so, that is wrong as power on the wire should only be on if it was a 4 post, insulated base solenoid. Checking with an ohm meter for continuity between the second large post and small terminal will tell if it is hooked up backwards. If that gives continuity, it would likely be connected backwards on the large posts. His saying the small terminal has power all the time and loses it when the button is pushed, makes me think it is hooked up right, and the battery or solenoid may be bad given the starter worked when he hooked booster cables to it.
 
I bought this tractor early this year. Up until this starting issue a week or two ago, i've had zero problems with starting the tractor. I've changed and done nothing with it. So i'm assuming everything was hooked up properly and that this issue is just something failing.
 
(quoted from post at 06:39:01 11/23/21) I bought this tractor early this year. Up until this starting issue a week or two ago, i've had zero problems with starting the tractor. I've changed and done nothing with it. So i'm assuming everything was hooked up properly and that this issue is just something failing.

Remove the wire that connects to the side of the starter button next to shift lever. Insure tractor is in N neutral. Touch the bare wire end to the transmission cover bare metal briefly. The starter should engage when the wire is grounded.

If starter engages, disassemble start button and troubleshoot why it is not making contact with ground(common due to corrosion when sitting).

If starter did NOT engage when wire is touched, use meter on ohms(resistance) scale, and check for continuity from bare wire at start button in your hand, to each small terminal on the start solenoid. One should be near a dead short, less than 2 ohms.

If both terminals show infinite or high resistance, replace the wire from the S terminal of the start solenoid to the lug on the start button switch. If one terminal shows dead short, check that it is the S terminal. Using a known good piece of jumper wire, hold one bare end to the S terminal of the solenoid, and briefly touch the metal of the engine or transmission to complete the ground circuit. The starter should engage. Replace the wire from the S terminal to the button lug.

If the starter did not engage briefly when the S term was grounded, replace the solenoid. Disconnect the battery before removing large wires from solenoid. Clean every wire connection when installing new wires or solenoid.
 
Yes, if it was starting ok and won't start now it is likely something failed and it could be as simple as a wire broke or a poor connection. I have seen a number of diagnostic suggestions given to you to help you avoid buying unneeded parts, and I don't really see any results posted, if you have done any of those checks. Would you please take a couple minutes and answer these questions with the results?

1. Have you had the battery load tested, given the questionable status of the battery when you first posted?

2. Is the solenoid small terminal live when the wire is removed from it? Or is the wire live? (Live as in showing 12 +/- volts)

3. If the terminal is live, what happens if the terminal is grounded with a jumper wire? (Make sure the tractor is in neutral before doing this.) If the solenoid is good. It should pull the contacts in and there will be power on the terminal to the starter motor.

4. What happens if you unhook the wire to the solenoid at the starter push button and ground it?

5. Have you checked the voltage at the battery terminal of the solenoid and then checked it again while the starter button is pushed? Then check the same on the terminal to the starter motor.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top