Carter W

Member
How do you men feel about oil brands and their quality? Are Pennzoil, Quaker State, Vavoline, etc., all about the same? I've had a 1948 8N tractor for 20 years and have always run Pennzoil 30 weight but was just wondering your thoughts considering some brands are cheaper then others.
Thanks
 
Now you've gone and done it :lol:

That's like asking which is better Ford's or Chevy's - You ask 10 people and you'll get their preference with little justification.

My point - Use any oil you want as long as you change it regularly. The worst oil on the market it better than the best when these tractors were built.
 
I agree with DB.

Anything sold today is better than anything sold in 39-52

I typically use walmart or tsc oil.. unless something like valvolene goes on sale in an oil change package. Hack.. I've run kendal even... nothing blown up yet.

soundguy
 
Hi I run what ever in for a little while and change oil over to Mobil 1 Synthetic and just ride and ride and ride. I know of a 80 model Caddy a friend of mine, hes old too his old caddy went 249,000 miles before his wife made him sell it and the only engine maint other than 10 12 thousand mile oil chages was to put new wipers on the valve stems and one timing chain. I saw the eng with the front cover off and that thing was as clean as it could be. No crud at all. Thats when I decided to go to synthetics. Have them in my big truck gear boxes and rear ends too. Good stuff far as I can see. Gonna look at the idea for my tractors too in a little while after I get my more pressing stuff done like make them run right. OK I will shut up. Devious
 
I sure wouldn't put a synthetic in a non rebuilt engine. I contactd amsoil asking that question and they mention seal and gasket incompatibilities on older engines and did not reccomend it for 50's era tractors that had not been rebuilt in recent decades.

soundguy
 
I prefer straight 30 wt but I live in FL where it works well all year. Actually I really don't think N tractors much care so long as the oil is clean. I used to collect a lot of oil cans to go along with my gas pump collection and for years my 2N has ran just fine on anything that came out of dozens of differing quart cans.
 
i was told by multiple people that unless you run synthetic from a fresh rebuild/new seals and gaskets there is a good possibility of it leaking.
 
(quoted from post at 14:02:11 06/15/10) How do you men feel about oil brands and their quality? Are Pennzoil, Quaker State, Valvoline, etc., all about the same? I've had a 1948 8N tractor for 20 years and have always run Pennzoil 30 weight but was just wondering your thoughts considering some brands are cheaper then others.
Thanks

Valvoline "Racing" oil and Rotella still have high zinc levels .

Newer oils are formulated for roller lifters and don't need the high friction additive that diesels and flat tappet cams require .

I believe I heard regulations are restricting the amount of zinc in automotive oils , I could be wrong on that .

The Mobile 1 web site debunks myths about synthetic oil .

Synthetic oil will NOT damage seals . It will flow better and leak quicker through worn seals than conventional oils will .

You can mix synthetic and conventional oil . You will lose the advantages of the higher priced synthetic oil but it will not cause any harm .

Running low on oil while on a 500 mile trip could damage your motor . Add a quart of conventional and change you oil sooner than the 5000 mile interval for full synthetic.

They have synthetic blends on the market now , I would use full synthetic or full conventional but would not waste money on a half and half product .

You CAN switch back to conventional oil after using synthetic .

When synthetic first hit the mass market it was talked about never going back to conventional oil in your motor but that has been debunked also . There is no magic coating , residue , wear pattern left behind from synthetic .

Mobile 1 Synthetic will rapidly dissolve carbon build up and sludge so and older motor that has been run on convention oil should have then next oil change at 2500 miles , then 3500 miles , then to the recommended 5000 mile intervals .
 
It surely does seem like this thread goes round and round every now and then. I'm surprisedc no one mentined API - the American Petroleum Institute code letters for motor oil. Basically, the further down the alphabet the letters are, the better the oil quality. My humble opinion is that API ratings allow us guys - the end users - to compare apples with apples, and forego all the hype and local wisdom typically associated with this subject. For my money, the API rating is much more important than who's name is on the label.

