electronic ignition for 8n

Anonymous-0

Well-known Member
howdo folks,
been an 8n owner for many years and remember when they were the tractor of choice around here.
Kind of dates me. was wondering if anyone has some experience with an electronic ignition for the 8n or is this some kind of evil act. My tractor runs not bad but as soon as it comes under load it seems to break fire. contemplating electronic ignition rather than replacing coil etc in an atempt to find cause.
 
" contemplating electronic ignition rather than replacing coil etc in an atempt to find cause. "

That's about the worst reason there is for installing EI.

The EI debate comes up here w/ such frequency that you would benefit from doing an archives search on the topic so that you can make an informed decision based upon factual information. Generally speaking, you will find a few facts, a lot of opinion, & some BS (“ my EI system doesn't have any transistors... “) . You will also find factual information that isn’t the least bit relevant to installing EI on a 23 hp, 60 year old tractor. (“the automotive industry went to EI 35 years ago”)

Once you parse out the BS & ill-tempered rants, there are specific factual pros & cons for keeping a points system and for using EI on an N. What it really comes down to however, is your use of the tractor & your ability (or interest) to perform maintenance on the tractor. Points require annual maintenance & replacement usually every 4 or 5 years. The EI unit itself does not have annual maintenance requirements.

I’ll offer my rationale for keeping the points in my N’s; if our experience & situation are similar, then perhaps EI isn’t the answer for you either.



Knowledge. I was probably 13 or 14 when I learned how to change a set of points; that was in 1962 or 63. Every car I owned up until 1976 had points. I can fix them or change them & I have the tools to do it; I understand how they work & understand the need to use quality parts. But, while I understand how EI works, I do not have the tools or knowledge to fix it when it breaks. When it stops, it stops. You aren't going to get it going again w/ a finger nail file, screwdriver & a dime to set the gap. Even as frustrating as points can be at times, worst case scenario is replace them for $16 and continue work. Not so w/ that EI unless you have some hi-tech testing equipment & the skills to use it. Don’t use the reliability of the EI on your car or truck as a benchmark for longevity on your N. Your car’s ignition system was designed for the EI & uses far different materials at much closer tolerances than your 60 year old tractor’s ignition system, designed for points. There are many specific & valid reasons that vehicles today use EI & most of those reasons are not applicable to a 23 hp, 2400 rpm 60 year old tractor engine. If you think an EI on these N’s is foolproof, then do that archive search I suggested. You will see many examples of folks who are not pleased to spend $135 for something that will fail & can't be fixed by the average-Joe tractor owner. Just click on the link below to find the most recent example. And, I'm also amazed at some of the EI owners around here who will constantly tell us how infallible EI is every time the debate comes up but are strangely silent when a unit malfunctions.



6v System. All 3 of my N’s are 6v & I haven’t had a reason to convert them to 12v. And, because of the precise voltage requirements of EI (it won’t work below 5.2v) EI on a 6v system is just a problem waiting to happen.



Maintenance. I keep my 2 front distributor & 1 side distributor N’s well maintained. Contrary to what some folks will tell you, EI will not cure a bad rotor or cap, worn plug wires, a bad ballast resistor, an ill-fitting coil or any other typical ignition problems found on these old tractors. The EI is only going to be as good as the system it’s installed on. All you get by putting an EI on an N w/ these problems is a poorly running N w/ an EI instead of points.



Consequence of error. If I hook up the battery cables backward on my points system nothing happens to them. Reverse polarity on an EI and it fries. If I leave the key on & the points are closed, I melt the points & probably the coil. That’s a $40 mistake. If you leave the key on w/ EI, that’s a $150 mistake.



Cost. I can replace a lot of points for the cost of EI. And, in my case, I’d need to convert the tractor to 12v, so that’s a total cost of around $235.

