Re: Narrow vs wide fronts?

Janicholson

Well-known Member
Narrow front and wheel brakes will out corner wide front by miles. Sandy loam is not an issue at all. Mud and clay can be gooey
and more difficult with narrow. Wide fronts ride a little easier but are not as nimble. A 300 and a 460 are derived from an H
Super H series and are not in the class of a 400 or 450. A 560 is in the range of your desire, as is a 656. H and M are not
going to be modern enough to do the things you expect easily. Jim
 
I think the term or idea you are
considering is flotation.
Does a NF have as much flotation as a WF?
My opinion is: Under 'normal' circumstances
there is not much difference.
Perhaps there will be someone here who has
some extreme example they can relate.
If they do, ask them if their extreme
example falls under 'normal' circumstances.
 
I have a 25 HP Farmall H, NF. Handy as all get out, but it is old, and only 25 HP Maximum. I think you would work something
like that to death, quickly. But it turns on a dime, pretty short turning radius. I got hold of the same tractor, H, 25 hp,
but wide front. and it took all day and half Armistice Day to turn it around. I went right back to NF. HOWEVER, I also have a
Massey Ferguson 240, 48 HP, wide front, and it turns on a DIME, very powerful, diesel, sips fuel. Just FYI.
 
Talking about a narrow front are you referring to a single front wheel, called a row crop. For my mowing I use a wide front, meaning two front wheels. I
think these are much safer around hills. a single front wheel will turn shaper. Stan
 
I logged for several years with an Oliver 88 narrow front on some pretty steep hills here in S.E. Ohio.
I did it because it was how I was raised. BUT I don't think I would recommend one for a novice on a
tractor like that especially working in the woods. The only ones you will find now are at or near 50
years old which is no problem if they have had proper maintenance. As far as bogging down, I believe I'd
be more worried about the rear wheels bogging down in sandy soil, now in mud, it's a different story
unless you have mud scrapers on the front wheels. I still own both narrow and wide front tractors, but I
would, if I were you, (and you can do what you wish)look for a wide front. I believe you will be happier
and at least feel safer on one. Just keep in mind that either can roll over backward or sideways if the
operator isn't careful. Just my thoughts, Keith
 
If muddy wet the narrow front can sink in some and plow with the front wheels though if that wet you don't need to be there. A wide front will go along better in muddy snowy conditions yet we have not really had a problem with a narrow front in many years with those problems. Bigger concern over time is the wheel bearings will collect mud between the wheels in clay type spoils. All the rollover stories are just that old wives tales. We are not flat and not all real hilly and nefer tipped on over using it yet in 75 or 80 years.
 
I agree with the other comments - narrow ones turn better and with the same tires generally have the same flotation.

Could be me but feel the wide front is more stable - nothing to back it up -- just my feeling. I'm also not a fan of the center wheels when cultivating -- just like the rear wheels to follow the front ones down the row - personal preference

Also look at the 666 and 686 (Last of the M design) as I think the engines are better and the D312 doesn't have glow plugs. It will start really well in the cold if you have good batteries -- but your in FL so not sure that matters.

The M, Super M, Super MTA, 400 and 450 are probably only availabel in gas and not sure I would want then in Diesel. For the 560, 656, 666 & 686 you want to spring for the Diesel.

Hydro is a good choice for transplanting, harvesting and hey work as the speed is infantly variable and really slow for transplanting. You set the throttle (and PTO speed) they move the lever for the ground speed

Not so good for tillage as you loose too much HP to the wheels - you want the gear version for that. The super MTA had the option of live PTO (note that not all came with live PTO).

The 686 (gear) will handle a 3-16 rollover plow in clay soil and no problem with a 8 or 10 ft disk. Regular M will only handel a 2-16 trailing plow and pull a light 8 ft disk. Yes their are aftermarket 3 point hitches for the M but unsure if they are strong enough for a rollover plow.

They all can handle a loader but limited by the 2 wheel drive. later models are better with power steering and more weight.

Big difference in operation comfort between the M and 686 as you would expect. Power steering, better seat, ergonomics, and the natural progression from a 1930/40's tractor to one in the 1970's

Good luck - I'm fan of the tractors listed.
 
I disagree with some of your comments. The M, Super M, Super MTA, 400, 450 are all available in diesel. The M is the oldest, obviously, and was made from 1939 to 1952. The M will handle a 3-16 trailing plow or a 10 ft tandem disc. Many Ms, Super Ms, and Super MTAs have had aftermarket power steering kits added. Not certain but I think the 400 and 450 both had factory power steering. Why would a 2 wheel drive limit their use for a loader?
 
