Submersible well questions

I have a well house out back and took the cover off today to check the heater. Noticed the pressure gauge was pegged but the well was cycling and working ok so I figured bad gauge. Put a new one on and the cut-in and cut-out pressures were way low. Didn't kick on until a little less than thirty, and cut off at 55lb. Thought maybe it was set for 30-50 but I'm "sure" I've always used 40-60. I have a bladder type air tank, and it was a little low on pressure: 34 lbs so I pumped it up to 38. And there was a note I put on there back in 2018 that I had set the tank pressure to 38, so that reinforces my thinking that it is supposed to be a 40-60 system. Anyway I reset the pressure switch to 40-60 but it sure took a lot of adjustment. I would have thought just a few flats of the adjusting nuts would have been sufficient but I had to turn them a lot. Everything is working okay, kicking on and off where I want it but here's my concern: There is a spigot right there on that I open up to drop the pressure, and pump kicks on at about 40lb or maybe a little less. Pressure doesn't change much, apparently that's maxing out the pump, but then after a minute the pressure drops rapidly to 25 lbs. When I close the spigot it jumps back up to 38-40 and then climbs normally.
What is causing that? And why did it take so much adjustment to get the pressures right?
 
I’m going to guess that when you crack open the spigot the pressure drops to 25 because you dropped it too that and the pump doesn’t kick in and build pressure fast enough. There is always a delay. I know on my pump. I have a 1.25 inch line with a tap. If I open it up the pressure drops so fast that the switch turns off as it drops below 10 lbs. as far as adjusting as much as you had to I can only guess the springs are getting rusty and week. Time for a new switch. And that is what I am doing on mine tomorrow as I’m having some issues as well.
 
Most pressure switches are design for certain cut on-off pressures (20-40, 30-50 or 40-60). Sounds like you got one for 30-50 since you had to do a lot of adjusting to get your pressure. Should be on the label. It may affect the way it functions with that much change.
 
It may be a good idea to buy a new pressure switch, I've bought them on Amazon, very inexpensive and work perfectly. In one instance there was so much crud in the fitting connected to the pressure switch I don't think the switch could respond as quickly as it should. I've had gauges that were hit by frost and would no longer give correct pressure reading.
 
The "rule of thumb" for precharge is to pressurize an empty tank to about 2 PSIG below the desired cut-in (low) pressure setting of the pump switch. If you want the pump to restart at 40 PSI, set the precharge to 38 PSI.

However, that "rule-of-thumb" is seldom presented with the standard conditions and adjustments for variations. That is generally a true statement for water at 20°C (68°f) and at sea level, or a barometric pressure of 14.69 PSIA / 29.9 in/Hg barometer. If your well head is located at 1,000 ft AMSL, that pressure needs to be adjusted to reflect the variation in barometer, and that can be up to 3.37% higher (about 1.4 PSIG). If the well water is a minimum 50°F (10°C) as is common in my area, the pressure needs to be adjusted up to about 3.5% lower to compensate - Again, PRECHARGE, not cut-in or cut-out settings.

Your results may vary depending upon the tank capacity, bladder or accumulator configuration, and operating temperature (of the ground water). Whatever combination of elevation and temperature may be involved will dictate the result. It's all easy to figure out, and is detailed in Perry's and dictated by Boyle's and Charles' Laws.

As for the pressure switches, the older-style Square-D 9013-F or -G series are the most capable since they include adjustable cut-out as well as a more adjustable differential (cut-in) setting to function wherever you want. I like being able to have a differential closer to 12-13 PSI instead of 20 to mitigate large swings in flow and the effect that can have on temperature mixing settings as well as overall function. the fixed 20PSI differential switches are what is normally found at most consumer home centers and average hardware stores, and are probably better left on those shelves than installed in any water system.
 
The pressure in your bladder tank should be less that the cut-in setting on the switch. I've always gone with 5 psi less. If it's less than cut-in the tank will empty out before the pump starts and pressure will drop drastically for a moment. You want the pump to cut in before the tank empties.
 
Turn off the pump, open the hydrant until the water flow stops and water pressure is 0.Leave the hydrant open. Add air until you are 2 pounds under kick in pressure with a tire gauge. Close the hydrant. Turn the pump back on.
 
