Electronic Ignition thoughts

JIM603

New User
Here a thought, if my timimg is right and my points are off the mark,then if i install a Electronic Ignition kit in will my problem go away.
 
Jim603 I will tell you what the gurus told me. I can go electronic and pay 100 plus bucks to fix it when it breaks or a few bucks for points etc leaving it like it is. I chose the old ways.
Devious
 
The EI debate comes up here w/ such frequency that you would benefit from doing an archives search on the topic. Generally speaking, you will find a few facts, a lot of opinion, & unfortunately, a little BS (“ my EI system doesn't have any transistors... “) . And sometimes you will find factual information that isn’t the least bit relevant to installing EI on a 23 hp, 60 year old tractor. (“the automotive industry went to EI 35 years ago”)

The opinions about EI you will find in the archives can be grouped in three broad categories:

1. EI on an N is the greatest invention since sliced bread.

2. If it's not broke, don't fix it.

3. EI on an N is a waste of money & will ultimately cause you more problems than points ever will..

There are specific pros & cons for keeping a points system and for using EI on an N. What it really comes down to however, is your use of the tractor & your ability (or interest) to perform maintenance on the tractor. Points require annual maintenance & replacement usually every 4 or 5 years. EI does not have annual maintenance requirements.



I’ll offer my rationale for keeping the points in my N’s; if our experience & situation are similar, then perhaps EI isn’t the answer for you either.



Knowledge. I was probably 13 or 14 when I learned how to change a set of points; that was in 1962 or 63. Every car I owned up until 1976 had points. I can fix them or change them & I have the tools to do it; I understand how they work & understand the need to use quality parts. But, while I understand how EI works, I do not have the tools to fix it when it breaks. When it stops, it stops. You aren't going to get it going again w/ a finger nail file, screwdriver & a dime to set the gap. Even as frustrating as points can be at times, worst case scenario is replace them for $16 and continue work. Not so w/ that EI unless you have some hi-tech testing equipment & the skills to use it. Don’t use the reliability of the EI on your car or truck as a benchmark for longevity on your N. Your car’s ignition system was designed for the EI & uses far different materials at much closer tolerances than your 60 year old tractor’s ignition system, designed for points. There are many specific & valid reasons that vehicles today use EI & most of those reasons are not applicable to a 23 hp, 2400 rpm 60 year old tractor engine. If you think an EI on these N’s is foolproof, then do that archive search I suggested.


6v System. All 4 of my N’s are 6v & I haven’t had a reason to convert them to 12v. And, because of the precise voltage requirements of EI (it won’t work below 5.2v) EI on a 6v system is just a problem waiting to happen.


Maintenance. I keep my 2 front distributor & 2 side distributor N’s well maintained. Contrary to what some folks will tell you, EI will not cure a bad rotor or cap, worn plug wires, a bad ballast resistor, an ill-fitting coil or any other typical ignition problems found on these old tractors. The EI is only going to be as good as the system it’s installed on. All you get by putting an EI on an N w/ these problems is a poorly running N w/ an EI instead of points.


Consequence of error. If I hook up the battery cables backward on my points system nothing happens to them. Reverse polarity on an EI and it fries. If I leave the key on & the points are closed, I melt the points & probably the coil. That’s a $40 mistake. If you leave the key on w/ EI, that’s a $150 mistake.


Cost. I can replace a lot of points for the cost of EI. And, in my case, I’d need to convert the tractor to 12v, so that’s a total cost of around $235.


EI does not give you higher spark voltage, eliminate all maintenance on your ignition system or give enough of a horsepower boost to cause the tractor to do wheelies. It replaces the points. That’s it. It will not correct or overcome other problems in the ignition system. While it may give you more HP or improve fuel economy, both would be so insignificant as to be hardly noticeable on a 23 hp engine. If you can’t set points or don’t care to do it, or you don’t want to spend the 30 minutes or so a year to check the gap & lube the cam, then you will be happy w/ EI. And, the EI unit itself will be maintenance free. (but the rest of the ignition system won’t) You will spend probably $235 for an EI kit & 12v conversion. If you install them correctly you will have an easy starting tractor for a long time. And, the 12 volt conversion & EI will have just about nothing to do w/ the good performance. What will make the real difference is the new wiring, cables, clean grounds & new battery.

Here is the key advantage to EI: you do not need to replace the points every 4 or 5 years or gap & lube them every year. If you perform annual maintenance on the points & change them every 4 years or so using quality parts, you will see no difference whatsoever between a points ignition system & EI on an N.

Here are the key disadvantages to EI on an N: initial cost, nearly impossible for the average N owner to repair, will not work w/ low battery voltage, & easily damaged beyond repair by polarity reversal & other common mistakes.

