selling a farm

Anonymous-0

Well-known Member
Hellow all.

this is not a tractor question, but I wanted lots of opinions.
I inherited a farm and am wanting to sell. Probably about 6-700k value, could go higher.

Auctioneer wants 7%. This seems like a lot.
This could be a 40-50k commission.

I tend to think its no more work to sell a 700k farm than a 200k farm.

I'm talking to a very good auctioneer and he will not discuss a lower fee; am I wrong to think I may be paying to much?

I appreciate any comments, thanks.
 
Ever thought about a land contract to avoid capital gains?

Out of curiosity, where are you located at?
 
Do you have a minimum value that the auctioneer may not sell your farm for less than? Even though it may not sell the same day(it won't) you may not to consider selling it vice auctioning it. The price difference could be great.
 
7% is exorbitant.We are in the process of doing the same thing in fact the sale is at 10AM today.
I checked around and 4% seems to be standard and you pay exp .I have a friend who is a well known auctioneer who is doing it for half of that, 2%.
This is 200ac. in central Ill.Million $ plus sale.I would check around,real estate agent only charges 6% for a straight listing and name your price.
 
If you're willing to do the advertising why not auction it yourself? It probably won't sell anyway at the auction.I've seen many farms offered at auction over the years and very few got sold the day of the sale but its still not a bad idea because it gets interest in the land up and help it sell private treaty later
 
How about holding onto the property and renting or share cropping? It maybe better than "money in the bank". Or wait at least until the economy picks up again.
Shouldn't let the thoughts of all that cash burn a hole in youir pocket.
 
first thing you should prolly do is find an attorney and or good tax accountant. if inherited, you could be subject to inheritance tax. then if the property appraisal is lower than the sale price, capital gain tax unless you 1031 exchange to another income property. hopefully john t, couuntry gentleman and attorney at will chime in with a few words of wisdom. get your ducks in a row before you do anything!!!
 
1) First of all, any auctioneer or real etsate broker etc can WANT whatever,,,,,,,,its all negotiable, so make an offer n see what they will TAKE !!!!!!!! Its your farm to sell and its what YOU WILL PAY that matters NOT what someone WANTS. Shop around for auctioneers or real estate agents is my advice, but cost isnt the only factor, of course, a well established professional might advertise more etc and you will end up with more even with a higher commission........ I can see 7% on a small sales price but as the price increases the commission percentage rates often decreases accordingly

ITS YOUR CALL NOT THE SALES PERSONS WHO ARE FISHING FOR A FAT COMMISSION

2) I practice law in Indiana, and in this state Inheritance Taxes are an issue anytime a real estate transfer occurs due to a death SO YOU BEST CHECK WITH A LOCAL CPA OR ESTATE ATTORNEY, cuz you may end up with penalties if taxes are due and you avoid them !!!!!

3) I DO NOT practice Tax Law but again, check with a local CPA because what I think or you think or farmer Billy Bob (maybe in a different state where laws differ) on this board thinks is WORTHLESS if the IRS thinks otherwise and Id be willing to bet (even in your state where Im unfamiliar with its laws) the IRS is gonna get its grubby greedy hands on some of this money when you sell the farm you inherited UNLESS you re invest within a certain time or take advantage of other tax loopholes CHECK WITH A LOCAL CPA

FINAL DISCLAIMER N ADVICE

CHECK WITH A LOCAL CPA AND ESTATE ATTORNEY FAMILIAR WITH YOUR STATES LAWS versus any lay opinions on this board or even an attorneys opinion cuz if the attorney isnt familiar with your states laws or isnt a tax or estate attorney and doesnt have allllllll the facts even his opinion is basically worthless. With this much money at stake I advise you get local professional advice and counsel and dont hang your hat on your brother in laws or a tractor boards lay advice however well intentioned. Then when you shop for auctioneers or brokers tell them what you are willing to pay (dont even ask them what they will take) n watch them squirm n let them start "selling"

Best wishes n God Bless

John T Country Lawyer in Indiana
 
Why in the H@ll are you even considering an auction? The chances of you being ripped off by the auction company are about 99.9 percent. See your lawyer first and then a good real estate agent. Tom
 
My son and I have bought two farms in the last 6 months, both from people we know and trusted. A 50 acre tract and a 120 acre tract.

We secured financing, went to the local title and deed office, they prepared all of the papers.

We met at the title office, along with sellers and bankers. Signed all of the papers, walked out and didn"t cost us a dime other than the fee the title office charged. Something like $250

Both tracts had long time boundaries and did not need a survey. We worked through Farm Credit Services, they did send out their appraiser on the last tract, he went over the legal locations with a fine toothed comb and all was OK.

I would not think you would have trouble finding a buyer, do some leg work on your own and pocket a bundle that the realator would have made.

Worked for us
 
If you just inherited it make sure you have a good accountant or tax lawyer involved. The same jack of all trades that handles DUIs and petty theft could make a an error that will make the 7% commission look small.

As mentioned below - what he wants and what he gets are two differant things - ever pay sticker price on car? Then again not all auctioneers are equal. One that's screwed everyone and their dog will not attract the quality and quantity of bidders that some "good" auctioneers will draw in. They might earn their entire commission by making a few choice phone calls to some people they know are looking.

As for auction prices - it must depend on the area. I know in NE Kansas auction prices set the realestate market prices - no shortage of bidders to make you wonder who has all the money.
 
My Dad put my sister,brother and myself on the title to his farm. When he Passed we sold it and had to pay no extra taxes or anything. It worked wonderful.
 
