Patents.....

How does a person go about patenting something? What if there is a similar item already patented, and I have a version that is new and improved, or make something that is similar, but different? anyone been through this before????
If something has a patent, can you "borrow" the idea for personal uses, as long as it is not sold???
 

Nobody can stop you from building your own machine or tool as long as it is for your personal use only. Makes no difference if it is patented or not. The problems and legalities arise when you try to mass produce and market that item.
 
I have a patent, and a pending patent.
First documentation. Write down the details and when you first thought of it and why.
Copy this info and send it to a friend registered mail and have him/her not open it but put it in a safe location. This establishes a time frame for claims.
Next go to USPTO.gov and work through the system to search for that idea, product, or any similar items. This needs to be done seriously and using 20 differing approaches to the task of searching. You may need to download a special viewing software to see the drawings (called Prior Art) related to the patents. It is time consuming, but necessary to prevent you from making an investment in ZERO. Next is to decide if a utility, or design patent is needed. A utility covers the concept as it applies to all uses of the idea. And costs much more to prove it for all parts of the process. A design patent covers only the specific structure idea and configuration of your idea, and is easier to get. But it is limited in its capability to protect you from others that make a different item that is just similar, but not a close copy, that does the same task.
A patent lawyer is a good idea after the above is under control. A utility patent Like mine can cost 10,000 or more to be granted.
A design patent can be in the 1500 to 2500 category.
My patent is #6,107,934. Some times making a million of something and flooding the market is a better strategy than getting a patent.
Do not talk or show the idea in a public forum, nor casually to others. This forces it to be public, and cannot be patented. If talking about it, or consulting is needed, a non-disclosure form should be signed and whitnessed between your parties. good luck..... JimN
 
Adding to the below content: Improving ideas is very patentable and much easier than new ideas. Do what I said below, I encourage you to act while there is fresh enthusiasm in your thinking. JimN
 
Supposedly only 2% to 4% of all patents make money to the holder of the patent.
 
It doesn't matter who "thought" of it first, so skip the letter to a friend. That's why you get a patent, to have a legally enforceable "right" in whatever it is you invented. You must get it "patented" first. Also the reason you don't want to publicize (by telling friends, etc.) isn't because you then could not patent it. It's because someone else may beat you to the patent office.
 
There's no exemption for "personal use" under
35 USC 271. If you make, use, offer to sell, or sell any patented invention, you can be held liable for infringement of that patent.

The other posters may be confusing patent law with copyright law. Copyright law has certain exemptions for "fair use"

Read about patent infringement at the link below.
US Patent law
 
A patent does not protect your invention. Quite the contrary, you must disclose to the public exactly how the invention works, and how to make it. The invention becomes public knowledge. You've given up your trade secrets in attempting to secure patent protection.

What an issued patent ultimately gives you is a set of exclusive rights to make, use, or sell the patented object, wherein these rights are set forth as a set of very specific and limited patent claims.

To gain in this process, and not lose, you must do a very good job of writing the claims, and think through all the different ways somebody else could evade the claims by making slight changes to the design, and thus try to make the claims broad enough to cover not only your exact embodiment of the invention, but many other ways of doing the same thing. This is a highly specialized task beyond the knowledge or skills of most inventors.

Most importantly, you must be ready and willing to enforce the claims. You must be prepared to file suit in Federal District Court, or at the Federal Trade Commission. You must assemble sufficient evidence of infringement prior to filing suit, lest you may ultimately be held liable for the defendant's attorney fees.

Finally, you must prevail in any ultimate litigation to collect damages. Litigation costs can easily exceed $10 million before you see a dime in damages, royalties, or settlement.

The individual inventor will tend to find it difficult to initiate and prevail at litigation. That is why patents, in effect, largely protect big corporations and not "the little guy".

Ironically, patent litigation attorneys, often working on a contingency basis, and "patent troll" specialty firms CAN easily profit from a patent. This despite the fact that they don't employ the invention at all, and act as mere holders of purported "intellectual property".

To sum up, corporations can win at the patent game, and attorneys can win, and patent troll firms can win, but it's a very tough game for individuals.
 
getting a patent for then its worth spending the $$ to talk with a patent attorney.

A tractor forum be the last place I want legal advice from
 
Sparktrician, as a retired engineer and now an Attorney who studied Patent Law (but am NOT a Patent Attorney and didnt set for the specialized Intellectual Property Patent Bar exam) back in my Law School days, THE BEST FREE ADVISE I HAVE IS TO CONSULT A PATENT ATTORNEY versus any lay opinions you may get here (somes good, other maybe not so good). You have to apply and search to see if your "invention" has already been awarded a patent. If what you have is good and perhaps worth something its best to consult a professional who specializes in intellectual property law because the money spent there might save and make you money, albeit if what you intend is already protected or not economically feasible, you will be out some legal fees...

Best wishes and good luck in the venture

John T Attorney at Law
 
I"ve got a United States patent....BIGGEST waste of money I ever spent....All someone needs to do is make an improvement on your patent and VOILA, they have a patent on their improvement on your patented article...Then , the patent office passed a bill that requires $1600.00 for a maintenance fee to "maintain" your patent..I didn"t realize there was that much "maintenance" on a patent....But before a certain date there is no maintenance fee ,but after that date, grab your ankles........No sir , not again.....
 
This man speaks the truth. If you don't defend it you lose it. If it is easily altered to get around your patent, you won't get a dime either.

If its cheap an easily copied, get a jump, make a million of em before the competition does and get out. Patent would be a waste of money.

If you really think you can make some money off it, pay for a few hundred $ at a good patent lawyer first. Chances are its not gonna make money enough to bother.
 
I heard the same advice as stated below to write all the information and send it in a regigstered letter, but I heard you should send it to YOURSELF. Then, if ever needed, you'd have the dated information there to "prove" when you thought of the idea.

On a side note, I had a couple ideas where I looked into this same thing...first idea was a pair of gloves with magnets sewn into the backside of the hand part, to use to hold staples when fencing, nails, etc. I mentioned the idea to one friend who I KNOW didn't tell anyone, but still, a couple years later I saw the exact same product for sale in a tool flyer....

Second idea I wont say what it was, but I did tons of online searching and never saw a similar product offered for sale. Then I found a website where you could search for patents, and found a very similar item that had been patented way back in the early 1900's.

So, always do as much home research as possible before investing a dime in any new idea. Like the old saying goes, there truly are very few new ideas....
 
When my father was working at Westinghouse during it's hay day in the 50s and 60s, He held 5 patents for smaller, more efficient Transformers and tap changers. He has told me that making their patents solid, they send big bucks and awarded dad $5000 for each one. The transformers are the ones that are still mounted on most telephone poles around most cities today.
 
Hello Sparktrician,
I'm pretty sure you can patent an improvement on any patent. The biggest hassle comes from trying to protect your idea/concept or whatever you are trying to patent.
One wise old man told me to take your idea or
whatever you want to protect and have the idea fully explained include pictures, NOTORIZED. Even if someone else comes up the the finished product on a later date, you would have the right to patent or receive payment for the idea, even if you never had a patent for it. I never had the opportunity to prove it, but it sounds right anyway.
Good Luck...................GUIDO.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top