Hard to beat an older narrow front tractor for cultivating veggie crops. C or Super C Farmall tractors work great and will handle a
small tongue pulled bushog well. Wide front Super A or Allis B tractors are great also. Eight acres is not a lot to take care of
and any of these tractors equipped with correct sized implements will work well. When looking to purchase it would be to your
advantage to get a tractor with correct implements (cultivator, plow and disc) if possible. If looking to expand acreage in the
future you might want to look at a slightly larger unit.
 
Amazing speed of replies here. thanks to all of you.

Keith molden:
I hadnt thought that the rear wheels could be a bigger concern over the front. Interesting. Shows you how I know little. So would this mean I should consider wider rear tires? I had the same thought about NFE vs WFE, it just seems the supply is very limited for WFE. I do admit that I am putting stock in my emotional want of a beautiful old tractor over feasible function. Its good to see you dont seem concerned about NFE in this soil.

37 Chief:
By NFE Im referring to the two small cambered wheels close together rather than two wheels spaced far apart like the rears. NFE is attractive to me for the turning radius, as Ive read many people say navigating these in the woods and in tight spaces is much easier. For mowing I cant see it making much difference NFE or WFE.

FBH44:
Yes, I definitely want one with 40-50Hp. 25Hp is too little. Im operating under the assumption that you should buy more than you need currently, as you will find use for it.

Ultradog MN:
Ive not heard the flotation term. Thanks. I imagine thats what Im after. Will the NFE and WFW perform/maneuver/handle the same or similar in this soil is the question. Sounds like youre not concerned. Thats good.

Janicholson:
sounds like youre also not concerned about the performance of NFE in the sandy loam. Thats good. I understand 300 and 460 coming from the H are not as powerful as the 400. I just have a few of each around me to choose from, but the only WFE is a 460 gas. Seems like M could do a lot according to other posts I've read on here, but maybe not without some mods. I honestly dont care much about making it easy as I really enjoy antiques and I want the immersion of the old tractor work. But I fully understand what you're getting at. When I get to needing to do things more easily for money and time savings I would certainly go for something more modern and streamlined. There is a 560 available near me. Would a 400 be a good choice overall if I could find a good one? I'm going to look at a 460 gas WFE soon. Whatever I buy will be restored or at least well maintained and cared for, as they arent too costly for me.

Ed12345:
Thanks for all of this. Also sounds like your take on floatation is the same. Good. When you say you wouldnt want certain models in diesel, why? There are a few MD tractors available around me and I was considering them as a possibility. It has seemed from the beginning that live PTO is what I should get. When youre talking about hydro vs gear youre referring to the actual implement itself being hydraulic or direct gear drive from the PTO, correct? Im not entirely set on having a loader for this first tractor, but obviously it would be immensely helpful. The only hesitation I have about NFE is with a loader. For that I would 100% want WFE.

Im currently in Maryland, preparing to move to Florida. Trying to decide if I should buy a tractor here and trailer it down there or try to find one there. It seems I have a much better selection here in Maryland and PA than I do in FL, but putting a big tractor on a trailer and hauling it 1,000 miles seems silly. Anyone disagree? It seems hard to find something nice where I'm going. Functional and good, sure. But nice and appealing to me, not so easy. Maybe I'm being too picky.

Thanks to everyone so far...
 
A my Farmall 560 with wide front is a north south tractor. I dont like it to maneuver in thight areas ,hard to see over left right fenders. Its a
brute and I love it for what it good at plowing ,combine ,disk .

I have a Farmall c with narrow front ,great for maneuver,excellent brush jogger,sickle bar mowers,raking hay ,baler ,small combine. Small
plows ,disk

I have a super c with wide front not good with maneuvering tight spots does everything thing the Farmall c does. They say C are for 50 to 80
acre farms .

Up to you but wide fronts would buy with power steering and live power.

Consider the ford 3000,4000 and 5000 . Ive used a 5000 row rop and its an excellent tractor also
 
If you want 3pt hitch power steering live hydraulics and live PTO then for get most all of the letter series tractors from IH the live PTO didn't come around till the supers and the price jumps for them some. If you want those things on a tractor move on up the 06,56,66 series tractors some models are not much more and it was not built like Live PTO and hydraulics were an after thought. I think one of the reasons for the rust and dilapidated looks down south is the sun and the ocean is not that far away at Marianna FL that you said was where you were looking to move to. There is also not a lot of agriculture around there like some other places a bit further away. Think of sand somewhat like driving in snow for getting around in. The hydro is not the implement but the type of drive in the tractor. It is hydrostat like in your lawn mower sort of.
 
