Suggestions wanted for a first tractor.

Like many in these tough economic times, I'm wanting to become more self-sufficient and independent. I've never owned a tractor in my life and never farmed or gardened either, but I'm ready to get started.

I'm seeking suggestions for a tractor make and model (and front end configuration) that is good for growing a very wide variety of different types of vegetables.

I plan on living off what I raise myself, so it needs to be an extremely reliable and robust tractor. I'm especially interested the older, vintage tractors for their durability and their overkill design.

I'm not looking to "feed America" or raise money by selling my crops to Uncle Sam (those days are long over), rather, I'm looking to feed myself and a small, growing family. There's a big difference here. Nothing more, nothing less.

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
 
A good roto tiller like a BCS or even a not as good Troy bilt is all you should need for a large garden.
 
I have a couple more questions for you, that will help make the suggestions more useful.

Do you live in the snow belt? If so, plan on freezing/canning a lot of what you grow.

How much land do you have to work with?

How much time do you have to spend on the project?

What type of budget do you have?
 
First thing....be realistic in your approach.

There are going to be people telling you all the wonderful things about their favorite ancient iron. I have had several different old tractors and I have never liked any of them, like I do my modern one. The machine has to be reliable, easy to operate, economical....not just fuel consumption, but what it costs to keep it running, and adaptable to common implements. The latter is what kills most pre 1960 machines. Until that time...give or take a few years, every manufacturer had their own proprietary hitch system.....which means of course, the implements were not interchangeable between brands of tractors. Over the years, folks have come up with conversion kits to modify the old systems to a 3 point setup. Some are good, some not so good.

Try to find yourself a decent tractor made in the 1970"s....a JD 830 diesel is an excellent machine. The various Ford 3600-3900 series are good reliable designs, the 245 Massey is another one.

These machines were made in era when the 3 point hitch was common to all makers, power steering pretty much standard equipment, 12 volt electrical and quality diesel engines being used. These models are old enough to be affordable, but new enough that parts are readily available. These tractors make good everyday users. My 2 cents.
 
I would look for a Massey Ferguson 135 diesel. Good tractor, plenty of parts available. I can't imagine what you could not do with it. It's not a huge tractor but very stout and perfect for a small farm. Just my $.02
 
From your description, I"m not sure you should be looking at tractors. You can do a LOT of family gardening with a good rear tine roto tiller. My experience is that it does a much better job of preparing a garden seed bed than a tractor with various implements.

If you have other uses for a tractor or just plain want the enjoyment of having one and you want an old one, there are probably two ways to go: A small utility tractor with a 3 point hitch. Just stick with a brand that still has some parts support and/or salvage parts available. (some suggestions might be Massey, Ford 2000, Oliver 55) I would think you would want to stick with a wide front.

A lot of "truck" farmers love some of the old small tractors like a Farmall Cub and I think it was the Allis Chalmers G. If you can find one with its proprietary cultivator, they were a pretty neat unit. But they don"t have modern hydraulics/3 points so you"re not going to be able to run a lot of the modern implements.

Larry
 
The 2 best tractors for that would be the IHC-Farmal Cub, 1 plow size and 1 row cultivator but with a vegetable cultivator that would handle 2 or more very narrow rows but would be very hard to find or the Allis Chalmers G with the engine in the rear so that you could see better what you were doing, same size plow and cultivator but vegetable cultivators were more easily avaible but tractor will cost more. What ever you would get make sure it would handle a 1 row cultivator set up for 36-40" rows. Very few tractors can do that. A Ford or Ferguson that is popular and the 1 row rear mount cultivator that is sold for them is not a good idea in that you need 48" rows then no crop clearance under the differental and that rear cultivator cannot be properly controled altho a lot of people would say to go with that.
 
We use a New Holland TC29 with a 5' tiller.
Then we use a Troybilt tiller with a row attachment to make rows and then cultivate between them. You really need a rear tine tiller if you go with the walk behind tillers a front tine one is next to useless. Good soil, fertilizer, rain, good seed, sunshine and lots of weeding will make a good garden. Good Luck.
 
