welding classes cancelled at Cornell

Anonymous-0

Well-known Member
I recieved word the other day that the Dean of the Cornell Ag school is removing a couple very popular welding/metal fab courses from the ag curiculum. These were known for generations as "arcs&sparks". The reason...to be able to use the lab space for storage. So now ag students graduating from Cornell will have recieved NO instruction on how to make the kind of day to day repairs that keeps machinery in the field or the modifications that improve the performance of machinery in use. This shows how out of touch these administrators are with the realities of life on the farm.
 
And yet our local technical college is adding welding classes due to the demand for welders in Wisconsin. Seems a shame they are being cancelled at Cornell.
 
Hi Mike. You are correct in believing these educators do not have a clue to wat the real world is all about. How is everything down your way? Farmers have started harvesting soy beans around here and alot of corn has been chopped.
 
Not necessarilly...... Show's how IN TOUCH they are with folks that are in a position to drum up work for local businesses.

Pretty sad huh???
 
How much does a year at Cornell cost? $30k? When I looked at attending (12 years ago) they were around $24k/yr. If someone is going to spend $120k on their bachelors degree, they can probably afford $300 for a night class somewhere, that will be more usefull for real world repairs anyway.

Cornell has been out of touch with the real world for years now. But that is just my opinion...
 
For that money they should be able to get that schoolin' as part of it not have to fill it in somewhere else.
We all know that all the scientifc and management skills can be nullified by a broken widget on a machine that needs to be in the field not in the shop.
 
I've gotta go along with Mathias- when I went to Washington State U 40 some years ago (Tuition: $199 per semester), it would never have even occured to me to take a welding class- In fact, I don't think they even had them, except as a brief part of the Ag Mech curriculum, just so you'd have some familiarity with the process. Of course, most of us learned to weld in high school or on the farm in those days.
 
Silage is mostly all chopped in Cayuga County. A few beans have been tried. No corn yet. A good hard freeze is needed to speed up the dry down. Wheat is going in now. Very little good wheat this last summer. It all sprouted due to wet humid weather.
The 730 runs good with the taper lock flywheel. I had to make a tool (with skills I learned in those classes) to push it on so I could get the end play dialed in. I couldn't get it right using the hammer method.
 
I heard this as well. I was a recent graduate of Cornell and took these welding and woodshop classed. To say that if we can afford to go there means that we can afford a night class is an ignorant statement that reeks of a bit of jealousy. I will tell you that I worked my butt off to be able to afford to go to school there. This college is a leader in education and technology and is a very good ag business school. The man that teaches these courses is very down to earth good guy. He has tons of experience and know about farmyard repairs. The things that that man taught me are priceless and it breaks my heart to think that maybe he will get the boot after 20+ years. There are electronic petitions going around I need to find them and sign them. Everyone else that likes young people to be educated to do real world hands on things should sign them too.
 
Shortage of welders here in SEIA as well. I am taking a night welding class at the local welding supply house. I have been welding since high school as a farmer, but never really formally trained, have really picked up some good info....Jim
 
I had a chance to go with my grand daughter to my high school. She was thinking of attending that school. I was supprised to see the metal shop, and wood shop were not there anymore. Just a sign of the times. I learned a lot from those classes. Stan
 
Hey, at the University of Illinois the south farms that were established in the 30's and 40's are quickly being turned into athletic fields and other sports facilities. Some smart person figures that agriculture isn't important and the grocery store will have everything that we coould ever need anyhow.
 
Cornell has an unusual structure. Part of the colleges under the University's umbrella are private, and others are state schools. The tuition varies widely between the two. The College of Arts and Sciences is on the private side and has a tuition in the typical Ivy League $30k range you cited. It's parallel, The School of Industrial and Labor Relations (ILR), offers access tot he same curriculum but is a state school, and its tuition is more in line with the flagship schools in the SUNY system, with resident and non-resident tuition rates. The Ag school is one of the state schools.
 
I guess it's all about priorities, here's my story. When I visited Cornell in High School they boasted the worlds largest English 101 class, at over 1000 students in the class. In my mind that isn't something to be proud of. I was accepted to Cornell, RIT, and Clarkson, but I actually went to SUNY Morrisville for my AS in Engineering Science, saved $30k, and was a class ahead of the private 4 year schools. Because I worked by butt off, I was debt free after my first 2 years.

I then looked at (and was accepted to) Cornell, Clarkson, RPI, and RIT to finish my Bachelors in Mechanical Engineering. I choose RIT becuase they have a mandatory CO-OP program that forces students into 15 months of real-world experience before they graduate. It still cost me $17k/yr for the 3 year program. I graduated with only $10k of debt, becuase I worked that entire time. In case anyone wonders, I graduated with honors from both colleges.

6 years later, I can honestly say that real world experience seems to be the only thing employeers actually want. Most of the stuff they throw at you in college is either garbage or forgotten anyway. Since graduating I have taken night classes in machining and welding. They were actually useful this time, because I had use for the knowledge.
 
Find out the names of the Board of Director's ( Trustees ) of your College/University.

Go visit with each one of them one-on-one and discuss your concerns.

Folks making personal appointments to discuss their issues with the Trustees will "carry more weight" than names on a piece of paper.

Your board trustees will probably be business people, not academics, with family or financial "ties" in the community.

The Trustees have a lot of influence on the "operation" of the college/university.

Let them know that you and all your family voted for them in the last election.
 
Find out who is responsible, and weld something big up in his office, make sure they have to cut it up to get it out the door!
 
Isn't it a matter of supply and demand? I seriously doubt that any university is going to cut a class that routinely has 100 percent enrollment. And I doubt that most students who attend Cornell do so because of its welding program, regardless of how good it might be.
 
i took the welding courses 40 years ago at cornell. they have been very valuable in keeping the aged equipment around here in operating condition. sometimes "progress" isn't progress.
 
Matt H mentioned that the instructor has 20+ years teaching the class, that makes him in his 60s at least. Maybe he retired and the college decided not to replace him.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top