Dave Erb
New Holland, pa
 
(quoted from post at 21:58:26 06/15/10) It surely does seem like this thread goes round and round every now and then. I'm surprisedc no one mentined API - the American Petroleum Institute code letters for motor oil. Basically, the further down the alphabet the letters are, the better the oil quality. My humble opinion is that API ratings allow us guys - the end users - to compare apples with apples, and forego all the hype and local wisdom typically associated with this subject. For my money, the API rating is much more important than who's name is on the label.

Dave Erb
New Holland, pa

You'd think that would be true, but that logic is actually not exactly on-target. Subsequent ratings do not mean the rated oil is better than previous ratings. It only means the oil has been tested to later standards. There may be no actual difference between SJ and SL oils except the testing regimen.

Cheap API-rated oil, frequently, is good practice. IMO (my personal preference is WalMart Supertech, straight 30 HD, but any brand is as good as another in this application.)
 
(quoted from post at 09:59:24 06/16/10)
(quoted from post at 21:58:26 06/15/10) It surely does seem like this thread goes round and round every now and then. I'm surprisedc no one mentined API - the American Petroleum Institute code letters for motor oil. Basically, the further down the alphabet the letters are, the better the oil quality. My humble opinion is that API ratings allow us guys - the end users - to compare apples with apples, and forego all the hype and local wisdom typically associated with this subject. For my money, the API rating is much more important than who's name is on the label.

Dave Erb
New Holland, pa

You'd think that would be true, but that logic is actually not exactly on-target. Subsequent ratings do not mean the rated oil is better than previous ratings. It only means the oil has been tested to later standards. There may be no actual difference between SJ and SL oils except the testing regimen.

Cheap API-rated oil, frequently, is good practice. IMO (my personal preference is WalMart Supertech, straight 30 HD, but any brand is as good as another in this application.)

Where do you get these things? The automobile gasoline service classification rating system(Sx) is performance based and has a strictly enforced pecking order. The following is straight from API:

[color=blue:61bc34a0c9]For automotive gasoline engines, the latest engine oil service category includes the performance properties of each earlier category. If an automotive owner's manual calls for an API SJ or SL oil, an API SM oil will provide full protection. For diesel engines, the latest category usually - but not always - includes the performance properties of an earlier category[/color:61bc34a0c9].

TOH
 
As a forum, we've been down this road before. But I sure do NOT subscribe to the "cheaper is better" philosophy. Or its lesser sister "cheaper is just as good". The API ratings are just established minimums, and a good place to start. The discussion that each subsequent API rating is better is just flat out wrong. This may have been a good generalization up until a few years ago. But now that oils have had to reduce or eliminate the ZDDP (Zinc) that protected the flat tappet cam systems, in order to reduce eventual fouling of the catalytic converters, the newest API rated oils are specifically designed for roller tappet engines built to very precise tolerances. Are all of our road cars, trucks, and off-road vehicles now in use built to these standards and design? All of our restored tractors, trucks, and cars are at risk for cam damage. I know that some of the "experts" on this site have denied this potential problem, and think I am goofy.

After having a quality engine rebuilder remachine my 8N engine, parts and labor approaching 2K, he warned me not to use the SM rated oils, but to use something with a higher % of Zinc. In today's market, those oils are found in dealerships specializing in serving the off road equipment such as Cat, JD, and CNH. These are quality oils, but usually do not carry the API rating. These and other manufacturers specify the formulations that the oil blender company must make for them.

We have had many forum members recommend Rotella for our applications, and I would have agreed with them up until this newest generation of oils has been marketed. I called the Rotella tech line and was very specific about my questions re the amount of zinc. Rotella has greatly reduced the Zinc, but has not totally eliminated it. Thus it seems adequate for a broke-in engine, but very questionable for a fresh rebuild. If you think I am wrong, visit a cam manufacturer website. Or better yet call a cam grinding shop and find out what they have to say. Sure the highest rate of cam failure is in high performance race engines, but the same problem is occuring in our vintage trucks and tractors.