EI does not give you higher spark voltage, eliminate all maintenance on your ignition system or give enough of a horsepower boost to cause the tractor to do wheelies. It replaces the points. That’s it. It will not correct or overcome other problems in the ignition system. While it may give you more HP or improve fuel economy, both would be so insignificant as to be hardly noticeable on a 23 hp engine. If you can’t set points or don’t care to do it, or you don’t want to spend the 30 minutes or so a year to check the gap & lube the cam, then you will be happy w/ EI. And, the EI unit itself will be maintenance free. (but the rest of the ignition system won’t) You will spend probably $235 for an EI kit & 12v conversion. If you install them correctly you will have an easy starting tractor for a long time. And, the 12 volt conversion & EI will have just about nothing to do w/ the good performance. What will make the real difference is the new wiring, cables, clean grounds & new battery.

The key advantage to EI is that you do not need to gap & lube the points every year & replace them every 4 or 5 years or. If you perform annual maintenance on the points & change them every 4 years or so using quality parts, you will see no difference whatsoever between a points ignition system & EI on an N.

The key disadvantages to EI on an N are initial cost, nearly impossible for the average N owner to repair, will not work w/ low battery voltage, & easily damaged beyond repair by polarity reversal & other common mistakes.

Bottom line……….this is the question you need to answer: “If tens of thousands of other N’s operate just fine on 6v and points, why can’t mine?”
EI Failure
 
you'd probably be better of 'contemplating' diagnosing what your tractors problem is, vs buying a bunch of parts at random and tossing at it.

i'd start by doing the normal checks..

check points gap, dizzy bushings, etc.

is it backfireing or after fireing?

check timing, and more importantly.. check mainjet / fuel flow.

if you are running lean it will pop and crackle and missfire... will also make it run hotter too...

soundguy
 
Brian,

I will say this. My 8n starts in any weather. It was 5 dgrees out yesterday
and she starts right up...6 volt and all. As soon as you put electronic ignition
in it.....it is no longer original...and this is a subjective thought, but it takes away the history and mystique of the old beast....There is just something about using an original 60 plus year old farm tractor in it's original condition.
Enough of my sentimentality....Many have done it...the electonic ignition thing...But as for me I would
cruise the archives for one of Bruce(VA)s primers on the ignition system!
He is a master when it comes to that, and has helped many guys, novice and
experienced. Lots of other sharp guys with lots of know how also willing to lend out advise.....It may be cheaper than electonic ignition!

Cheers,
Ed
 
When I bought my 8N at a sale it hadn't ran in 10 years. The first thig I did was convert it to 12 volt neg. ground. Now it starts faster then I can let off the starter switch. Its smooth under a load but acts a little like yours with no load. Not sure what to try next.
 
" Not sure what to try next. "

Front or side distributor?

When is the last time you replaced the points, plugs, condenser, rotor & cap & set the timing?

Had the carb apart & cleaned?
50 Tips
 
My tractor runs not bad but as soon as it comes under load it seems to break fire. contemplating electronic ignition rather than replacing coil etc in an atempt to find cause.

Your points are a simple switch although they have to stay open for a relative number of degrees .

The EI unit will only cure a malfunction in the opening and closing cycle of the points due to an improper gap or a wore lobe .


It sounds like you have one of two problems , a point gap that is too much or too little or a bad carburetor adjustment/ clogged filter .

Personally I would install a temporary wire and check the points with a dwell meter , then check your fuel flow from the drain plug on the bottom of the carb before ordering any parts .
 
