Starter Problem

Stephen Newell

Well-known Member
I've got a Case 210B which has had starter issues ever since I've owned it. It uses a Prestolite MBG4105 starter which I've had two different places overhaul over the last few years. I also purchased a used starter from someone which I've had to replace the brushes
once. Now I can't get either one running. I found a new Gladiator brand starter I could get for about 300 bucks with tax or I could have both of the old starters overhauled for about the same price. The only catch is the overhaul shop is about a 2hr drive one way and
I would have to make two round trips. What do you think would be the best?
 

Hold on before you go and buy a third starter.
Just what exactly is nether doing not working?
Suggestion asking
What voltage are they?
Did you test the battery ?
Is it the right battery for that tractor design?
Are they the correct cables For the tractor?
What the voltage drop throughout the cables with starter engagement?
I always find it something simple I overlooked in starter system I neglected to check.
 
Any chance the problem is with the ground strap? Maybe needs a heavier gauge strap, or better strap-to-ground connection.

I once knew of a vehicle that went through starters. In the end, it was the ground causing the issues.
 
Is this the same 210B that you had to use a cheater pipe on a 15 inch crecent to get the engine just to turn? Might not be the starter's fault. Do you have a hydraulic pump that may be deadheaded?

Beagle
 
Stephen Newell,

By your description had started issues ever since I owned it. It's not the starters.

From overworked, too small for the application,
To low voltage at the stater, and possibly wrong size cables, battery, hydraulic pump drag to name a few.

Guido.
 
I read the post from 2018 where you were having starting problems.

The engine being hard to turn does sound suspect, but after all this time, if there were something binding the engine, whatever it was would have freed itself up or reared it's ugly head by now! If it were bound so tight the starter couldn't turn it, it would be noticeably underpowered, having trouble idling, and would instantly stop when the ignition was turned off, not coast for a second and settle to a off compression stop as a normal engine does.

Before taking the starter off, do some basic tests. You'll need an analog volt meter.

Scratch a clean spot on the case to hold the ground lead of the volt meter against, hold the other lead to the actual cable that goes into the starter. Not the stud on the solenoid, but the eye of the wire going into the case.

Get the engine warmed up so it will have trouble turning over, pull the coil wire so it won't start, have an assistant crank the engine. The reading will jump up and down as the engine hits each compression stroke, but it should stay up in the 9 to 12 volt range. If it is dropping down to a lower voltage, chances are the starter is not getting the voltage it needs.

Move the test leads to the battery posts, the posts themselves, not the cable ends. Take voltage readings again while cranking. If the readings are considerably higher, there is a weak connection somewhere between the starter and the battery. Could be a bad cable end, dirty/loose connection, bad solenoid contacts. Keep moving the volt meter leads, systematically narrowing down where the voltage drop is, always testing under load. Also feel for hot connections along the way. A hot connection is a bad connection.

If the low voltage traces all the way back to the battery, could be a bad battery. Try a known good battery.

If still low voltage with a known good battery, that is an indication of the starter drawing too many amps, especially if the battery cables jump and get warm.

A starter drawing too many amps can be caused by worn bushings, shorted field windings, or back to something holding the engine back.

Might take a look at the bushings and the inside of the starter in general. Discolored field windings, burned smell, black, grainy brush commutator, especially any that appear a darker color are a sign of a shorted armature.

With that information, you can decide whether to save the starter or go with a new one. Might call the starter shop and get a price from them on a new one. Sometimes they can come up with a better price.

Are you using Ft Worth Starter and Generator? They have good aftermarket prices, not so good on rebuilding.
 
Steve@Advance,

Way too many starters burned up. You are right about taking voltage readings at all the spots.
Started lug is were he should be taking the voltage drop. A 12 volt starter should have a minimum cranking voltage of 9.6 volts. You would be hard pressed to see much more voltage above 10 to 10.5 volts at the starter lug.

Anything lower then the 9.6 volts will increase amp draw and generate heat. Sooner or later the smoke will come out. There are a few tings he can do to find the problem, but this long distance guessing is really just that.
We are assuming that the cranking time is kept to the proper time, AND the cooling time following that,

Guido.
 