About the only reason to auction real estate is desperation, IMHO. If you just inherited it, you're obviously not "under the gun" financially, so why not advertise and sell it yourself, or list it with a good farm realtor? Auction just isn't a good environment for selling real estate- too difficult to get people pre-qualified, etc. And by the way, 7% is outrageous- for as little work as he will do, 2 or 3% is much more in line. If you're going to pay what amounts to a real estate commission, why not get the services of a realtor as well?

If it were mine, I'd sell it on a real estate contract. Best interest rate you can get- where else are you going to invest at 6% these days? And if buyer defaults, its pretty cheap to forfeit the contract and get it back.
 
7-10% used to be the norm. Some continue that, altho as land prices have gone from $1000 an acre to $4700 an acre, some have cut their fees in 1/2.

Same with real estate agents.

Actually, most realestate auctions 'here' are sold with a buyer's fee - 5-10% added on to the bid price. So it looks like you the seller doesn't pay anything, but of course you will get 7% lower bids so of course you are....

Might want to shop around.

--->Paul
 
You have received a lot of good advice here. Those who advise against an auction are not necessarily in my camp. Though I have no personal experience with a land auction, I have been on both sides of land transactions. The land auction prices that I am aware of in Iowa, Minnesota and Nebraska, have most of the time, pleased the sellers. There are some cases where it was felt that the buyer really made out. Not always, a year ago in Iowa there was an instance where a bank offered the buyer $100K profit for a quarter he had just bought at auction. My take is that there are many areas that I would favor an auction, but not all.

Often my feeling toward auctioneers has been that they needed an attitude adjustment. Here is how I might approach your problem, wish I had a few problems like yours. Pick a price at or below what you know the land will sell for, say $550K or get an offer for it at the best price you can. My reasoning is that if you can sell it without help for $550K there is no reason to pay a commission on that amount. Now, if the auction people can bring value to it by way of an auction, pay a commission on that value. Rather than pay 7% on the total of the sale price, offer a larger percentage on the price you receive over the amount you have obtained with that help. For example if it brings $750K and you paid 12% of $200K, or $24K that would better than 7% of $750K or $52.5K. Hey, I will be happy to split the savings with you. Wire transfer instructions provided upon request.
 
Thats cuz it was done RIGHT and prior to his death, thats how I do it for my clients TO AVOID PROBATE its a non probate transfer that passes OUTSIDE the estate by operation of law...HOWEVER thats not to say necesarily alllllll taxes can be avoided, that still depends on several things, sounds like yours went well and thats sure posible if planned n done correct

John T
 
I'm in Bloomington, Indiana but wont return there from Florida until around April 1 so give me a call or e mail me then if you wish, what you need is relatively inexpensive n painless lol

John "T" Nordhoff [email protected] Home phone after April 1, 812-824-4608
 
Depending on what part of KY the land is in, there may be some on here who could help him out if he decides to go this route.



Dave
 
I'd shop around but, from what I hear 6-7% is pretty standard. A lot depends on which area board they are members of, some of them have rules that dont allow realtors and auctioneers to accept less than a certain percentage comission unless its for a family member. It does depend a LOT on who your auctioneer is how much a property brings. There are some who I refuse to attend their sales, some others that do a fabulous job.

I do tend to disagree with the majority of posts. Consistantly, in this market, I see more land bringing a better price at absolute auction than any other way. Thats another catch, if it isnt absolute, I wont go, period.

One idea is to try selling it on ebay or craigslist. That will save you the comission. Its some hassle but its quick and relatively cheap. I've sold property a lot of different ways, mostly, I've found that with a house a realtor is the way to go. With land, I seem like I end up doing what Im paying the realtor for. Thats why I generally sell lots and development land my self or at auction. My email is open if you want some referrals for auctioneers.
 
Just got home from the sale of my Dad's farm at auction .He died 11/8/08,4 of us kids all in our 60's inherited it .204 ac. in central Ill.,4 tracts ,1 80A and 3 40+A $1,080,000 .Had a super good sale for the time,Good auction company ,everything went well.I don't understand the bitter comments about auctioneers.There are good and bad in every line of work. Do business with the good avoid the bad
 
I appreciate all the comments. Wish I could answer each one.

The farm is in south central KY and I share it with two sisters. One wants all the money she can get; I don't blame her, and theres no other fair way than auction. Thought about dividing farm in sections, but no way for all to agree.

I guess that when you hire the best seller in the area, you just have to pay.
 
Do you know many farmers in the area? I know some say that that the auctioneer matters but here in North West Ky it don't make a dimes difference. There is not alot of outside money comeing in. It don't matter here if you use one of the two biggest out fits in the state or the small local guy who only has 3 sales a year. Yes the more adds on the net and in the fastline the more folks will show up, but "here" in my county there has only been about 5 folks who have bought 75% of production land at acution the last 5 years. They are the only ones that matter. They will show up if a sale just gets one little $20 add in the county paper.

Down there yes you might get some folks down from Louisville or up from Nashvagas. Not sure where it is but I know Mills in Scotsville puts on a good sale and does alot of adds. Larry Sanson also sells some farms down that way and clains to work cheap. Give him a shot.

Good luck.

Dave
 
One way you might want to consider, if you have operator of the land, you could get the land appraised, and offer it to him at the appraised value. Maybe there would be a neighbor who would be interested in it. this price would be less than an auction sale price. The auctioneer would get a better price for it but then he gets the commision, so that could be a wash. If you sold it on your own you'd have the appraisal cost, lawyer's fees, and other, but some could be paid be the buyer.
Anyway, I'd talk to a lawyer and a good tax accountant first, you'll want to know the tax you will have to pay.
Brian(MN)
 
Yesterday's Tractor Forums

We sell tractor parts! We have the parts you need to repair your tractor - the right parts. Our low prices and years of research make us your best choice when you need parts. Shop Online Today.

Back
Top