Milk Prices

LEH

Member
I don't milk, but there are a few left around here that do. Guy down the road is getting out, milk price was $30 / hundred, now $10 per. Is this happening in other areas? I'm in central Ohio.
 
I don't milk either, but in Minnesota, farmers are leaving the dairy industry very very quickly. It is very sad to see that people's livelihood has to halt because of the current economic crisis. I find it hard to believe that those of us that feed and clothe the world are probably the least appreciated on a daily basis. Maybe I'm wrong but that's sure how it feels to me.
Kow FArmer
 
I hang out with a couple of dairymen. Its the same story here as well. With all the incentives one of them is getting in the low 13's, others not so good. We lost one this spring, another says he can stay in 3-4 more months unless they get some relief. From what I read, bad as it is here, its worse in California.
 
in my area of ontario you really have to look hard to find a dairy farm anymore when i was a kid they were everywhere
hard to beleive they can jack oil / gas prices to guarantee a billion dollar profit but have no qualms about choking the life out of the dairy producers guess people won't be drinking milk much longer if enough dairy guys say to heck with it they can only bleed so much
bob
 
I have heard that wells Fargo bank may pull the plug on some corporate farms in the mid west resulting in a noticeable drop in production.
 
We milked for 31 years here in Wisconsin.Got out 9 years ago and glad we did.I think base price for Grade A milk here is 10.30.Does not even make sence.My Grandfather used to say people have always had cheap food and they always will.We still have a few dairy farmers here but they are going out fast.So sad to see.
 
It's a strange world out there.In the U.S. there is no market share quota system because people don't seem to want it as they have critisized ours (Canada) for decades.What will indeed happen,as it always has in those viscious cycles,is once enough producers close their doors there will become a shortage in milk supply than the price will surge giving relief to those who were able to somehow weather the storm.Once they get caught up on their losses they will begin to feel comfortable with the market situation and start keeping some older cows again and purchace more replacements from Canada if they can find enough.Than cheese and butter stocks will be rebuilt to the point that it is building faster than it is being consumed and the fluid market can't use up the extra production and yet again CRASH! Down comes the price yet again.With the supply management system here,it may be awfully awfully expensive to purchace quota,but atleast,till we loose a WTO negotiation and it's dismantled,we are guananteed a reasonable price as the rate of consumption is very closely monitered and quota allocations are adjusted accordingly.No violent price swings for the consumer or producer,just a steady slow upward keel.This note may peeve some off who are against supply managment,but it works.
 
Naw!!! We don't want no goobermint involved!!!! Next thing, the goobermint will want to take over medicare!!!! I likes my insurance cumpany!! They really care for me!!!
 
I was a dairyman for most of my life as was my father. The answer s to much government. the establish the milk pool price, they're bueacracy control the milk check off, They cover the inspection of the producer, The EPA tells you how to dispose of your manure.They manage to shut down all of the small processors so it is just the giants. Just try and sell a gallon of milk to a friend. The dairyman have let to many educated nuts tell them what is best. They formed so called Coop's that were suppose to look out for the dairyman. I am talking about AMPI and DFA. Yeah they looked out for there own managment with dairyfarmers mone. In eighty years I have seen it all. A bunch of do gooders riding on the dairy farmers shirt tail.
 
Central MN, some that have been growing as the can pay cash for are doing OK, they had socked away money and paid off debt when the milk prices were high. Many off them had contracts for feed and hay supplies so they didnt get hit as bad when feed prices were high. Many of them are buyin g milk cow/heifers now as others are selling oput. These are all 30-100 cow dairy's with mid 20's-30's owners. A few others are struggling,, were duped into thinking they had to expand when milk prices were high, tyrpically they also believed tey had to have the nice stuuff too and upgraded alot of equipment thinking, or were told, milk prices were going to stay high, just like they were forecasting corn to stay above $4.50. Thaem folks are in real trouble, interest is accumuling faster than their monthly income. Very sad to see. I hope it turns around, banks squandered their bailout, auto guys still filed bankruptcy, who knows where the rest of the stimuus went, and you see nothing on the news about these farmers that are passing up grocerie shopping just to make the farm keep running, so they can feed the world. The middle man reaps the rich's.
 
What do you mean, "start" importing milk??! It's been happening for years, although usually as milk producets. (some fluid does come in from Canada and Mexico)
 
I milk around 100 or so and my last check was 11.80 with all my bonuses.Its bad times around here.Had to cancell my families health insurance so I have enough money to pay electric bill.I sold 80 acres to pay off one operating loan just to turn around two weeks later and get another one.Sold all our angus cows so I had enough money to plant my crops this year.and the list goes on.Done everything I know to do except get caught in the forage harvester so my wife can get my life insurance.Dont know how we made it this far but another couple months of this and I am done.
 
