Cash for Clunkers

MarkB_MI

Well-known Member
Location
Motown USA
A couple of weeks ago, someone posted a message to effect that a "cash for clunkers" bill was being considered in Congress, and that everyone should immediately start calling Speaker of the House Pelosi to stop the bill, since it would bring a halt to restoration of old cars and tractors. Unfortunately, nobody could find the actual bill since it didn't actually exist.

Last week an actual cash for clunkers bill WAS introduced by Senate nnalert Feinstein and Schumer, along with nnalert Susan Collins of Maine. A link to a press release from Sen. Feinstein is below.

Curiously, they seemed to have completed omitted tractors from the bill.

It pays up to $4500 for cars 2002 or newer, to be used on purchase of a new vehicle. Or $3000 towards a used car. The payment drops to $2000/$1500 for 1998 and older.

Cars and trucks eligible must have a gas mileage of less than 18 mpg, must be in drivable condition and must have been registered in the last 120 days. Which means that most of the cars in junk yards or headed that way won't be eligible.

The press release doesn't say how the cars are to be disposed of. Presumably they will go to scrap yards for salvage and/or crushing.

Don't shoot me, I'm just the messenger. If you have a problem with this bill, then I suggest you contact your congressmen.
Cash for Clunkers Bill
 
This is amusing at best. If one is thinking purely in the mode of saving gas, the buying public has a very narrow view of the actual savings. By my figures if I continue to drive my old F-150 at 15 MPG VS. a new F-150 getting 18 MPG (maybe), over the course of 100,000 miles or 14.3 years in my case, I stand to save $370.33. That is about 4 tenths of a cent per mile of $25.90 per year. Now start calculating the cost of a new vehicle, interest, depreciation, insurance etc. VS the cost of an older cash aquisition vehicle, no interest, liability only insurance and still has some scrap value.
The 4 tenths of a cent saved per mile in 100,000 miles doesn't total up real well. You say 'well it will nickle and dime you to death'. Yes an older vehicle is a little more trouble, but I see comparable new vehicles that spend a lot more time in the shop at an average of $72.50 per hour, than mine. Emissions? mine meets the same standards it did when new in 89'. Supporting the economy? that's a good one. Tell me why I should feel sorry for a guy whose compensation package totals out to at least $50 or more an hour and is looking forward to retiring at age 60 with lifetime insurance and pension and is only qualified to thread a bolt in to a hole. Now his job is in danger of being sent off shore.
I look at my situation, I try to be fair and give an honest day's work for an honest day's pay and be of value to the company. Only God knows my retirement date as by my calculations, that date will be the same as the day they slam the lid on my burial box. I'll stick with my clunker thank you.
 
It's already being done in Germany, and our politicians are just playing copy-cat. One bad idea deserves another, I guess.

I've got over 30 cars and trucks in my fields. Wish I could cash in on some of this inane auto-welfare.
 
Sounds like it would return to the highway being running when sold. Only way it could work is the entire vehicle be cubed, motor and all. Scam in Illinois on the vehicles given to charities was the tow company (not the Lincoln park one) never took when to they should have gone. Took and sold, cause they had title in hand when picking up cars. Another one was to tow stalled vehicles on express ways and chop. State police put planted cars on express ways and caught the crooks.
 
The idea is nobel but with the Gov running it disaster is immintent. personally i would like to see a clean up of these old cars that are worth scrap prices toward a new vechile.
 
Might be worthwhile to see if ya can get some of the oldies running. Kinda like a crop subsidy for ya!!!
 
So, I've upgraded my vehicle the old fashioned way, by paying for it through hard work and a successful career.
Under this legislation, citizen X down the street can get my tax dollar to trade in their older vehicle?
Sounds like welfare to me.
 
I'd think about taking the $4,500 for my 1996 Chevy pickup, but not $2,000, atleast not until its even more of a clunker. $2,000 is only enough money to buy another old vehicle.
 
They have been doing this for a while in some states. California was probably the worst one doing it and I am not suprised since Pelosi is from there. New York and New Jersey may also have been working on this. Basicly it was a Co2 or Smog Credit for large industrial polluters. By taking older (more polluting) cars off the road, they didn't have to clean up thier plants and keep the air quality at least somewhat better, but it was partially funded by those polluters (Unical oil is one of them). Once those cars were bought by the program, they were scrapped out totally and immediatly with no parts to be sold from them. Idea was that if no availability for parts that kept other older cars on the road, they would get more Credits when those cars would be "turned in"! The Antique Automobile Club of America is a BIG Lobbyist for stopping this activity because it seriously threatens the hobby and if the abundant environmentalist politicians who are in the pockets of those polluters get their way, TRACTORS will be next! No more tractor shows! That is one time I can say a lobbiest can be a good thing if they take your interest like with the NRA. Go to AACA.com and go to the message boards, look for the legislation section. It will tell you everything you need to know. This could get to be a serious problem in the next few years!!! I heard Colorado was trying to pass a law requiring ALL engines to be rebuilt every 4-5 years whether they needed it or not and it included Farm tractors!!
 
I don't know yet how I feel about the bill but I figured I would play devil's advocate.

When you are figuring the cost analysis make sure you figure in the lower maintenance costs of a newer vehicle (parts are new, designed to last longer and with a warranty).

Also keep in mind that the idea isn't necessarily to get you out of your F150 and into a new F150 the idea is to get someone out of their Suburban and into a Mazda 3 Hatchback. That will drastically change the mileage numbers, going from 14mpg to 33mpg.

It still is obviously not going to pay for itself to change but it does make it a bit easier to decide that the 98 Yukon XL with 150,000 milesand a slipping tranny might be better off traded in.
 
Hmmm. I wonder how much fuel will be burned to make the steel and plastic for the new cars that will replace the clunkers? I wonder if there will be a net gain or not.
 
History is repeating itself. People were put in homes they could not afford through just this kind of program and now people are going to be put in auto's and trucks they can't afford the same way. Our fine leaders at work and leading us straight to He77 !!
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top