I run a mixed fleet of older diesel tractors, 8 year or older diesel trucks, vans, and a few gas tractors, big trucks and a couple of newer autos. I used to be able to buy a 55 gallon barrel of motor oil to serve them all. But no more! I need to buy SM oils for the newer roller tappet engines with cat converters, and a good off road rated oil for the older equipment. I am still very price conscious, but will not sacrifice needed oil quality to save a few bucks and then have huge repair bills for excessive wear. I know that Cat and CNH have oil sampling programs, and I have used them. With the Cat system, you buy a half dozen prepaid sample containers for about $15 each. Their report gives the complete oil analysis, and a phone number to call for specific questions. I have talked with the lab manager for a few hours (different occasions). Each engine can be a bit different, different brands of engines will give expected significant difference in lab results, and the brand and viscosity of oil used is significant.

Yes, just about all of today's oils are better than what was available when our N engines were built. But as a hard working tractor with the original oils, engine overhauls or sleeve, piston, ring and bearing replacement could be needed on 2 year intervals. On tractors doing heavy tillage on hundreds of acres, farm site overhauls could be an annual maintenance task. JD advertised how easy it was for the farmer to replace rings and bearings (and clutch discs). MM advertised that their 4 cylinder engine in the R and Z tractors could be serviced by a farmer sitting on a milk stool because the access to rods, bearings etc was available through a large removable side panel in the engine block. Yes all of our common oils are better than what was available when these tractors were built and heavily used, but none of us wants to go back to the high level of maintenance formerly required to keep these machines running. So the important issue is comparing today's oils as related to the engine and task it is expected to do, and not to sophomorically compare it to ancient dinosaur juice, or naievely believing that all oils are the same.

Paul in MN
 
Uwee, somebody or bodies got their ashes hauled and over a little thing like a brand of oil. I got mine when I mentioned useing Synthetics and seems like Paul of MN has some ideas about API or some such thing. Wonder how that works out. I besy just stick to that ole Mobil 1 synthetic and if it leaks, it leaks. Devious inHumble Tx
 
(reply to post at 00:53:14 06/17/10)

TOH, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that if brand X oil met SJ standards last year,... and API comes out with SL standards this year...and brand X meets that new standard also (and therefore they print new labels to reflect the new standard they meet)..... that does NOT mean that any change whatsoever actually took place in the oil. It only means the oil met both standards.

The logic that says because the label was changed means the oil is better.... is poor logic. (It might be true that brand x oil did NOT meet the new standard and required some recipie change to do so...and subsequent to the change of recipie the brand x now meets the new standard and therefore qualifies for the new label..... but the mere presence of a new standard being met does NOT guarantee any change was made to the oil in the bottle. It's possible the old oll met the new standard without any change whatsoever.)

Paul... if these old engines were designed for plain old non-additive oil (like they actually were/are)... and some new EPA rule requires the removal of zinc from modern improved oils.... Just how does that hurt the engine which was designed to run without zinc to begin with?
The cams/followers of these engines are generous with mating surfaces in order to avoid excessive wear....WITHOUT zinc. They've always been so.
Just because a machinist happens to be a good machinist, does not mean he is omnipotent with regard to oil requirements. The proof is in aircraft engines which have similar relationships as these N's do in regard to cams/followers. Zinc is not allowed in aircraft oils, and never has been.
Just because some new high-tech engine has roller-tappets does not mean the oil designed for that engine is harmful to engines without roller tappets, either. If it were....then how do you suppose these N-Fords got to be 70 years old?

(Meanwhile, anyone obsessed with having zinc dithiophospates in their motor oils are in luck. It is THE active ingredient in STP oil treatment and it's CHEAP. Read the label!)
 
My guess of what you are hinting is that I am mad about the discussion or advice given. No such thing, I am not mad, but am just sharing what I've learned. Unfortunately we have been fooled into thinking newer ratings are better for all applications (backwards compatable). On newely rebuilt engines, that can be an expensive mistake. So I'll spend a few more $$ to buy a known oil, and forgo whatever might be on sale for a lesser price. I make my oil decisions on recent solid data, and admit that a badly worn engine showing up in my shop will get the "sale price special". But with our big diesels having an overhaul cost in the $10,000 neighborhood (plus R&R), I do not want to save a few bucks now just to sacrifice thousands later.

