(reply to post at 07:42:48 06/18/10)
Hoke, ... I don't want to change the subject. YOU want to change the subject with a diversion because your argument based upon your misguided logic is so defective. Now you've quoted me out of context, and you and I and everyone who's followed this discussion knows it.
Here's my original contention:
(quoted from post at 09:59:24 06/16/10)
Subsequent ratings do not mean the rated oil is better than previous ratings. It only means the oil has been tested to later standards. There may be no actual difference between SJ and SL oils except the testing regimen. ....)
YOU seem to stick on the fact that later testing standards are higher standards than previous ones for the purposes of this discussion. You are wrong and being obtuse about it. That is not an axiom. Here's why (again):
We are talking about oil for use in a N-Ford.
We are talking about oils that have traditionally been used satisfactorily in N-Fords. Those oils were not originally rated at all by API.
Satisfactory, non-rated oils, were later found to meet API "SA" rating.
Using YOUR logic...oils that previously were bottled before their later brethren were placed in bottles labelled "SA" ...are not satisfactory. Capital "B" Capital "S".
Much later, virtually ...(did you see that little word "virtually"????).... virtually all oil producers saw to it that their oil formulations met the latest API standards.
Jump ahead a few years to standard "SJ". An oil meeting SJ would only be LABELLED SJ if it met that standard. When SL standard was developed, virtually everyone producing bottled motor oil made certain their oils met the new standard so they could sell the stuff. But VIRTUALLY all the oils already being produced under SJ were capable of passign all the tests of SL...even tho' bottles already on the shelf labelled SJ were not recalled and relabelled. In other words, the later STANDARD is not necessarily disqualifying of existing products which were already in satisfactory service applications. (Like N Fords, for example!) The later standard in itself is not what is disqualifying of existing products. The test would have to be RUN before that conclusion could be drawn.
Now that's an extreme effort in typing in order to clarify for you why my previous statement that a new STANDARD does not necessarily mean an existing oil is inferior. It only means the existing oil may not have been yet tested to the new standard. I can't make it any simpler than that.
But back to the discussion at hand: If N-Fords operated on SA oil quite nicely because that's all they needed... then SJ oil is good for it too, most folks would agree. Not you, perhaps, but most folks.
Now comes still later standards which meet EPA mandates that no zinc should be in the oils. ONLY as regards the older engines .... that new standard is NOT NECESSARILY an "improvement" as regards those old engines.
...If that were the case an SJ oil would meet the SL standard and it doesn't....
That failed logic is the sticking point. You don't KNOW it doesn't meet the new standard until it's TESTED against the new standard. All you KNOW is that it's not labelled to claim it meets the new standard. If it were tested...it might very well MEET the new standard. It's my contention that whatever standard it meets...new or old...it's sufficient for N-Fords. In fact, the OLD standard might be BETTER than the NEW standard, as far as N-Fords go. And that is logical. Why? Because as is already discussed....the NEW standard got rid of zinc which many, very smart people credit with good behavior in older cams/tappets. Doh!
(Make whatever claims you wish with regard to whatever you spent your career doing, it means nothing to me. Not only is it undocumented except for your own self-promotion... it's also very well known there are plenty of people in the world positioned at jobs in which they have absolutely no business.)
I'm not wasting any more time on this sillyness. One, or both of us has a synapse that misfires when we deal with each other.
It is not the ratings that changed the oil. It was the oil that was changed that met still-later standards.