Computor model / not CEO's

An Exerpt from a Article stating That it is possible some CEO's qwuill face Jail Time , HOWEVER ...Tillions of dollars worth of these investments were sold based on intricate computer models that turned out to be fatally flawed. Unwinding this mess will take time. So will piecing together the lengthy paper trail to show a jury just how these schemes worked.

The problem is compounded by the legal standard required to prove guilt in a financial crime. You have to show, essentially, that the people who created this mess knew at the time what they were doing was wrong, and that they knew they were taking other people’s money through deceptive means.

In some cases, the people who created these now-worthless investments sincerely believed they were smart enough to turn a risky, sub-prime mortgage into a perfectly safe investment. It was all right there in the computer.

Unfortunately, stupidity is not a crime.

What's in the bailout deal for those suffering foreclosure on their homes?
— John N., New York, N.Y.

Not much.

Many nnalert who balked at approving the plan the first time around cited this as one of their biggest concerns. Both sides have been arguing for over a year about what — if anything — the government should offer in the way of direct relief to homeowners. So far the best they’ve come up with is a program to help homeowners get in touch with lenders in the hope that those lenders will voluntarily agree to take losses and renegotiate more affordable monthly payments.

But it hasn’t worked very well. The pace of defaults and foreclosures is still rising. Several million more homeowners will likely lose their homes. The estimates are only best guesses at this point; much depends on how much further the economy slides before it begins to recover.

The latest data aren’t encouraging. Friday’s report on unemployment showed the pace of job losses picking up in September. Until that number peaks and begins falling, the outlook for housing will only get worse. Lost jobs mean lost paychecks — which makes it a lot harder to make a mortgage payment.

CONTINUED : Why not give consumers the $700 billion?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 2 Next >
Discuss Story

On NewsvineRate Story:

View popularLowHigh

4 after 742 ratingsEmailInstant MessagePrint
MORE FROM ANSWER DESK
What's your take on bailout?
Can’t we put the bums away?What's your take on bailout?The financial mess and youWhy no bailout for homeowners?Are W-4 changes a good idea?Who cares about Fannie, Freddie?Is it better to save or pay off debt?Placing a heating oil betHow far will gas prices fall?When nest eggs get friedAnswer Desk Section Front
Add Answer Desk headlines to your news reader:
• More RSS feeds from MSNBC.com


Top msnbc.com stories
Economists' outlook gets more dismal
Former Goldman exec to run rescue
Dow under 10,000 first time since '04
 
My own opinion, and I'll probably see a bunch of incoming for this position, is that when a young couple, not yet financially established and stable, buys a $350,000 house with 0% down and a variable rate mortgage with interest only payments for the first couple of years at which time the whole thing balloons, it's hard to feel too sorry for them. Sure, a lot of them are taken advantage of by predatory lenders, but the onus is still on the buyers to read and UNDERSTAND what they're getting into.

My wife and I bought our first house two weeks before we were married. At that time, the lender required 30% down. We shook trees and scraped barrels, then went back and shook the same trees and scraped the same barrels, but we did it. My wife told me after the fact that her father offered to loan us the money for the down payment and she refused his offer. She told him we'd either do it on our own or we wouldn't do it. Those happened to be my sentiments, also, even if I didn't have the chance to express them at the time.

Too many young couples nowadays think the world owes them a big fancy house simply because they're Americans. As Mark Twain put it, "the world owes you nothing; it was here first".
 
My dad was an unemployment ins. claims examiner and always sneared at news reports of rising unemployment in the fall because it always rises as winter approaches and seasonal jobs begin to wind down.
Didn't a lot of the trouble begin with ajustable rate mortgages which became unaffordable when rates were raised? Seems like it would have been smarter to hold the rates where they were so people could still make the payments rather than drive their payments too high. I never liked the idea of an adjustable rate. I'd find that hard to sleep with.
 
WELL, YES, BUT...
banks should not be in business to make loans that they KNOW they will foreclose on. That's not making a loan, that's loan sharking. And, now that the loan has gone sour and you've taken the the home- don't whine about how you need BOTH the home AND the money to survive.
These banks should be forced to renegotiate the loans at a "do-able" payment- either by extending the loan period (50 or 60 year home loans?) or eating a part of the principle (which they would do when the sold a foreclosure anyway).
Hundreds of elderly folks get scammed out of their dough also- somehow we all accept that as reprehensible, why is it any less so when a scoundrel preys on the young?
 
No sense in extending the loan payments -- people aren't going to live there forever.

If ten years from now you're still upside down on your extended mortgage (paying gadzooks amount of interest in the meanwhile), and your company moves...you're still between a rock and hard place of income v. taking the loss.

IIRC, it took Massachusetts housing prices in the suburbs of Boston about 10 years to fully recover after their bubble burst in the 80s.

I *do* wonder if there's an equity swap to work out though for the people in distress -- if the bank reduces the principal by say 10%, thus the loan payments. However, when the people sell the house in the future after prices have recovered for more then the reduced mortgage balance, the bank gets to be paid up to 10% more then what the original balance was when the wrote it down.
 
This isn't on morgages but on credit cards but what you said applies the same. If for some reason you run your balance up at say 15% and can't make the payment then what is the logic behind punishing that person by RAISING the interst rate? If ya can't pay it at 15% you sure can't pay it at 20%.

All that does is force the card user to file bankruptcy on it which means the loan company gets nothing. I would much rather recoup the principle and lower interest than lose it all.

