Building Permits, One More Time

Anonymous-0

Well-known Member
I've got a couple of points I want to bring up on the subject of building permits. The house where I live was built in 1973, in a rural area where the soil drains so badly that septic permits shouldn't have been issued to begin with. But it's in a subdivision,and my house, a FmHA spec home, was one of the first built here. I bought it in 1994, not knowing all I do now about the septic system problems of the neighborhood.

But my problem concerning building permits doesn't have to do with the original construction; it has to do with the addition the original owner built across the back side of the house. The original house was built over a crawl space,and the owner built the addition on a slab foundation. The house is on a sloping lot, so the slab addition is about 3 feet below the floor level of the main house, making a "sunken" living room.

The problem is, when I bought the house, the seller [original owner, and builder of the addition] was kinda vague about the location of the septic tank. He only told me that it was accessed through the "manhole" cover in the concrete pad behind the addition. What I didn't discover until a couple of years later, when I had to have the tank pumped out, is that about 1/3 of the septic tank is UNDER the slab foundation of the addition!!!

Had there been an adequate building permit procedure, and an actual inspection of the site, this would never have been allowed to occur. Of course, the county also has no maps of these homesites and where on the lots the septic tanks and lines run, so when a system fails, it's pretty much a "Where's Waldo" situation of dig here, and if it's not here, then dig there.

Just a word of warning to folks who think building permits are silly and a waste of time. Had there been a proper permit issued for this addition, and an inspection, I would have grounds to get the situation corrected at the expense of the fools who allowed it to occur. As it is, if I ever have a problem it's all on me. It just never occurred to me that anyone would build a house--much less a concrete slab foundation--over a septic tank...it just seems incredibly stupid.
 
Personally I can't see what the big problem is, if you intend on replacing the top of the septic tank then what's wrong with where it is. If its sealed from the house with the extra layer concrete then what's the problem.
Seems to me to be a silly thing to complain about after all it works doesn't it and you can still pump it out. I would not get all excited it could leave to worse things like your health worrying about it.
Walt
 
On the other hand, a building permit helped out in a situation dealing with my mom's property in town. Back in 1960, Grand-dad converted the barn on the back of his property into a business where he sold Farmall tractor parts and he and Dad did tractor repairs.

After Dad died in 1991, the town attorney began hassling Mom about the vehicles and farm equipment on the property, telling her that the property had never been rezoned for a garage, that it had only been "grandfathered in" and that zning had expired when Dad died. Mom was in a panic, and when going through some papers after Dad died, Mom and I found the building permit issued when Grand-dad built the addition onto the barn for the parts department.

The building permit clearly stated that the entire property had been zoned "business" [at the time there wasn't any B-1 or B-2, as there is today]. Going by the date on the building permit, Mom found the legal notices in the newspaper archives in the town library that announced the date of the hearing, and the notice of the zoning change. The town, which had previously claimed that those records had been "lost," had to back off...all because we found that original building permit. Prior to finding the permit, Mom was hassled unmercifully by the town attorneys, threatened with lawsuits that would've taken the property away from her.

Grand-dad always told us that he'd gotten the property properly zoned as an "ace in the hole" for the family...all we had to do was prove it. He knew he could've had the property "grandfathered in," as he'ddone some machinery set-up and repair there back in the 1940's. But he told us grandkids that "with that business zoning, some day the property will be worth something to you kids." Just for getting the town attorneys off Mom's back, it already has been worth a lot.
 
That's why you buy title insurance and have a lawyer represent you. When you were in the process of buying there should have been an inspection of the house to ensure it matches the legal description on file with your local governing body.
You have the lawyer look over the documents before you sign them so you don't knowingly walk into a trap. With that addition on your house, it will affect the tax assesment. Sooner or later the county or whoever asesses real estate is going to come by and asses your property. If they figure out it doesn't comform to the description they have on file, you're going to almost certainly have your taxable value increased and they will make it retroactive to the last tax assesment.
Thumbnail sketch is you better talk to a real estate attorney and find out what can happen. With the house over part of the septic, they could possibly go so far as to condemn your house forcing you to fix everything before you can live in it again. Then if there is any question the property was misrepresented, it could get ugly fast. Hate to be the bearer of bad news, but better to be safe than sorry.
 
Walt, what I'm worried about is what happens when that septic tank caves in, as some in the area have done...and the sturctural damage it'll do to the rest of the house.

Apparently you've never heard of a septic tank caving in? Happens around here several times a year.
 
As I understand it, the legal description of the property was updated AFTER the addition was built, and the taxes were paid as assessed all along. That's not what I have issues with.

Around here, every few months we hear of a septic tank caving in. Probably older systems, but that doesn't matter. What matters to me is, it happens at all. If it happens to my house, no doubt there'll be considerable structural damage. And since I've been in the house almost 15 years already, the seller--who built the addition--has already spent the money, so I'd have little chance to collect any damages from his stupidity from when he built the house, or from the fact he'd concealed the issue of building over the septic tank from me. I mean,a jury might award damages if it got that far,but it's doubtful I'd ever collect a nickel.