Turn off the pump, open the hydrant until the water flow stops and water pressure is 0.Leave the hydrant open. Add air until you are 2 pounds under kick in pressure with a tire gauge. Close the hydrant. Turn the pump back on.
And to add what rrlund said, while the tank is empty try moving it to see if the bladder is going bad and has water leaking through, that will cause switch/pumping problems. That's if yours isn't hard piped in.
 
I replaced 2 tanks in 4 years...bladder came loose inside the tank both times. Quality control.
I'm so done with failing bladder tanks and their short 'life-span'. The last one I bought from our local hardware store said 'replaceable bladder' on the box, I asked how to get a replacement bladder? They said "generally they will just give you a new tank within 5 years". That was very good news to me. Nobody ever hinted to me about that before nor was there any guarantee posted on the box that I have ever seen. I've probably gone through at least 5 bladder tank failures. 🥲🤷🏼‍♂️ The last few years have seen a drastic price increase on bladder tanks.
 
I don't recall if it was here or not but a few months ago someone was having similar problems and when he finally went to replace his switch he found that the water passage in the switch was all but blocked.
 
well10.jpg

well11.jpg


This was sluggish to turn on/off. I've had worse some years back.........where the doggone thing completely refused to start the pump.

I believe this pipe nipple was a hurry up deal. I couldn't find a brass nipple, so opted for the galvanized nipple. Brass lasts a bit longer without plugging up.

well12.jpg

I did take the time to find a brass nipple this time around.

Crazy pressure problems are usually the switch. Constant cycling is usually the pressure tank...........waterlogged, or air has leaked out of the bladder over time.

well5.jpg

If you're getting weird cycling.......it pays to do a simple soap test on the valve.

well4.JPG

These sealing valve stem caps can solve the problem.
 
The "rule of thumb" for precharge is to pressurize an empty tank to about 2 PSIG below the desired cut-in (low) pressure setting of the pump switch. If you want the pump to restart at 40 PSI, set the precharge to 38 PSI.

However, that "rule-of-thumb" is seldom presented with the standard conditions and adjustments for variations. That is generally a true statement for water at 20°C (68°f) and at sea level, or a barometric pressure of 14.69 PSIA / 29.9 in/Hg barometer. If your well head is located at 1,000 ft AMSL, that pressure needs to be adjusted to reflect the variation in barometer, and that can be up to 3.37% higher (about 1.4 PSIG). If the well water is a minimum 50°F (10°C) as is common in my area, the pressure needs to be adjusted up to about 3.5% lower to compensate - Again, PRECHARGE, not cut-in or cut-out settings.

Your results may vary depending upon the tank capacity, bladder or accumulator configuration, and operating temperature (of the ground water). Whatever combination of elevation and temperature may be involved will dictate the result. It's all easy to figure out, and is detailed in Perry's and dictated by Boyle's and Charles' Laws.

As for the pressure switches, the older-style Square-D 9013-F or -G series are the most capable since they include adjustable cut-out as well as a more adjustable differential (cut-in) setting to function wherever you want. I like being able to have a differential closer to 12-13 PSI instead of 20 to mitigate large swings in flow and the effect that can have on temperature mixing settings as well as overall function. the fixed 20PSI differential switches are what is normally found at most consumer home centers and average hardware stores, and are probably better left on those shelves than installed in any water system.
With that narrower differential sounds like you would benefit from a cycle stop valve.
 
I'm so done with failing bladder tanks and their short 'life-span'. The last one I bought from our local hardware store said 'replaceable bladder' on the box, I asked how to get a replacement bladder? They said "generally they will just give you a new tank within 5 years". That was very good news to me. Nobody ever hinted to me about that before nor was there any guarantee posted on the box that I have ever seen. I've probably gone through at least 5 bladder tank failures. 🥲🤷🏼‍♂️ The last few years have seen a drastic price increase on bladder tanks.
I went through the same thing a few years ago and the last one I put is a FloTec, and luckily it is still working after several years.
 
Reminds me that I should see if my submersible pump still works. It quit about 5 years ago and I found the problem but never fixed it since we have rural water and all we used the well for was watering things outside. When I had the pump replaced quite a few years ago the well company got a wire caught between the casing and the well cap. It finally wore through and caused a short. Then a dog we had decided to chew up the wires when I had it all opened up and wires exposed. Still the same pressure tank that was installed when we plumbed the house in the late 70s or early 80s.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top