O/T Union, hard at work.

Craig Braun

New User
This message is a reply to an archived post by Kelly C on December 19, 2008 at 09:11:36.
The original subject was "Re: OT Union, hard at work.".

As a former Union worker for Bobcat Co. in Gwinner No.Dak. I can relate to the crap that takes place. The Union protects the lazy good for nothing workers but screws over the hard working ones. I was a steward for the union and did my very best that I could to serve my union brothers.After nearly 13 years of 6 day work weeks I thought I would try a different job that offered less time on the job. I then quit my job at Bobcat and after one day reconsidered my poor decision and called the Company to see if I could reverse my decision. The company said no problem because the paperwork had not been turned in.They would grant me a one day leave and I would return to work the following Monday. This until the UNION BIG Shots at Gwinner got hold of it. They would not allow it stating that I quit and that was final. What a great way to treat a union brother and former steward. Had the company fought my return I am certain the Union would have fought for my return. The Union leaders are a disgrace to the Union in Gwinner!
I have spoken with one of the Union leaders and this person also agreed I got screwed by the Union board.I can so relate to how leadership screws the Union and the company. I have seen it with my own eyes and am disgusted with how they act.
I feel for the average worker cuz they are scrutinized in every aspect of every situation concerning work and company policies,breaks absenteeism,talking on the job, and so forth.
This is my response to the Union Leadership screwing the Ford Motor Co.
 
Unions are made up of people, just like businesses...some people work their way to authority in unions for the same poor reasons some people work their way to authority in Corporations: for power, for money, etc., and unions can be as arbitrary and uncaring as corporate executives.
You can tell a great deal about a society by its laws and organizations; with unions, if workers had generally been well treated, they wouldn't've felt the need to shed their blood to organize...but once organized, they attracted people who wanted power, authority, money...
No unions leave the worker defenseless against corporations whose legal fees etc are business expenses; unions that control a segment of business can become just as predatory.
 
If you had been non-union and quit and tried to worm your way back in to the shop and they said no... would you post about your uh, loyalty then?
 
It isn't just the union "big shots". It's all the other guys lower on the senority list, and very probably the guy who replaced you as union steward. And maybe the company told you one thing and the union something else. You may never get a straight answer. If your coworkers liked you, you would have got back. The union is made up of your coworkers, who may or may not be your friends. If the membership wanted you back, you would be back, period. Sorry. I always adhered to the first rule of wing walking when changing jobs: Never let go of what ya have until you have got ahold of something else!!
 
I been on both sides, Belonged to 4 different unions, was a Steward in 2. Spent 20 years in Management. Negotiated 4 different contracts with Unions as Management. I have seen much more detriment than benefit for workers by Unions. I could write a book. Some people want an organization to do their thinking. Example straight ticket voters allowing political party bosses to make their choices.
 
If he had been non union then the point wouldn't be mute because they wouldn't have a say in whether the company hired him back or not.
 
Couldn't you have taken a withdrawal card from the craft? I did that when I left the teamsters in the mid 80's, was no problem to get back in, of course I never went back.

Really is a expansive topic for discussion, I spent a good part of my career so far, working with, union construction trades, it sure seems that the unions organized with manufacturing trades, like U.A.W. etc. are much more involved etc. In construction, there are ways to work with the unions, building owners still pay a premium, but even a lot of open shops are competitive with union wages now, so depending on the job, may not be all that different. Most if not all jobs I have been involved with, the union trades had best be productive, or they go down the road, a lot of them realize they represent a company and if they do not produce, their job is on the line, most realize this, many still take a lot pride in their trade, and overall it is still a good situation for the trades person and the company. Yeah, we have standby trades and job site stewards, sometimes they are outstanding, other times those standby trades/stewards can cause a lot of trouble, takes a good manager, superintendent to keep things rolling, you need to get to know the business agents etc.

I have seen local companies here gone back to unionized labor, some even have separate union divisions. I have seen and have dealt with all kinds of union related problems, but even then, in construction, if managed properly, it is still a win-win situation, even in NYC where I spent a lot of years working. I've dealt with just about every kind of problem there is with the unions, but can tell you one thing, if I needed to fire or replace a person due to failure to perform or what have you, most times it gets done. I had a crane operator pull some real crap on me once, cost us a lot of money, held up a 25 person crew, and I could not get him off the job, had 2 cranes swinging, he was first on site, so I had to play the game due to the trade agreement with the operating engineers, but I soon figured out how to get him off the job and get a new operator on site, just shut the job down for a week, he was a company man too, was not out of the hall. I told the crane outfit, I'll take all our business to your competitor, (which I would have genuinely hated doing because we had a great business relationship) if I ever see that guy show up on one of my jobs again. They apologized for his behavior and never sent him out on my jobs again, union or non-union, a real jerk can cause serious problems sometimes, no matter what affiliation they have with organized labor or not. Once he was replaced, production was booming again and the job was very profitable, would not have been the case if I continued with that jerk on the crane, get the wrong person in the seat and it can ruin your profits, boy I'll never forget that job, one of the best decisions I ever made, we even made up the lost time on the schedule.
 
The Union body or membership was never made aware of this until after the fact. I have many friends there and some went to the Union meeting to stand behind me but were shot down.I am quite aware of knowing what I have and what I have been offered for a differant job, but there is no guarantee that what you are told is true.
 
