ratchet strap test

old-9

Well-known Member
I found this today , learned a lot. Take it for what it is worth, I will keep using chains and binders for my tractors and use the straps for smaller loads.
here
 
Many years back and old timer once told me that it takes IRON to haul IRON . Now after my last WHOOORAW of hauling the big ugly oversized STUFF sometimes i had to use Straps and when usen STRAPS i always use something to protect them . IF you COULD get by with five straps it got 8 . I hauled several loads of concrete reinforced sewer pipe 10 and a half foot in dia and 28 .5 long and weighed in at 72 thousand and change , you could not use CHAINS and it had to be strapped . the outside of the pipe was rough and the FIRST load i did not have what was needed to protect the straps . I had 12 straps holding that load on . I loaded in South Belot Il. headed for Cleveland Ohio . When pulling a RGN you are hauling a load on like two leaf springs as the trailer flexes big time if you have a weak stomach this is not the trailer you will want to drag behind you and ya really never want to look back and see how much flex your working with . Once the load was off all straps were trash and had to be replaced . To keep on hauling this good freight we cut convair belting into 6 inch stripes then put that over the pipe then the straps.
 
old-9,

Thanks for the link! I watched every moment and am sure that what I haul/tie down will be just fine with the ratchet straps.

I will probably care a lot less if I happen to have a twist or two when I strap the load down.

D.
 
I use chains and straps with chains.
My straps are 10k tow straps.
Straps are to prev
cvphoto112344.jpg

Lateral movement.
Chains are for forward and backwards movements.
8 tie points. Overkill.
 
Interesting video!

Kinda surprised they broke at the wind up spool.

Thought the fold over on the hook would have been the sharpest stress point, or the stitching would have pulled out.
 

Watch some more of his videos. He made his own vise, then tested against a bunch of other brands. His won.

Then he built a wildly oversized one.

He reviews welding tables in another video. Of course, the $10k one was best, but it is surprising how bad the cheaper ones are. They were perfectly acceptable for a farm shop, but not good for production work.

He runs a good channel.
 
I have had them break Going down the road due to trailer flex . i have had G 70 chains pop due to flex , had two G 70 3/8ths chains let go in a panic stop. That time i almost lost a brand new Gradall not more the 38 miles from the plant . That would not have gone over vary well. . The binders flew over a 100 feet from the truck with one landing on some peoples ft porch. all because some dumb freight hauler came flyen around a blind 90 degree turn like a mad man and cut over into my lane . Good thing i was slowing down for the turn , this happened inft. of a friends road side fruit stand , John saw it all happen . The freight box never stopped . The gradall was hanging off the one side with only a 1/4 of the steering tire still on the trailer.
 


Yup, more proof that when used properly that straps are just as good as chains when used properly. Old 9, just be sure that you don't try using a 5/16 chain to take the place of a 10,000 lb strap.
 
"IF it has wheels chains are the law"

Prove it. I can find no-where in the DOT regs that wheels need chains.
AaronSEIA
 
(quoted from post at 02:53:06 12/30/21) IF it has wheels chains are the law


Gene, apparently you missed a half dozen posts a year or two ago that soundly trashed this old wive's tale, LOL. You may want to read the FMCSA instead of facebook, LOL.
 
Great video.
I noticed he used great care not to have any pinch points.
And when he did include a pinch point (A Knot) the strap broke easily.

That brings me to ask why so many of you have a problem understanding tie down laws especially for straps.
Some claim straps can not be used.
Some claim straps can be used but do not understand pinch points.
Both are dead wrong.
I guess it mostly comes from people getting a ticket while using a strap and blaming it on the strap when it was really a pinched strap that got them the ticket.

Here are the laws for wheeled and track vehicles.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/49/393.128

https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/49/393.130

No where does it say straps can not be used.
In fact the law for vehicles below 10,000 even includes straps in the wording when it says..
Edge protectors are not required for synthetic webbing at points where the webbing comes in contact with the tires.

