AAA towing - what good is it!

JML755

Well-known Member
I've been a AAA member since I got my license at 16 over 47 yrs ago). Bought all my daughters' memberships when they got their licenses, telling them how to use it if they need a jump or a tow. I'm the 1st one they call when they have a problem, so they've never had to use it (that I know of). I've done my share of pulling them home, cleaning jumper cables, etc. I've never used my membership card for a tow or jump.

Yesterday in the snowstorm that hit here in Michigan, my daughter calls and says she slid over the curb in a turnaround of a median. She had tried to call me but I was on a conference call and by the time I got back to her, she had a tow truck on the way but was teary and frustrated because of the runaround she was getting.

Here's the story: She slid up over the curb and over the top of a steel sign pole remnant sticking up out of the ground. A previous car (tracks still there, sign on the ground) had hit in the same spot and taken out the sign. Right rear wheel of her car was now lifted off the ground with the post wedged under her rear door rocker panel.

When she called AAA and told them what happened, they said "Oh you hit something, that's an accident, call your insurance company".

Insurance company gave her the runaround presumably because there wasn't any damage (yet). Made her file a claim over the phone before they'd send a tow truck to take her to a collision shop.

I got there before the tow truck (2 hr wait, not unusual in a bad storm, no complaint there) with a jack. Looked underneath and the post stopped an inch or 2 short of ripping a brake line. No damage other than a slightly dinged rocker panel. Jacked up the car off the post remnant. Tow arrived, and he and I decided best way to get her clear was to winch the car sideways a foot or so, pulling it off the jack. He had us sign a "damage waiver", no problem there. Pulling it sideways worked, but the jack did damage the rocker panel some as it didn't "roll" in the snow, it pivoted up as he winched. 5 minutes of his time and she was on her way again with a slightly banged up rocker panel.

I told her to call the insurance company and cancel the claim.

My beef is that AAA refused to send a tow truck to someone who was in distress. Someone at work said that AAA once refused to send a truck to pull them out of a vacant lot they were looking to purchase because they were "off the road". They had hit a pocket of sand about 20' off the curb.

I'm going to call AAA and voice my complaint that after 40+ years of paying annual dues I wasn't aware of the "fine print" in my "roadside assistance". I suspect I'll not be renewing my membership.
 
They sent me a flyer once wanting me to sign up. If I remember right it wasn't that cheap ?
So 40+ years of dues you could of bought your own tow truck by now ! LOL
 
That towing crap is just to give you a warm fuzzy feeling that if something happened you are covered.

But, the towing BS is just for them to make more money off of you.

My wife smashed into a tree a few years ago due to icy roads, the insurance company paid $ 1,500 for her car to be fixed, due to carelessness of my wife. No towing involved.
 
You may not need it anyway. Most insurances have a roadside assistance/towing hotline as part of the insurance (not necessarily the same number as a claim). I know I had it through state farm and I think I have it through Geico. As soon as my parents stopped paying for my AAA I let it go.
 
That is why I pay a little extra on my insurance so I am covered if I ever need a tow for any thing. Might cost me an extra buck or 2 every 6 months if even that much. Have 3 cars covered for less then $75 a month to boot
 
Exactly what I'm thinking. Actually, what I used to use my membership more for than anything else was the maps. I would get a new set for every car in the family each year. (Don't need that anymore with nav systems in most cars and on my phone). I'd also get TripTik for travel and the guides for each area that showed motels, restaurants, etc. Also don't need that with access to the Internet from my Smartphone). Never thought much about Roadside Assistance from my Insurance company. Been through so many of those through the years, I can't remember what was included and what wasn't. I'll have to look into that.
 
I have had AAA for ten years and had no problems with them. Son in law has it and was rear ended and it totaled car they towed the car 150 miles with no charges.With AAA you also get discounts on rental cars and motels and hotels. We travel several times a year and saving on car rental and lodging pays for dues.
 
the wife and I HAD AAA but I canceled it.

last 2 times it was needed ( out of? 14 ys ) they did not come thru.

1 was for a jump and they never showed and my wife got a jump from a co-worker eventually. and 2, we were in an under-developed part of the county, on a county maintained road. not a private road. and it was a gravel road with a washout and muddy area.. got stuck because an oncoming car was running about 60 and swerving all over so I pulled a bit close tot he edge and found 2 good wet spots right where front and rear tires go. AAA gave us the runaround as we dod not have a corss street address to give them. my wife was on the phone for 45m while i dug out the front and rear tires by HAND and then walked off the road and brought back rocks and deadfall wood to wedge under the front of the tires. at that point it had been 45m.. and they had not even dispatched a truck.. still arguing over where / when..e tc. I pulled us out of the rut and reached over.. grabbed the phone.. told the AAA person what they could do.. and hung up...
 