So I'm saying, learn from my experience, and don't fight the building permit process so hard. Had the process been effective, and had it included an on-site inspection, this house would never have been built with an addition over any part of the septic tank. THAT'S my point.
 
There are 2 sides to every situation.

It never occured to me that anyone would be so stupid as to buy a house & not understand the well & septic situation. If you had done your job right of previewing what you were buying, you would know what you have.

I very much prefer 'as is where is' deals, as a buyer & a seller. I do not understand this effort by some to be terribly lazy when they buy something, and then want to come back at the previous owner 5, 10 years later.

These same people tend to be bottom feeders, and want to buy as cheap as possible - then hang every problem upon the previous owner & get all house improvements financed by the previous owner.

Not thinking of you Buzz with that papragraph - one of my city slicker friends was all upset his crank windows didn't work 3 years after he bought the house, & wanted to talk to the realitor about getting it fixed through the previous owner. Another city slicker friend demanded his tub be replaced 15 months after buying the house because there was a crack in it in some location that didn't cause a leak, wasn't visable unless you put your head on the floor. Now everyone knows crank windows are krap, and the previous owner of the tub got even by supplying the new tub without instalation instead of meeting costs 1/2 way. I'd a done the same, and that is with a pretty good friend.... I just do not understand such frivilous claims.

I find such ideas silly.

I think buyers need to be responsible for important issues. Obviously the seller should be held responsible for actively hiding something. Now, if they had said the septic & leach field was over here in this nice draining area, and you come to find the situation you have - then go after the liar!

But if you asked, and were told where it is and you can surely inspect it if you have a mind to, then it's all on you. Period.

My opinion.

Less govt micro-management is good. Real regulation of actuial issues is also good. The current direction we are going..... Oh boy.

--->Paul
 
I believe in building permits, only as long as the inspector isnt a *ickhead and has common sense. And the homeowner or builder has knowledge of what they are doing and they are not a screwup.
I will give examples of what has happened in my life experience(s).
I built an upstairs addition on my old house, it went well. I hired a gen. cont. to rough in the upstairs addition and he got paid and walked away, I put in all finish work, drywall, paint, light fixures, flooring. (all permits were pulled and followed)
I also built my own home in 1999. I was the gen. cont. for the whole job--start to finish. The building inspector was (and still is) a bit of a moron. Here is why.---6 months before I bought my land my neighbor in front of me built his house on 2.5 acres. (both our lots are 2.5 acres) each is 165' wide by 660' deep. On the north side of my neighbors property is my driveway easement (full legal description is that the easement belongs to me for my use ONLY) Well while my neighbor built his house he put his driveway on my easement drive and he eventually had to put in his own driveway, the inspector penalized ME by making him put in his own driveway due to the fact that the inspector had no recourse cause a cert. of occupancy was issued. The building insp. was neglegent in catching this simple obvious fact. I was real nice about my neighbor using my driveway until he made his own drive. And now my neighbor still uses my drive but for a firewood side business that he has and stores the wood timbers in the back of his property. The legal description of the easement is that my driveway is for my use only and not my neighbors use. (I am nice about him using it) IF he ever blocks me in or out he would get an earful and the cops might show up.
So in short building inspectors can miss a lot of important things during the building of a home or garage.
I believe in pulling permits for building homes and large additions. But not for building decks, sheds, ANY interior remodeling, finishing basements, finishing garages or any repairs. Some building permits are just an excuse for the city/twshp to make money. I will never allow an inspector to just show up and come in cause he thinks I remodeled my kitchen. I would walk his silly a** back to his car and tell him to leave.
I feel for you on the septic tank issue but you should have the tank relocated and repiped by a qualified and insured contractor. I would not do that myself.
 
Or, without any big govt interference or zoning at all - there wouldn't have been any issue at all.

The other side of the coin. :)

I know, with no zoning at all we run into the 'bad neighbor' issues and that is no good either.

Just for the argument - your point seems to be that the early zoning was good to protect you from the later zoning.... But, if there were less zoning at all, then there would not have been any past or present issues for your grandma at all. Your arguement does not support a lot of zoning & government being a good thing.....

This is not an issue with you - I like to debate these issues on their merrits, not on the personality. I know we are in for more & more & more govt regulation, and the govt bodies keep telling us it is for our own good, it will make life so much better for us.

All it does is drive up insurance costs, fees, taxes, and the cost of doing business, and drives jobs over to other countries. Why does business move to China & Mexico? 'Zoning laws' and their costs and hassles are a small part, as your grandma found out, just makes doing anything in this country cost more. It is easier to sell a few parts out of an old barn in a country with less zoning laws.