I did however only graduate High School so my economic lessons are limited as conpared to those college graduates who decide it is better to get nothing than something.. Not knocking college grads here I know most all still have common sense after they graduate but then there are those.......
 
That would be a prime example of where regulation was needed by the government so those variable mortages didnt exist.
 
I agree with what you say there.I think it would be interesting to see just how much money the bank would make as a profit,and cut that,rather than look at what people cant afford to pay for a house payment.Just as you said it makes no sense to allow the bank to be a loan shark and then pay them for the loan and still kick the folks out on the street.If you want a country like that I have to question just what do you think is the sane thing to do here?This is not going to work I can already see that,and I graduated from High School not college.This looks like something that needs regulation to me.Heck,what are we taxpayers for?If this government only protects loan sharks,who has a chance,unless you are a loan shark?I dont get all the onesided stupid stuff coming out of Government nowdays.Seems like there is nobody watching out for the people at all,just stealing from us.To buy a house is a big deal,then have some crook weasel word a contract and throw you out of it needs a real stiff penalty for it.If you think thats fine as it appears some do,thats the reason right there.Humanity is such a bunch of slugs they cant even think whats good for them.Like some bird brain its go along with it and even say its good,but who is watching out for you down the road when they throw you out of yours?The old saying is give them an inch and theyll take a mile.There is another one too,give them enough rope and they will hang themselves.Maybe there has always been a lot of slugs in humanity?
No offense Jose Bagge,it was kind of all mixed up with something I read up above,I think you are right,its the others that think this behavior is alright that I am worried about.
 
This is simply part of a massive transfer of wealth,i.e. real estate, from the lower and middle class to the bankers and the upper class. Even if you evict these people from their homes, they still have to live somewhere. So when the banks finish their foreclosures, look for a lot more rental properties--formerly single-family homes--to hit the market, not for sale [you can't get blood from a turnip] but for rent. Eventually, you'll see a class of landowners and a class of serfs, just like what was seen in the Middle Ages.

With the killing of the middle class' 401(k) "nest egg" in the stock market, a large chunk of wealth has already been transferred out of the hands of the masses. I predict it's not coming back anytime soon, at least not soon enough to fund boomers' retirements. That money is long gone.

At least that's the plan I see. But if the rich push their agenda too far, nobody will be able to afford the rent, and instead we'll see another Great Depression...because if the masses can't pay them, the rich won't have income, either. Then the government takes over the properties for unpaid taxes, and the government becomes the landlord.

Think of it as a reverse version of the type of "redistribution of wealth" that a lot of folks are telling us that external_link is planning. Truth is, the wheels are already in motion, and not much external_link does--or doesn't do--if he's elected will matter. And McCain appears to not understand quite what is going on, but apparently since President Bush thinks it's important, it must be.

God help us all.
 
Goose,
I agree with you 100%. When we bought our first house 30+ yrs ago, we bought what we could afford on my income alone even though both of us worked. When we bought our second home 10 yrs later, we did the same thing and upgraded to a 2400 sq ft place but still stayed conservative on the financing so it would be paid off in 15 yrs. We bought it in 1987 and credit was tightening up and the only way to finance was with an ARM. We didn't like it, but negotiated a 5 yr ARM with a cap on the interest rate. We calculated the worst case scenario on the ARM to make sure we could still afford it and monitored the fixed rates for the next few years. When credit loosened up, we converted to a fixed rate and then paid it off in 15 yrs.

During that time, lots of people we know bought "trophy houses" or "McMansions" that cost a lot of money to maintain in taxes, heating & cooling, furnishing, landscaping, etc and we just shook our heads wondering how they could afford it. Those same people now have thousands and thousands of dollars in credit card debt, are upside-down on the big SUV payments and are blaming everyone but themselves. Just look at some of the cable shows on home makeovers. It's not unusual to have $100k plus on a kitchen remodel or $50k plus on a bathroom remodel. They are beautiful to look at, but who needs a $1000 dollar kitchen faucet? Or who needs a $50K Cadillac Escalade to get to/from work?

As you say, no one held a gun to those young couples buying a $350k home. The "predatory lending" theory is a "red herring". I don't blame the lenders but I also don't feel sorry for them. Example: The 90" year old lady who shot herself was given a $45k mortgage and an equitly line of credit 4 yrs ago. That transaction alone lacks common sense on both sides. Now Fannie Mae gives ther the house and forgives the mortgage. Guess who really picks up the tab? You and me as taxpayers. I'll bet there's a lineup at local ammo dealers of senior citizens buying handguns, shooting themselves in the leg and then expecting to have their medical bills paid by Medicare and their mortgages written off. :lol:

It all boils down to people living beyond their means, crying "woe is me" and epecting others to pick up the tab. However, I'd bet that most of the people that read this forum are salt-of-the earth, fiscally conservative types and you're preaching to the choir, Goose.
 
Some of thats right,the transfer of wealth part.Now you think since they got away with it so far that things will end up with a bunch of serfs?If it was you in that position,you wouldnt like it,and I dont think people will put up with it.Yeah they can make it hard on working folks,but when working folks make it hard back on them,it changes the world.Look in any history book.Sometimes it makes things worse too.So you better hope somebody does make it matter what they do,because if the people start doing like say the French Revolution,it might be a lot different than you think.The problem with serfs is,they dont like being serfs,then they get mad and go crazy.Then things get worse for everybody.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top