Yea, many Americans tend to distrust government. Beyond that, artificial restriction of the supply or increase in demand (labor unions, quotas, government subsidies, import restrictions, tariffs, all the same thing) work for a while. Eventually real world economics will prevail ("we lose a WTO negiotiation"). Look at the steel and auto industries; union labor and import restrictions/tariffs seemed like a great idea back in the 60's and 70's, now US automakers are bankrupt and the US steel industry is gone.

I also think you would have a hard time finding very many farmers who would want the current administration telling them what and how much they can produce.
 
The government isn't involved? What stops a group of dairy farmers from producing more milk without buying quotas? The Canadian Dairy Commission wouldn't have anything to say about it?
 
I talked to an Amish farmer a couple of weeks ago and he said he couldnt make a profit at 40 some cents a gallon.No electricity,farming with horses,they werent very happy either.Middleman hasnt lost any money.Everything on the stock market is so the paper pushers get rich,the producers dont matter.I could be wrong but it could also be to force the small producers out so the big ones have more of the market and can jack the prices up higher.Its not good whatever is going on.
 
I really feel bad for the small dairy farmer in these modern times but it is hard for us that have been out of the business for generations (myself) or never been in it to understand the big picture and make a educated decision.

The average milk buyer could care less about the farmers of today. All they know is store price and we want it as cheap as we can get it.

We hear farmers talk base price but that is not really the mail box price.

We wonder if price pooling is taken place where the grade A fluid milk farmer that has to meet stricter guidelines is on the same pricing base with the cheese milk farmers.

We hear about government price support (that I thought was in the $12 range) that the taxpayers fund to keep the price of milk at a artificial level.

We wonder if a dairy closes because of bad management; low prices; or the fact that the industry has gone to a Wal Mart type of business where only the mega big will survive.

I am sorry if this post did not sit well with some.
 
yea hard to believe this part of il and southern wi
can't get enough milk locally to meet demand for making cheese and bottling milk.
milk has been brought here from other parts of U.S.
for years.
several years ago local cheese plant was buying milk on open market for less than support price
 
I thought you could produce milk without quota, but weren't guaranteed a price. I don't believe you get enough for the milk to stay in business. Been a long time since reading Britian's Farm Weekly but it seems I remember that if a producer overshoots his quota he pays a penalty.
 
A couple of long-timers just got out in the last year. They are both above age 70 and had been carrying minimal debt for quite some time. The Amish and the Mennonites are the only ones milking in the township now. Even they will admit the money they came to New York with is being tapped out if it already has not happened. Like one said, they still have the same overhead structure (fuel, seed , fertilizer, taxes) as everybody else.
About the only ones going well are those having outside (the farm) financial resources. I do not see how younger people could do it, otherwise. In those years one is typically paying on a mortgage and improving the farm to make it more labor efficient and generally more productive. The guys that used to preach marketing (i.e contracts) of inputs and farm products were gone before the conservative, older (I'll run junk before I take on debt) farmers.
Would like to discuss further but need to batten down the hatches before the thunderstorm hits.
 
I looked and looked and all I come up with is this,and Im sorry,but this answer stinks.Milk on the world commodity market is a luxury???????
There are some people in control of things somehow that are clearly evil to use a lame excuse like that.They should be run out of the news business if that is all they can say about something as bad as this.
I also read somewhere that tried to tie low milk prices to the production of ethanol.Also the jump in fertilizer prices in 2007 and 2008.
I think what I found was what some bunch came up with that are supposed to be "analysts"and wrote something to justify the existance of their job.
Its market manipulation plain and simple,however its hard to find out who is behind it and why.
I dont see where we import any from India but Canada and Mexico for sure.external_link raised Government support on some things August First,which didnt look like but maybe 10% if that which doesnt look like near enough.
Other than that,it looks complicated.I think its a backlash from the jump up of those commodities when fuel went out of sight.I think there is some artificial means involved just because they can mess it up and could even be foreigners.However I have no proof and cant seem to find anything either.
One other thing is there are less farmers all the time.With the Wal Mart form of government we have,workers are just slaves,you go to the store to get food,farmers dont matter to them.If farmers would make them listen somehow things might get better.I could be wrong.
 
Conspiracy!!!! Conspiracy!!!! They're everywhere!!!! But like you said you have no proof but hey don't let that get in the way it never has before. You fellas ever heard of the Basic Laws of Economics? No.1 is the Law of Supply and Demand.If there are fewer goods than buyers the price goes up on the goods on the other hand If there are fewer buyers than goods the price goes down on the goods.
 
