Would someone explain to me what the resistor on my to 30 does. the tractor will run without it but I wont because I know it has a good reason for being there. Thanks
 
If there is a resistor in the primay ignition circuiton a 12V electrical syatem, you have what I call a "half breed" ingnition system. Whoever replaced your generator with a 12 V alternator or generator,saved the old 6V coil and to prevent burning it out, they put a 3 ohm resistor in the primary circuit to limit the current through the coil. If thee didn"t do that, then the current would roughly double through the coil and since the power=I^2 x R, the heat dissipated in the coil would go up by a factor of four. This would result in an overheat in the coil which melts the tar-like insulation and after about 20-30 minutes, the coil would short and the engine would die. After a 1-2 hr cool down period, the engine would restart only to die again in 20-30 minutes. You can get a real 12V coil(NAPA IC-14SB) for ~$15 at NAPA and eliminate the reistor. Otherwise you need to keep the resistor in the circuit.

If you happen to have a real 12V coil( not the one with the fine print that says "needs an external resistor") then you can remove the resistor.

By the way, make sure that the small wire to the coil from from the distributor is connected to the coil terminal with the same sign as the battery ground.

Hope this helps you.
 
On some Deere tractors (for sure on my '68 4020) the resistor is there for better starting. An auxilliary contact on the starter solenoid shorts out the resistor feed full battery voltage to the coil while cranking. Since the battery voltage gets pulled down by the starter this gives a hotter spark, then the resistor protects the coil from excess current while running that would tend to over heat the coil leading to short coil life. I have the I&T manual for some of the Dubuque 2 cylinder tractors but its upstairs. It may show whether that resistor is original. I have the parts book for a 420 up there too, though that's a few years later than the 30. It could well be that the 30 was 6 volts originally and the resistor was added when it was converted to 12 volts. Nothing wrong with that, just means you need the resistor with the original coil or the coil will fry eventually.

Gerald J.
 
I have a 'real' 12V coil on my Ferguson 2085 and it overheats without a ballast resistor. I've been told that the tractor originally had around a 30 Amp battery; today's batteries are around 60 amps. A coil will 'draw' all it can take hence it overheating without a ballast resistor.
 
Total rubbish.

The 30 ampere hour and the 60 ampere battery still supply only 12 volts. The resistance of the coil circuit determines the current in that circuit, not the battery ampere hour rating. A 12 volt coil should draw 4 amps, no more. If it draws more than its rated to draw it will heat more than its rated to heat but may give better spark. So that "real" 12 volt coils was made to work with the external resistor to give a total coil circuit resistance of 3 ohms. A coil that uses an external resistor will give good ignition at a much higher speed than one with all the winding resistance in the coil. That is not a factor on a tractor but is why some automotive coils always used a resistor, even on 6 volts.

Gerald J., Electrical Engineer.
 
if you check the voltage after the resistor when key is first turned you will see a full 12 volts for a short period. this allows for a hotter spark when starting. the voltage will drop after the resistor heats up . i think when i checked mine on my 1955 chevy truck it was 10 volts after the engine was running. the reason the resistor has the porcelin body is to protect from heat. i have three engines running a 12 volt charging system using a 6 volt coil with a ballast resistor.i have never had any issues with starting,performance,or lifespan of the parts. when i originally changed my chevy truck to 12 volts it burned the points up in a few days using all 12 volt parts. a old mechanic told me to run a 6 volt coil with a ballast resistor and thats been over 20 years ago with no problems. the only thing he told me was to keep a extra ballast resistor at all times because they do fail and mine has 1 time. i am not telling anybody my way is right only that it works for me.
 
Not true! The battery capcity has nothing to do with the current draw of the coil The only thing that matters is the battery voltage and the reisitance of the primmary circuit. However, If you charging system over charges your battery , it can cause the charging voltage to get as high as ~18 volts and this can overheat your coil.
 
Gerald J.,

Can you explain why 3 ohms external resistance is better than 3 ohms internal resistance regarding the coil performance? I thought reisitance was resistance. What am I missing?
 
If its resistance with say iron wire not a part of the inductance of the coil, the only advantage of the internal resistor coil is there's only two wires to connect, not four.