(quoted from post at 14:19:01 01/30/12) howdo folks,
been an 8n owner for many years and remember when they were the tractor of choice around here.
Kind of dates me. was wondering if anyone has some experience with an electronic ignition for the 8n or is this some kind of evil act. My tractor runs not bad but as soon as it comes under load it seems to break fire. contemplating electronic ignition rather than replacing coil etc in an attempt to find cause.


brian, you will read here some "very limited" (few) defined information on which way to convert to 12 volt EI system, as this is a 6 volt crowd and their stance is profound against converting to 12 volts. I'm one of the "very few" here that has switched. That was in year 2000 when Electronic Ignition was unheard off on the "N" series tractors. My 12 volt EI conversion kit (system) came from the people at Genesee Products in Owasso, Ok. I was one of the first if not the first to have the kit made for the front mount distributor, as Genesee first made the kit for the side mount distributor. If you should call Andy at Genesee, he will sell you all the parts, wiring, alternator with pulley and brackets, and instructions to make the change. You will need to keep the old original roter (bug) has it is called. I didn't use my roter bug for the simple reason I had a different type to use, and it works. This "pickup probe" was designed my Leon Dutcher in Liberty, Ky back in 1968 to use on Ford flathead engines with 12 volt EI system. He sent me one in 1974 to be used when I was considering switching to 12 volt EI conversion.

Here is a complete write up by Genesee Products.


Recommendations for 12 Volt Conversions
By Genesee Products
When converting a tractor from 6 to 12 volts, five basic areas of the electrical system must be considered:

Charging System
Ignition System
Starter
Accessories
Battery
Charging System

There are many different methods for converting a charging system to 12 volts, however, the most popular approach is to use a Delco alternator with an internal regulator. These alternators are available in several different configurations with the most common being the model 10-SI which was used on General Motors vehicles from the 1970’s through the early 1980’s. Because there were literally millions of these alternators built they are readily available and have proven to be very reliable. The 10-SI was also built as a “one-wire” or marine alternator, but this model is less common and therefore more expensive. A one-wire alternator is slightly easier to install (one wire versus three), however, the standard automotive 10-SI offers better charging characteristics at low speed.

The price range for the 10-SI ranges from as low as $10 at a salvage yard up to $50 for a rebuilt unit from the auto parts store. The 10-SI was built in several different amp ratings, but any of them will work since a tractor’s electrical requirements are typically very low. Probably the most common 10-SI is the 63 amp model and many auto parts stores stock it as part number 7127. Another variable to consider with the 10-SI (or any alternator) is pulley diameter. The smaller the pulley, the faster the alternator will spin. For example, if the alternator pulley is one fourth the diameter of the crankshaft pulley, the alternator will turn 4 times the speed of the engine, if it is one third the diameter of the crankshaft pulley it will turn 3 times engine speed, and so on. A typical 10-SI (3-wire) will begin charging when the alternator is turning about 1200 rpm.

Mounting the alternator tends to be the most difficult part of any 12 volt conversion because a bracket usually needs to be fabricated. On some tractors the “bracket” will simply be a long 3/8” bolt but for others the bracket will be more involved. For many tractors, a hack saw, some strap metal, and a little common sense is all that will be required to mount the 10-SI. The most important consideration is safety, the bracket must be substantial enough to handle the weight of the alternator plus the tension from the belt without excessive flexing.

When using a standard Delco alternator, it is necessary to change from positive to negative ground. On a tractor this normally only affects the ammeter and coil. (Coil is discussed below.) The ammeter is affected because it senses the flow of electrical current and is sensitive to which direction the current is flowing, i.e. charging versus discharging. Reversing the wires on the ammeter is all that is required to make the ammeter read correctly.

Although not required, a voltmeter is strongly recommended for 12 volt conversions. The voltmeter can be used in place of the ammeter or in addition to it. A voltmeter offers several advantages over an ammeter. First, because the amp draw of a tractor’s electrical system is so low, it is often hard to tell if the alternator is charging because the ammeter needle is so close to zero. With a voltmeter, a voltage of 13.5 - 14.5 volts will register anytime the alternator is charging regardless of how low the amp draw may be. Secondly, the wiring for a voltmeter is much simpler because it can be connected to the ignition switch versus an ammeter which must be wired in series with the heavy 10 gauge wire from the alternator. This provides for a safer installation since all of the amperage from the alternator doesn’t have to pass through the dash. And finally, a voltmeter is more effective when troubleshooting the electrical system as it can help identify problems such as poor connections, a weak battery, dragging starter, or a faulty alternator.

