Federal scrapping program

TGP

Member
This needs some serious action on our part, Tractors are included.

Urgent Action Alert
Oppose Federal Vehicle Scrappage Program

Washington lawmakers are drafting a large economic stimulus package to help create jobs and rebuild infrastructure. They want to include a nationwide scrappage program which would give U.S. tax dollars to consumers who turn-in older cars to have them crushed, as a misguided attempt to spur new car sales. The lawmakers need to scrap this idea.

The stimulus package is being drafted right now. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) wants to introduce the bill on January 6 and have it approved by Congress by January 20, so that President external_link can sign it into law after he is inaugurated.

Contact House Speaker Nancy Pelosi IMMEDIATELY To Oppose Cash for Clunkers!
Call: 202/225-0100
Click here to send an electronic message: http://speaker.house.gov/contact/

the entire article, plus the talking points can be seen here:


http://www.semasan.com/main/main.aspx?id=62498

----

You can also easily find out who your representative is and contact them as well, by going here:


http://www.votesmart.org
[i:75f94ea323][/i:75f94ea323]

TGP
 
Well, scrap metal to help create jobs and money for the economy sounds good. If someone wants to scap out their tractors is that your concern ? There are alot of tractors out here that they made 100`s of thousands if some get scrapped-well eventualy there price will go up. The neighbor has JD A`s &B`s sitting outside with cracked blocks beat up sheet metal all rotted rims and tires , parts missing everywhere does it make sense to fix or scrap ?
 
It is not the governments job to create jobs. It is up to the private industry to do this. The government has never created a job that didn"t wind up costing more than it accomplished.
No $$$ for scrap is not going to help. Just another way for them to raise taxes. And with the media in his pocket they will report just what he wants them to.
Just another play from the old FDR playbook. Remember the fiasco the WPA was. FDR did not get us out of the depression WWII did. Not saying I want another war to solve this issue. Only stating the facts.
 
Well......The governement cant make me turn in an old car if I dont want to. If I had an old IH tractor and it was worth $3000 to me and the goverment was going to give me $4000 for it then I made a little bit of money and I would pocket the $4000. Where would it stop, What if uncle sam offered you money to turn in your living room furniture to increase sales of lazy boy's? What if it was home appliances too?
If uncle sam wants to give me money for turning something in and I make out on the deal then, Cool, If it isnt worth it to me then I keep the item(s)
Politicitans are crooks and will do anything to get reelected. Should be 1 term, 1 time, no running for office for decades. Period!
Remember that the US fed. gov. is run like a train headed for a wreck. The fed. budget deficit is insane and if the elected clowns want waste more of your money on buying junk then.....So be it. They shouldnt be in the garage sale business though.
 
I can see the writing on the wall. Read between the lines! Think about the dealings behind closed doors. Another crooked move. What a way to get more scrap metal for CORPORATE AMERICAN COMPANIES over in CHINA. And useing TAX PAYER's dollars at that. Not just China, but anywhere in the world these corporate S.O.B.'s set up shop. They know how to mend the economy. BRING THE JOBS BACK! But they don't want to do that.
 
I googled on "pelosi cash for clunkers" and got page after page of basically the same thing: That this bill is going to ruin old car restoration, and that we need to call Nancy Pelosi right now to stop it. Interestingly, though, I could find nothing about what this provision actually says, which leads me to believe that it may not even exist, except as a rumor.

These sorts of programs have been around for years. About 20 years ago, there was a program to buy up old cars in southern California. I think it was run by ARCO Petroleum. The argument was that an old car generates ten times as much pollution than a new one, so getting them off the road is a very effective way to reduce pollution. In spite of these programs, old car restoration is alive and well in California. The recent high demand for steel crushed far more old, restorable cars than any "cash for clunkers" program ever will.

If you want to call up your congressman and tell him you won't stand for legislation that will pay you 300 bucks for your beloved Yugo, go right ahead.
 
IF it is true that the GOVERNMENT is going to pay you more money than something is worth you should be up in arms about the expense of such a program. After all who do you think the government is? The government is you and I and so the money would come out of one pocket and go in the other with the exception of the administrative costs. When will people realize that they ARE the govenment?
 
This isn't so much about creating jobs as it is about the followers of Al Gore trying to get older cars that they consider less efficient and more polluting off the roads. They'll use job creation as a cover, but that's just a smoke screen (so to speak).

As soon as the economy improves you can be sure Pelosi and friends will return to their roots and tax anything they don't like out of existence. Whenever you hear the term "carbon credit" you can be sure it's another one of their social engineering initiatives.
 