If the resistance was all copper wire turns on the coil primary it could be made to run with less current because there would be more turns to charge the magnetic core, BUT that added inductance (proportional to the square of the turns) would require a longer dwell to get the current rise and that would only work for a slower running engine. In the typical 4 cylinder tractor engine never running over 2200 RPM, that's probably not a limitation, but an 8 cylinder car engine running 6000 RPM that's a definite impediment to high speed performance. Some 6 volt Chrysler products used a 3 volt coil with external resistor for that reason.

So the "12 volt" coil is probaby wound as a 6 volt coil with internal resistor. The "12 volt coil needing resistor" is essentially a 6 volt coil relabeled for those who can't fathom the difference. When there is the external resistor then its handy to use an auxiliary start switch or solenoid contact to apply full battery voltage to the coil while cranking for better ignition from 9 volts.

The fundamental nature of an inductor is it tries to prevent a change in current either rising or falling. That means the current rises according to the L/R ratio of the coil and the supply voltage when the points close and what makes a coil useful for spark ignition when the points open. When the points open the coil raises the terminal voltage very rapidly trying to keep the coil current the same. That's inductive kick, expressed as Ldi/dt and it is essential to ignition.

Gerald J., Electrical engineer
 
Gerald J.,

I read your reply with interest and would offer the following comments.

"If its resistance with say iron wire not a part of the inductance of the coil, the only advantage of the internal resistor coil is there"s only two wires to connect, not four."

The reference (Motor Auto Engines and Electrical Systems, Motor Publications, 1977) that I have on this subject implies that the resistance is not part of the inductance but is rather in series with the primary winding. This is a distinct advantage, in my opinion, since the less connections the fewer connections to go bad, come loose, corroded, get greasy, etc.

"If the resistance was all copper wire turns on the coil primary it could be made to run with less current because there would be more turns to charge the magnetic core, BUT that added inductance (proportional to the square of the turns) would require a longer dwell to get the current rise and that would only work for a slower running engine."

That"s an intersting point. However, since the subject is a relatively low speed tractor engine with a max rpm of 2200 rpm, in my opinion,this statement is not material to the discussion at hand.

Most high performance coils used for high rev engine that I have seen (and I have certainly not seen them all) have internal resistance built in. So they must have the resisitance in series with the primary also.

"When there is the external resistor then its handy to use an auxiliary start switch or solenoid contact to apply full battery voltage to the coil while cranking for better ignition from 9 volts." (I think you mean 6 volts)

I believe Chrysler used to use resistors with positive temperature coeficients( dR/dT >0) to provide high voltage for start up and reduced voltage for normal running thus no additional switch or special wiring was required.
 
No, I really meant 9 volts, that's the battery voltage when the 12 volt battery is not doing well, and its cold, and the engine is cranking hard. That voltage applied to a 12 volt coil gets a wimpy spark, but applied to a 6 volt coil gets a healthy spark and the coil won't overheat too much while cranking.

True the high inductance isn't a limit with tractors but its a reason for resistors with coils either internal or external for car engines. And the low voltage coil has most or all of its resistance in the copper winding since copper has some resistance though lower than any practical metal.

With the resistor inside the coil, the number of circuit connections remains the same, there still has to be a connection from coil to resistor, just its inside the coil case where its protected from grunge, but also in a place it can't be fixed if it goes bad.

The thermal resistor could fail to give good starting with the engine hot if the engine stopped time was shorter than what it took for that resistor to cool off. I think I prefer the auxiliary contact on the starter solenoid and a fixed value resistor.

Gerald J.
 
(quoted from post at 23:54:16 10/03/07) If you charging system over charges your battery , it can cause the charging voltage to get as high as ~18 volts and this can overheat your coil.

It will also mean your battery is being seriously damaged! A 12V battery shouldn't rise above about 15V or 16V or it will be bubbling and overheating. Modern alternator systems float charge the battery at around 14.4V, which is quite high enough to maintain a full charge in an automotive situation. Any higher and the battery life will be reduced, particularly for sealed batteries.

If you ever see 18V across your battery, stop and check out the charging system!

David
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top