MarkB_MI
Well-known Member
- Location
- Motown USA
I returned the radiator I bought from YT last Friday. It took almost a week to get an RMA; I think that's because it was drop-shipped from Dennis Carpenter and had to be returned there. In the meantime I took my old radiator back to the shop and they re-cored it. I'm real happy with the results, but it cost me $358 with tax.
One of my concerns with the new restoration Dennis Carpenter radiator is how weak the frame under the bottom tank is. That's the only thing that attaches the radiator to the tractor, and it's only about 0.100 inches thick. On the original radiator it's .0125. It's not surprising that whoever tried to install the DC radiator before me bent the frame. I guess these aftermarket radiators are OK for show tractors, but aren't appropriate for working tractors. It's a huge annoyance to me that pretty much all aftermarket tractor parts skimp on metal gauge. I understand that certain US metal gauges might not be available overseas, but they NEVER go thick. Aftermarket sheet metal parts are consistently thinner than the originals. The companies that sell these parts, like YT, DC and Steiner, could insist on better quality but they don't.
When I installed the new radiator, I saw that the only thing keeping the radiator tank from contacting the fuel tank is the upper radiator hose, which is squeezed between the radiator inlet and fuel tank (see pic). I thought maybe the radiator dimensions were different after the recore, but worn-off paint on the gas tank shows it was that way before. Plus, there's really nothing to keep the radiator from flopping backwards if it doesn't bump into the fuel tank. I jammed a piece of radiator hose between the two tanks; now there's an 1/8 inch separation between them.
I discovered why there's an extra set of screw holes in the fan shroud when I fired up the motor. There was a slight ting-ting-ting as the fan hit the shroud. Moved the shroud down using the upper holes and everything is fine now.
Just waiting on my BIL to finish up my hood.
One of my concerns with the new restoration Dennis Carpenter radiator is how weak the frame under the bottom tank is. That's the only thing that attaches the radiator to the tractor, and it's only about 0.100 inches thick. On the original radiator it's .0125. It's not surprising that whoever tried to install the DC radiator before me bent the frame. I guess these aftermarket radiators are OK for show tractors, but aren't appropriate for working tractors. It's a huge annoyance to me that pretty much all aftermarket tractor parts skimp on metal gauge. I understand that certain US metal gauges might not be available overseas, but they NEVER go thick. Aftermarket sheet metal parts are consistently thinner than the originals. The companies that sell these parts, like YT, DC and Steiner, could insist on better quality but they don't.
When I installed the new radiator, I saw that the only thing keeping the radiator tank from contacting the fuel tank is the upper radiator hose, which is squeezed between the radiator inlet and fuel tank (see pic). I thought maybe the radiator dimensions were different after the recore, but worn-off paint on the gas tank shows it was that way before. Plus, there's really nothing to keep the radiator from flopping backwards if it doesn't bump into the fuel tank. I jammed a piece of radiator hose between the two tanks; now there's an 1/8 inch separation between them.
I discovered why there's an extra set of screw holes in the fan shroud when I fired up the motor. There was a slight ting-ting-ting as the fan hit the shroud. Moved the shroud down using the upper holes and everything is fine now.
Just waiting on my BIL to finish up my hood.