plow or disc? food plot for deer.

Braxmaier

Member
Im wanting to plant a food plot for deer,I have come across a dearborn plow in great condition, is it better to plow or use a disc, the disc's I have been looking at are kinda pricey, I have never done either so im here asking, thanks.
 
I plan on doing the same thing for the first time. based on what I have read I will spray the weeds and mow what's left then get a drag for my 4wheeler and use that instead of a disk as I was originally going to do.

what I need to know is what do folks here plant ???

gonna start this week end.
 
I put in right many wildlife plots and I use a heavy offset disk to tear the land up as most of these plots are near or against woods so with a plow I'd be getting into a lot of tree roots.It takes a pretty decent size tractor.I pull an 8ft IH offset disk with an 80HP
tractor.
 
Did someone mention deer plots?
Ah yes, Deer plots.
They are a big deal here and one of the main reasons I have a tractor.
I keep a couple of plots planted up at my land.
They don't need to be tilled up as well as for a garden or crops that you are going to harvest.
If I had only one tool for plots I would look for a Dearborn or Ferguson cultivator like this one. Around here one like this will set you back about $300.

TQ63B_1370640742.jpg


A good disc will do a lot too though. Add some weight to it and make a few rounds in multiple directions and it will cut up the soil well enough for a plot.
If you can find even a pull type disc it will do the job.
This is my buddy Mike going round and round in a new area we planted late last summer.

IMG_20140823_091023.jpg


Of course it's nice to have a plow but you would still need a disc to chop it up afterwards. So if you can only have one tool the plow is not it.

Here is a view from the seat on my main plot. I plow this about every two years. Then disc and reseed.

IMG_20140517_133337-1.jpg


For seed I just go in to the local feed/seed store and buy their big rack mix. It's tuned for your climate/area. I've tried other things but get the best results from a pre mix. It's a mix of clovers, alfalfa, timothy, rape and turnip. About $40 for a bag - enough to do 2 acres. I use a broadcast spreader that I bought on Ebay a few years ago. But when I first started I just broadcast the seed by hand.

100_2065.jpg


Lastly, you will want to lightly cover or press the seed into the ground.
For years I used an old bed spring and pulled it around behind the tractor.
A wide chunk of chain link fence will work ok too.
Last summer though I found this 8' cultipacker and made some repairs on it.
A cultipacker will give you a better germination rate as it presses the seed into the soil instead of covering it. Fine seed does not like to be covered too deeply.
I'm looking forward to using it for the first time this year.

cultipacker2.jpg


Here is a photo of my main plot. About 1 1/2 acres. I tried mixing my own seed that years and put too much turnip in it. The deer really hit it but it choked out the grasses and didn't come back well the next year so I had to replant.

P1010001-4.jpg


Lastly, if you want some comfort you gotta build yourself a deluxe deer stand.
I built this at home and hauled it up to my land on the trailer a few years ago. Then we trenched in power to it for an electric heater, coffee pot and radio for the Gophers games. We can stay in it all day now and that helps a lot.
I have spent a bunch of years slowly getting all the right stuff together for my plots. Improving things, better tractor, adding implements, learning what works and what doesn't. If a guy had lots of dough he could just go out and put everything on a credit card but I can't do that. But it's been fun and it has improved our sucess rate.
In Minnesota only about 35% of hunters harvest a deer each year.
We have improved on that so we are somewhere close to double that. We don't hunt big horns. A good spike or nice doe (when we get a permit) suits us just fine.
Sorry this got so long. But when you mention deer plots and hunting, I kinda get cranked up.


100_14051_zps90c5002b.jpg


After 50 years of freezing my behind in a stand I guess I've gotten soft.

100_14071_zps00c54766.jpg


100_12941_zps8febb85a.jpg
 
I am similar to T. Farmer. Either use a disc or chisel plow. You don't want to plow very deep because of roots, stumps, etc. that you will find. All you need is to basically scratch the surface. Mow, remove cut material, spray with herbicide, work ground, spread seed, lightly cover.
 