Several good ideas already stated here.
If I may add to the following

"These machines were made in era when the 3 point hitch was common to all makers, power steering pretty much standard equipment, 12 volt electrical and quality diesel engines being used. These models are old enough to be affordable, but new enough that parts are readily available. These tractors make good everyday users. My 2 cents. "

Add
Live pto, live hydraulics, high presure/high volume hydraulics,remote hydraulic connections, differential lock and a rops or new enough to add a rops to it. A equipment line and dealer that is going to be in business in 20 years.
 
If you want to go vintage, a n old 8n is pretty low tech.. and not much thrills.. but a standard tool box and a 1/4" thick manual and you can rebuild it top to bottom.

Something a lil newer.. say a 660/661 or an 860 / 861 will get you more horses, and live pto and live hyds...

Still newer into the thousand or X600 series and you are getting a little newer tractor, with that classic feel.. say.. a 3000 with power steering an dthe 8spd tranny, with live pto and hyds.. etc.


I'm a ford guy.. but will throw in that a good MF 35 or 135 is a GREAT tractor in the same size range of the ones I spoke about.

soundguy
 
I grow about 1/4 acres of garden every year. I plow and fit the ground with a pull type plow and disc. A spring tooth harrow helps level it. I use a Mantis rototiller to weed. I have six old John Deeres from an H to D. No live PTO, no 3 point hitch. Most of them are hand start. You can make do with just about anything, but the old smaller equipment is getting hard to find as it's getting restored or cut up for scrap.
If you are only gardening a rear tine tiller would be all you would really ned. If you have other jobs for the tractor maybe a Farmall Cub would work for you if you can find cultivators. Too small to run a bush hog, but will plow a little snow if that's an issue. To give good advice I think we need to know all of the potential uses you have. A small utility tractor like an 8N Ford is fine for preparing your garden, but useless for cultivating it. Good luck--have fun,
Paul
 
Ford 8N, Ford Jubilee, Ford 600, Ford 800, Ford-Ferguson TO-30, Ford-Ferguson 35, Massey 135, Ford 2000, Ford 3000, Ih 404, IH 424, Oliver 55, Oliver 550, Deere 820 (3-cyl), Deere 1020, Deere 1520, Deere 2020, Deere 2510. any one of these would be an excellent choice, which one depends on the price and the deal. There are other good ones, but these are the most common and cheapest to buy and easiest to get parts and service for.
 
If a hand tiller is too small to do the job, a Farmall Super A, or later models 100, 130,140 all have that offset design that makes cultivating easy and can pull a small disk and 1 bottom plow. It would be big enough for a few acres. This tractor was made for small crops. A small diesel compact tractor with a rear tiller like the Japanese use would also work and they have standard 3pt hitches for other attachments. Also they are physically smaller for smaller areas. Just more thoughts if it was me doing it.
 
Either a Farmall Cub or Farmall Super A would work. The Cub is not that great for plowing, though. You could probably buy either one in good condition for under $2,500 with all the implements you need.
 
(quoted from post at 05:11:20 08/12/08) A good roto tiller like a BCS or even a not as good Troy bilt is all you should need for a large garden.

+1, not sure how spending tens of thousands of dollars on farm equipment would pencil out compared to a $500 tiller. Or how spending that much time scratching in the dirt would pencil out rather than going to a grocery store (unless it is something that you always wanted to do)

My WD-45 helps in the garden, I plow with my 2-14 snap coupler plow and then disk it smooth... more or less an excuse to play with it since a tiller would do the same thing. Aside from that I am not sure what you plan on doing with a tractor in a garden.

My grandparents took care of their garden with a $10 (now) garden hoe, and it was much larger than most today.
 
Unless owning an old tractor is one of the goals, the rototiller sounds like the best option, but you will want to abandon the tillage and planting conventions used by traditional farms.