Choosing a good quality voltmeter is as important as having one to begin with. For accuracy and reliability, heavy duty gauges such as those made by Datcon and Stewart Warner are a good choice for tractors and other heavy equipment.

Ignition System

The coil is the only component of the ignition system affected when converting from 6 to 12 volts. Like the ammeter, the wires on the coil must be reversed. This means the negative (-) terminal of the coil is the one that connects to the distributor, while the positive (+) terminal connects to the ignition switch. Also, for the system to operate properly, the coil must also have the correct resistance value for use with 12 volts. Since there are several ways to accomplish this, there seems to be considerable confusion surrounding coil selection. Most of the confusion comes in when referring to “6 volt” coils versus “12 volt “ coils and the accompanying ballast resistor that is sometimes used. The important point to remember is:


The total resistance of the coil plus any external resistor (if used) should be 2.7 to 3.3 ohms for a 12 volt system. This level of resistance will maintain the correct voltage and amperage in the ignition circuit. Coil resistance is measured between the plus (+) and minus (-) terminals.
Most original equipment 6 volt coils are about 1.2 ohms, while most original equipment 12 volt coils are about 1.5 ohms. In order to get to the 2.7 to 3.3 ohm requirement, a ballast resistor such as a Napa ICR13 (Approx. 1.8 ohm) can be added to these type coils. Another approach is to eliminate the ballast resistor altogether by using a replacement coil with 3.0 ohms of resistance. Two commonly available 3 ohm coils are the Napa IC14 and the Pertronix High Voltage 40511.

If the tractor is equipped with a magneto, the basic ignition system itself will be unaffected by the change from 6 to 12 volts. Some tractors with magneto ignition, however, will need a new ignition switch for controlling the power to the alternator and other accessories. Most auto parts stores stock universal ignition switches such as the Napa KSI-32 or Borg-Warner CS-101 which have terminals for grounding the magneto and controlling 12 volt accessories.

Starter

The starter will be unaffected by the change from positive to negative ground (it will rotate the same direction) and generally will tolerate the increased voltage, assuming the starter is in good working condition. Like other parts on an older tractor, starters were designed with considerable safety factor and as a result they can be run on 12 volts without damaging the windings. A common practice is to use the starter as is, and rewind it for 12 volts when and if it ever needs major repair. As with any vehicle, it’s best to avoid sustained cranking and the starter should be given ample time to cool between starting attempts if excessive cranking is required. When converting to 12 volts, it’s a good idea to check the starter drive and flywheel ring gear to make sure they are in good shape since the additional “kick” of 12 volts will put more stress on these components. Also, if the starter is dragging, now is the time to repair it because the additional voltage will only aggravate the situation.

Accessories

The most common (and usually the only) accessory on a tractor is the lights. In most cases the 6 volt bulbs can be replaced equivalent 12 volt bulbs. In those instances where a 12 volt replacement is not available, a new holder or lamp assembly will be required.

Battery

Changing the battery is so obvious it is seldom mentioned when discussing a voltage conversion. When selecting a 12 volt battery, the physical size and electrical capacity of the battery should be considered. A typical Group 1 six volt battery measures 8-7/8” long x 6-7/8” wide x 8” tall, so most battery trays have ample room for a 12 volt battery. The popular Group 26 (8-1/4 x 6-3/4 x 7-1/2) battery will easily fit most applications as it is somewhat smaller than the Group 1 dimensions. A Group 25, will provide an even better fit since its dimensions are almost identical to the Group 1 six volt. Also available is the Group 35, which is identical to the Group 25 except the posts are reversed.