A Farmall M is a very poor substitute for a 460. A Farmall 460 has independent PTO and hydraulics and about 45 HP at the draw bar and most (all?) have power steering. On an M everything stops when you press in the clutch - and an M only has about 28 HP at the drawbar. A Super M has 44 HP at the drawbar - but no IPTO and only a few have independent hydraulics.

The 400/450 are good tractors except they are thirsty and tend to go through a lot fuel no matter what you have them doing. The 560 is the evolution of the 400/450 with a 6 cylinder engine instead of the big 4 cylinder engine. The gas engine in them is fairly economical when used for light duty work (mowing, raking baling) but when pushed hard (plow) will burn more fuel than the 400/450/M. The diesel engine in them is very economical to run but have more than their fair share of head gasket issues. A 460 has the same engines as a 560 only with a smaller displacement in the both the diesel and the gas. While not as economical to run as the H/300/350 they are fuel efficient doing light work but again - the gas version can suck down the fuel when pushed hard.

A narrow front vs a wide front isn't much of an issue except in mud. A narrow front is more tippy than a wide front and it can become very apparent running through a field with a big round bale hanging off the loader on the front of the tractor. My dad owned 4-5 narrow front tractors and had 8 boys run them for years without issue. One brother did roll a tractor on the back side of a terrace - a 656 with a wide front that he thought wouldn't roll because it was a wide front. I noticed it the most cleaning out feedlots - the narrow front would get so clogged with mud that the wheels would quit turning and the tractor was cutting three paths through the mud were a wide front is cutting two.
 
Every run of the mill average M I have had on the dyno is around 50 hp. A healthy 400-450 is 57 hp on dyno. 460/560 a step backwards from 450
 
Think for a moment as the NFE as relating to the form of a tricycle. Now compare a tricycle to a kids 4 wheel toy car. Which will turn over the easiest on a 25 degree hill? The
tricycle of coarse right? Now you see the point right? Wingnut
 
Oh Ron Ron Ron. If you ever went from a 2 wheel drive to a fwa with a loader you would think you died and went to heaven. Will a 2 wheel drive work with a loader? Yes, we all did it and got by good but once you get a fwa you would never want to go back.
 
I wouldn't worry that much about the front end, I'd be more worried about the back end. That's to say, at least for me, a independent PTO and a three point hitch (NOT a Formal Fast Hitch) would be a must. I'm not that familiar with Farmalls, so I don't know how much newer than the ones you're looking would have those options. John Deere had them with the 20 series starting in 1957 or so and lots of other makes also had them maybe earlier.
 
Thanks. I've also looked at JD. Just they seems to be way more expensive than comparable Farmalls. At least around here. But maybe you get what you pay for. I will certainly look at them.

A short tangent, but what about utility models? There seem to be many of those around here also. To me it seems the lower height of them would be restrictive for food plot and some field work. But again, I am new to this. I understand there are uses for row crop and utility versions. Just thinking which would be best as an all around first tractor. I'm sure I will have multiple at some point.
 
I ask you to consider the fact that the toy car had no suspension and a far lower center of gravity. Thus there is no pivot point at the front at all and it is lower to the ground with smaller wheels. A wide front has a pivot under the radiator that is totally flexible (in the tractors we are discussing) the limits of axle tilt will allow the entire tractor to be freely tipped to the side such that it is already beyond the flipping point. There is a slight edge to this pivot point, but it is not a critical component. The stance and weight of the rear wheels is more directly involved. Jim
 
Never owned any flat ground so never had a narrow front. But I would never own a tractor without live PTO and 3 point hitch. Unless you are a
teenager...I suggest you climb on and off the tractor 10 times in a row...like when hooking up equipment or opening and closing gates, to see
if it is doable. Some older tractors require gymnastics....easy once....but tough 20 times a day.
 
If I were you, I would find a good 5000 Ford. They have all the features you want, are economical to run and parts are very affordable and
available. One of best older tractors made and about as bullet-proof as you will find.
 
I'm a Farmall guy. The Ford 5000 may be great for you. My comment is the Farmall 460 (& 560) and the Farmall 450. I owned a 460. Now I own a 450.
The reason I got rid of the 460 is because it was so darn unhandy. It took a country mile to turn, even tho mine was a NFE. When you sit in the seat
of a 460 (and a 560 is similar) and look forward, the hood looks like the deck of an aircraft carrier. It is long and does not turn sharply. I owned
a John Deere 3020 at the same time as the Farmall 460 and the difference was night and day IN FAVOR OF THE DEERE. It was a truly a new generation,
powerful, but handy, turned sharp, etc. while the Farmall 460 was the newest version of the 1939 Farmall H. I do like my Farmall 450 as it has the
live pto, power steering, fast hitch adapted to three point, etc. Good luck in whatever you choose. kelly
 
I have used narrow and wide fronts on the
same ground, soft worked soil, medium
hills, and flat. The narrow front with the
aid of brakes does a much better job. Does
not ridge the soil on turns and is easier
to turn tight onto the next pass, such as
drilling wheat. All tractors require common
sense, and just like cars, those that don't
have it, get sorted out.
 