If your grandma lived in _my_ county/state, she will find out the very bad _negatives_ of that zoning ruling if she ever tries to add on or rebuild the house............. Oops, not a residential, can't do that.

You are proving that zoning laws are a major hassle, not that they are a good deal.

--->Paul
 
Do you have room to put in a new septic tank? Then you can pipe your sewage thru your old one into the new one and still use the original distribution box. Fill your old tank with sand. I did this five years ago and my old leach field is nearly 45 years old and still works fine (clay tile)
 
I got to pay for correcting my share of stuff I didn't know to look for...like "half-fast" construction techniques used when he replaced the pipes inder the house with PVC, then didn't properly support the waste lines...allowing them to flex and come apart at the joints. Fixed that mess, and never complained because I just wasn't experienced enough about home buying to know I should've crawled under the house myself instead of taking anyone's word about anything.

And I'm living with the shoddy construction og the block garage, because I didn't know that you could actually make so many mistakes when building a structure.

But the septic tank issue...with the tank underground, I had no idea that an "experienced" builder, as this guy was, would build over the tank. He actually led me to believe that the tank was behind the house and beyond the foundation, not under it.

Know what this guy's doing for a living today? He runs a home inspection service. Guess it takes one to know one.
 
Where I lived your spetic was inspected by the health dept. Didn't have to have building permits out of the city or if it was owner built. Got a book and built by regs anyway. Only thing found when I sold was a bad outlet.
 
Do you know if you have a concrete septic tank or a steel one? The old steel tanks could eventually rust and cave in . Concrete tanks are not known for caving in at all around here . Have you ever checked it out by opening that cover - or had it pumped? Although it is not an ideal set up to pour a slab and build over a tank , if it is a concrete tank and accesible to be pumped, you probably wont have any problems with cave-ins. If there is a vented trap on the inlet side of your tank, that is now inaccesible , hopefully that wont cause you problems.
 
Businesses move to China because the wages are about 25 cents per hour. Tell me how you can compete with that?
 
Building permits are a good thing when the municipality applies them in a common sense manner.
In the township where I live you need a permit for everything except painting your house and installing carpeting. Example, if you change a bedroom door or replace a kitchen cabinet you better have a permit and don't replace a lose shingle on the roof.

We have a zoning officer plus we have a retired state trooper who is also a private investigator who is always checking on anybody who has a 2X6 in the back of their pickup.

In our area it is all about bringing in more MONEY!
 
Brass knuckles need to be given to all the residents of that town. Sounds to me like that building inspector is a real horses *ss.
 
I was doing remodeling for awhile, and always wanted to place my yard sign for marketing, plus the van was clearly marked. A permit was necessary to not draw the ire of the city. They would tell you that anything over $250.00, labor and materials, required a permit. In other words, almost everything. I had a purely cosmetic kitchen remodel to do, (replace a window, rework existing cabinets for dishwasher, new oven, and microwave). So, I go to the courthouse and ask if I need one. I explain what I am doing-yes you do! So, I get one. I call for inspection at completion, since nothing needed inspecting in between time, and he chewed me out for wasting his time! What a mess! Greg
 
Being named as a defendent in a Civil Lawsuit, or creating broblems with an inspector dosen't give me the thrill it used to. You can sell 'as is where is' all you like, but you are not going to get as high a price. If the buyer plans on financing it the appraiser will think something is wrong with it and appraise accordingly. If you are selling only to cash buyers you will find them few and far between and they are tough negociators. The law of the land, all 50 states and territories, is that you must disclose all known defects, and anything you reasonably should have known about. So if even if you sell 'as is' the buyer can still sue you. When I sell a house I have about 10 pages of disclosures about every thing that is wrong, might be wrong, or could even conceivably be wrong, example,"This may be a native american burial ground, UFO's may obduct people here, ect". Don't forget the required EPA lead paint disclousure information, and no, it dosen't matter if the house you are selling has lead paint in or not.
 
Around here, you don't need a permit for repairs like a new roof. But if you add square footage or are adding electrical service, you need a permit. One guy I know decided to put a addition onto his house. He found out the building inspector lived about a mile down the road, had to pass his place to go anywhere!!
 
Are you sure you are reading your easement correctly. I would have assumed it ment that only you have a easement to use that driveway and no other non owners of that property. That being said I would believe the owner who has the deed in his name and who pays the taxes on that land should have every right to use that drive way for his own use, but he has a responsibility to not block your access.
 
It would have to be a deeded right of way for him not to be entitled to use it. I suspect you have an "exclusive easement"- this means he can't sell it to anyone else, but he still owns the property, and can use it himself, so long as his use is consistent with your use of it. Your two parcels were obviously subdivided from a 330 X 660 five acre parcel, and it would be unusual for someone going through the subdivision process to do something as stupid as granting a deeded right of way without someone smarter catching and preventing the error along the way.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top