Bottom line……….this is the question you need to answer: “If tens of thousands of other N’s operate just fine on 6v and points, why can’t mine?”
50 Tips
 
Some solid state ignitions do use transistors,I put one on my 38 Dodge in the early 50s.The points were still to make the transistor conduct.Since there was little current flow thru the points the had to be cleaned often.The magic ss ignition that Dufus blows over 100 bucks on has a pick up coil, a silicon controlled rectifier and a diode.Everthing is potted in epoxy so you cant repair it.SCRs I use cost my customers 4 bucks,diodes are 50 cents to 1 buck.SCRs and diode are big failure items in electric fence chargers.I buy SCRs and diodes in 50 lots.SCRs short often.They need a trigger voltage of 30 volts to conduct.They can self trigger or not trigger at all.They need a protective diode shunting them to protect them against inductive kick back from the ignition coil.I dont want any solid state devices in my tractor, they would increase the chances of a break down.My present points and condensor are on year 23,I had to clean the points with a pocket knife twice during that time.When you add parts to a machine you increase the chance of break down.New cars are a good example.
 
If you have a problem with defective points then an EI unit would fix your problem , so would a quality set of points . The cheap ones with a soft rubbing block will make you cuss a little .

I would recommend to anyone with a front mount distributor N to buy a used distributor (ebay?) and rebuild it with points for a spare . This can usually be done for less than the price of an EI unit .

If you still want an EI unit go for it and don"t look back . I had a distributor that had bad lobes . It was $70 for new parts or $100 for the EI .
 
My'41 9n runs well,and the maintenance time is not hard work,and kinda like therapy.---lha
 
(quoted from post at 09:12:06 07/13/10) My'41 9n runs well,and the maintenance time is not hard work,and kinda like therapy.---lha
ust read article in paper here about a school teacher's pick-um-up being hit by lightening while driving down the road. Made me think of another potential advantage/disadvantage for points/EI. Let us say you are out plowing & your tractor is hit by lightening and neither you or your tires are blown out......with points you can keep on plowing, but with EI, your ignition is likely shot! :twisted:
 
My points beat that easy.That figures out to 15 cents per year.Friend EI ignition cost him 300 bucks when it died on the road ,had to be towed off the interstate.I talked with a fellow at a gun show, he asked if there was an auto parts store nearby.This was module #4 failure on his truck.Google pertronics ignition failures.
 
Really???? Older model cars had to have a tune up with new plugs, points & condenser every 12k. Been there done that..HEI didn't come out till after I learned to drive. New HEI systems run 100k then just change the plugs. Older cars generally went about 100k to rebuild (been there done that too) new cars are running 200+k without the engine being opened up.....facts you can look up on the net and verify yourself.

I'm going to convert my N over this summer yet. It gets run at least 5-6 hours a week and sometimes more between lawn mowing and drive maint.....

AS far as the original problem....fix it first! Then if you decide to go IE it should be a snap.

Rick
 
Comparing EI on an N to EI on a modern vehicle is apples to oranges.

Use good quality points, gap & lube them once a year (or, every 100 hours) and they will perform just as good as the EI. If you can't/won't do that, then EI is a good choice.
 
No need for me to do that Coupe. I'm really not that interested.
Looking around me here I see that my microwave, window air conditioner, radio, pickup, computer and cell phone are all solid state. I don't own a TV but I know they are all solid state as well.
I have found every one of those devices to very reliable. Never had to have any electronic part fixed on any of them. So to me I find no reason not to use a solid state ignition system in my tractor.
It makes no difference to me if you don't like EI and do like points. I'm not here to try to convince you to see or do things my way. Not at all.
If a guy wants to learn about his electrics there are plenty of people here to help him keep his breaker point ignition system sparking and/or his 6 volt tractor charging.
But there are many guys who don't understand tractor electrics as well as you and are not really inclined to learn. In my book that does not make them stupid. Maybe they know more about paint and bodywork than the two of us put together.
Those are the guys to whom I keep suggesting modern electrics. Hire a pro to convert for you if you need to. Why make the tractor a hassle?
I've got no beef with you Coupe if you want to run points because you think they are better.
It's just that my cell phone, radio, pickup, etc lead me to think otherwise.
Why belittle folks for thinking different?
 
All the solid state devices you mention are not that reliable ,the dumps are full of them,I worked repairing them from 1951 on.The early color tv sets were breaking down constantly.Pick ups are loaded with features they dont need.It can cost more to fix one now than it did to buy a new one in the 1970s.I refuse to replace a set of points with a 100 buck part.I refuse to remove and junk parts that are working fine.The problems with ss ignitions and 12 volt conversions are well known.The evidence of failure of ss ignitions is on the web for all to see.
 
This guy thinks Eisenhower is still president and not smart enough to make the connection that he is using solid state computer to post his bs
 
SOS,different day.Not 1 iota of new useful info from these 2 in last several years,just bicker,call names,insults.Need old fashion duel to end this sh1t! At least swap e-mail to spare rest of world!
 
Well innmann and lol,
36 Coupe and I may go round and round but at least we've got the stones to post under our regular handles. What's your excuse?
 
(quoted from post at 15:27:56 07/14/10) Computers crap out every day.Hot weather will get rid of many.



If the day comes and the doctor tells me I need a pace maker I think I'll ask if they have a model with blue streak points .
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top