(quoted from post at 16:01:45 10/04/22) Every run of the mill average M I have had on the dyno is around 50 hp. A healthy 400-450 is 57 hp on dyno. 460/560 a step backwards from 450

Yeah, don't try and tell any of the old timers around here that an M is a poor replacement for a 460. The IH dealers tried marketing the 460 as a replacement for the M in this area. More than one farmer demanded their M back because their tired old M could work circles around the "gutless" 460's. Most refused to buy the 460 after a few times around the field on the demonstrator model.

Farmers around here really didn't upgrade until the 706 came out. Lot of M's and a lot of 706's around here.
 
Either one will go over just as easy. The wide front axle pivots on a central pin. If on a 25 degree hill, and some maneuver gets the uphill wheel off the ground, the front of the tractor will rotate freely on the pivot, until it hits the stop. Momentum will take it the rest of the way over.
 
PTO dyno is different than drawbar. The factory claimed 28 hp, at the Nebraska test they made 33. Personally I've never seen an M on a dyno - but around 30 HP sounds right with a 248 CI engine with only 5.6:1 compression. After 60-80 years if the average unit in use as a farm tractor is making 25 hp (if its even running) its probably doing pretty good.
 
Wasn't alive when they were new - but I find it funny that both the factory and the Nebraska tests found the 460 about 30% to almost 50% more powerful than an M - but what do they know.... If they were
trying to move from a 450 to a 460 and found it lacking that would make sense.

To be honest in our part of the country it was the exact opposite. 460s and 560s were bought up as fast as they could be had - especially the 560s, and the 706, 756 tractors are rare. The early 706 had the
exact same engine options as the 560 - moving up in weight class with little improvement in power wasn't considered much of an improvement. The 806/826/856 sold well but the bigger tractors like the 1206,
1256, 1456, 1066, 1466 were huge sellers. Tillage was a big tractor (90-150 hp) job, the smaller tractors were doing cultivating and hay. The guys that never farmed more than a quarter their entire lives
were still scratching out a living on 80 acres of row crop probably did tell themselves that their M was a great tractor.

I now own a 706 with the D282 engine - it works well for running a big round baler and doesn't get pushed around by it. We bought it because it was cheap and was in good shape. We were looking for a 656
sized tractor but our 8465 baler would push it around on the hills and the brakes had a lot of trouble holding. I would dread having to use a 706 as a heavy tillage tractor - the power just isn't there.
560s and 656s in my area that are in good shape still sell high - but most are in completely wornout condition and even those seem overpriced.
 
The MD was a gasoline start engine

Start in gas and then switch over to diesel. Just more complicated to use. - More to go wrong

Hydrostatic is the type of transmission the tractor has. The 656 came with a 5 speed or with a hydrostatic transmission like many garden tractors. Great transmission except for tillage. You loose 25% of the go to the drawbar. And they dont hold up as well as the gear ones

But for transplanting cabbage, harvesting, loader work you cant beat them

I believe live pto was first available with the super MTA as an option. So you want something newer than that. Id recommend the 666 or 686

Saw some other posts talking about the Ford 5000. It was also a really good tractor and one to consider. The Ford 4000 is also really good as are the older 800 series . Certain 800 power masters came with live PTO. Think it was the 860

Dont think you will go wrong with the fords or IHs

IH was the top dog until the JD new generation tractors. The 4 digest model numbers. IH messed up a little and did come back with the 806 which was a really good tractor that competed well against the 40x0

The JD transmission. Was a big improvement in that era of tractor along with the shifting

For the price the IH or Ford will be hard to beat and think they are just as durable/reliable as the JD

Guess it comes down to the color you like
 
Yes their was a diesel option but think a gasoline start diesel just adds more complecation. Even the glow plug models could have difficulties. Very few early diesels were sold which is why I believe avability is limited.

For the clay soil I referenced lets hook up the 3-16, fill the tires, add the cast iron and drop to first gear.

For the clay type of soil the M is better matched with a 2-16 in 4th. We tried a 3-14 on the M but it didn't pull that well. This was for spring planting - we had 2 m's plowing all day long when I was a kid.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top