Supply and demand is not the main reason for low milk prices.Main reason is that big companies like kraft are importing MPCs an caseins from other contries because they can substitute that for REAL milk and do it alot cheaper.Which means more profit for them and losing money to me The Producer.Thing about mpcs is it was never regulated by the fda so they are using a big loophole to make big profits.Dont buy into the supply and demand thing like the big corps want you to.My milk rep has been trying to pull that card on me since January but he does work for DFA.Also dean foods has made twice as much profit so far this year then last year.If there was no demand for milk they sure are selling alot of it.
 
Medicare is trillions in the hole over the 30 years. But you like that just fine don't you? You don't understand that we have to pay that back someday, or at least our children and grandchildren will.

So I guess you are for burdening your children with your debt.
 
Because you think like that is why things are this way.Its not supply and demand,its market manipulation.Corn is down 20% from last year.If the 20% used for ethanol was causing a shortage it should be higher than last year.Its the foxes watching the chicken house in the SEC.Nobody is even trying to say its supply and demand,at least nobody that knows anything.
 
Casien is imported form Ireland by the 40 ft containers 10 to 15 containers per customs entry has been for years with untold volume. Had an Irish man come all the way from Ireland to see one day and wanted to know why I was not releasing his casien?? Now let me tell you that was a migthy long trip to ask one question I was thinking. My responce was that when the broker provided all the clearance docs and vet certificates by the Irish agr I released the same day for import. He thanked me and left. I noticed a change for custom brokers for that company in a few days. The lazy broker was laying it on my office for the delay. Must not be an oz. made in USA. Big item in ice cream. Whole milk 2.28 per gallon in a major food chain in chicago are for a couple of years.

How are the BIG hog confindments doing with 50 cent hogs?????
 
Published on New York State Senate (http://www.nysenate.gov)

Home > Aubertine Applauds Federal Legislation for Dairy Farmers

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Aubertine Applauds Federal Legislation for Dairy Farmers
By Darrel J. Aubertine
Created 03/27/2009 - 12:00am

Legislation from U.S. Sen. Feingold similar to bills introduced by Sen. Aubertine at state level

ALBANY (March 27, 2009)—State Sen. Darrel J. Aubertine today applauded U.S. Sen. Russ Feingold for introducing a series of legislation intended to give dairy farmers a say in decisions that affect their bottom line and help them get a fair price for their milk. Two of Sen. Feingold’s bills are similar to legislation introduced by Sen. Aubertine in the state Legislature.

“I’m pleased to see that Sen. Feingold is helping to build momentum for our dairy farmers,” Sen. Aubertine said. “In this economic downturn our farmers are struggling with low milk prices. They deserve a say in the policies that affect them and they deserve a fair price for their milk. These measures at both the state and federal levels would help farmers in both of these areas.”

One bill would give individual farmers the right to vote on any referendum tied to a milk marketing order. Under current law, a farmer’s cooperative is authorized to vote on behalf of the individual farmer. In some instances, cooperatives double as dairy processors and may cast votes on behalf of farmers that the individual farmer may feel benefits processors over the producer.

“All too often these votes take place to affect the milk marketing order and the farmer’s bottom line, but the farmer doesn’t even know it has happened, let alone have a say in it,” Sen. Aubertine said. “What we want to do at the very least is make sure that farmers are kept informed about decisions being made on their behalf. If they choose to let someone else vote for them, then that’s their choice, but I don’t think it’s the coop’s job to say we’re going to vote for you regardless.”

The second bill from Sen. Feingold of Wisconsin would prohibit any cheese made with dry milk protein concentrates or caseins from being labeled domestic natural cheese. Sen. Aubertine introduced similar legislation to prevent products enhanced with MPCs, casein or casienates other than what naturally occur from being labeled as “dairy.” The vast majority of MPCs used in the United States are dry imports produced without U.S. health and safety regulations that undercut the value of domestic fluid milk.

“Imported MPCs and caseins are still an issue of concern for dairy farmers, who have been among the hardest hit in this economic downturn,” Sen. Aubertine said. “This is an important issue for both consumers and farmers. These MPCs should not be treated as equal to the quality fluid milk produced by our farmers in Wisconsin, New York and throughout the country. Consumers should know the difference between cheese made with real domestic milk and what has been processed with dry MPCs.”