When considering battery capacity it is easy to get caught up in the “more is better” approach and base the selection strictly on the CCA (cold cranking amps) rating. CCA ratings of 500-800 amps are seldom needed in vintage tractor applications and furthermore high a CCA rating doesn’t necessarily mean the battery is well constructed. Unfortunately, most battery manufacturers don’t publish details of the their plate and grid construction, so it’s hard to compare brands. However, for tractors that see infrequent use, a “commercial” or “heavy duty” rated battery will hold up better over the long haul than a typical discount store automotive battery. Most of the leading name brand manufacturers (Delco, Interstate, Diehard, etc.) offer heavy duty batteries that are well suited for tractor use.

After converting to 12 volts, 4 gauge battery cables typically provide ample capacity for tractors up to about 40 HP, unless the cables are over 6 feet long. For long cables and tractors above 40 HP, 2 gauge cables are usually adequate. In reality, poor connections are more often the cause of excessive voltage drop than undersize cables. And of course, a little preventative maintenance at the connections (both ends of both cables) is all it takes to avoid a problem in this area.

A final thought………..

10-SI Wiring Instructions:

The 10-SI alternator has three terminals, however only two of them get connected to the tractor. (Thus, the 10-SI is sometimes referred to as a two-wire or three-wire alternator)


The “Bat” terminal should be connected to the ammeter with a 10 gauge wire. If a voltmeter is used instead of an ammeter, the 10 gauge wire can be run directly to the stud on the starter where the battery cable connects.
The number “1” terminal should be connected to the ignition switch with 16 or 18 gauge wire so the alternator only receives power when the tractor is “on”. A one amp / 50 volt diode should be installed between the ignition switch and the “1” terminal to prevent backward current flow through the alternator when the ignition switch is “off”.
The number “2” terminal should be connected directly to the “Bat” terminal (16 or 18 gauge wire) on the back of the alternator.
Note: Genesee Products offers several products to help with your 12 volt conversion, including a wiring kit for the 10-SI alternator. For more information on these products, please visit their web site or contact them at [email protected]
 
gentlemen
I have been without 'at home' access to the internet for about two years since my daughter who must use it for work, moved into her 'new to her' house. No cable of fiber optic service here. A tower/dis network exists but not all that reliable. Last week I learned of a service through the Bell cellphone network at $45.00/mo instead of the option's $65.00 so had to reevaluate access to "the Earth's knowledge" or continuing to clutch onto that little ball of money! Always knew I was doing wrong not plugging into the net again and the sooner the better. Just like the magazine Farm Show who's subscription I have never let lapse since first I saw it decades ago. Pays for itself every issue by stimulating one's quriousity, and enthuiasm for living over and over again as one is exposed to the creativity, individuality and ingenuity of the many contributors.
Enough babbling on, just want to say having all these wonderful contacts from you all, and especially so quickly, have renewed my former awareness of this magical communication medium, and energized my zest for such a challange my wonderful old 8n is currently presenting to me.
So thank you all so much and now with all the help each have, and can offer, lets get at the old girl and get her fixed.
The background is that it was working as good as it could needing a little tlc. This I did and went through the misery of Mr. Fords use of 'all the old parts' before he would switch to the side distributor and took the entire front off the tractor so I could see what I was doing. Thought I was thorough and I am quite careful with more than a little experience. The old girl worked worse!!! Now been through it all once more at least. There is some distributor shaft shake but not enough to account for the fairly rapidly worsening of the fire issue.
The reassembly and subsequent crappy results resulted in a few new bits of info like a correction of spark gap that was incorporated into a new disassembly check everything out and reassembly, with the same embarassing results.
As soon as it warms up around here (-12C tonight) again, I will head in again Not dumb at this boys but from experience over the years I have learned that the reasnon it is trying hard and messing up will probably be found to be something dum that dum dum dum didn't catch the first few time!
OK IT WAS TEMPORARY INSANITY DUE TO TRAUMATIC FRUSTRATION CAUSED ME TO CONTEMPLATE THE ELECTRONIC FINAL BLEEP BLEEP SOLUTION. mY OLD GIRL IS ALL STILL ORIGINAL AND I SO WANT TO KEEP HER SO FOR ALL THE WONDERFUL SOLUTIONS MANY OF YOU HAVE POINTED OUT.
Actually I have forgotten all the little things one notices when doing such an "visit to the points world" in an 8n front distributor but all that inside cap cleaning and checking for cracks I did do and the rotar looked good, points were good and gap confirmed several times. No dwell meter used though.
My guess going in again is that I missed something in the cap, but at this stage that is only a guss.
Well got to go for now.
Thanks again so much for all your responses so far and I do hope you will continue to give good suggestions and worthy criticisms!
Brian
 
