OT Sharpening a knife

What is the correct way to sharpen a knife on a stone? Ive heard you push it, heard pull it. Also heard to spit on the stone, or oil the stone. How does YT do it?
 
I am sure others will have their say but---- I was always taught to put a small drop of light oil on the stone and then move the blade almost flat in a figure 8 motion, both pushing and pulling. Works for me for the lat 70 years. Henry
 
Hello F150Mustang,
The stone determines wether you use it wet or dry. A little oil won't hurt and the angle you keep is more important than which way you stroke the blade. Try an angle equivalent to the tickness of 2 quarters. The quarters would be at the thick side of the blade to provide the angle to the cutting edge of the knife.

Guido.
 
F150Mustang: Lots of methods out there, but the basic one is to push the knife into the stone. This ensures you are removing metal in the correct direction and gives better control over the angle, which MUST be kept consistent for best results. Whether you put oil or water on your stone depends on the stone--there are both oilstones and waterstones. If you don't know what one is correct for your particular stone you'll probably be further ahead using oil, as it's by far the most common. Any good hardware store will sell honing oil--a 4-oz bottle will last years and will only cost a couple of bucks--though some people use kerosene, WD-40, 3-in-1, or other concoctions. You should always use lube on a stone--it serves to keep the stone from glazing, floats away the particles of metal as they're removed from the blade, and lubricates the surface as well. My typical method is to form the edge on a coarse diamond stone then move to progressively finer stones, each time taking off the wire edge formed by the previous stone. I finish with a leather strop (which, contrary to the stones, you HAVE to use with a pull motion, as it would otherwise bit into the leather) to remove any burrs and test on my arm--a good, sharp blade should easily shave hair. Again, this is what works for me--there are certainly other methods, but this one WILL produce a shaving-sharp edge without damaging your blade or stones, which is easy to do with incorrect methods or techniques.
 
My dad could sharpen a pocketknife with a dry stone,so sharp I was afraid to borrow it,fearing I would cut a finger off,and almost did a time or two.Could never do it myself.
 
Kids bought me a Chef'sChoice 110 diamond hone, electric. 3 station, first basically grinds the correct shaped edge, second is usually where I stop, the 3 and final stage gets the edge too smooth for me. I have found that most of my knives were too thick for good slicing. I guess I finally figured out that it takes 3 or 4 different shapes/thickness of knives. You cant split the chest cavity of a whitetail with a fillet knife. I had a big ole Schrade and never liked it cause I couldn't keep an edge on it, well it was just too thick. Takes the right kinda knife to do several jobs.

Cutco makes a darned good all around knife, rubber handle and really sharp blade. Comes in two point styles and smooth or diamond edge (searated).

For touch up on a stone, you cant beat a diamond stone. I use the diamond stones dry, then when I can see a build up of metal I rinse them under warm water to flush off the cuttings. I still have a bunch of whet stones of various kinds, but rarely use them any more.

Good luck,, Gene
 
You always want to push the knife against the stone like you're trying to cut a slice of the stone. Dragging the knife backwards will tend to form a thin "wire" edge that can break easily.

Don't waste your time with hardware store stones. The best you can get are the Japanese water stones. The Japan Woodworker carries a large selection
The Japan Woodworker
 
My wife is a dental hygienist, has to sharpen her instruments. I've found the best way to sharpen a knife is to give it to her.
 
Thanks to all who replied, good to get other ideas. While in the Air Force and flying for hours on end i always kept a stone with me and kept a real sharp knife, often doing other crew members knives. Never figured i was real good at it thou.
To change subject and add my 2 cents, i always carried a smith and weston knife. I liked it because it was a thicker blade as i often used it as a screwdriver- prybar. Never have broken a S&W yet. But the cutting edge seem "soft" and needed sharpening often. All in all was the best knives i carried for what i was doing with them.
 
Stainless --Pull (Dragging the edge)
High carbon--Push (Like trying to shave off stone, but don't)
Either method ends in very light pressure.
 
I skin a lot of critters in the fall and got tired of wasting time sharpening...
I have ended up using a Dunn system..mounts on a bench grinder ..one wheel has grit to put the inital edge..other wheel uses buffing compound to put the finish on....I have a cheap bench grinder Ive comitted to this...saves taking wheels on/off...

Note: make sure you lay knife on wheel properly...I had to put a note on my grinder so in case someone uses it they know it turns backwards....I mistakenly shot a knife across the garage due to forgetting about the rotation.. :shock: I have the grinder flipped so that the switch is facing away....this allows me to lay the knife on top of the wheel to better see the edge forming...
 
I ran into a guy that used to be a butcher. He sharpened my knife so sharp on a Metabo grinder, it was scary.
 
I got a S&W commemorative 150 years of texas ranger Folding knife. Made in China! I have carried it about 10 days and noted all but two of 6 body screws and spacers were gone, and the two were loose. The blade iron seems to be fine and at the rockwell that sharpens and stays sharp. I also have (this season) a gift from a student of a Winchester three knife set. Beautiful inlaied Mother of pearl and fittments (made in China . The steel is OK, but the handle is loosing trim pieces from the single folding blade knife, and the buffing was done so poorly that the rivets anf edges snag the pocket lining and wearthe skin. It depresses me to the bone. JimN
 
Whenever I'm travelling in the vast Australian outback, I ALWAYS carry a kinfe and stone. It can save your life in a survival situation. If you are stranded without water, take your knife out and start sharpening it. Within two minutes, some one will snatch it from you, tell you that you are doing it all wrong, and sharpen it 'properly'. When they have finished, you can ask them for a drink of water.
 
Grinding wheels should be kept away from knives.The only time you should grind knives is on low speed wheels that run in water.
 
One of the best stones I use is a Sears axe stone.My mother in law used to pick up stones on salt water beaches for her dad.He was a fisherman and never spent money on sharpening stones.I have a stone she picked up at the beach,works fine.Wire edges can be taken off on leather or with a knife steel.
 
Good thread. I have never been very good at sharpening knives that's why I carry one of those folding utility knives. When the blade is dull either turn it or replace it. With the information I learned here I may try sharpening.
 
Start with coarser, finish with finer. Oil or water good. Final leather. If you can't dry shave your arm, keep working on it. Some steel is almost impossible to sharpen. 30 years ago, this was not the case. Dave
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top