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license are available at http://www.nysenate.gov/copyright-policy. NYSenate.gov is powered by Drupal.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Source URL (retrieved on 08/09/2009 - 8:40pm): http://www.nysenate.gov/news/aubertine-applauds-federal-legislation-dairy-farmers
 
That is exactly supply and demand.The companies have found a cheaper substitute to replace milk happens all the time.Its called Increased Productivity.If you fellows had been around when tractors were invented you'd be talking about the
Conspiracy against horses and the tractor companies were manipulating the market etc etc etc.If you really want to do something about milk demand
tell the dairy farmers to quit using artifical Hormones on their cows that has given dairy farmers a black eye with consumers.
 
No... the CDC doesn't deal with that.
Supply management is administered by producer organizations, elected from our own ranks, in each province except British Columbia. These organizations are responsible to administer the 'Dairy Act' which is the provincial legislation...
If anyone thinks they're going to start shipping milk without quota they will quickly find themselves in court, and they will lose in court.
If you want in, you buy quota and have your premisis approved for use, pickup etc.

The main function of the CDC, that I'm aware of at least... is setting the support prices for milk according to our class system. Our producer organization is then responsible to allocate that milk to be used in a cascading class system where it is sold into the highest value classes first, then cascades on down into the lower value classes.

As far as day to day operation of the dairy industry is concerned, the government has very little to do with it, and deliberately so. We've been given the power to manage it, and they stay out. Particularly in the financial sense... as there are no subsidies of any kind for dairy operations.

The sad thing today is that the world prices are so low that we are presently in a position where our tariff walls are vunerable to breach in both fluid and butter... I'd hate to have to produce the milk that could come in here at a profit over a 300% tariff wall.

Rod
 
I dont use artificial hormones and the dairy I sell my milk to does not take milk from cows injected with hormones anymore. Even though there is absolutely no difference at all in the milk.They made all of us sign contracts we would not use artificial hormones.So you agree with importing non fda approved food into this country while local farmers like me cant even buy my 2 year old daughter a birthday present because we need every extra penny to survive.You can go eat all the imported crap from wherever it comes from.Personally I like to know were the food my family eats comes from.At least we got all the milk we can drink around here.
 
Hey you think you're the only person that the current Recession/Depression is having an effect on? I raise cattle you checked the prices now compared to a year ago? Thats the way economics works,prices go up,prices go down.And BTW with the bunch thats now in DC things are going to get a whole lot tougher before they get better.But I still don't want a Gov't handout if I can't make farming pay I need to hand it over to someone else that can and find another way to make a living.Odd thing is those in farming that have received the most Gov't money are usually the first to go broke when tough times set in.
 
Well prices go up and down tied to supply and demand.You cant say commodities prices are tied to supply and demand any more.So you need to find out whats causing them to go down for producers and up in the store.When you find out whats doing that,ask this bunch of politicians running things to fix the problem rather than give you a handout.Its known to be market manipulation.There is where you can start.Im sure there are plenty of bad politicians on both sides.Now as long as the rest of the politicians dont have a clue as to why the market is doing this,the ones that will do something will try and give you a handout so they wont look like they didnt do anything.By finding the problem for them to fix you can maybe survive farming.What other job did you want to do?Everything is messed up now thanks to the politicians that were in office.A lot of them are still in office.When you find a crooked one its time to vote him out.Im thinking some tarriff on dairy imports could help the dairymen,so could country of origin labeling maybe?That might help beef prices if they have to put on their beef where if came from,and a tax on it so yours can be more profitable.I dont care which politician it is,you cant let them be ignorant and ruin another American industry because he doesnt know whats going on.Import lobbyists will keep him ignorant voting for their interests,and for sure know whats going on.They just dont care about farmers,probably dont live in this country and dont care if our industry goes bankrupt and dont care if we starve.
 
I just read where New York Senator Schumer proposed a tarriff for milk product imports.He said these imports cost New York dairymen 103 million dollars.He did this July the 29th 2009.About 5 years too late but at least something.
 
The Iraq war cost is now 667 billion dollars.5000 to 6050 per second.Medicare needs 334 billion between now and 2019.Also if medical prices could go down that could be different.Canada insures everybody for 1/3 the price of the USA per person and 40 million arent covered in the USA.
Do you see what Im getting to?
Im all for a strong defense,its a necessity,but ever since the 1980s this has been just give the defense contractors whatever they want.They ask for 10 billion,by the time it goes through all the crooks hands it turns into 50 billion.Like that movie Charlie Wilsons war.Its even worse than that most likely.There are so many people"on the take"in the military industrial complex now,its running the government.
If you want to fight against something fight against whats destroying the country,not against what makes it worth living in.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top