Need a New Battery

WNYBill

Member
Tractor has room for 2 batteries, but I have been using just one since the other shorted out. Now is is time to replace it. I am going to
stay with just one battery since we don't use the tractor in the winter. Do I buy a deep cycle with 750 MCA or a regular battery with 800
CCA? The regular battery is $50 more expensive.

Bill
 
Regular battery is best for your application. Even better would be 2 regular batteries. Less stress on the starter with the proper voltage/current. You may not notice it but the starter drags (spins slower) with only one battery. Will the starter spin fast enough to start the motor? Yes but the starter life may be reduced. Your tractor, your choice.
 
As I understand it, deep cycle batteries are designed to be drawn down considerably through the use to drive a load, like a trolling motor. I'd recommend the 800CCA.
 
For relatively short term but sudden high current loads such as engine starting, that's what a conventional STARTING battery was designed for..

For lower current longer term deeper discharges (say a boats trolling motor or RV use) that's what a DEEP CYCLE battery was designed for..

Often and typically a DEEP CYCLE is rated/labeled in Amp Hours while a STARTING BATTERY is rated/labeled in Cold Cranking Amps CCA

That being said and even if sure either would still work even in the wrong application

I RECOMMEND A STARTING BATTERY

You didnt ask, I respect YOUR decision, so I purposely didn't get into the use of one or two batteries and the advantages etc..

See what others may use but this is ONLY my recommendation based on experience and what I have learned about how different batteries were designed TO EACH THEIR OWN OPINION THIS IS MINE, LETS SEE IF OTHERS DIFFER or agree with me ???

John T
 
Bill,
RK is my place for batteries. I recently bought the biggest battery I could find for dump trailer. Around 800 CCA, not sure. Cost around $100.

Problem with deep cycle or marine batteries, one year warranty. Other batteries warranty around 5 years. No brainer.
geo.
 
I have a tractor that I switched from two batteries to one. It had room for a group 31 battery so that is what I used. Group 31's are usually priced much cheaper than smaller batteries.

My tractor starts fine even in the winter but it is only a 90 HP 4 cylinder diesel.

I have trouble buying into the It will ruin your starter mindset.
 
Some great advice below. I'm also a big fan of the Group 31 solution, if you have room (including height, as it is a tall battery). Wherever you go to purchase, try to look for the manufactured date/sticker of batteries on the shelf. Get the newest one.
 
Deep cycle batteries are not for starting! There seems to be a big difference in the price of batteries, and I don't think there's that much difference in quality. If you have a Costco membership they sell Interstate, that is one battery that I would pay a little more for, they have a good reputation. Our local L&M has a Durastart, by Exide, 800 cca for $80, and I have had good luck with them. Shop around!
 
WNYBill,

Your application required a SLA battery, start, lights, accessories.

A group 31 is the one that will work for you.
You will be surprised when winter comes,

Guido.
 

Marine cranking batteries will have a shorter life versus a automotive cranking battery.

Marine cranking are estimated to last 3/4K starts
Automotive are estimated to 6/8K starts.

All marine cranking batteries I have seen are overrated when it comes to cranking amps : ( they are short winded for that application.
 
My tractor with CDC [Cummins] 5.9 does well with one group 31 battery. Any chance I get I change the cables/batteries over to the stud/threaded terminals. All group 31. My tractors/combine with CDC [Cummins] 8.3 have two batteries. My truck with Cummins L10 could have more, but also gets by with two batteries. But, it sets inside, and I have the block heater operational when the temperature drops below freezing.
 
(quoted from post at 07:44:36 05/04/21)
If you have the room, I'd put in a 4D sized battery.

Why? A 4D battery is no better in capacity than a Group 31, but costs twice as much, and doesn't last any longer.

The only battery type that presents any capacity advantage over a Group 31 is an 8D but you can do two Group 31's in parallel and have even more capacity in the same space as a 4D or 8D, for less money.
 
(quoted from post at 12:54:13 05/04/21)
(quoted from post at 07:44:36 05/04/21)
If you have the room, I'd put in a 4D sized battery.

Why? A 4D battery is no better in capacity than a Group 31, but costs twice as much, and doesn't last any longer.

The only battery type that presents any capacity advantage over a Group 31 is an 8D but you can do two Group 31's in parallel and have even more capacity in the same space as a 4D or 8D, for less money.

I stand corrected. Just always thought the bigger battery would last a little longer cranking on diesels. I got a 31D at Sam's a couple months ago for 109 bux and the bigger 4D was 149 bux and the 8D was 199 bux. Sam's carries the Duracell brand.

Two 31D's would be about the same price as an 8D.

If OP still has the connector cable, he could still slip another battery if needed during the winter. I use a battery booster when something needs a jumpstart.
 
We have been converting everything to group 31 batteries. Fix bad cable ends and where possible use shorter runs and the tractors will start off a single one usually. Too expensive to have an 8D batteries sitting around going bad. Pretty cheap to switch to gear reduction starter too if needed.

Our tractors that aren't used in winter we haven't bothered with the double batteries. If we do need to start in winter the lithium boost box comes out to help. Also no shame in moving batteries between equipment that is being used, batteries last much longer in daily use than sitting months at a time. Even maintainers are not a substitute for regular use.
 
Got the 31 at Sams, $109, $20 off starting next week, just my luck! Only draw back I see is that is is only warrantied for 12 month, rather than 36 like their car batteries.

Thanks for all the suggestions.

Bill
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top