O.T. Keeping it in perspective.

flying belgian

Well-known Member
When I look at what I spend to insure my pickup which I use maybe an average of 20 min. a day, maybe my health insurance premium ain't so bad for my body which I use 24/7. I don't know, I'm just sayin.
 
Here's the different models of insurance around the world.
No matter how the media portrays them, most are better than ours, because they're service based instead of money based.

There are about 200 countries on our planet, and each country devises its own set of arrangements for meeting the three basic goals of a health care system: keeping people healthy, treating the sick, and protecting families against financial ruin from medical bills.

But we don't have to study 200 different systems to get a picture of how other countries manage health care. For all the local variations, health care systems tend to follow general patterns. There are four basic systems:

The Beveridge Model
Named after William Beveridge, the daring social reformer who designed Britain's National Health Service. In this system, health care is provided and financed by the government through tax payments, just like the police force or the public library.

Many, but not all, hospitals and clinics are owned by the government; some doctors are government employees, but there are also private doctors who collect their fees from the government. In Britain, you never get a doctor bill. These systems tend to have low costs per capita, because the government, as the sole payer, controls what doctors can do and what they can charge.

Countries using the Beveridge plan or variations on it include its birthplace Great Britain, Spain, most of Scandinavia and New Zealand. Hong Kong still has its own Beveridge-style health care, because the populace simply refused to give it up when the Chinese took over that former British colony in 1997. Cuba represents the extreme application of the Beveridge approach; it is probably the world's purest example of total government control.

The Bismarck Model
Named for the Prussian Chancellor Otto von Bismarck, who invented the welfare state as part of the unification of Germany in the 19th century. Despite its European heritage, this system of providing health care would look fairly familiar to Americans. It uses an insurance system -- the insurers are called "sickness funds" -- usually financed jointly by employers and employees through payroll deduction.

Unlike the U.S. insurance industry, though, Bismarck-type health insurance plans have to cover everybody, and they don't make a profit. Doctors and hospitals tend to be private in Bismarck countries; Japan has more private hospitals than the U.S. Although this is a multi-payer model -- Germany has about 240 different funds -- tight regulation gives government much of the cost-control clout that the single-payer Beveridge Model provides.

The Bismarck model is found in Germany, of course, and France, Belgium, the Netherlands, Japan, Switzerland, and, to a degree, in Latin America.

The National Health Insurance Model
This system has elements of both Beveridge and Bismarck. It uses private-sector providers, but payment comes from a government-run insurance program that every citizen pays into. Since there's no need for marketing, no financial motive to deny claims and no profit, these universal insurance programs tend to be cheaper and much simpler administratively than American-style for-profit insurance.

The single payer tends to have considerable market power to negotiate for lower prices; Canada's system, for example, has negotiated such low prices from pharmaceutical companies that Americans have spurned their own drug stores to buy pills north of the border. National Health Insurance plans also control costs by limiting the medical services they will pay for, or by making patients wait to be treated.

The classic NHI system is found in Canada, but some newly industrialized countries -- Taiwan and South Korea, for example -- have also adopted the NHI model.

The Out-of-Pocket Model
Only the developed, industrialized countries -- perhaps 40 of the world's 200 countries -- have established health care systems. Most of the nations on the planet are too poor and too disorganized to provide any kind of mass medical care. The basic rule in such countries is that the rich get medical care; the poor stay sick or die.

In rural regions of Africa, India, China and South America, hundreds of millions of people go their whole lives without ever seeing a doctor. They may have access, though, to a village healer using home-brewed remedies that may or not be effective against disease.

In the poor world, patients can sometimes scratch together enough money to pay a doctor bill; otherwise, they pay in potatoes or goat's milk or child care or whatever else they may have to give. If they have nothing, they don't get medical care.

These four models should be fairly easy for Americans to understand because we have elements of all of them in our fragmented national health care apparatus. When it comes to treating veterans, we're Britain or Cuba. For Americans over the age of 65 on Medicare, we're Canada. For working Americans who get insurance on the job, we're Germany.

For the 15 percent of the population who have no health insurance, the United States is Cambodia or Burkina Faso or rural India, with access to a doctor available if you can pay the bill out-of-pocket at the time of treatment or if you're sick enough to be admitted to the emergency ward at the public hospital.

The United States is unlike every other country because it maintains so many separate systems for separate classes of people. All the other countries have settled on one model for everybody. This is much simpler than the U.S. system; it's fairer and cheaper, too.
 
