Looked at a 504 Today - Clutch or MCV Issue IDK

RTR

Well-known Member
I went and looked at a 1962 Farmall 504 gas today. The deceased owners grandson in law said that the neighbor had gotten it running, but he had never heard it run. They are in town (Tennessee) from Washington state to handle some affairs. He mentioned that the neighbor told him the tractor has a transmission issue and it’s probably hydraulic related. I don’t know a lot about 504s, but I do know they have a dry clutch and a gear transmission. We went ahead and tried to start the tractor and it started pretty easy once we jumped it off. Battery is shot, carburetor leaks, and needs a rebuild, fuel settlement bowl leaks badly, and none of the gauges work, so I’m not sure if it’s charging or whatever. The gas engine runs excellent with no smoke, no hiccups, and is strong the hydraulic lift and power steering work perfectly with no odd noises clutch pedal feels good but when you go to takeoff in any gear even first, it doesn’t want to move, but you can fill it trying to. If you open the throttle up wide open, it starts moving slowly and does so even if you change to a higher gear, it will barely increase in speed and move slow slowly. If you pull the TA lever back or Forward it has very little change in speed and pulls about the same… And it may have no change as the slight pause may make it feel like it does.

I’m not sure what to offer them, but the guy wants $3000 for the tractor, 6 foot generic box blade, and a 6 foot old but solid rotary cutter….all 3 point hitch. In my opinion, the tractor by itself in good mechanical shape is worth $2,500 Maybe $3,000. I just don’t see a lot of demand for a narrow front 504 gas. I would be buying to fix up and sell because I just hate for it not to get a new life for someone and it not be under my watch. Sheetmetal is very straight and all there except for lower dash panel and rear sides. Fenders are slightly bent. Original seat is surprisingly in decent shape. It has rear weights and 2 front frame weights.

What could Be the issue? The dry clutch, MCV, or TA ?? Or a combination of all? What would it cost to fix if a TA or MCV ? I’m aware the TA could be deleted also. I’ve done clutches but have not been around the others. Not really looking for a long term project to add to the list but Inwish I could save it if it makes financial sense to make a little money.

9878.jpeg


9877.jpeg


9591.jpeg


9592.jpeg


9880.jpeg
 
Kinda hard to say what’s wrong without being there but does the clutch pedal have at least one inch of free travel. I don’t suspect TA at this point because it would be unusual for both high and low to be bad, but possible. Another possibility, with transmission in gear and clutch realeased if you push one brake pedal at a time and then the other will the tractor move, to eliminate bull pinion shaft broke. Hydraulic has no issue with tractor moving, is all mechanical. Could just be a bad clutch… For a tractor that won’t move, I wouldn’t offer over $1200. And that’s the high side for me.
 
Kinda hard to say what’s wrong without being there but does the clutch pedal have at least one inch of free travel. I don’t suspect TA at this point because it would be unusual for both high and low to be bad, but possible. Another possibility, with transmission in gear and clutch realeased if you push one brake pedal at a time and then the other will the tractor move, to eliminate bull pinion shaft broke. Hydraulic has no issue with tractor moving, is all mechanical. Could just be a bad clutch… For a tractor that won’t move, I wouldn’t offer over $1200. And that’s the high side for me.
My thoughts exactly! $750 to $1,000 seemed fair to me because you never know what you’ll find plus it needs everything a tractor that age needs. I think I’ll just tap out respectfully so I don’t hurt hurt his feelings.
 
I went and looked at a 1962 Farmall 504 gas today. The deceased owners grandson in law said that the neighbor had gotten it running, but he had never heard it run. They are in town (Tennessee) from Washington state to handle some affairs. He mentioned that the neighbor told him the tractor has a transmission issue and it’s probably hydraulic related. I don’t know a lot about 504s, but I do know they have a dry clutch and a gear transmission. We went ahead and tried to start the tractor and it started pretty easy once we jumped it off. Battery is shot, carburetor leaks, and needs a rebuild, fuel settlement bowl leaks badly, and none of the gauges work, so I’m not sure if it’s charging or whatever. The gas engine runs excellent with no smoke, no hiccups, and is strong the hydraulic lift and power steering work perfectly with no odd noises clutch pedal feels good but when you go to takeoff in any gear even first, it doesn’t want to move, but you can fill it trying to. If you open the throttle up wide open, it starts moving slowly and does so even if you change to a higher gear, it will barely increase in speed and move slow slowly. If you pull the TA lever back or Forward it has very little change in speed and pulls about the same… And it may have no change as the slight pause may make it feel like it does.

I’m not sure what to offer them, but the guy wants $3000 for the tractor, 6 foot generic box blade, and a 6 foot old but solid rotary cutter….all 3 point hitch. In my opinion, the tractor by itself in good mechanical shape is worth $2,500 Maybe $3,000. I just don’t see a lot of demand for a narrow front 504 gas. I would be buying to fix up and sell because I just hate for it not to get a new life for someone and it not be under my watch. Sheetmetal is very straight and all there except for lower dash panel and rear sides. Fenders are slightly bent. Original seat is surprisingly in decent shape. It has rear weights and 2 front frame weights.

