Whats stopping you?

connor9988

Well-known Member
Location
Central Iowa
I see plenty of people attending plow days especially on youtube but I don't see many new faces competing in plowing competitions these days.

To put it simply, why do you think that is? Are there some barriers to entry for you? What do you think would make it easier for more new faces to get into plowing competitions?

Thanks
cvphoto146940.png
 
I would need a plow, then a tractor that would be worth putting into the dirt (yes I have a trailer queen, but do have others that aren't) and then I would have to find one around me. Then I would have to figure out how to set it up correctly. Lastly, I would have to have a place to store the plow. Would I love to learn, yes, but will I ever be able to, I don't think so.
 
Most clubs/associations do not take to outsiders despite any advertising they may put out to the contrary. They are founded through a small group of like minded neighbors having a common purpose. Then soon somebody wants to know if a person outside the group can join. Friction soon results as the newcomer is not accepted. Before long it is decided there is not enough money coming in for club dinners and events so the club advertises for new blood to participate in meetings and events. So now more people that do not have the same outlook on things as the founding members. If the club survives all that it shrinks down to near its original membership. No newcomers to events. I'd love a plow day to go to but I don't see an invitation coming. A corn picker event would be nice as well but they are not done around here to my knowledge and I am sure insurance would need to be addressed.
 
None around here that I know of. Also whenever someone posts a picture of a tractor and plow on here how long is before others are ridiculing them for not having it adjusted perfectly. Constructive criticism with advice is fine. Very seldom does anyone do that. Just not worth the headache.
 
I have been to a few plow days, our local Ford group held several over the years. Now some are gone and all are older. We had a great time and most tractors were equal. Went to a couple by our local Power club,they had a miss match of plows and tractors, some only set 3 or 4 inches deep. Others 6 or 7 hard to plow behind a 3 inch deep furrow. Due to the flue none for a few years. They were fun but my tractor hauling days are fewer now. joe
 
Plowing competitions may not reflect modern day practices in either the desired end results or the equipment used today. Fifty years ago two and three bottom plows were already obsolete and used units were mainly purchased to plow the family garden plot.
 
I've pulled a 4 bottom behind a Farmall M. It works but it's a load for that tractor. I don't know of any plowing events around me. There are a few antique tractor pulls but it seems that you have to be a part of the good old boys club and newbies aren't generally accepted. Heaven forbid one of the new guys actually wins the competition! The GOBs throw a tantrum and cry foul and accuse the winner of cheating. I know one guy who used to only go to pulls he knew he would win. If he thought someone else was going to have a chance he wouldn't enter. That's the way it is around here anyway. Maybe that's what happens at plowing events too?
 
Plowing has become non-existant in modern day farming. Modern day farmers are selling thier plows if they happen to have one around. John Deere has even quite producing plows. Everything has went to no-till (around here anyways). Young farmers around here have likely not plowed even one day in thier life. It is a rarity to see somebody even plow thier terraces anymore. And if you do happen to see that, it's likely just an old timer who is just doing what they always did.

That said, back to your question, new clubs are generally started by who? Younger guys, right? And if they don't have an interest it? Or worse yet, never have done it in thier life?

I went to kind of an Old Homes Day last summer. Wasn't really a plow day, but they were demonstrating alot of stuff at the event. And plowing was open to the public (could plow with your own tractor and plow in between a certain time frame). I would say 15 to 20 tractors plowed that day. But they also had a tractor show and a tractor parade. I don't think they would of had as many tractors that plowed that day, if they hadn't of already been there for the show and parade. Meaning, some wouldn't of came if it was only for the plowing. Basically all the tractors that plowed, were also in the show and parade. Only about 1/4 of the tractors in the show, also plowed. But about 90 percent of the tractors in the show, were in the parade. This was all at the same place, on the same day.

So out of all three things (show, parade, plowing), the show was clearly the most popular, with parade trailing a close 2nd, and plowing being a far behind 3rd. This of course is just looking at the popularity at this one event.

I have thought about trying to start up a plow day. But one of the guys that I thought would help head it up with me, actually lost interest in old tractors. His interest kind of turned to other things. And I've always had concerns about the number of both participants and spectators. How well it would go over? Figured if I got the participants, the spectators would either happen or it wouldn't. But when my friend lost interest in old tractors themself, I figured the numbers on the participant side was likely to be thin at best. Figured if I started a plow day, it would end up being just me that plowed with nobody watching. And you sure aren't going to build something up from that.
 
Yep, people often get in the way of the very objectives they claim to be seeking. As to the relevance of plow days today for quite a number of years it has been a social event and sometimes a bragging opportunity. It was never about educating the public about a practice that was becoming increasingly irrelevant.
 
Attracting "new blood" is a problem with just about any activity or organization. There are many reasons.

Could be the people, as mentioned earlier. The old pharts bellyache about how no young people are interested, when they're the ones driving the young people away with their poor social skills, cranky natures, and bad attitudes.