It's not a lack of ground, I have run an auxiliary ground wire right to the starter. Anyway I've had the starter off three occasions this last week. I opened it up and checked the brushes and polished the commutator. It still won't run testing it on the bench.
Since I had the starter overhauled in 2018 it's been doing a lot better however I've had to replace the brushes once since then. Probably don't have more than about 100 hours on the tractor since 2018. I think the starters are just too wimpy for that tractor. What has helped the tractor hard starting more than anything is I put the biggest battery in the tractor that would fit.

I believe the place I used was Advanced Starter Service in Dallas.
 
The starter I have just had on the tractor was on the tractor when I bought it. Don't know if one like that was put on by case or not. I do believe the starter is too wimpy for the tractor but I don't know the HP of the starter or if there is a larger starter that would fit the tractor. It wouldn't be low voltage, the tractor and starter were originally 6v and has been converted to 12v. The cables are about as big as they come and I put the largest battery in the tractor that would fit. I don't know about the hydraulic pump. As old as it is I don't think it's dragging.
 
Yes it's the same tractor. I don't know how to tell if the hydraulic pump is deadheading. The front loader seems to be working very well.
 
Since I've been having starter problems I've gone overkill on everything. I had NAPA make me a set of cables and big as they could do. The battery is the biggest I can fit in there. There was some voltage drop when starting do to the way the engine just takes a lot to
turn over. I think really the starter is too small for the engine.
 
Stephen Newell,

You answered your own question. If more cranking amp capacity alleviates the problem, you have a VOLTAGE drop somewhere, as I pointed out on my other post. Burning brushes in 100 hours? Get your volt meter out, any type will do, and find where you are dropping the voltage.

You are looking for 9.6 volts at the starter lug while cranking, you obviously do not have the 9.6 volts at the starter. You are doing pretty much the same thing, and hoping for a change-fix.

When you do the voltage thing you WILL find the problem,




Guido.
 
Stephen Newell,

Here is how you can find out what your starter is drawing in power. Power is volts times amps = watts.
Measure the volts and the amp draw at the same time. 1 H.P. equals 746 watts,

Let me know what you find out. My e-mail is and has always been open.

Guido.
 
I don't see how I could be loosing voltage anywhere, The tractor is so simple about the only thing running at the time is the starter. I think it's a combination of a tight engine and a too small starter. Might be why they only made about 300 of those tractors. Anyway, right now I don't have a starter to do any testing. I was going to take both starters to the overhaul shop today but the car had a flat tire and the tire shop can't get to it until Thursday morning.
 
Stephen Newell,

I read a bit more of your post, and it sounds like the hard start issue is happening when the engine is hot. A wrong starter would do just that. Is it possible that the starter is getting too hot?

Some car starters have to have a heat shield on them, as they would not start when the engine was hot. SO even with everything checking out fine, the extra heat on the starter was the culprit.

But you really should you voltage readings when the engine will not crank over, then you will know for sure, you can then concentrate on the starter. There are shops where they load test the starter if you can find one. But they will test it at room temperature, not at the temperature that its not working, that is why you need to know the voltages at the the terminals

Guido.
 
Yes, before I had the starter overhauled when I got the engine up to normal running temperature I couldn't shut the tractor off. It had to cool a minimum of 20 minutes before I could start it again. With the engine hot the starter wouldn't turn the engine one revolution.

Not sure how hot the starter was getting under normal circumstances. Occasionally when it got stubborn the starter did smoke a little. I did when cranking on it whenever I saw any smoke and let it sit for a couple hours before trying to start it again.

According to the parts manual the starter listed is an autolite MZ4176 which is a 6v starter. What I have is a autolite MBG4105 which is a 12v starter. I don't know what other difference they are. They don't say what HP they are.
 
Stephen Newell,

If it starts cold, it must be the starter then. Cool it down with water when it happens.
Run water on the body of the starter. I have done that on top mounted started solenoid.
A thermos and creek water, saved me from walking home.

I would call the starter people and tell them your situation you would bring the starter in and wait for it. Maybe they can get you a better one?They may do just that and save you some time and money.Worth a shot,


Guido.
 
I picked up the starters from the overhaul place today. The one I didn't know the maker was a Delco, still don't know the model number. I asked them about the HP to get a feel for the size of the starter and they told me 2.6 Kilowatt. Still don't know how that translates.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top