For my cars, I also use Mobil 1. My brother was a fleet manager of a 500 vehicle fleet and did the oil sample testing on many vehicles. The data provided then gave them a much longer oil change interval with no sacrifice of accelerated wear. His fleet vehicles often ran 100,000 miles per year. He sold them as used vehicles after 3 years of usage. They ran well, some of the family members bought them and drove them 100,000 to 200,000 miles more. Taxi companies often get 500,000 miles out normal production automotive engines.

Use any oil you want to, it makes no difference to me. I've got nothing to sell here. Just don't try to tell me they are all the same, I have seen too much data to the contrary.

Paul in MN
 

I didn't think you were angry at all, sorry if my words seemed to imply that.
My point was similar to that of gasoline octane requirements. These engines don't need 87 or 93 octane. Any octane higher than about 76 is a waste... blown out the tailpipe.
Same thing with oil. You can spend $15 qt for it if it makes your feel good all over..... but ordinary $2 qt oil is not going to prevent it from going another 70 years if it was properly rebuilt to the same standards that got it thru the first 70.

My brother uses Mobil 1 in his Chevy. He got 120K miles on it when it was wrecked and it was running great until the wreck.
My 92 Jeep had 370K miles on it using Supertech (WalMart) and Supertech filters. The oil started out at 67-cents/qt and finally got inflated to $2.40 qt when the Jeep was totalled. That cheap oil may not be the reason the Jeep got 370K troublefree miles.... but it also did not prevent it either.
Do the math and see who wasted the most money on motor oil.
This truly is a silly subject that keeps popping up. IMO
 
You are making some good points. And I do not know much about aircraft, I defer my questions about that topic to my little brother who has had a few Cessna 152s and 172s. From what he has told me, the maintenance intervals are tight as to number of hours before o'haul. I suspect the absence of zinc in aircraft oil has to do with the potential for fouling out the spark plugs, and thus the plane falling out of the sky. But slow engine wear is acceptable and addressed by the frequent o'haul schedule.

But your question about how our 60+ year old tractors got to this age with a much lesser quality oil has to do with the frequent overhaul intervals expected as "normal". In the 1940s and 50s, an auto engine having 60,000 miles was often in need of an overhaul (or in the junk yard). Heavily worked engines were in need much sooner. As our oil got better, engine life increased and our recollections of high maintenance happily faded. Oil change intervals increased. In the early 60's I worked in some corporate offices of Conoco oil. Their regional managers demanded 1,000 mile oil change intervals, and expected to get 100,000 road miles out of their big Buicks before o'haul. A significant part of the wear reduction was attributed to the ZDDP additive, along with improved oil filtration.

Enough for tonight....

Paul in MN
 
[b:257a30858a][color=darkred:257a30858a]Now you've gone and done it[/color:257a30858a][/b:257a30858a]

[color=indigo:257a30858a][b:257a30858a]I told you so[/b:257a30858a][/color:257a30858a] :wink:
 
(quoted from post at 01:39:40 06/17/10)
TOH, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that if brand X oil met SJ standards last year,... and API comes out with SL standards this year...and brand X meets that new standard also (and therefore they print new labels to reflect the new standard they meet)..... that does NOT mean that any change whatsoever actually took place in the oil. It only means the oil met both standards.

If that were the case an SJ oil would meet the SL standard and it doesn't. When API issues a new rating it does so in response to a need for a change in performance. That change is the result of feedback from the automotive engineering community and the oil producers and reflects a change in the formulation of the oil. It is an expensive undertaking for the oil industry which API represents and is not undertaken frivolously. Regardless of brand an SJ oil is not suitable for use where an SL or SM oil is specified - if nothing else it will void your vehicle warranty.