What could Be the issue? The dry clutch, MCV, or TA ?? Or a combination of all? What would it cost to fix if a TA or MCV ? I’m aware the TA could be deleted also. I’ve done clutches but have not been around the others. Not really looking for a long term project to add to the list but Inwish I could save it if it makes financial sense to make a little money.

View attachment 169299

View attachment 169300

View attachment 169301

View attachment 169302

View attachment 169303

I agree with the others here, in its current condition the tractor is closer to $1000 - then whatever the shredder and the box blade is worth. It surprises me that the tractor keeps moving on both the high and low side of the TA - yet barely moves. I am thinking you have a clutch problem. Having sat so long and the previous operator not being available it's hard to say what the issue is. I would lean towards the clutch being bound up with rust or mud dobbers not allowing it to properly engage. I do know for a fact if I bought it I would learn on day two of ownership the previous owner had been riding the clutch peddle and the clutch was fried and the tractor needed to be split to make the repair.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RTR
Could be main clutch but would be my guess t/a ramp and roller assembly is bad and t/a clutch slipping. Some would love to get good sheet metal and weights If engine runs good probably worth fixing to keep if price was lower, but not to fix up and sell. although some nicer ones do sell pretty good sometimes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RTR
Well, I called the guy to respectfully pass on it and he hit me up with just tell me what you'd give so it would go to a good home and not a scrap yard. I offered $1,000 and not a penny over so I guess we will see what happens. If we make a deal, it'll have to be by mail at this point as he flies back to Washington State in a couple hours. Didn't bring any money to work with me. Having an adjustment issue or a bad dry clutch would be ideal. The TA not so much as I've never done one and know they're expensive to fix. The other would be to part it out, but I hate to do that too,.
 
Well, I called the guy to respectfully pass on it and he hit me up with just tell me what you'd give so it would go to a good home and not a scrap yard. I offered $1,000 and not a penny over so I guess we will see what happens. If we make a deal, it'll have to be by mail at this point as he flies back to Washington State in a couple hours. Didn't bring any money to work with me. Having an adjustment issue or a bad dry clutch would be ideal. The TA not so much as I've never done one and know they're expensive to fix. The other would be to part it out, but I hate to do that too,.
One thing I keep in mind now is how the high cost of fluids adds up on repairs. Seems like it's terrible what I pay for maintenance on oil and filters on what I use now. Now gas is cheaper than diesel for that tractor.
 
Boy, you guys live in low end markets. The rear tires would almost be a grand here in good ol' upstate NY.
Weight and implements would bring another 4-800 . Straight tinwork on a running tractor,wouldn't last long
around here at $1000.
 
Boy, you guys live in low end markets. The rear tires would almost be a grand here in good ol' upstate NY.
Weight and implements would bring another 4-800 . Straight tinwork on a running tractor,wouldn't last long
around here at $1000.
IF you part it out, maybe. I think the market is like it is because the young and middle aged people are financing new Kubota tractors and lower line import tractors that don't have to be tinkered with to use each time (because they wouldn't know how).
 
IF you part it out, maybe. I think the market is like it is because the young and middle aged people are financing new Kubota tractors and lower line import tractors that don't have to be tinkered with to use each time (because they wouldn't know how).
I would buy it because the sheet metal looks pretty straight. someone would pay good money for the sheet metal because its in good condition.
 
Not a bad looking old girl . Now as to what is wrong with it ???????? She is old school built and for me vary easy to work on . Simple dry main clutch and unless the ft. T/A seal is leaking like a chive it is also dry . Like others have said i am not there to see for myself . For me to rebuild the T/A complete with a new main clutch in today your getting close to a grand in parts and around 20 hours labor . So if your having to pay big shop rates at around a 150 and hour for some KID who has never worked on old iron and knows all the short cuts ya have way more in repairs then that tractor would ever bring . As for the transmission and rear end they are almost bullet proof . Back in 69 a buddy bought one like that one only in diesel and Ronny farmed 115 acres of plow ground . He pulled 3 x14's three points plows . Huge up grade from his old H . I can still hear it screaming at he had it turned up . I am telling ya that was one tough little tractor . I bought a 504 gas like that one one year to bale with that needed a couple easy fixes . Made two cuttings with it and sold it when i was done with second cutting due to the fact i was never going to make hay again due to the lack of half warm bodys to help. Now as for what i would give in todays market on say a dead row tractor 1500 as that would leave room to fix it and cover parts and labor and some adult refreshments for a couple months as that now is a substantial cost of semi retirement each month .
 
They are one tough tractor. My gess is the clutch. That looks like a Howse brush hog. If you get the tractor and implements for $1000.00, I am calling the Sherrif.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top