I put a Pertonix Elec. Ign in mine Nov. 2010. couldn't find good points and to lazy to mess with making the Tisco ones work. Tractor ran great till last week when I was plowing snow across the road, and it quit right there in the middle of the road. No spark No way.

This was out at my camp. Got the tractor back home and eliminated everything but the Elec.Ign..
When they run they run great when they don't you'r kinda up a creek.

I'm going to try to get Pertonix to warrenty it and if they will I'll keep it as a spare.

I'm in the process of converting back to the old point system and a spare set to keep in the shed.

Just my 2 cents worth.

BP
 
Ahhhh yes, 8N1949, the EI expert. The link below is all I needed to know about your EI expertise.

Is this the same EI you told us about in on January 25th, 2010 when you said “ Genesee Electronic Ignition system doesn't have any transistors... Any other so-called electronic ignition system is not a true EI system.
DID I SAY.."NONE"?”

OK, this is a truly revolutionary system…..never set the timing, no rotor….and doesn’t even have transistors!

Suffice it to say that you're previous posts on this topic, as well as many others, call in to question your knowledge of N tractors.
EI w/o a rotor & no timing
 
Google electronic ignition failures.Ive had one die in my pickup,Friend had one quit on the road.Cost him 300 bucks for tow and repair.I was at a gun show,fellow asked me if there was an auto parts store nearby.His Ford pickup had lost 3 ss ignitions and # 4 just quit.I told him store was a 1/4 mile away and he said he was buying two so a spare will be in the truck.Google Ford Motor co ignition module failures.My truck quit in the drive way so it didnt cost me.Pulled the module from a distributor I had under the bench.
 
I didnt say it was no good.I dont want to pay 100 bucks for a lump of epoxy with 3 bucks worth of parts in it.I paid 4 bucks for new points and condensor 25 years ago,Tractor starts when I need it.
 
The pestronix ignition module has a Hall effect transistor and an Scr in it A Hall effect transistor conducts when a magnet is brought near it.This triggers the SCR TO CONDUCT and cause current to flow in the coils primary.I replace a lot of scrs and diodes in fence chargers.
 
took the entire front off the tractor so I could see what I was doing..........................................................................
Thanks again so much for all your responses so far and I do hope you will continue to give good suggestions and worthy criticisms!
Brian

Brain , take 3 minutes and a 1/2" to remove the two bolts holding the distributor in , bring it into the shop and rework it on a bench , use a test light or volt meter to check that the points are working correctly ( sometimes they look good but do not actually work ) The wrong size gap will make them run worse , if at all .

When you reinstall the complete unit , align the distributor tab into the cam slot . The slot and tab are off set to one side , it should only fit one way . You can turn the rotor until it drops into place . If it feels too tight , don't force it , it may be 180* out ( ask my brother in law what happens when you force it in 180* out ).

I have an EI unit that has not failed me and a 12v point system on another N that works fine too . I keep a back up rebuilt distributor so I can swap one out in a few minutes if I break at a bad time .
 
Ken, just came from a walk in the snow and now know where there are two new half inch bolt heads that sure look like I need to develop a relationship with them. Thanks thanks thanks!
Will pull the unit off as soon as I get a chance.
I am glad to find out that there was some forthought in putting that distributor up there where it hides so well. Back when I have new data!
brian
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top