TOH
 
(quoted from post at 02:45:28 06/17/10) ...But your question about how our 60+ year old tractors got to this age with a much lesser quality oil has to do with the frequent overhaul intervals expected as "normal". In the 1940s and 50s, an auto engine having 60,000 miles was often in need of an overhaul (or in the junk yard). Heavily worked engines were in need much sooner. As our oil got better, engine life increased and our recollections of high maintenance happily faded. Oil change intervals increased. In the early 60's I worked in some corporate offices of Conoco oil. Their regional managers demanded 1,000 mile oil change intervals, and expected to get 100,000 road miles out of their big Buicks before o'haul. A significant part of the wear reduction was attributed to the ZDDP additive, along with improved oil filtration.

Enough for tonight....

Paul in MN

I heartily disagree.

The reason modern engines get longer life is due to UN-leaded gasoline. Same reason aircraft spark plugs foul...because aviation gasoline still has lead in it which fouls the plugs and contributes to heavy wear and sludge in engines (and only one of the many reasons the engines are overhauled at specified periods in commercial aircraft. Private aircraft do not have to overhaul except at the choice of the owner.)
 
(quoted from post at 07:23:37 06/17/10) ...If that were the case an SJ oil would meet the SL standard and it doesn't. ...
TOH

Pardon the harsh wording, but... You seem to be stuck in a viscious-circle of bad-logic.

The mere fact that a superceding standard of testing is created...does NOT automatically prove an existing oil will not pass that test.

The existence of the standard isn't what makes the oil good or bad. It only provides a point of reference for testing. Surely you don't believe that every time a new standard is developed that every oil company throws away their product and competely re-develops a new product?

Their previous product meets the new standards in virtually all cases.

The SJ oil I purchased 5 years ago could be the exact same oil that was bottled last week that has an SL label on it. The label isn't what makes the oil, it only attests to the oil meeting the standard.
 
(quoted from post at 12:49:28 06/17/10)
(quoted from post at 07:23:37 06/17/10) ...If that were the case an SJ oil would meet the SL standard and it doesn't. ...
TOH

Pardon the harsh wording, but... You seem to be stuck in a viscious-circle of bad-logic.

The mere fact that a superceding standard of testing is created...does NOT automatically prove an existing oil will not pass that test.

The existence of the standard isn't what makes the oil good or bad. It only provides a point of reference for testing. Surely you don't believe that every time a new standard is developed that every oil company throws away their product and competely re-develops a new product?

Their previous product meets the new standards in virtually all cases.

The SJ oil I purchased 5 years ago could be the exact same oil that was bottled last week that has an SL label on it. The label isn't what makes the oil, it only attests to the oil meeting the standard.

There is nothing wrong with my logic skills - I am actually pretty good at it. You are stuck in this mindset that API develops new standards for some arcane and meaningless reason unrelated to any performance issue. They just like new standards that do nothing and have no impact on the formulation of existing oils. Lets go back a ways.

Question:Why does API say "CAUTION: SE oils are "not suitable" for use in automibiles built after 1979?

Answer: Because most if not all do not meet the SF standard - they don't pass the tests.

My 1983 Ford Thunderbird turbo-coupe owner's manual makes it very clear in plain English - use of an oil that does not meet SF requirements will shorten engine life and void my warranty. SE oils had shown themselves to be inadequate in protecting autombiles equipped with turbo-chargers and the industry (API and car makers) developed the SF standard to address that shortcoming. They wanted existing oils to be improved to meet the more demanding requirements.

Maybe some SE oil made the SF mark without reformulation but the vast majority did not. The API has made it very clear - EVERY oil with a newer service class certification meets ALL of the requirements of previous service class designations. The inverse is not assured and use at your own risk.

Service class designations developed in the last decade have tended to focus more on emissions related performance than engine wear. They typically require use of new compounds or specify limits on existing additives used in the mix - ZDDP is a prime example. Again this typically requires a reformulation of existing oils. If emissions don't concern you use whatever you like. But if you want to be sure your newer vehicle continues to pass your state's emission's tests without expensive repairs use an oil with the proper certification.