Older cars are better and older tractors are better still. I won't get rid of my '63!
This thing is made out of some good metal. USA!
 
Live in Canada so the program dont effect us, but thinking here is hope all the tractors except ours get scrapped that way only farmers and serous restorers and junk collectors will have them.Make any sense?
 
Actually some of the autos built during the mid 90's get better mileage than the same models built at the turn of the century of 2000.
 
Nobody's going to hold a gun to your head and make you turn in your old car.
So don't do it, then. And if you have the only one left, your parts will be worth a lot more than they were before.

Much ado about nothing.........
 
I do agree that this would be a very dumb move. Robbing Peter to pay Paul. I for one, would not scrap my paid for vehicles, not even the wood truck to get a partial payment of my own tax dollars back. I know this is hard for the people in Washinton to believe, but most of us cannot afford a new car.
 
Now just where did this come from? There sure seems to be a whole bunch of wild stories being posted on this site about wild programs like the livestock tax and old diesel tractor buy-outs and the list just goes on and on. Stop spreading such tall stories this site can sure come up with some good ones.
 
"some of the autos built during the mid 90's get better mileage than the same models built at the turn of the century of 2000"

I don't doubt what you say, but it doesn't matter what the newer models get. They'll go after cars that have low MPG ratings or don't have anti-pollution devices they like.
 
(quoted from post at 12:30:51 01/04/09) Now just where did this come from? There sure seems to be a whole bunch of wild stories being posted on this site about wild programs like the livestock tax and old diesel tractor buy-outs and the list just goes on and on. Stop spreading such tall stories this site can sure come up with some good ones.

Copy & Paste this Link to inform yourself.

http://www.semasan.com/main/main.aspx?id=60852

You do know how to copy&paste?
TGP
 
How about a link to the actual legislation? Or maybe the bill number? Or perhaps a news report that actually quotes Representative Pelosi?

Looks like a rumor or hoax to me. Probably from some crank who doesn't like Pelosi; she's not the most popular person in Congress. If this was legit, they would state the bill number rather than just her phone number.
 
SEMA is the Specialty Equipment Market Association, and includes such companies as Edelbrock, Holley, Crane Cams...pretty much a "who's who" of the automotive aftermarket industry. These are not fly-by-night folks, but companies who have been around a long time. So when SEMA notifies me that there's something going on that might affect old cars and trucks, I generally sit up and take notice.

This is important because what YOU call a junker, I might call a parts car, truck, or tractor.
SEMA homepage
 
Friend sort of in car repair business and trucker were talking about East coast- Conneticut or Massachusetts(?) where old cars not registered and inspected were being siezed and crushed- the local model A clubs had had some of the partial restores and parts cars taken, a couple running model As had also been siezed and crushed as they didn"t pass emissions tests. These vehicles had been taken from private property and garages. The other older 1950s up runners that failed emissions tests were being impounded pending repair to bring up to emissions standards- 90 days or something without passing retest meant a crush order plus a fine. Only way out of fine for owner was a scrapping certificate from a salvage yard that would pick it up from police impound. Antique car clubs were trying to take state to court and haveing difficulty getting heard- state points to some kind of dealer/collector license that would let them keep cars that didn"t meet standards but expensive conditions as commercial zoning and secured storage required for storage area, business licensing and inspections of premises- few home garages would meet standards. About like Bloomberg saying he wasn"t against people having pistols IF they first got a license from New York City. RN
 
That sucks big time. I couldnt imagine what would happen if I had an old Model A or T and the state gov. made me turn it in for scrap and fine me too. I would get an attorney and fight it. Time for another tea party when you are not allowed to own a certain car or truck because some bureaucrat says so. That is bull$hit.
Realistically you would just tell the state that you scrapped it already and they say, Oh, okay and walk away. (just hide the car and sell it later to someone else.)
 
I'm not too worried. Their scrap program won't get very far. The people that is driving the clunkers are doing so because they can't afford something else, and even if the goverment was to give people $1,000 for their clunker, they couldn't buy much for a replacement for that.

I agree the high price of scrap got rid of an awful lot of old stuff. The local fencerows are a whole lot cleaner than they once were. I noticed enough old haybalers got scrapped in this area so that there is no such thing as a cheap one anymore when I was looking this past year. Used to be able to buy an old square baler like a JD 14T for a few hundred dollars.
 
Thats funny as there was an EPA guy on the radio the other day during the farm news said that story was a hoax about the livestock tax so just what is going on.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top