Could be the perception of the activity. Take plowing competition for example. The perception of that is, stuffy overdressed old Englishmen putt-putting across the field on weird old tractors you've never heard of, pulling weird old plows you've never heard of. Then some other stuffy overdressed old Englishman comes along with a clipboard and a stick, pokes the stick in the ground, takes some notes, and moves on. Wow. How could young people NOT want to do that? Seriously.

Sometimes you just have to face the reality that it's an activity that nobody wants to do anymore. The people that used to participate have either lost interest or gotten too old, and it's so far removed from the younger generations that they have no interest in it.

Even if there were plowing competitions around here, I would not attend or participate because it's of no interest to me. If someone were to have one of those crazy "speed plowing" competitons, on the other hand, I might have to check that out.
 
One of the clubs I was in had a plow day. I mentioned bring a 6 bottom plow and was told they wanted smaller 2-3 bottom. Our smallest is a 4 bottom and it is 75 years old about. The 6 bottom is around 50 years old now. So I gave up on the idea. Then I saw where they had a plow day and most of it looked like they were only plowing about 4 inches deep. I think the guy that owned the ground ran the chisel plow over it all so it would be even.
 
I love plowing and do about 3 areas per year plus a sizable garden usually using my Farmall M and 3-14 JD plows from the 1950's. I would like to one day take one of my smaller tractors to what around is called just plow days where people basically show up to just play with their toys. I would not like to be in an actual competition where someone can tell me the furrows aren't straight, plowing too deep or not deep enough, not pretty enough furrow, etc. My plowing is plenty good enough once working up the field is done to grow a good crop even though I don't plow as deep as some people and certainly can't mark out a perfect first pass. I've never heard the crop complain.
 
A couple thoughts,
As far as plowing competitions, they are few and far between where I live. I went to my first one ever (as a spectator) last summer and was surprised at how technical those guys were. It looked fun but would take a lot of practice to match the skills I saw. Tractors and plows were dialed in within fractions of an inch.
As far as plow days - they too are far and few between. Most farmers around here don't want their field turned over with a mold board plow. If you are in the gov't program, big brother is watching and if you don't leave enough residue on your field, you are subject to fines. I would like to attend plow days if not too far away but www searches turn up nothing within driving distance.
I have a handful of tractors and plows that need to be worked but nowhere to go.
It's been 45 years since I did any amount of plowing so I'm ready to give it a go again.
 
There are a number of reasons:
1)The next generation is not joiners. They do not join clubs or organizations as their forefathers. They do thing have other ways of interaction that we do not understand and/or care for.
2)The plows on most farms, including mine are gone except for 2 single bottom horse plows that are rusted decorations in the garden area. Therefore equipment is hard to come by..
3)We spent many hours following a furrow, the next generation never have plowed. It is an antiquated method of farming that they have no interest in.

You have to remember what is fun for us, probably is not fun for the next generation. Im sure you remember when your dad wanted to do something he thought was so much fun and you just wanted to go somewhere else.

BTW: besides last fall in Andover SD, the last plowing contest I attended was at my cousins farm in the 1960s. The local dealers,JD, IH, MM, Ford & Case were competing for real.
 
I have never attended a plowing competition where one is graded. I do however attend as many plow days as I can, both as a spectator and participant. I am now able to attend more events and would like more information on these in northern
Indiana, southern Michigan and northern Ohio. More fun for me than pulling.
 
Still plenty of smaller plows including trailer, IH fast hitch, and AC snap coupler styles around these parts. Got my eye on a 3 bottom barely a quarter mile away from me. Kind of sad that the paint has weathered off of it. Made around 1960 I remember the original owners keeping inside when not in use and looking like new at their auction in 1975.

Clubs and organizations have taken a hit as people who belong do not know how to be truly sociable on average. I am sure many younger people can recall how their parents were snubbed by such clubs or grandpa's heritage was unacceptable. Even if somebody got in a lot of times they got treated like crud.
 



Barnyard

"Could be the perception of the activity. Take plowing competition for example. The perception of that is, stuffy overdressed old Englishmen putt-putting across the field on weird old tractors you've never heard of, pulling weird old plows you've never heard of. Then some other stuffy overdressed old Englishman comes along with a clipboard and a stick, pokes the stick in the ground, takes some notes, and moves on. Wow. How could young people NOT want to do that? Seriously."


I'll bet that less than one in a million Americans have any perception of plow competitions and one in a 100 of them have any perception of the Englishman that you describe , LOL.
 
Never seen a competition except in pictures. I dont know if id be interested. I finally made it to my first plow day as a participant a couple years ago. It was put on by the brand X club I belong to. It was sort of fun but unfortunately the were still cliques that grouped up and it wasnt as friendly as Id hoped. There is also one right in my neighborhood that has been happening for a few years now. Its grown and many young farmers went out and bought restored tractors and plows. The same farmer offers his land every year but a local crop chemical service sponsors the food. I went once and plowed. I felt like a square peg. Even though they are my neighbors, they all farm and use that crop service and I dont. I was completely shunned by almost all there. I'm not going back. I have to laugh. 25 years ago they all laughed at me with my goofy old tractors now they all ran out and bought their own!
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top