TOH
 

I rest my case, regarding your use of "logic".

I never made any statements you claim I made.

What is MEANT by a statement such as " SE oils not suitable..." for cars after a certain date is.... Oils that ONLY MEET SE TEST STANDARDS.... are not suitable.

Doubtless there are many many oils that in their contemporary formulations met whatever newer standards API devised without modification. Hence.... you cannot say that oils that are not labelled as meeting a later standard are automatically less quality than those which are so labelled. It only means the oil in THAT bottle was not tested to the later standard.

The fact a later standard exists...does NOT mean an oil not tested to that standard won't pass the test. If you can't back off at arm's length and see that then there's no further point in discussing this logic thing with you because you don't get it and likely never will.
 
(quoted from post at 21:25:23 06/17/10)
I rest my case, regarding your use of "logic".

I never made any statements you claim I made.

What is MEANT by a statement such as " SE oils not suitable..." for cars after a certain date is.... Oils that ONLY MEET SE TEST STANDARDS.... are not suitable.

Doubtless there are many many oils that in their contemporary formulations met whatever newer standards API devised without modification. Hence.... you cannot say that oils that are not labelled as meeting a later standard are automatically less quality than those which are so labelled. It only means the oil in THAT bottle was not tested to the later standard.

The fact a later standard exists...does NOT mean an oil not tested to that standard won't pass the test. If you can't back off at arm's length and see that then there's no further point in discussing this logic thing with you because you don't get it and likely never will.

The logic of standards was my profession for 20 odd years. Up until my retirement from NIST last month I spent the last two decades helping develop such standards and design and execute conformance tests for them. I'm pretty comfortable in that world.

So now you want to change the argument. Your original assertion was clearly stated I thought. Here is a direct quote:

"Their previous product meets the new standards in virtually all cases"

I took exception to that assertion - my assertion was most legacy motor oils require some sort of reformulation to conform to superceding service class specifications.

Now it seems you want to change the argument. Your assertion now is that just because a legacy oil hasn't been tested against a superceding specification doesn't "prove" it doesn't meet that specification. Of course it doesn't. But if a manufacturer doesn't have his legacy oil tested and certified by the appropriate testing authority they cannot claim it is conformant. And that sir is what you are now trying to do.

TOH
 
(reply to post at 07:42:48 06/18/10)

Hoke, ... I don't want to change the subject. YOU want to change the subject with a diversion because your argument based upon your misguided logic is so defective. Now you've quoted me out of context, and you and I and everyone who's followed this discussion knows it.

Here's my original contention:
(quoted from post at 09:59:24 06/16/10)
Subsequent ratings do not mean the rated oil is better than previous ratings. It only means the oil has been tested to later standards. There may be no actual difference between SJ and SL oils except the testing regimen. ....)

YOU seem to stick on the fact that later testing standards are higher standards than previous ones for the purposes of this discussion. You are wrong and being obtuse about it. That is not an axiom. Here's why (again):
We are talking about oil for use in a N-Ford.
We are talking about oils that have traditionally been used satisfactorily in N-Fords. Those oils were not originally rated at all by API.
Satisfactory, non-rated oils, were later found to meet API "SA" rating.
Using YOUR logic...oils that previously were bottled before their later brethren were placed in bottles labelled "SA" ...are not satisfactory. Capital "B" Capital "S".
Much later, virtually ...(did you see that little word "virtually"????).... virtually all oil producers saw to it that their oil formulations met the latest API standards.
Jump ahead a few years to standard "SJ". An oil meeting SJ would only be LABELLED SJ if it met that standard. When SL standard was developed, virtually everyone producing bottled motor oil made certain their oils met the new standard so they could sell the stuff. But VIRTUALLY all the oils already being produced under SJ were capable of passign all the tests of SL...even tho' bottles already on the shelf labelled SJ were not recalled and relabelled. In other words, the later STANDARD is not necessarily disqualifying of existing products which were already in satisfactory service applications. (Like N Fords, for example!) The later standard in itself is not what is disqualifying of existing products. The test would have to be RUN before that conclusion could be drawn.

