tlak

Well-known Member
I figure the pirates are a way to jack up fuel prices. Just the cost of doing business. If you make billions by raisng the price a dime or so, what's it matter if you give the prirates a few million.
With all the modern weapontry, it's obvious they're just letting the pirates do this.
 
International law does not allow merchant ships to defend themselves with anything but firehoses. Any military action that was not a result of a direct attack or credible threat to the military vessel would result in an international outcry and possible prosecution of the officers involved, depending on which Nation they serve.If it were US ships involved it would probably be OBammy leading the crucifiction of US servicemen.
These are Somali Pirates operating in the Indian Ocean, this has been a problem for years,I have ridden a heavy lift transport ship taking a drilling rig to the middle east through these waters and there are approximately 3 alerts per week of ships being attacked or captured in this area.
 
Maybe you think they should just blow them out of the water with your comment on weaponry. Let me ask you how you'd clean up the mess? or do you not eat fish?
 
Thats not exactly true. You have every right to protect your self at any time.
There are companies that provided Armed men to provide protection to merchant shipping.
This is expencive though. Companies tend to only protect high value cargos that are hard to replace.
Unfortunately, most ships, cargo, and crew. Can be replaced via insurance, paying ransum or just hireing new ones.
Companies will do what cost the least.
 
Pirates? Aarrggh! I wonder how many of them have peg legs, metal hooks for hands, black patches on their eyes, and striped shirts.

Seriously, looking at this pirate situation, can you see the similarities with gun control efforts in this country? There"s little to deter the thug pirates from attacking the basically unarmed ships. Will this be like us American citizens in a few years when the left wingers, who have all the momentum right now, along with the media"s full backing, start to confiscate OUR personal means of self defense?
 
Your conspiracy theory is a bit inane. You make it sound like modern weaponry is the answer - which is a little silly in today's world. I think you need to read the rules of NATO, and the new Atalanta’ mission that it now taking charge. Basically, "too many chefs and not enough cooks." Right now - the players who are allowed (and invited) to fight the pirates are - France, Germany, Greece, the Netherlands, and Spain, with a little less help from from Portugal and Sweden

First - who's jurisdiction does the act or piracy fall under? Who (which counrty) is going to bring in the weapons you mention? Who is going to be blamed if the tanker sinks and there's a huge environmental disaster?

NATO was first involved, and now another big "club" - the "Atalanta’ mission" is taking over.

Last week, India went after a "pirate" ship, sank it, and now - it seems they sank the wrong one and . . . someone is in trouble.

Right now, it seems Germany might get permission to send soldiers and weapons in to fight the pirates who have this oil tanker.

Now - I don't know how good your memory is - but Germany started TWO World Wars. Germany is the last place I want to see with tons of modern weaponry. Aren't our US soldiers still over there keeping an eye on them since Hitler bit the dust?

And, should the USA go there (if we get asked)? I say, NO. We waste enough money as it is, to help foreign countries out of messes and never get thanked - just condemned. They beg us for our help, and then spit in our faces.

There is no conspiracy here. Just one big stinking mess of laws, committees, questionable rights, etc.
 
Most companies pay the ransoms. The vast majority of the worlds merchant ships are registered in tax havens such as Panama, Vanatu, caymans etc. all of these places have very weak regulations and roughly zero Naval power. 99.9% of the worlds ports would deny entry with an armed contingent on your merchant vessel, in particular any US port. If you travel the high seas and break another countries laws, whether you are defending yourself or not, you will be subject to that countries justice system if apprehended. These are some of the reasons that there are international treaties in place that prohibit arming crews.
 
Arm all of the vessels with 50 cal. BMGs and trained gunners, that will repel boarders sufficiently!

Oh wait! That might hurt someones feelings...............maybe in the fututre the crews can just ask the pirates, nicely, to stop all illegal activity.................
 