Make your planting areas relatively small, 4'x20' is a nice size. Grow grass (lawn) around them. A couple dozen of these fields will grow all the food you can handle. The advantage is that you can focus on making some really good ground in the garden plots (lots of mulch, compost, no rocks), and a rear tine rototiller is very much at home in this environment. You can grow plants very closely together (under 1'), not using the 3'-6' row spacing that conventional farming utilizes. Also, since you are not always driving over ground with a heavy tractor you will not have to deal with compaction problems that many farmers have.

Its not as much fun as using an old tractor, but if growing food is the only goal...
 
Hmm. From what you describe, I would advise you to think smaller and get an old john deere or cub cadet garden tractor with a hitch. You can hook up a plow, a disk, a cultivator and a tiller. Plus, depending on the model, you should be able to get all those for under $2000. A John Deere 110/112 or 140 would work well, or perhaps a cub 71/72, 100 or original. Small cast iron Kohler engines and readily available parts. Any of these would easily take care of a small garden, up to a couple of acres.
 
Keep it simple. As you mention, you haven't got a lot of experience with tractors. Stay with 3-point hitch. There's other options, but implement availability will be more limited, and use is generally less "user friendly" to the unexperienced.

Power steering is a VERY nice feature, not a necessity, but I'd do what I could to end up with PS.

Live power. Don't let anyone talk you out of that. It's handy as a shirt pocket and makes for a MUCH safer tractor in the hands of a beginner.

I MUCH prefer diesel, but avoid old worn out diesels.

GOOD brakes. No need to explain that one. Just remember, they don't all have good brakes.

Good hydraulics. Chances are you won't need a super high volume/high pressure system, but make sure whatever you get, the hydraulics are in GOOD CONDITION.

Pick a brand (and a model) that was and still is popular. Orphans are cool collectors items, but scavenging for rare Egyptian parts in a rush can be frustrating.

I'll always believe the BEST tractors ever were built in the late 60's through early '80's. Technology and built in obsolescence were ships passing in the night until then. They crashed into each other after that.

OK.... My picks. Massey Ferguson 135 or 150, 245, or, if you have the urge for new, the 533 is a low cost option. Ford 3000, 3600. Deere 2040. (Avoid early 5000 series like the plague. Had one STILL regret that purchase) IH 454, 484. GREAT little binders!

JMHO, and worth just about what you paid for it.
 
(quoted from post at 16:49:25 08/12/08) you need a Satoh 650G...and i just happen to know where you can get a smokin' deal on one! ;>

Thanks for all the great ideas, keep 'em coming. It sounds like maybe a small tractor or a large garden tractor would suit me fine. Trouble is, I'm confused and bewildered by all the models out there. Like I said, I'm partial to older machines for their durability, but not against buying newer (or even brand new). I'm also partial to diesel so I can run waste vegetable oil in it if I need to for fuel.

I'm starting to think that a garden tractor might be better for me, but I don't know of any garden tractors that are capable of pulling a plow. I've read a lot of bad things about roto-tillers and roto-tiller attachments for tractors (soil compaction, tiller pan and so forth), so I'm a little hesitant going that route.

Anyone know of a diesel powered garden tractor capable of pulling a plow?
 
(quoted from post at 19:15:17 08/12/08)
(quoted from post at 16:49:25 08/12/08) you need a Satoh 650G...and i just happen to know where you can get a smokin' deal on one! ;>

Thanks for all the great ideas, keep 'em coming. It sounds like maybe a small tractor or a large garden tractor would suit me fine. Trouble is, I'm confused and bewildered by all the models out there. Like I said, I'm partial to older machines for their durability, but not against buying newer (or even brand new). I'm also partial to diesel so I can run waste vegetable oil in it if I need to for fuel.

I'm starting to think that a garden tractor might be better for me, but I don't know of any garden tractors that are capable of pulling a plow. I've read a lot of bad things about roto-tillers and roto-tiller attachments for tractors (soil compaction, tiller pan and so forth), so I'm a little hesitant going that route.

Anyone know of a diesel powered garden tractor capable of pulling a plow?

Just get a big tiller you walk behind, like a Troy-Bilt.
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top