I agree Belgian, Im glad to pay my premiums for good coverage at a reasonable price and have my choices which is why I pray O Bama care dont take it over and force socialized medicine down our throats and let bureaucrats make our life and death choices NOW THATS A SCARY THOUGHT

"If you think health care is expensive now, wait until its free"

God Bless yall n take care now n best wishes

John T Conservative Christian and Patriot
 
Remember even 25-30 years ago, before the days of HMO's? When people had "hospitalization insurance."

If you stubbed your toe or had a sore throat, you paid the Dr. bill on your own. If you broke a leg or had something else major, the insurance paid.

I'm sure there are lots of flaws with a system like this, but wouldn't it be better than we have now?
 
Nobody gets turned away at the emergency room. It don't matter if you have insurance or not. We have the BEST healthcare in the world. People come here from around the world for treatment. Our system is not perfect, but it is the best. If you get cancer, your best chances of survival is here in the US.
If people like you get their way, our healthcare WILL be rationed. Old people will be out of the loop for care, because it won't be "Cost Effective" to treat them. Oh, they may get some pain pills. But money won't be spent on them for a quality of life operation like a hip replacement. No, that money won't be spend on them. It will be spent on an illegal alien, or some drug addict's new teeth. But, I guess that's fine with you, huh.
You know, one thing I see that bothers you more than anything TLAK, is profit. You always whine about somebody making money. Well, that's capitalism, that's what America's about. To you, nobody should have ANYTHING more than the next guy, no matter how hard He has worked. A richer man should just happily give up HIS hard earned money to some turd who won't get off his a$$ to do anything for himself. That's your America, right?
Jack
 
People lose their homes to hospital bills. I have seen this in my own family. This is the only place I know of that getting sick, or having a child get sick, can cost you your home. I also have relatives in Canada, and none of them wants our system. Quit believing the health industry propaganda - they spend a lot of money to influnce opinion.
 
That's exactly what we should have. But now we have too many people with the entitlement mentality who think they should get everything for free, or as close to free as they can get. To alot of people, personal respsonsibility just does'nt exist. They'll always have their hand out looking for somebody else to pick up the tab.
Jack
 
Well, as one who spent some time in the hospital and run up a bill, I call BS. The money I owed beyond what my insurance paid for, I paid over a span of 10yrs. I paid what I could, some months, I paid nothing. At NO POINT did they threaten to "Take my house". So what was I, a special case? I doubt it. Also, I don't care WHAT THEY HAVE IN CANADA. I don't want some government beuracrat calling the shots when it comes to my healthcare.
Jack
 
A year ago this month I was diagnosed with prostate cancer. stage4 type 7 which is a very aggressive type. I am 77. During treatment the Dr. said that he had recieved a new set of guidelines for finding prostate cancer. They contained a suggestion that men over the age of 75 no longer be screened for PC. Thats because they are going to die soon anyhow so why spend the money? Sounds like more of that is to be. Dr. said that whoever makes those rules has never seen anyone die from PC Lets keep our great system the way it is. Henry
 
Still don't want to believe they're just yanking your chain, even when somebody shows examples. Canada was a big Repug point "we don't want the bad Canada health care", but now you say Canada's health care doesn't mean anything.
So you paid out once, what happens next time, there goes the house?
 
When my children were born starting in 93, my ins paid for one day in hosp for my wife. Medicaid baby factory moms got three days paid by gov't. This is what you have to look forward to. Your hard earned dollars paying for freeloaders, just like how I'm helping buy new cars for many. they're already talking about limting treatment if you are over 59 and have dementia. (everyone, can you say, "communist Russia"?)
 
What are you talking about? Repug point? Answer me this, If Canada's system is so great, how come we always hear about Canadians coming here for treatment? You NEVER HEAR ABOUT AMERICANS going to Canada. Just Canadians coming here. How come, if we have such a "Terrible System"?
Jack
 
Ive been sick and in the Hospital with no insurance. As long as I tried to pay them something each month they were not too demanding.
 
The underlying theory of this as I understand it is that most prostate cancer is slow progressing you will die of other causes before the cancer gets serious.

Areo
 
Right, it's not cost effective to do a screening. What else is going to be deemed not cost efective. Got a cateract in your eye? Well, who cares, you still have another eye. Got a bad hip joint, Well it's more cost effective to just dope you up, you've done enough walking in your life.
This crap they're trying to ram down our throats is far from, just politics, to me. Wake up.
Jack
 
Two weeks ago Thursday I stepped on a nail. Since I couldn't remember the last time I had a tetanus shot, and not having any health care, I went to the 24 hour ambulatory care center at 9:00am.