The common procedure for field prep is to plow then disc then drag then plant. If soil is soft enough, you can get away with just discing after you clear of weeds. Mow down high grass/weeds with bush hog, then use Round Up to treat the remaining weed roots. After a few weeks of decaying remnants, you can plow or disc the field to get soil ready for a seed bed. Small areas can be planted with a hand spreader (best)then covered lightly with a drag harrow or by using the rear gangs only on your disc harrow, set to just lightly cover seeds. The key is to work the fields every spring and/or fall. This will ensure that you won't have to plow all the time. You can usually just disc the fields and get the seed bed ready to plant. What to plant depends on your area. Contact your DNR or local grain elevator store as they will be able to tell you what works well in your area. I plant rye, buckwheat, turnips, rape, wheat and brassicas. Being in farm country, there are plenty of corn and soybean fields and though the deer won't touch those until late in the season. For turkey I plant sorghum. What seeds I buy in the spring will depend on prices too. Some years the prices can get high on many seeds. Sorghum has a poison coating on the seeds so be careful handling if you use that. I disc the fields in the spring, plant buckwheat and let grow all summer. After it matures and goes to seed, I'll disc again in the fall and plant rye, wheat, rape, or wheat for winter. Based on studies by my conservation club, turnips have become a good choice lately too. Shoot straight...

[i:654c4848f0][b:654c4848f0]<font size="4">Tim *PloughNman* Daley(MI)</font>[/b:654c4848f0][/i:654c4848f0]<table width="100" border="1" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" bordercolor="#000000"><tr><td height="25" colspan="2" bgcolor="#CC0000">
<font color="#FFFFFF" size="3">*9N653I* & *8NI55I3*</font>​
</td></tr><tr><td>
TPD9N100.jpg
</td><td>
TPD8N100.jpg
</td></tr></table>
 

You could have a decent food plot by just spraying then using a disc. That's if you're planting clover. Mostly anything else i would want to plow first. You will need a heavy disc to dig in good so plan on adding weight to any disc you buy. They are pricey, especially this time of year. Go slow for the first couple of passes. You mainly just need to break the ground to mix in the fertilizer and lime(again I'm assuming clover). Another option that may work is a set of cultivators, cheaper than a disc but may not be good in heavy soil.

As for what to plant, variety is key. If the area is big enough do three strips. I would plant buckwheat in one now and beginning of sept replant with oats and white clover. Plant the other two in crimson clover now. Replant one mid July in brassicas and the other in Sept as a cereal grain (winter wheat or rye)
 
We use a Dearborn/ferguson cultivator and disc also. This year we are going to bring up a 2 bottom and break some new ground. We also use a hand spreader to plant and drag it. I'd like to get a cultipacker one day. We built a stand out of an old walk in cooler last fall. Ultradog we've been buying mixed seed from Rivards. We're going to plant some sugar beets this year. The deer love them. Last year we didn't get a good kill on the weeds so we will have to replant this year. We have such sandy soil where we hunt that by the end of the fall if we don't get the rain everything burns up from the sun.
a189078.jpg

a189079.jpg

a189080.jpg

a189081.jpg

a189082.jpg

a189083.jpg
 
Plow is followed by secondary tillage, to work the soil down and level things up, creating a seedbed. First, it would be good to know the soil conditions or where you'll plant, is it sod or rootbound with weeds, brush, or tree roots, stumps or any of that?

A moldboard plow will turn the soil over completely, and you can learn how to use a moldboard plow without difficulty, plow needs to be in decent shape, good shares at least. If you have thick tree roots or rock, it would be advisable to use a plow that has trip back, shear bolt or reset type, the latter you just back up to reset it after it trips. Spring trip is usually found on larger plows, mostly used by farmers for crops. Its possible you could use a subsoiler to sever roots, but with both of these, using an N or similar with no weight up front, a loader or something, I don't believe you'll want to use ground engaging implements like these where there are lots of interferences in the soil, given the potential.