Not told enough here to really analyze this, but it sounds like you made a hasty, poorly thought out decision, and failed to handle it properly with your beloved union. You made someone high up in the union mad and he/she nailed you. Could have been that you went straight to beg back with management instead of going through the union, and letting them play big shot. Love by the sword, die by the sword. Tom
 
Pat,
I to have been on both sides, now an independent consultant, if I don't produce I'm gone. Keeps me on my toes, lol ! Your last two sentences remind me of trucker40's post, they look to be straight out of the union "newsletter"
 
I have had dealings with unions also, most bad. I worked for a new car dealership that was union. The union helped with a few small problems, but for the most part did not help. When contract negotiations came up he wanted us to slow down on the job, and when we were about ready to strike, we found out that the state that I work in was an "at will" state and we could be fired for any reason except for descrimination. I now have a new job working for a construction equipment dealer and go to several construction sites. One site I go to is a large nationwide company that has some union mechanics and they are the laziest bunch I have seen. They will not do anything to get their hands dirty. All the "hard jobs" are farmed out. I am not totally against unions, just that I don't have any use for them.
 
(quoted from post at 10:54:07 01/01/09) This message is a reply to an archived post by Kelly C on December 19, 2008 at 09:11:36.
The original subject was "Re: OT Union, hard at work.".

As a former Union worker for Bobcat Co. in Gwinner No.Dak. I can relate to the crap that takes place. The Union protects the lazy good for nothing workers but screws over the hard working ones. I was a steward for the union and did my very best that I could to serve my union brothers.After nearly 13 years of 6 day work weeks I thought I would try a different job that offered less time on the job. I then quit my job at Bobcat and after one day reconsidered my poor decision and called the Company to see if I could reverse my decision. The company said no problem because the paperwork had not been turned in.They would grant me a one day leave and I would return to work the following Monday. This until the UNION BIG Shots at Gwinner got hold of it. They would not allow it stating that I quit and that was final. What a great way to treat a union brother and former steward. Had the company fought my return I am certain the Union would have fought for my return. The Union leaders are a disgrace to the Union in Gwinner!
I have spoken with one of the Union leaders and this person also agreed I got screwed by the Union board.I can so relate to how leadership screws the Union and the company. I have seen it with my own eyes and am disgusted with how they act.
I feel for the average worker cuz they are scrutinized in every aspect of every situation concerning work and company policies,breaks absenteeism,talking on the job, and so forth.
This is my response to the Union Leadership screwing the Ford Motor Co.
think there is more to this story than you are telling :roll:
 
My experience was different.
Worked for a stripping contractor (Isbell) at Santa Rita (open pit). Used to be called "Indian Hill", 'cuz anything from not being fast enough under the shovel to complaining about a sagging dump edge got you hacked off the payroll. Plenty other guys waiting for an opening.
Voted Teamsters in (corrupt even then!) but pay raise several times dues, Eucs, Cats, all eqpmt kept in better shape, and shifters even became almost human (emphasis on almost; management, including shifters, got paid by tonnage moved).
 
I agree with the post above. There's a few times when a union could have helped me. However, you said you quit on your own. Whether the union got the paper work yet or not is a moot point. Once you quit, why should you get special treatment? If you quit once, who's to say you wouldn't quit again? If you're unhappy with your job, you can't just quit and try another job and if you don't like it either, come back to the first job you quit. If the union was so good, why would you quit? Unless I'm missing something, I agree with the other posters who said you made too hasty a decision and have no one to blame but yourself. Sorry but thats how I see it. Dave
 
Been a union member and leader. All I gotta say is that the union is only as good as the members.The company is charged with hiring the workers not the union. If your union was a bunch of bums then so were you guys.Remember you cant get a silk purse from a pigs ear.
 
Been a union member and leader. All I gotta say is that the union is only as good as the members.The company is charged with hiring the workers not the union. If your union was a bunch of bums then so were you guys.Remember you cant get a silk purse from a pigs ear.
 
I am a union retiree. I think there is one thing has been missed in this case. That one day that was missed from quiting also stopped you from being a union member. If you would have got hired back you probably would go to the bottom of the seniority list. But I don't think we are hearing all of the story. Some where you got on the wrong side of the union AND the company and they BOTH got even with you together.
 
The unions served their purpose at the turn of the 20th century improving safety and wages. Now they have spiraled into a monster that is hurting business... GM. I work in manufactuing. I work with a former Toyota engineer. I also work with a former Production Manager from GM. Toyota builds a better product and the variable cost is roughly 1/2 of a union plant while the morale is higher. The manager from GM said you cannot run out the sorry ones and the hard working people get run off by the sorry ones for making them look bad.

FU*K the UNIONS...

Union Free and proud for having to work for a living, not riding the Union Bank!
 
Craig made the decision to quit. the company accepted the signed paper work that stated that Craig was quiting.
Under the contract we bargained with the company that covers about 900 members of our local union,

"8.061 An employee shall lose all his seniority, shall be removed from the seniority list, and shall cease to be an employee if:
8.0611 He quits."

In this case the union didnt think that it should turn its back on the many union members that had less senioity than Craig. The Union told the company that they (the company) were exclusivily in control of hiring and the union had NO problem with the company hiring Craig back. Craig didn't want to start at the bottom of the seniority list so he appealed to the company. The company filed a grievance against the union.
The Union made an offer to settel the grievance with these terms,

the company bring Craig back with a loss of 1 day of seniority for each day that had passed since his quiting
AND from that point on, every member of the local will have a 2 week window to change their mind after quiting.

The company did not accept these terms. the 3rd step hearing of the grievance was held, and the Union maintained that the facts were that Craig had quit and the contract language was clear that he had lost his seniority, and reiterated that the company could hire Craig back when ever they wanted to.
The union acted responsibly on behalf of the whole Local union Body by upholding the collective bargaining agreement.
Craig needs to accept responsibility for making the decision to Quit.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top