Winch Questions

Jason1Pa

Member
I always wanted to mount a winch on my gooseneck trailer just incase one of the old girls didn't want to start after a show or when hauling a new toy home that don't run. I don't know much about them so i thought I would ask. Now I know they have several kinds of ratings. Say for instance if it can pull 8,000 lbs is that rolling weight or dragging weight? I just wonder how much it would effect the winch when I'm pulling a tractor up over the dove tail. If a tractor would be say 5,000 lbs would I need a winch that could handle double that because of the hill it has to pull the tractor up? I don't want to spend BIG bucks on something I may never really use so I want to try and get the smallest winch I can to cut costs. Since my trailer san handle 8,500 lbs I would want a winch that could pull that much if possable. I'd like to hear any good advice on what you guys out there have. thanks!!
 
8,000 would be plenty, I would also recommend a snatch block as an accessory in my toolbox, makes pulling alot easier. I would look for alot of cable capacity, seems I'm always 10' short with all the cable and chains I have. Warn 5687 is a great winch with alot of cable but it's not cheap.
 
I had a 2,500# rated electric winch just kicking around out in the shop. Got curious one day so I mounted it on the front of my gooseneck trailer and gave it a test. Believe it or not, it pulled a Farmall H right up the ramps and onto the trailer with very little effort. This was using the single line pull. No pulley block.
 
If your trailer is 16 inches high and you're loading a 5000 lb. tractor, which is close to the weight of a JD "G", the additional pull necessary to get the tractor up the ramps is determined by the length of the ramps as the length of the ramps determines the angle of incline. Using these figures and the use of vectors, a winch with capacity of 5500 lbs would be more than addiquate. But considering some unusual loading conditions and the fact that you might want to load a larger tractor, I'd go with at least a 6000 lb. capacity winch. rw
 
My 8000# Ramsey wrecker winch that we mounted in the gooseneck frame is rated 21,000lb line pull or 8,000 dead lift. Not all mfrs use the same rating system that was used years ago, be careful when buying something. We mounted 2-1100 amp truck batteries in the gooseneck that get charged off of the tow vehicle when in tow, so they're always charged when you need them. I agree, snatch block is a must have for doubling your cable strength. It can also be used for redirecting your angle of pull by chaining the block to one side of your trailer, tree, deadman, etc when pulling around an obstacle or getting the vehicle lined up with the ramps/beavertail. Fairlead roller properly adjusted is crucial to cable life. I have several winches that I thought about using but this one was most practical for this aplication. I agree with "lots of cable theory".
 
Also, don't forget that if you put a snatch block on the tractor and deadend (hook)the cable back by the winch, it gives double the amount of pulling power minus the friction of the snatch block but only half speed. So, a 5000# winch would theoretically pull close to 10,000#'s if the cable is large enough and you have enough cable to do that. Be sure to have a good strong mount for it, a snatch block rated for the amount being pulled and you'll be in good shape. ohfred
 
Warn and Ramsey rate their winches on dead pull weight. Alot of cheaper ones rate theirs at rolling weight. You can find out the specifics on their websites. I personaly prefer Warn. A wormgear drive is better and more expensive. The 8,000 lb and up usualy have a wormgear drive. Rick
 
I never mount a winch on a piece of equipment any more I mount a 2 inch reciever peg on the winch and mount 2 inch recever block on each piece (trailer ot truck , even the front of a truck). winch is then much more versatial, DON'T let friends know you have winch mounted this way asthey will all want to use it!
 
My brother has a either a 8000 pound or 12000 pound winch on his tilt-bed car trailer. He does a little junking and pulled an old straight eight buick sitting on dirt with no motor in it. It had a small tree growing through where the motor was. the winch pulled the buick on the trailer regardless of the tree.
 
That old Buick probably still weighed 4000# without the engine. Dragging it and adding the resistance of the small tree likely added another 1000-2000# of resistance. I have 3 HD winches off of wreckers and oilfield equipment if anyone's in the market. 1 Garwood that's missing the brake, 1 Tulsa complete and mounted on a headache rack for big truck & 1 Braden that's complete with brake but only mounted on an angle steel frame. All have sprockets so they can be chain coupled direct drive to hydraulic motor, pto, electric, air or hand crank. All had 1/2"-5/8" cable on them. I'm thinking about building a skidding winch with log arch with one of them for use on one of my tractors for pulling logs out of the woods.
 
Don't forget your wheel chocks. The largest winch isn't any use if it pulls the tow vehicle instead of the intended piece of equipment.
 
the use of 1 snatch block only permits a change of direction for the pulled object, you have to use 2 snatch blocks to acheive the increase in pulling strength.
 
Dude. If you put the snatch block on the item being pulled(tractor) and the hook back to the trailer then the pull is 2:1 or the 8000lb pull becomes 16,000.

If you put the snatch block on some other object and the hook on the item(tractor) then the pull is 1:1 or still 8000lb, but yes you can change the direction of the pull toward the snatch block.
 

Pete,

Count the number of parts in the line from the
movable block, that is the multiplier for the
increase in pull.

george
 
Something you may want to know if you want a good winch. I found a 12000 lb hydraulic winch and an electric over hydraulic unit with it off of an old garbage truck in a truck salvage yard. I gave $100.00 for the winch and another 100 for the hydraulic unit. It will pull anything I need to load and it was cheap.
 
Most replies are sensible.

Always dead weight, ie. vertical lift (although they are not designed or tested for this type of operation!!). Never rolling weight. Rolling resistance will be different on diffrent surfaces.

Note though, the rated pull will only be on the first turn on the winch drum. Double the diameter with extra winds on the drum and the pull will be halved. A lot are often much worse than this.

Advice. Big is better. The hydraulic winches are definitely better but much more expensive. Simple. You pays your money and if you are lucky you get what you pay for.

Snatch blocks are for doubling your line pull, or for changing direction of pull (with no change in line pull). Less the small amount of exrta friction involved, of course.

There is a difference between continuous rating and 'maximum operating time use' say 20%. Read the small print. Like small welders might stike a rod but will soon cut out or burn out!!

The slope (length) of your ramps will make a difference to the ability to pull any load onto the tralier, as will the design of those ramps

Regards, RAB
 
didn't know that one statement could generate so much response. seems like I will be rereading the physics book again (mechanical advantage). hey onefarmer, its pete, not dude. thanks.
 
didn't know that one statement could generate so much response. seems like I will be rereading the physics book again (mechanical advantage). hey onefarmer, its pete, not dude. thanks.
 
Is that the third time, or more times than that?

It is fairly simple. Effort and distance moved are the operative factors. Halve the recovery rate with the same drum speed will double the force applied, if necessary. Pretty simple really. Usually usinfg a snatch block results in lower loading on the winch and slower recovery.

Work done by the winch will be the same but the mass can be doubled if the distance moved is halved.


RAB
 
(quoted from post at 00:44:40 11/29/08)
Pete,

Count the number of parts in the line from the
movable block, that is the multiplier for the
increase in pull.

george

:D Now if you have something real heavy you can get even more pull IF you have 2 snatch blocks and enough cable! :shock: Put 1 block on the tractor, run cable through it and back to trailer. Now put second snatch block on trailer and run cable through it and back to tractor! :shock: NOW you have THREE times the pull, but will move three times as slow! :roll:
Dave 8)
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top