If you have clean soils or the site is been cleared, just sod, or root bound soil, moldboard plow is an effective way to start.

Good friend has a cultivator like Jerry shows in the picture and we have used it to start new patches, takes a lot of passes, you will drag and bunch up clods, rootballs and clumps of sod mixed with soil, sometimes it will perform like a backblade. It would not be my first choice on new ground, but it does work, probably even better in soils with more sand or not as dense, or compacted. Its a good implement to have, friend has that one, I have the rest, plow disc and cultipacker. I don't recall using it after plowing yet, only concern would be going too deep and catching or dragging up sod, probably best to use it diagonally across the area in the same direction as the furrows were turned over, increasing depth a little at a time.


Plow and disc, or just a disc, or the cultivator, being my last choice, could work. A lot of the seed used for plots is smaller, so maximum tillage depth, may not have to be done, nice to have a deep seed bed for roots, depends on the plant. I think the worst is spending money on more expensive seed and not having the soil right. A poor job with the tillage, not turning the grass/weeds under completely, will show lots of it coming back. Initially, plowing is one way to get a good kill, I don't use chemical sprays or weed killer, for the most part and I've been able to get decent stands, might use it if I did imperial clover again, just to get it established, or spot spray later to keep it to a minimum.


Whitetail institute offers some nice products, expensive seed, but worth it. However, the local feed or supply store or elsewhere(off the web) may have something to fit a budget, I've planted a lot of oats mid to late summer, because its cheap and but works and does benefit the deer immensely, the larger the plot the better. Feed oats will provide a nice lush patch if planted in dense populations.

You should do a soil test, amend as needed, then till, plant etc. Small seed is planted shallow, oats being a larger seed, can go 1-1/2"-2" into the soil and you can plant them after plowing, and one pass with secondary tillage, I plant oats like that, plow then one pass withe disk, broadcast seed, then one more pass with the disc to finish, it almost looks like it was planted with a grain drill, meant for planting crops like oats.

Whitetail institute website will provide lots of information about food plots.

The 3rd video is entertaining and educational, check it out at 9:44 minutes in ! Nice pair of late model Ford industrial tractors and some blunt advice LOL !
Food Plot Instructional

Food Plot Instructional 2

Video with Ford industrial tractors in food plots
 
Great pictorial, I get cranked about plots, its a great hobby, is that a McCormick Deering cultipacker, ( soil pulverizer as they call it LOL !) ? I just picked mine up, 7' I think, had it 2 years but it was at the other place, I just disc'd up my lawn for overseed and smoothing, will be using it for the first time, though I've run a 12' Brillion, this one I own, needs a few wheels and one axle endcap has a piece of out of, looks repairable or I could make a new cap without too much trouble. Friend has the same cultivator in a ferguson, not the wide shovels, the narrow cultivator type, though its not my first preference, it was a good find and we have used it quite a bit with good results for sure, he's got some nice garden patches, we want to set it up for row crops. I don't see those very often, he was lucky to find it, but between us, we have all the implements at least.
 
Depends on the soil for me. If I can rip it with my cultivator,
like the one UD pictured, I use that. If the ground is too hard
I plow then disk. I use a 9 foot "oat roller" to roll the seed down.
I fill the barrels with water to roll my yard too.

mvphoto19258.jpg


mvphoto19257.jpg


I have this JD cultivator for sale on CL. It's a beast!

mvphoto19259.jpg
 

Haha, bet you were sitting in the shade enjoying a cold one and waving each time he went around and around...lol :)
 
Im going to pick up the DearBorn plow to day or at least look at it,by the pictures it looks to be in great shape, am I able to ajust the depth of the plow to just go in about 6 or so inches,its pretty much an open field with thick weeds, its all been mowed over and weed killer is on it now, I just dont want to buy it then not really need it when I could use the money on something different. 300 is the price of it. thanks for taking the time to help me out.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top