Wrecker owner/operator here. I am not AAA because
there is no one else close. A unlock at 2am pays
$50 (from AAA) and I might have to drive 50 miles
one way. NOT HAPPENING!!! As far as getting
stuck in the ditch due to weather, I have yet to
see an insurance company not pay the bill. I get
calls 24/7. I run out, pop'em out of the ditch,
give them a bill, they pay me and I tell them to
turn their receipt into their insurance company.
In a week or two I get a call thanking me as they
never knew their car insurance would pay.
Everybody is happy happy happy!

Casey in SD
 
Hello JML755,

You have been your own AAA for all the years you thought they were! Why bother at all. Sounds like you have done what you thought they would do. I think the free tow is only for 4 or five miles. After that its on you. Too bad it took so long to find out they are not what you thought there were
I would drop them


Guido.
 
I had AAA years ago until I needed a tow from my
drive to a repair shop,when driver showed up he
said I would either have to pay for the tow or push
my vehicle onto the street Cuz AAA was for
"Emergency Assistance" only.No more AAA for me.
 
Now that's a crock of sh!t!!! I have several customers who have AAA. Had one call AAA to have his car towed to my shop from his house for repair. He lives 2 miles from my shop. The nearest AAA wrecker is an hour away. They came out and towed it in from his garage, no questions asked.

Casey in SD
 
No no no, I wasn't calling you out. Sorry it came across like that. I meant the wrecker not towing your car unless it was on the street! Bad driver!!!

Casey in SD
 
Others aren't much better. Truck quit on the entrance ramp. I called the station that does our work--he has wrecker service too. He gave us a tow bill and I submitted it to my insurance company. They denied it because I didn't use their service or garage. I told them to keep their road service. I wasn't interested in having my vehicle hauled to someone I didn't know or standing in the cold waiting for their approval.

Larry
 
Here in W. Pa. if you have a truck with a company name on it, AAA will not touch it. It doesn"t matter the size of the truck. My brother in law has a printing company. He has a Ford Ranger with the company name on the door. He slid on some ice and ended up in a ditch. AAA came out after a 2hour wait only to tell him AAA doesn"t cover commercial vehicles. He no longer has AAA.
 
had AAA come out and jump start a company vehicle in Athens Ohio back about 95 using a friends AAA account. So I bought my own membership in Athens Ohio, which is part of Pittsburg Pa AAA.
I joined up and they have unlocked numerous (10+)times for me, towed me at least 5 times, two of which were 100 mile tows. Pulled my son out of the ditch 1 mile from my house.
Currently on the best plan which allows for one 400 mile tow and 3 100 mile tows for RV's, trailers, motorcycles along with unlocks, maps, etc.
Finally switched over to Columbus Ohio AAA this year after moving to Lancaster Ohio in 99. Sure hope they treat me as good as the Pittsburg AAA has.
Defintly have got my moneys worth out of them.
 
[i:654c4848f0]I don't trust AAA,AARP <strike>or the extended warranties.</strike>[/i:654c4848f0]

^^ This.

Altho I have benefited on a couple of occasions from extended warranties. Probably a loser in the long run, but a chance I'm willing to take based on past experience.
 
It can vary a lot from one club to another.

When I was in the Marine Corps, I was at various time a member of the New Mexico AAA Motor Club and the Carolina Motor Club. Good experiences with both.

Then I tried to join the Nebraska Motor Club and was turned down for membership because I was in the military. And they made no bones about the fact that they considered me a sub-standard citizen because I was in the military. I told them off, and I've never had much use for AAA since.
 
I had an extended warranty on a 1977 Ford Granada. Transmission went out for the second time. First time was under Ford warranty.Second time was six months after the Ford warranty ran out. They denied the warranty,because they said the first repairs were not done properly. They never even saw the car.
 
(quoted from post at 17:12:05 01/03/14) the wife and I HAD AAA but I canceled it.

last 2 times it was needed ( out of? 14 ys ) they did not come thru.

1 was for a jump and they never showed and my wife got a jump from a co-worker eventually. and 2, we were in an under-developed part of the county, on a county maintained road. not a private road. and it was a gravel road with a washout and muddy area.. got stuck because an oncoming car was running about 60 and swerving all over so I pulled a bit close tot he edge and found 2 good wet spots right where front and rear tires go. AAA gave us the runaround as we dod not have a corss street address to give them. my wife was on the phone for 45m while i dug out the front and rear tires by HAND and then walked off the road and brought back rocks and deadfall wood to wedge under the front of the tires. at that point it had been 45m.. and they had not even dispatched a truck.. still arguing over where / when..e tc. I pulled us out of the rut and reached over.. grabbed the phone.. told the AAA person what they could do.. and hung up...