Why don't we do it the abundant way. We can send an envoy to talk with the pirates. He can whine and grovel, and ask why they're doing these nasty and unkind things. Maybe he can offer them a bunch of money to stop. Maybe we can send over a bunch of mental health professionals, to try to understand what makes the pirates do what they do. Maybe we ALL can take some kind of class, so we can be made to understand what it means to be a pirate and the harsh life that they lead. I just know Pres. external_link can just go talk to them, and after a few pretty words, we can all just hold hands and dance and sing songs. You know, YesWeCan,YesWeCan.
Jack
 
There is a lot more to it, than meets the eye, besides nato and international laws etc. etc., you have a country, Somolia that is in shambles, no ruling government since around '91 or so, almost 20 years now + or -. All those pirates have to operate out of somewhere, they control ports, gather intelligence on shipping schedules, routes, generate funds and apparently have the means to execute piracy operations in the range of several hundred miles. It's becoming a means to an end for these people, more lucrative than anything else they can do, before they used to excecute the crew, since large companies are paying ransomes, they have changed tactics, it pays more. Don't forget the terrorists in that country too. Another hot spot that needs to be dealt with, no doubt.

It would be interesting to see some would be pirates dealt a hard blow with the use of some weaponry, and one would think this has been seriously considered. As a crew member you are a sitting duck, it's hard to imagine this problem will not be dealt with, with the frequency of these attacks. With the technology today, especially due to necessity, like what has been developed out of dire need for both wars, it would not suprise me that something or some technology is developed to mitigate the problem, sure would be a valuable tool. A couple pair of .50 BMGs or 20mm, or that new 30mm sure would seem to be a stop gap, but that opens another can of worms does'nt it ?
 
Doubt he eats fish or even bathes. Some of the comments on this are just plain ignorant. Blaming external_link?-he"s not President yet. So why doesn"t Pres Bush act? Or is he too busy figuring out who to pardon!
 
A lot of ships are looking into sonic repellers but face it, piracy isn't a huge problem. It still costs more to do anything about it than to keep paying.

The pirates are actually keeping some type of order in their towns and keeping the nnalert extremist groups at bay. There is a lot going on there.
 
Smart bombs to ports nuff said. The India navy sunk a mother ship. Should check if the are looking for arms?
 
ARRR..I be looking long n hard for Pirate Reparations !!! Give us our due or face our wrath ! You think it;s easy ? No medical , no dental . We need a union !! lol
 
Modern weapons...

But it's a small arms war over a big area.

It's a war for small frigates and PT Boats...and a lot of them, not Aegis destroyers and aircraft carriers.

It's also complicated by how much in a knot our legal system is becoming. The U.K. and some other European countries have issued directives to their military to NOT arrest pirates -- they're governments are concerned if pirates are brought to European nations for prosecution they'll be eligible for political asylum. Many were surprised when France actually did haul some back for prosecution.

So how the heck do you fight someone? Can't be by clandestine operations...look at the furor over "extraordinary rendition." Can't do it by military operations, 'cause we might sink the wrong boat. Can't do it by police & prosecution, cause if we arrest them then they'll seek their rights under western nation's laws and ask for asylum.
 
Aye, give the ship some firepower and knock 'em asunder.
JollyRoger.jpg
 
Seems to me the most effective approach would be sinking them on the spot and shutting up.
When enough go missing, the message will sink in...
I'd think it shouldn't be too hard to keep a proper lookout and deal with them as needed.

Rod
 
Bush doesn't have to try very hard to figure out who to pardon. Just look at Clinton's pardons and then don't do the crap he did. Simple, very simple.
 
More of tlak and his conspiracy theories.

So let me get this straight. You think that our leaders, or the "Tri-Latteral Commission" is hiring pirates to to hijack tankers so the price of oil will rise? What about all the ships they hijack that aren't tankers? Just a cover for when they do get tankers? And isn't that more complicated than what they did last time? Just getting the speculators to bid up the price?

Do you really think they'd do something so obvious that a simpleton like you could figure it out?

Tell you what, get a better job, move out of your parents house, and maybe you'll have less time to sit around thinking up different ways that The Man is keeping you down.

Or maybe buy a tractor to fix up in your parents garage, that would take you mind off of these ridiculous ideas of yours.

Crimanilly, you get kookier by the day.
 
All right DA, the tankers are talking about taking the long way around and this will raise the price of fuel. If they don't do something about an obvious, simple, local problem then they're using it to raise the price of oil, which is now below $50@barrel. They say that the ships could fly the American flag and then our ships could protect them.
Don't spend all of Thanksgiving in the back of your van w/ a turkey sandwich. Go back to the homeless shelter or your mothers use to taking care of you.
Happy Thanksgiving.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top