Polarity again

JohnNKy

New User
OK. playing devils advocate or just the village idiot, I do not see that the coil +/- or bat/dist coil connection has any meaning. Looking at the construction of an ignition coil the primary wiring is simply a coil of wire around the outside of a secondary coil of wire & iron core. No direct connection of any kind between the primary & secondary... all induced. So what difference could it make in the current coming in from the left or the right so to speak, if all it is doing is making a big or many circles around the other winding?
8852CG03.gif
 
Well, I can't give you a scientific explanation, but I have a practical example. Back in the 60's, I went with my Dad to look at a '49 Chrysler. The owner said it was real hard to start - especially warm. My Dad bought it, took it home and started trying to figure out the problem. The coil was wired backwards. He switched the wires and never had another starting problem as long as he owned the car. He didn't change anything else, so I'm confident that switching the wires was the fix.

Doug
 
Well,........this topic has been worn out! But, I realize that not everyone has been here to read every post, so here is a briefing. If you want more, ask, I have MORE than a boat load of other material.
Hope this helps.

The Question:

Someone has written to me with a query about ignition coils asking which low-tension terminal (+ or -) on the coil should be connected to the distributor contacts on a positive earth car. All my coils are marked SW (ignition switch) and CB (contact breaker). There are various numbers on the base of the coils and also a letter, some are L, others R or LO.

Obviously somebody thought that polarity matters otherwise why mark the terminals at all? Are coils different for positive and negative earth cars or should positive earth cars connect the SW terminal to the distributor?

The real problem in this case is engine cutting out due to coil overheating, could this be caused by incorrect polarity?

The Answer

There is a good reason spark coils are wound the way they are. Positive and negative ground coils have their windings thrown (wound) in different directions in relationship to each other. Spark coils are always wound in such a manner so that the high tension connection on the coil goes negative when the distributor points open. This means that the rising potential at the spark plug is also negative. Why would one want an operating condition where the rising pulse from the spark coil is negative?

The center electrode in a spark plug runs hotter than its grounded electrode. Since electrons can be striped off of a hot electrode more readily than off of a cold electrode, the center electrode is always made the negative electrode. The result of this choice is that the arc across the spark plug electrodes can be initiated at a slightly lower potential when the center electrode is the negative electrode. (In this manner, thermionic emission aids in the establishment of the initial discharge.) As Pete observed, his vehicle will run with either a negative output or a positive output from the coil. I have operated my TD with the incorrect high tension polarity from the spark coil for over 20 years. So it requires a slightly higher potential to strike the arc - big deal. This polarity reversal occurred when I converted to negative ground so I could more conveniently install contemporary electronic devices. I never bother to fit the 'correct' negative ground spark coil.

After the arc (plasma) has been initiated, the circuity oscillates and the thermionic emission consideration becomes meaningless.

Conclusion -- The coil will work and your MG will run no matter what you do. If you want to be sure that you have the slightly more desirable initial negative output then pay close attention to the polarity of the primary connection. The primary terminal marked (-) must connect to the (-) terminal on the battery.

Also, Think about a vacuum tube. The purpose of the heater filament is to heat the cathode (negative source point for the electrons) to increase electron thermal energy/mobility so that they will more easily depart as they are attracted to the Positive plate of the tube. It is physics. A very good analogy is the heating of water such that molecules can leave the liquid body, evaporation.

The next point of confusion: The high voltage provided by the secondary circuit of the coil has absolutely nothing to do with whether the battery is POS or NEG ground. That is determined by the direction of current thru the primary of the coil and by the direction of the physical windings of the wire on the coil's core and the way the primary and secondary wires are connected. We can't change the last two items inside the sealed coil, but the manufacturer can. We can change the current direction by connecting BAT+ to coil + and BAT - to coil -, or BAT+ to coil - and BAT- to coil +, thus causing the High Voltage out to be either NEG or POS as we choose. EXCEPT, EXCEPT in the case of the front mount distributor Ns, where due to the lack of easy access to the coil's points side connection (springy thing), you really do not have this choice. Somebody will say I'm wrong & that you can reverse these connections...yes where there is a will there is a way, but do you want to butcher your tractor? There are thousands of Ns, just like the MG running around happily reversed. The difference is too minor to loose sleep over, contrary to mis-information spread about "loss of 40% energy" and other such bull.
My opinion & more! Free! No charge!
Happy tractoring!
:)
 
Oh, and by the way Mr. Weaver, when & if you read the associated post by me, I am NOT saying that you & your Dad are/were wrong, rather that there were likely other issues/weaknesses at play that caused this normally insignificant difference to be material.
Sometimes a single grain of sand tips the scales.

Where possible, make it the best possible configuration.
 
John..........did you know that depending upon the direction the coil is wound, (CW or CCW) the polarity changes??? Now that is profound. Known as the "righthand" rule of thumb ...or... is it "lefthand" rule of thumb??? Dang.....I gottz CRS.

The common ignition coil is called an auto-transformer. Meaning that internally, the 2-windings are connected together for a common connection (usually ground) and in this case, the POINTS. Remember, I told you ground can be both negative and positive at the same time.

As I said, incorrect coil polarity can cost you up to -25% of yer sparkie kilovolts output. In a good fresh ignition system, thats notta problem. But when normal wear and corrosion occur, that missing 25% kilovolts can be the difference between starting and running well.