Even though I "bargained" down the price, it still cost $100 for the admission, $65 for the doctor to look at it, $49 for filled out paperwork, $85 for the treatment room! Then they wanted to have an X-ray of the foot. (To check for fragments and bone injury, another $165!)All of this to receive a $29.00 shot. Lordy!!

Seems to me that costs could be lower if GOOD doctors and hospitals didn't have to pay such high premiums on malpractice insurance, thanks to ambulance chasing lawyers.
 
Geez, show me where anybody said they would stop doing screenings at a given age, Are you part of that angry fringe mob that believes external_link was born somewhere other than Hawaii also? Keep it up, It only helps my side.
 

Thanks tlak. This this most informative and factual post I've ever seen anyone make on the subject.

I don't pretend to know what the proper solution is either, but it seems to me that the for-profit nature of our health care system is what's primarily responsible for making my family's premiums less affordable every year. You just have to look at the percent of GDP each developed country spends on health care to see how we are getting robbed blind.
 
Some things to consider. I have been a nurse for 24 years. Is this "new" government insurance going to fund research? If not who will? Now private companies do it. It may cost a lot for newly released meds, but thanks to the profit motive there are new meds every year to treat diseases. I ANYTHING being done to reform tort laws. In all these other wonderful countries what happens if a government doctor really is negligent? Who pays?In my career I have been called to testify twice. Not sued, nurses have no money, but testify. Had I been on the jury there would have been on judgment. But the minority juries in both cases gave over a million dollars. For nothing. If Dr. Smith has never been sued most likely the malpractice insurance is over half a million a year. If he delivers babies multiply that times 5 or 6. Yes doctors make mistakes, don't you? Yes there are incompetent doctors that should not be allowed to practice. If the best doctor is going to get paid the same as the worse where is the initiative to improve?
Don't even get me started on the class of people who currently get their meds and medical care provided to them through the "free" clinics and the welfare system. Many of who cannot even be bothered to take their free or extremely low cost pill, or go tho their doctors appointments. What are the provisions for these people? Most people have insurance. Take the illegal immigrants out of the equation, maybe 5 to 6% of the population is not insured. Lets get them covered, we do not need to destroy the best system in the world to do it.
 
What do you base that on? Do you have examples of those who have lost their homes due to medical bills?

There were 3 or 4 posts from 1st hand people with experiencs contradictory to your non 1st hand claim.

You can add me to that list. I've had teatment at the hospital, couldn't pay, and they set me up with a payment plan, and asked me how much I'd like to pay. It was all very standard, they even have an office in the hospital just for these arrangements. They are very accomodating to people in these situations.
 
You did'nt see or hear about the town hall meeting. Where external_link told the woman who asked a question about her 90yr old mother, who's in great shape for her age, and who might need a pacemaker. Your man told her that's just what he was talking about, costs involved with putting a pacemaker in somebody that old who's probably not going to be around much longer. Said money would be better spent on medication for the old lady in her remaining time on earth.
What about mandatory "End of life Counseling"? What do you think that's about? They get this plan through, there will be rationed healthcare. They will look for more and more ways to cut costs. You honestly believe they won't?
As far as to where external_link was born. I don't give any serious time or thought to that. He's a proven liar. He's a marxist. The man has been on the world stage all of 5 mins. He had accomplished nothing of any note. But, due to a media that promoted him as a rock star and covered up all those nasty things in his background. He's carried to the whitehouse.
Somebody to believe in, right? Not me, and it seems like an increasing number of Americans are waking up and not buying it either.But, they are the "Fringe" though, right?

Jack
 
No, not all are "fringe" in my view. That was out of line on my part. You may be right, who knows. My views are not so much media induced as you might suspect. We can be worlds apart but so long as you dont reduce yourself to calling me names, I will respect you and your opinions.
 
We will never see any kind of Tort reform. That, would definently help with costs. But, With having nothing but a bunch of lawyers in congress. With those same lawyers being thrown huge amounts of money from their lawyer friends. There's a slim to none chance of any kind of Tort reform.
Jack
 
Uuhhhh...John...
Now, before you go further, sit down, and take at least three slow, deep, breaths, because this may be a shock...
Unless you own your own health insurance company, decisions affecting your life and/or death are now being made by your insurance companies' accountants and executives, people who's primary responsibility is not to you as a policyholder and patient, but to provide profits to the Company, and since greater company profits may well translate into higher salaries or bonuses, it's an incentive to reduce "payouts" (read: your medical care)...
If you prefer that, fine, that's your right; it's still a relatively free country...
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top