Now that's an extreme effort in typing in order to clarify for you why my previous statement that a new STANDARD does not necessarily mean an existing oil is inferior. It only means the existing oil may not have been yet tested to the new standard. I can't make it any simpler than that.

But back to the discussion at hand: If N-Fords operated on SA oil quite nicely because that's all they needed... then SJ oil is good for it too, most folks would agree. Not you, perhaps, but most folks.

Now comes still later standards which meet EPA mandates that no zinc should be in the oils. ONLY as regards the older engines .... that new standard is NOT NECESSARILY an "improvement" as regards those old engines.

...If that were the case an SJ oil would meet the SL standard and it doesn't....

That failed logic is the sticking point. You don't KNOW it doesn't meet the new standard until it's TESTED against the new standard. All you KNOW is that it's not labelled to claim it meets the new standard. If it were tested...it might very well MEET the new standard. It's my contention that whatever standard it meets...new or old...it's sufficient for N-Fords. In fact, the OLD standard might be BETTER than the NEW standard, as far as N-Fords go. And that is logical. Why? Because as is already discussed....the NEW standard got rid of zinc which many, very smart people credit with good behavior in older cams/tappets. Doh!

(Make whatever claims you wish with regard to whatever you spent your career doing, it means nothing to me. Not only is it undocumented except for your own self-promotion... it's also very well known there are plenty of people in the world positioned at jobs in which they have absolutely no business.)

I'm not wasting any more time on this sillyness. One, or both of us has a synapse that misfires when we deal with each other.
It is not the ratings that changed the oil. It was the oil that was changed that met still-later standards.
 
(quoted from post at 19:16:46 06/18/10)
Hoke, ... I don't want to change the subject. YOU want to change the subject with a diversion because your argument based upon your misguided logic is so defective. Now you've quoted me out of context, and you and I and everyone who's followed this discussion knows it.

Here's my original contention:
(quoted from post at 09:59:24 06/16/10)
Subsequent ratings do not mean the rated oil is better than previous ratings. It only means the oil has been tested to later standards. There may be no actual difference between SJ and SL oils except the testing regimen. ....)

Let me try to give you a little insight into how the API service class standards process works using this hot button zinc issue.

The SL service class rating apparently had nothing to say about the levels of zinc in the formulation - no minimum - no maximum - the producer was free to use any level they wanted as long as the product conformed to ALL of the [b:2bd4fef643]explicit quantitative requirements[/b:2bd4fef643] contained in the SL specification.

The SM service class set a new quantitative limit (800 PPM IIRC) on the amount of zinc in the formulation but still no minimum. This was done because higher concentrations were known to decrease catalytic converter life and API testing showed that levels greater than the new limit were not needed for wear protection - [b:2bd4fef643] i.e oils with this newly established maximum level still passed all of the very same wear tests specified in the SL specification.[/b:2bd4fef643] It did not eliminate any of the requirements of the SL specification - they are carried forward as are all of the ones from SJ, SE, etc.

From that it should be obvious that some oils meeting the SL specification might conform to the SM limit and some might not. It should also be obvious that any oil that is SM conformant has no more than 800 PPM. And it should also be clear that oils with either rating might have less than - [b:2bd4fef643]perhaps even 0 zinc [/b:2bd4fef643]- as long as they pass the basic wear tests. So buying an SL oil doen't gaurantee you higher zinc levels - the SL specification doesn't have anything to say about it. If you want a oil with higher zinc levels get the product data sheets - that's the only way you will know. If you want an oil with lower zinc levels to protect your catalytic converter get any SM conformant oil - it gaurantees you a maximum of 800 PPM which the API has determined is safe for ypur converter. It also gaurantees the oil passes all of the same wear tests as any SL oil.