This becomes a GREAT PROBLEM with the weaksister frontmount 1-terminal squarecan ignition coil which is internally hardwired for POSITIVE GROUND and can't be changed for negative ground battery installations. (6-volt shadetree mistake or 12-volt alternator)

Yep, ya gotta pay attention to coil polarity for longer ignition life. Sometimes they're labled "P", "I", "D", "(-)", for the points connection and then the hot terminal can be labeled "BAT" or "B", "I", "S", "(+)". Nowdays, most roundcan ignition coils are simply labeled "(+)" and "(-)" and "use with resistor". Many mechanics only know about 12-volt NEGATIVE GROUND. Like, who ever heard of 6-volt POSITIVE GROUND???....DUH!!!.........Dell, yer self-appointed sparkie-meister
 
I had an experience much like ddweaver. My new employer bought me a new 79 Dodge Pickup back in 78 as part of the hiring package. That thing would "die" and have to be started again about 10 times to get me home 13 miles in stop and go Houston TX traffic. The Dodge Dearlership was no help,"not doing it now", as in in the automotive stall. Indepentdent Garge finally found it after changing many parts. Primarily wire to Secondary and vice a versa at the coil. Changed that, then it was just a Dodge.
 
Thank you for that very informative and easily understood explanation.

I suppose there are literally hundreds - maybe thousands - of N tractors out there (including mine) that have been converted to 12 volts without any thought to polarity. We polarize 12 volt tractors negative ground, because that's the way alternators are made.

I wonder if the 12 volt square-can coil I bought when I burned up the 6 volt coil by leaving the ignition on overnight, is polarized correctly for negative ground? No way to know, and nothing to do about it if it's wrong, as you pointed out.

It's good to know, though, that this could be the grain that tips the scale if I'm having unexplained hard-start problems.

Historically, it's interesting to see how this developed. My 1923 Model T was built as 6 volts, negative ground. Still is. Somewhere about the time Ford switched to the Model A (1928) the thinking of engineers was that Negative meant charged with electricity, and if the body of the car was charged, leakage to the earth could occur in rain or snow, or if you parked touching a bush, etc. They also worried about wire wheels, which replaced the old wood spokes, and tire rubber with a high carbon black content, making for more leakage. They used this theory to explain frequent dead batteries, which we now know was mostly due to poor construction of battery cells. So, they switched to positive ground. That continued into production of the N tractors, which were built 6 volt positive ground. Later, when other car makers stayed with negative ground and science proved the "leakage" theory to be less of a problem than thought, Ford switched back to negative ground, and as far as I know it's now universal world-wide.
 
In almost ALL "Kettering Ignition System" ignition coils, the coil's primary and secondary ARE connected. Depending on the construction of the coil, this common point of the two windings is either the (+) or the (-) terminal.

It really doen't make a whole lot of difference WHICH way the coil is made, as the resistance of the primary winding is so small as compared to the resistance of the secondary winding.

Ignition coils are actually a sort of "autotransformer".

<img src = "http://www.stephenbottcher.net/~omega/coils/coil1.jpg">

<img src = "http://www.eng.cam.ac.uk/DesignOffice/mdp/electric_web/AC/02145.png">
 
You have to watch what you are doing when using coils maked "BATT" and "DIST" or synonyms of those works.

A coil designed for a (+) ground system and marked "DIST" and "BATT" will produce a reverse-polarity spark if used on a (-) ground system, and vice-versa.

The results are obvious, when viewed on an igntion 'scope.

That is apparently why MOST coils, especially replacement units, are simply marked (+) and (-).

Simply matching the polarity of the coil's primary terminal connected to the points to the battery ground polarity will give a spark with a "negative-going" leading edge.
 
At initial startup, the center electrode and the ground electrode of the spark plugs are BOTH at ambient temperature, so I can't see where the "hotter spark 'cause of thermally-enhanced performance of the center electrode applies AT ALL!

HOWEVER, as soon as the engine is running the center electrode heats up more than the ground electrode, enhancing electron emissions, so NOW spark polarity matters, for less chance of mis-fire WHEN RUNNING.

Does anyone agree with this... I see NO way for spark polarity to affect starting, when the two electrodes are at the same temperature, just the benefit as soon as the plug's center electrode begins to heat up when the engine HAS BEEN STARTED.
 
What about a magneto? Every time the rotor turns 180 degrees it reverses. So in a 4 cylinder engine, 2 plugs fire + and the other fire - . Right?
 
You're absolutely correct on the mag thing.

The fact is... as long as the spark is MORE than adequate, there will be no misfire. There's simply enough voltage to ionize the mixture in the spark plug gap, and FIRE it!


Also, MANY modern cars have a waste-spark system, where each coil fires 2 spark plugs, one with (-) polarity, and one with (+) polarity.

The whole secret is to have ENOUGH spark voltage to do the job!
 
Ignition 'scope peculiarity...

Traditionally, automotive ignition 'scopes typically display the secondary spark pattern INVERTED... with the leading edge RISING, making it easier to read peak spark voltage on the graduated graticle scale, even when connected to a system set up correctly, with the leading edge of the spark pulse "negative-going".

Some have an "invert" option, so you can view the trace in it's actual perspective.
 
Yep.. I agree.. Look at the original application of the coil, and then define bat/distrib from that original application polarity setup.

Ditto on the autotransformer issue., waste saprk, et al.. etc..

Soundguy
 
Coil polarity, and this spark polarity is going to be a neglible issue in most cases.. IE.. the small ohm primary winding either in line or not inline with the secondary.. As you have said.. not much difference other than polarity.. Also with metal deposition/erosion.. it will be perhaps measurable.. but negligible.

I would tend to agree with you.. Since if you look at ratio of starting time to running time.. the starting time befor ethe electrode heats up is infintessimal compaired to normal running time.. Overall.. I'd say it's better to have tha hotter electrod bonus during running.. and not worry so much about it during the start condition.. etc.

Soundguy
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top