So lets look at why you can get in trouble using straps.

The big one that gets straps in trouble is abrasion or cutting IE pinch points.
393.104 (f) (4) clearly says...
Edge protection must be used whenever a tiedown would be subject to abrasion or cutting at the point where it touches an article of cargo. The edge protection must resist abrasion, cutting and crushing.

This is not limited to straps but since most of the discussion on here is chains vrs straps we will only talk about straps.

While I hate to use someone on this site as a example he did post the perfect picture for me to show you how people get in trouble with straps.
I tried to take out what is tied down to leave that out of the discussion.
So lets assume the strap is big enough to tie down the piece of equiptment.
Lets assume the strap is marked and up to standards.
I have the abrasion point circled in red.
Even if the strap is still in perfect condition and no wear is being caused by the abrasion point this is still a clear violation of tie down laws and could land him a ticket.

Hopefully this will clear up some of this discussion if starts are suitable tie downs.



<img src=https://www.yesterdaystractors.com/cvphotos/cvphoto112387.png>

This post was edited by john in la on 12/30/2021 at 05:02 am.
 
(quoted from post at 10:06:07 12/30/21) I had to edit something I said and it took out the picture.
Sorry I let my typing go faster than my brain.
But here is the picture.



<img src=https://www.yesterdaystractors.com/cvphotos/cvphoto112388.png>


3 pinch/abrasion points in the pic.
 
I don't like using straps on things that can bounce or spring like equipment with tires. Straps stretch as they are in use. Chains will hold solid and tight so things like tractors don't bounce as they are hauled. The reason for not, using straps on moveable objects. Things like lumber, drywall, and such are a solid mass and don't tend to move much nor bounce. Straps work well there. I liked straps on loads like brick were it would crack the bricks sometimes if you pulled down to hard on the cube when tying it down. Corner boards were the order of the day for containment hauling them. Yes straps can be used for many things and so can chains just is good to select wisely on their use. I used old packing corners from pallet wrapping and some vinyl siding corners for some things under my straps to protect them. I suppose some would even find fault with the correct use of a rope for hanging with.
 
(quoted from post at 07:07:38 12/30/21) I don't like using straps on things that can bounce or spring like equipment with tires. Straps stretch as they are in use. Chains will hold solid and tight so things like tractors don't bounce as they are hauled. The reason for not, using straps on moveable objects. Things like lumber, drywall, and such are a solid mass and don't tend to move much nor bounce. Straps work well there. I liked straps on loads like brick were it would crack the bricks sometimes if you pulled down to hard on the cube when tying it down. Corner boards were the order of the day for containment hauling them. Yes straps can be used for many things and so can chains just is good to select wisely on their use. I used old packing corners from pallet wrapping and some vinyl siding corners for some things under my straps to protect them. I suppose some would even find fault with the correct use of a rope for hanging with.


Due to the stretch straps are advisable for things that can bounce like a rubber tired vehicle. Chains can slacken then tighten then slacken more and allow hook to come off or a boomer to open.
 
Used fire hose slipped over straps make good protection on corners. If you look at rigging charts angle of use makes a difference .So the test does not show the real tensile strength of the strap
.
Jim
 
[b:654c4848f0]If you look at rigging charts angle of use makes a difference[/b:654c4848f0]

What you say is true.
But you are not thinking the equation all the way through.

Let's say the straps are at a 45 degree angle to the table.
Each side of the strap will carry 9,000 lbs while the ram is exerting 12,000 lbs of force.
Yes these figures will change as you change the angle of the straps to the table but let's use this as an example.

Since he has the weight indicator between the strap and the table he is measuring the true force on the strap.
And each side of the strap will have the same force.
So his measurements are correct.

Now if he were measuring the weight on the ram; such as with a scale under the ram cylinder your statement would be correct.
In that case the scale would be showing 12,000 lbs while the straps would only have 9,000 lbs of force on them.

All these figures are close but not exact or figured with a calculator to just show a example.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top