Every service class specification is a set of quantitative measures of explicitly enumerated properties of the oil. And as such the new SM specifciation ensures ALL of the preceding properties of the SL specification are met as well as the newly specified ones. If there is a minimum it can be raised but not reduced by a superceding specification. If there is a maximum it can be reduced but not raised. If there is no specification a a new minimum or maximum can be added. We can debate the [b:2bd4fef643]value[/b:2bd4fef643] of the new zinc rule all you want - there is plenty to be debated there and it is not a slam dunk case. But what cannot be debated is the nature of the rating system. A new service class rating establishes new properties and/or modifies exiting properties. It is a superset of the previous specification. This is by design and it is gauranteed behavior.

Despite your doubts I did this stuff (unrelated to oil) for a long time and I was good at it.

TOH
 
Now, THAT was an excellent dissertation! And I found it informative and easy to understand. Thank you.

By the way, I was not intending specifically to infer any particular levels of zinc in SJ, SL, or SM. I was only referring to a subsequent standard addressing the amounts of zinc previous standards may not. (But I admit, that other persons have posted info that led me to understand that zinc was to be removed from present and future standards. Thanks for addressing that issue.)

Do I understand correctly, that whatever zinc existed in previous standards is not removed by the latest standard?...merely prohibited from being increased?

Regardless of the standards allowed/disallowed w/regard to zinc in API rated oils, I doubt seriously that any typical N-Ford owner/operators have the resources to self-determine if any, or how much, zinc might be beneficial to their engines. I also doubt it is necessary at all in these things, and so is a moot point.

And on that thought, IF a Dodge 3.7 V-6 (I'm only making an example, no factual need relative to that engine is inferred) requires a degree of zinc which SL provides.... would it not be possible for a subsequent standard to reduce the element to a level below that which Dodge intended?
 
(quoted from post at 10:18:03 06/19/10) Now, THAT was an excellent dissertation! And I found it informative and easy to understand. Thank you.

By the way, I was not intending specifically to infer any particular levels of zinc in SJ, SL, or SM. I was only referring to a subsequent standard addressing the amounts of zinc previous standards may not. (But I admit, that other persons have posted info that led me to understand that zinc was to be removed from present and future standards. Thanks for addressing that issue.)

Do I understand correctly, that whatever zinc existed in previous standards is not removed by the latest standard?...merely prohibited from being increased?

You are more than welcome - I tried to be as clear and concise as possible..

I am not an expert on the API service class specifications - I "know" only what I read on the web and that isn't always 100% accurate. My explanation is based on the general principle of backwards compatabilty as it applies to technical stanndards in general. So my characteriizzation of the zinc issue wasn't intended to be definitive - simply a foil for my example and it may well be inaccurate or incomplete in the minutia.

That said I do believe the SM specification established a maximum limit of 800 PPM for zinc (might be 500 PPM as I vaguely recall that figure as well). Since it's a maximum the SL or any previous specification may have EXPLICITLY allowed a [b:d23b6eac4f]higher maximum [/b:d23b6eac4f]- that wouldn't break the backwards compatabilty rule. Or it may not have been explicitly enumerated at all as no one saw it as being a problem (my guess). What is clear is that significant numbers of SL conformant oils contain concentrations greater than the 800 PPM allowed under the SM specification and consequently are not SM conformant. They remain SL conformant and are still being sold with that labeling. But as I noted - just because an oil is labeled SL it doens't gaurantee the zinc level is greater than the SM limit of 800 PPM.

Personally, from all I've read, the limit is a non-issue for anything but "pathological" cases - custom high performance flat tappet motors running very high spring loads, severe loads, etc. Possibly something of an issue during the inital break-in periiod on conventional flat tappet cams but not signifacant afterwards. The API has explicitly commented and they are adamant that it works fine under normal conditions in flat tappet motors. If it worries you get an SL oil for your N or fresh flat tappet rebuild that you know has 1000 PPM or more and run it during the break-in period. If you have a catalytic converter on the vehicle you might seriously want to consider switching to an SM oil later.

I don't run Cx diesel oils in my gasoline engines or Sx gasoline oils in my diesel engines. They are two distict service classes and the API believes there is a reason for keeping them so. I defer to their expertise.

TOH
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top