I don't think it can warp. I suspect it has never been taken apart (wife's grandfather was not a mechanic or carpenter). but it didn't go back in easily either even with the old O-ringThank you for this post. It'll help when I get that far.
Is the filter barrel possibly warped & causing resistance when pulling the plate out?
Mike
the "plate" (more of a plug than plate) does have a bit of original paint that looked like it dripped/ran inside and I did scrape some of that off but still hard to get in/out. wouldn't hurt to take some scotch bright to it once I get the O-ring and a spare minute (right) and take a punch to try to line it up.
Will try to remember to take a slide hammer too to help get it off. To get it out the 1st time i had to put a bolt in the hole in the plate and give it some love taps sideways and up and down and pull on it to encourage it to come out.