Yeah, I'm used to dealing with things myself. While we were waiting for the truck, I was thinking of different ways to get out without the use of a tow-truck. One option was my oxy-acetyline torch which was about a mile away. I could cut the metal post at ground level in less than 5 minutes but I had come from work, not dressed for near-zero weather, no hat, wimpy gloves. I would have had to go home, change my clothes, grab the torch cart, get it into my pickup bed (which was full of snow), drive back to the scene. Another option was to go home, grab a stack of 2x6's, jack the rear wheel off the ground, insert 2x underneath butting up to the post remnant, repeat until I could drive off the stack without running over the sharp end of the post. Third option was to go get a friend's tractor w/ loader about a mile away. In each case, I figured it'd be the better part of an hour messing around in a blizzard. "Roadside assistance" sounded so much better and, that's what it's there for, right? In the end, the tow driver got her on her way. Biggest gripe is that AAA gave her the runaround and ended up not being the one who bailed her out.
 

Been a member since 1985, I contracted to do their road service for 12 years. I ended up with a worn out tow truck and broke...
While I was under contract my membership was free (I wrote a few tickets a year to cover my membership) :wink: Theirs no money in it unless the folks you service patronize your business...
When AAA plus came along you could do well on a tow as long as you racked up the millage but at that time very few had AAA plus...

AAA service around here sucks its at least a 2 hr. wait because the service comes from far away. I don't need it but kept it for my wife and kids it has payed off a few times when they were travailing are when the kids were in collage. When the kids were in collage it was a 3 hr. round trip. I did not have to stop what I was doing call AAA and the kids car was delivered to my door...

When it did snow here I did not run my tow truck... AAA could stick it were the sun don't shine... Folks that did chance it could chance they could find a tow truck as far as I was concerned... The times I did go out in the snow are ice I always tore something up so I stayed home and play in the snow with the kids...

The only reason I keep it is because I can keep my kids on my AAA cheap even tho they are 25 and 28... I think its $125 a year for AAA plus on us and worth it to me that my Daughter may get help when she is out of town and she has its worked well for her...

I look at it this way I hope I never need it if I do I stand a better chance of getting a emergency service and AAA will keep them honest... Keep in mind contracting to AAA they are working for peanuts... If you are going to have AAA buy the best service offered a AAA tow truck driver will give better service when he knows his service is completely covered thru AAA verses a lost leader hook and charge tow.. In this day of cell phones and GPS there's no way in ell I would contract to AAA...
 
Then you ought to try National Motor Club, what a joke. I got talked into it once and after paying dues for a few years the pump on my Dodge dsl. expired less than 20 miles from home. They towed the pickup to my farm but what they would pay for a tow wasn't much. I cancelled it and decided that if I ned another tow I will pay for it and be way money ahead than paying $28.00 per month to those people.
 
I have Onstar for my wife - it's been great both times we have used it. No more than 20 minutes wait once, and about 12 minutes the other. For a older person or a woman, I think Onstar is very good protextion. I think it is about $17 per month.
 
I lost any interest in AAA when they admitted that they know having everyone travel at the same speed is safest, but that they were going to support Illinois keeping their split speed limits because their members don't believe it.

When my sister moved to Raleigh NC, I wrote out directions for my dad that took them right to her apartment door. Then grandma got AAA maps for them and screwed them all up. They were east of Raleigh on I40 before they realized they missed their exit.
But now I know why grandma turns the map every time you make a turn with the car. Those stupid maps, you didn't know which way was north unless it had an interstate or a known road on it.

Also one of the few times dad told me he should have listened and threw the AAA junk out.
 
Some years ago, while on my way home from work, I passed a out of state vehicle on the side of the road changing drivers. In a short while they caught up to me and started to pass, I noticed the right front tire was very low and flagged them over. It was a couple in the process of moving from a northern clime to a retirement location near Pinehurst, NC. He asked if I could change the tire, which I did, and when I finished he handed me a $20. bill. I told him that I did not want his money but he said, "Well, I have motor club but I didn't want to wait two or three hours for them to show,and insisted that I take the money. He didn't seem too favorably impressed with motor clubs either.
 
whatever towing service you buy,
check the fine print and different price levels in the same service.
most have tow mileage caps, different plans for rollbacks only.
(I used to drive restored little unibody Fords, hook em and they are junk)
and most importantly, WHERE they are allowed to tow to.
Got into a few arguments, as of course, I want them towed home to my shop to be fixed.
Nowadays, I just take my chances, and pay for the rollback if I need one. This time of year, I'll walk home and go get it myself.
Weather delays could be days
 
I tried to get AAA 22 years ago and they asked me why I would
want there insurance. I left and ain't checked with them again
 
I have towing thru USAA with my car insurance. I think it is less that $70 a year. only used it once when I locked the keys in the car. They came in less than 20 min. As for car rental and hotel discount stuff, I get that thru the American Legion and the NRA. I am happy.
John
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top